Radiohead-You And Whose Army (Live at Rock Am Ring 2001)

[metzradiohead]

worst crowd! spoil!

[myrtlebox]

This song is wrapped inextricably to the greatest movie of the past 10 years

Movie: INCENDIES (Canadian - English subtitles)

If you haven't seen it - RENT IT! You won't be disappointed. Don't let subtitles deter you.

[jeefojava]

@myrtlebox Just watched it last Saturday, couldn't agree more!

[kimdew23]

love. this song

[xyzdtl]

he said "sing with me" not clap

[W78516]

Wonder what kind of piano that is. It looks really old fashion. But it does sound great.

[DeViezeWilly]

STOP CLAPPING :@

[PearlJammer07]

Not a bad live rendition of this song. It just does not even come close to sounding as magical as the studio version. Amneisiac sesions captured something truly magical on tape. That will never be replicated.

[lordmeowmeow]

@PearlJammer07 Agreed. Amnesiac is eerily beautiful. 

[david181993]

Don't get me wrong I love radiohead and think they are incredible live, but I just think this is the one song where they just cant perform it well live. It just never sounds anyway near as good as the studio version, I think most of the time the piano doesn't sound powerful/aggressive enough and the backing vocals are too loud which kind of ruins it.

I have no doubt that someone will call me a fag or something for posting my opinion but whatever.

[malonervozan]

@david181993

Well you are not a fag,you just probably didn't hear "Paris live 2001" version...or maybe i'm wrong ;)

[david181993]

@malonervozan You're actually right I have never heard that one before, I think that is easily the best live version I have heard of it. I just think the balance between Thom and Ed's voices make or breaks whether it will sounds good or not, Thom has to be the louder one for it to sound good... maybe it's just me being picky. They sounded great on that one though.

[Cosbitron]

@david181993 I actually agree, what makes this song so great on the recording is the massive hit of the piano when it comes in, it's just never loud or heavy enough live

[TheWastedDude]

Why these german idiots don go visit some of their laim metal bands instead of one of the deepest bands of all time........

[captainkidding]

@TheWastedDude so all germans are idiots. i feel sad for you.

[TheWastedDude]

@captainkidding Actually i said " these German idiots" which refers to the crowd.....! but im sorry....I didnt mean to be a racist fuck...

[StefanL1982]

I´ve been there 2001, great show but the audience was full of idiots! That´s the reason why I don´t visit radiohead anymore on a festival. But Thom was just great! I love his smile at 2:01 !!!

[farizzal]

DUDE! Go Ed with that falsetto lead!

[aledobretociastko]

Stop complaining about the crowd, pls. Great performance, indeed.

[ThePurpleZeppelin]

if Radiohead was on a stage in front of me, I'd be screaming my balls off

[Raposaum]

LOL the crowd should sing out loud with him to form a chorus, specialy at the beggining. Whose army indeed? This audience sucks for an army, it ruined that the band tried to accomplish lol.

[icantgetnosleeep]

they are all German. maybe they just don't know the words.

[Redstarlomania]

fuckin awful crowd

[robertogberit]

that crowd should be ashamed.

[defpoet28]

This audience was abysmal at following Thom's cues.

[saquito]

come on.... COME ON...

You think you drive me crazy !

[rockerchick613]

lol they're so dumb they're not singing along, Thom's getting agitated haha <3 love this.

[hornsofarabbit]

ghost horses is the cherry on top of the lyrical cake. it gives it this whole sci-fi fantasy twist.

[tellytubies123]

I really fucking love Amnesiac. More than HTTT , and its even pretty close with Kid A for me.

[phewilostmyself]

the start should be the song, that would be cool. love you and whose army though.

[tommyneumann]

incredible performance of one of my favorite radiohead tracks.thom wrote this from the heart

[juanman100]

their voices blend perfectly..

[sunshinefromhell]

that red puff of smoke around 2:39 could be a ghost horse

[irstanci]

badass

[furterteam]

amo inconmensurablemtne a este grupo de hombres.

que hermosa musica.

que vengan a argentina diosssssssss

[simonpra]

this must be the worst crowd ever!

[HLGGanoth]

@simonpra

This was filmed in 2001, the year Amnesiac came out, so the people probably didn't know the song very well, hence not singing along.

[fourminutewarning]

@simonpra Holy !@#$ I was thinking the same thing then I read your comment. Nothing like what I experienced in Upper Darby!!!

[Copey0009]

@simonpra Thought that too but its 2001 so this song would have been brand new + not as well known/ recepted/./

[litlemadguitarist]

@simonpra At the same time, rock am Ring crowd prefer rammstein. XD

[RacaCobain10]

@simonpra The worst crowd ever is on Rock am Ring but on a gig of Pendulum.

[Chaossangel]

@simonpra It says 2001 in the title.

[igorchillipeppers123]

@simonpra why?

[metzradiohead]

@igorchillipeppers123

its radiohead! everyone should be silent and listen. HEAVEN

[igorchillipeppers123]

@metzradiohead agree

[bajuriphd]

@metzradiohead US gig even worse..continuous screaming on "exit music" aint t that a bitch??

[Juanchupumpkinhead]

thom is god, i love how he entertains the crowd.

[ljoekelsoey4]

is rockpalast the same as rock am ring? i didnt know, kl

[crispy185185]

rockpalast is the arena, rock am ring is the whole event's name.

RADIOHEAD FTW

[ModulationCracks]

wrong.

Rockpalast is a legendary german TV Show where concerts of bands are shown.

[joeevans87]

an underated radiohead gem.

[Banco86]

underrated by who??

[bzradiohead18]

the amnesiac haters xD its a shame really it make look dark but its beautiful, like an ugly duckling that turned into a swan

[radioheadyorke]

FUCKING AMAZING

[Mightypoo007]

and thanx for uploading mate!

[packofsandwiches]

magical indeed