小城大事 - 張學友 2007

[kesel5588]

too many bells and whistles. I like Jacky and all, but he overworked this song.

[SiuBoo201000]

個人鍾意千嬅的版本多d

尤其是當學友到 " 無回憶的男人... 抱抱我不過份"

XD 心頭一震

[oz1989710]

@SiuBoo201000 haha

[wayne9394]

beautiful!!!



[ki0610]

佢唱變左BL版..- -

[ednamiyazaki]

張學友只有技巧...

[ozalice96]

@ednamiyazaki I beg to differ. Technique alone is not enough to melt people's hearts! The fact that so many people are touched by Jacky's interpretation of this song is because he is able to convey the sentiments of the song fully to the audience! Bravo, Jacky!

[sskycloud]

這首歌果然是女人唱最好聽



[mindspectre1]

No need mixing or anything. Legit voice. Jacky Cheung is the best.

[GKPJ0GrUvs]

他唱的真的很棒!

[TheYohoio]

張學友唱這首歌時尾音有點像日本的佐虅篤志...

[TTUNGGG]

千嬅的比較好..這個版本有d作狀

[anc68001]

好"友"feel 連聽不懂廣東話的我都覺得超好聽

[dtc0210]

我覺得很棒 不比03年差:)



[richsteve33]

Miriam should learn more from Jacky for how to sing this song better, especially in her own Live concert.

[MrFish1314]

跟03年相比之下雖然疲憊了,但聽起來反而多了一份感情

[SING95210]

good soon ;)

[ddvwvbb]

[iminent blink][iminent=fp4PY7YVffOB] [/blink]

[tormentalous18]

Nice version!

[LiMingChieh]

看歌神臉上的汗水就知道了 03在唱的時候狀態很好 這個版本看起來就很疲憊

[rage30341]

@TaylorMomsenfans26 I bet the 58% is from the younger geneneration who don't really know to much about Jacky, so that pretty much tells me your brat with issues with classic music

[niwang9600]

the best one

[Seymourbuts]

i heard this live.... i sat there shocked... i wana hear it again!

[kkabcdef]

03 年(好像)的版本更完美, 07年這版感覺他有點累

[jeansowner]

@kkabcdef I agee! 03 is a better version

[ozalice96]

The first time I heard Jacky sang this song, I was completely carried away by his

captivating vocal and immense emotions. Then, I searched for Miriam's original

version to see how she measured up. To put it mildly, had I listened to her version

first, I don't think I would fall in love with this song in the first place. Well done Jacky!

[rage30341]

Jacky is 98% better then miriam, she still has 2% which is not bad

[TaylorMomsenfans26]

@rage30341 haahh .... Miriam Yeung has 58 % and Jacky has only 42 %. You are a loser !!!  = (

[bedonken]

楊千嬅的表達是做到歌聲和歌曲共嗚...

個人覺得千嬅比學友唱得好,

各人有不同感受

[LifeAsTheMoon]

大師級/ 有實力 / 認真投入或代入的才唱到那種傷感

翻唱新不了情﹑味道﹑領悟﹑明知故犯﹑原來你甚麼都不要

那些人該行開啦

近年我聽過翻唱而好過原唱的…我覺得只有這曲,和"我真的受傷了­"

有無奈與傷心的Feel…好touch

[ray1443224]

@LifeAsTheMoon 我真的受傷了­係學友架WO

[ka619]

@ray1443224 ...下..我真的受傷了係王苑芝自己作自己填詞架喎..

[yanggc12]

学友哥，你热吗?

[xyndy89]

oh noo!!! i think i like this version more now than miriam. he is a good singer!!!!! like it.... he has lotss of emotions!!! agreee!!!

[clokie]

by far the best out of the four heavenly kings, and dare i say he is probably the best singer to ever come out from the Hong Kong music industry

ive listened to jacky since i was a little kid, he is the one that made me want to become a singer.

still is and will forever remain my idol

[funnybunny9396]

每曰都要黎拜一拜神至舒服

[joycehou8751]

wow～～～



[CarlChongKC]

黎明 之後到千嬅 之後到歌神(2次)..........

[sonia12b]

好凄惨。

[TRISTON93]

歌神。。。

[C0nn13]

I love his voice, it has so much emotion

[henrykarfor]

歌神~~~~~

[ro62327]

-v- 學友 支咪 痴到好埋@@"

[VIPVICT]

因為佢有105場巡迴演唱會，場場3個鐘，如果唔咁做把聲好快垮­

[funnybunny9396]

這個版本同04版本有些不同但一樣咁好听 歌神点唱都好听過原唱.

[TomAnkit]

就算張學友係好聽d...但係其他人都可以有唔同意見架..唔駛­比個負人地呀...

你地d人.....真係專制...仲要成日話要自由..

影衰晒..

[Newcastlefans]

agree

[stranger4135]

07年版都唱得比較大器

活出生命比較像輕輕哼唱的分享感覺

現在的歌手都應該聽聽張學友

整個旋律性詮釋得極好

[kwokyungfui]

jacky sing is very good!!

[milkiwei]

好像有一點哭腔？

好感人。。。 好喜歡 :)

[Kijado]

很动人

[eternalsn0w123]

Jacky's version is so much better!! When I first heard Miriam's version, I didn't feel much emotion, but in this version, I started getting teary-eyed towards the end.

[popcan0303]

他唱的很棒很棒

[kai11304]

毋係香港歌神 係亞洲歌神啊

[bear101ify]

真係唱得好感人~真不悸為香港歌神!

[InspectorDante]

亚洲歌神..

[bbislonely]

點解佢可以唱得咁好...

[dedomvUser]

聽 张学友 学友光年世界巡回演唱会07 香港站 CD2 完整專輯 在 dedomv 滴兜 MV 音樂網 ! : bit . ly / 4s11C

[chanwchung]

因為兩個版本不同的原因是貼咪唱及不貼咪的分別,確實學友真係同­之前演出方式有所不同,但一樣這麼好聽,真是真真正正歌神:

[funfunpiano]

好好聽!!!好有感情~我好鐘意呀~!!!!!

[Devilmaycry11121992]

我觉得杨千嬅唱好听点....但学友唱的这个版本会好听过千桦的­....

[wanchiandy]

不過我鍾意呢個版本

因為長d..........

[scaredcool]

不知道是不是巡迴演唱太累了@@

感覺2004活出生命唱的比較好聽

[Cantoner]

音色是2004好很多...而且活出生命的echo 比較好

[revendrous]

老實說,張學友比楊千嬅唱得好多了,無論是技巧或感情表達

[benyakult]

同意~~

[ellanblogcontinue]

@revendrous agreed you said that right

[u3wu0ru04]

@revendrous 各有特色

[sonson3701]

@revendrous

如果真的感情這麼投入 那個詞怎麼忘了 1:05 戀上命數的事?

你知唔知 對於好多人來講依首歌每一隻字的感情表達有幾重要??

無可否認...學友是絕少有的天王巨星 實力 什麼都非常高...但說到這首歌 真的有保留 只是唱功和學友的實力太高了吧...不過就整首歌的感情區 我覺得千 女華 的畫面比較感人...如果唱歌是可以說出一個故事的吧 我並不認同比楊千嬅唱得好多了 這一句

[gu4992]

jacky concentrates when he sings. can really feel the sorrows of the songs from him through his expressions and voice.