I adore this poem. It's beautiful. So haunting and gives me the goosebumps every single time. Those who have posted really bad comments need to take a good look at themselves.
I found that the animation was quite crude and the music didn't really capture the poem. It was a good attempt but It wasn't a strong portrayal of the poem.
Oh my gosh who is doing the reading of this, in the film not the commentator, I love it! ... please anyone??? His name is on the tip of my tongue & it's driving me crazy...
I haven't read any of the hateful comments below but I read the two most popular ones above and have to say that I had no idea that Wilfred Owen was gay, and to be honest don't care. His personal life is not the point, it's the beauty in his words. In summary, I'd like to add the possibly inflammatory comment:
"FUCK OFF GAYBASHERS! SEXUALITY DOES NOT AFFECT PROSE"
It was because of the vile, cruel, horrible trenches that these veterans in their forties, who now had families, were so reluctant to enter World War II. Americans weren't cowards, they just remember what a World War coud do, and it would refuse to fight as hard as it could. When America was forced into World War II, it did so totally understanding of the Great War! No generation ever has ever agreed to fight a war knowing so well what its cost would be. God Bless them all!!
I have written for as long as I can remember. I have never read anything as profound as the poetry of the great war. It is impossible to overestimate this work. We live in a blinded age to humanity. When it comes down its all about life and death. Forget addictions and anorexia etc. This is the real deal. Right or wrong. This is it...
@Blakebaby23 Its easy to drop conclusions on the human race while sitting on a soft sofa and a cup of tea within reach. Please never tell these kind of nonsens to the ones who fight their own battles in the zone somewhere between life and death. Dying is and never will be an elegant thing, after all there's no such thing as the olympics for the most horrible way of dying. As if it is some kind of contest fgs.
THANKS TO EVERY ALLIE THAT DIED TRYING TO GIVE US OUR FREEDOM AND WITH OUR LIVES AND FREEDOM THEIR MEMORIES WILL LIVE.......if that makes any sence to any1 please tell me
@nikoli46 I think freedom was at stake in WW2. But the stupid pride of old men was what spawned the Great War. All of the men of both opposing sides who fought and died in the conflict were Heroes and should be remembered as such. The greed and ignorance of those who wasted their lives in a pointless war should be regarded as crimes against humanity. The only victory to be gained from the Great War is the hope that such a tragedy will never happen again.
I came here to watch and listen to this amazing poem, when i read thro the post im astounded by some peoples coments...
This is an amazing, breath taking and heart felt Poem about young men- some too young to even be called men. Thay fought and died in some of the most harrowing condition known to man.
What century are we living in for god sake. Whats important here?. thousands of people dying and 1 man speaking so truethfully and so sorrowfully about it or that the same man was gay.
Some of you have serious problems. Homophobic doesn't begin to cover it! Downright nasty & ill informed. So Owen was homosexual - that's not the proclivity of the 'Officer Class'! Records show his men were impressed with him (even if he was a poof). Whilst huge numbers were killed in WW1 the Officer Class suffered most - it's been assessed it lost 30% of it's young men. That left a vast number of young widows, not to mention women who would never meet an eligible man & have children ....
OK. So he was gay, big deal. If anything, it made his work better and it proves that homosexuals should be allowed to serve in the armed forces. It also proves that you can be gay and still be masculine.
I think the most powerful ever reading of this poem comes from the Flanders WW1 Memorial, with the tubes of green gasmasks and the hauntingly empty voice.
It could've just been me because I went after visiting Tyne Cot on Langmark, but when I was there, I wasn't far off tears.
As was Rupert Brooke, Siegfried Sassoon, Tennyson, Byron, E.M Forster, Evelyn Waugh, T.E Lawrence (of Arabia), W.H Auden, D.H Laurence had homosexual affairs, half of the Bloomsbury group and Cambridge University. In short, large numbers of English literature's most eminent figures were homosexual, bisexual or at least laid back enough not to worry and have to give it a lable. Would that we were all a little more tolerant these days.
if you were forced to fight with men all day every day, see nothing but men, be forced to care for, look after and mourn only men, for months and months on end, i think you might be a bit fuking queer too. Either way, he's a fantastic poet, and it didn't effect his poetry so who gives a damn?
Sign, this is amazing.
ooo1309 2 months ago
I adore this poem. It's beautiful. So haunting and gives me the goosebumps every single time. Those who have posted really bad comments need to take a good look at themselves.
ninacat88 2 months ago
After 42 yrs...first of many!!!
HopeWithPandora 5 months ago
Comment removed
JoooshTube 8 months ago
We studied thsi in year 8.
TehAntt 9 months ago
I found that the animation was quite crude and the music didn't really capture the poem. It was a good attempt but It wasn't a strong portrayal of the poem.
Oredan22 10 months ago
Oh my gosh who is doing the reading of this, in the film not the commentator, I love it! ... please anyone??? His name is on the tip of my tongue & it's driving me crazy...
springrobin 11 months ago
@springrobin i think its Samuel Barnett in the film...
madmum23 10 months ago
That poem is beautiful
Solarissis 11 months ago
an inspirational poem
1goldendude 1 year ago
an inspirational poem
1goldendude 1 year ago
reminds me of blackadder goes 4th lol but baldrick is a better poet lol
vaughan4082 1 year ago
I haven't read any of the hateful comments below but I read the two most popular ones above and have to say that I had no idea that Wilfred Owen was gay, and to be honest don't care. His personal life is not the point, it's the beauty in his words. In summary, I'd like to add the possibly inflammatory comment:
"FUCK OFF GAYBASHERS! SEXUALITY DOES NOT AFFECT PROSE"
kowst 1 year ago
this program is so great
marcbolanfan 1 year ago
The best reading of this poem can be heard in the 'In Flanders Fields' museum (Ypres). All the others mostly aren't that good.
AndaTuraa 1 year ago
I have heard several folks reading this poem and everyone is terrible. the poem is magnificent, but the readers all have no idea how to read it.
I like this commentary very much, but the actual read is wretched
PTCello 1 year ago
It was because of the vile, cruel, horrible trenches that these veterans in their forties, who now had families, were so reluctant to enter World War II. Americans weren't cowards, they just remember what a World War coud do, and it would refuse to fight as hard as it could. When America was forced into World War II, it did so totally understanding of the Great War! No generation ever has ever agreed to fight a war knowing so well what its cost would be. God Bless them all!!
giannivee1 1 year ago 2
I have written for as long as I can remember. I have never read anything as profound as the poetry of the great war. It is impossible to overestimate this work. We live in a blinded age to humanity. When it comes down its all about life and death. Forget addictions and anorexia etc. This is the real deal. Right or wrong. This is it...
Blakebaby23 1 year ago
@Blakebaby23 Its easy to drop conclusions on the human race while sitting on a soft sofa and a cup of tea within reach. Please never tell these kind of nonsens to the ones who fight their own battles in the zone somewhere between life and death. Dying is and never will be an elegant thing, after all there's no such thing as the olympics for the most horrible way of dying. As if it is some kind of contest fgs.
bolderiks 1 year ago
THANKS TO EVERY ALLIE THAT DIED TRYING TO GIVE US OUR FREEDOM AND WITH OUR LIVES AND FREEDOM THEIR MEMORIES WILL LIVE.......if that makes any sence to any1 please tell me
nikoli46 1 year ago 3
@nikoli46 I think freedom was at stake in WW2. But the stupid pride of old men was what spawned the Great War. All of the men of both opposing sides who fought and died in the conflict were Heroes and should be remembered as such. The greed and ignorance of those who wasted their lives in a pointless war should be regarded as crimes against humanity. The only victory to be gained from the Great War is the hope that such a tragedy will never happen again.
EbsNhexz 1 year ago
Turn off the 'embedding disabled' - I want to link to this from another website but your present settings won't allow. Thanks.
thelad101 2 years ago
It's not brave or fitting to die for your country - it's horrible! The Goverment is so brainwashing.
joshjosh1996 2 years ago
@joshjosh1996 That's why it's referred to as 'The old lie' in the poem.
elektrikalex 1 year ago
This was the one that got me started, the only poem that grabbed my attention at school. Great to hear it again - strong stuff!
dashpoet 2 years ago
same here :)
CheekyChinchillas4 2 years ago
I came here to watch and listen to this amazing poem, when i read thro the post im astounded by some peoples coments...
This is an amazing, breath taking and heart felt Poem about young men- some too young to even be called men. Thay fought and died in some of the most harrowing condition known to man.
What century are we living in for god sake. Whats important here?. thousands of people dying and 1 man speaking so truethfully and so sorrowfully about it or that the same man was gay.
trisha3397 2 years ago 34
Some of you have serious problems. Homophobic doesn't begin to cover it! Downright nasty & ill informed. So Owen was homosexual - that's not the proclivity of the 'Officer Class'! Records show his men were impressed with him (even if he was a poof). Whilst huge numbers were killed in WW1 the Officer Class suffered most - it's been assessed it lost 30% of it's young men. That left a vast number of young widows, not to mention women who would never meet an eligible man & have children ....
Insperato62 2 years ago 27
This poem is so moving. I'm glad that I got to study some of his amazing work! :)
kwurly 2 years ago 10
What a hard hitting poem. Very real.
mcrxtillxixdie 3 years ago 7
his poetry is rele kl, i studies it from my english literature a-level last term. i miss it :(
shezz0123 3 years ago 2
There is no concrete proof of him being either hetero-, homo-, or bi-sexual. Can we just leave his sexuality out of it, please?
Herobelle 3 years ago 4
OK. So he was gay, big deal. If anything, it made his work better and it proves that homosexuals should be allowed to serve in the armed forces. It also proves that you can be gay and still be masculine.
MaikuxSAN 3 years ago 7
I think the most powerful ever reading of this poem comes from the Flanders WW1 Memorial, with the tubes of green gasmasks and the hauntingly empty voice.
It could've just been me because I went after visiting Tyne Cot on Langmark, but when I was there, I wasn't far off tears.
501135127 3 years ago 2
I agree completely, I also went there after visiting Tyne Cot and found it a very moving experience.
rosygirl52 1 year ago
you know some people reckon that if u r queer it makes you more creative...
sophyloo 3 years ago
Who the hell cares about his sexuality? It has no bearing on the beauty of his poetry and work. I wish people would realize that.
SassoonOwen 3 years ago 2
right queer and WW1 english officer! an't they the same thing!
jezzeronthecoast 3 years ago
No. I bet you think Gallipoli and Braveheart are in some way factual.
snooked 3 years ago 3
Yeah, thats funny..
Take the piss out of some of the bravest and most daring officers fielded by any nation in what was our country's most deadly conflict.
I bet you've never been anywhere near a firefight...
TakehikoKun 3 years ago 8
He was more of man than you'll ever be.
haggis95 2 years ago
I love Wifred, but I hope you all know ..He was a right queer and no mistake.
dabsy71 3 years ago
Indeed,
As was Rupert Brooke, Siegfried Sassoon, Tennyson, Byron, E.M Forster, Evelyn Waugh, T.E Lawrence (of Arabia), W.H Auden, D.H Laurence had homosexual affairs, half of the Bloomsbury group and Cambridge University. In short, large numbers of English literature's most eminent figures were homosexual, bisexual or at least laid back enough not to worry and have to give it a lable. Would that we were all a little more tolerant these days.
starlakid 3 years ago 4
Right queer? Is ths important?
nbatterby 3 years ago 3
if you were forced to fight with men all day every day, see nothing but men, be forced to care for, look after and mourn only men, for months and months on end, i think you might be a bit fuking queer too. Either way, he's a fantastic poet, and it didn't effect his poetry so who gives a damn?
zQWASZX 3 years ago
now that was awesome
foldedintobeauty2 3 years ago
Samuel Barnett sounds great! He's not that bad looking with a mustache too..
cr0wdedh0using 3 years ago
sounds like Jude Law doing the second part of the reading...very good poem
stewbacca117 3 years ago
thank you!
ImNotOk123 3 years ago