this is just from the heart! God's ways are uninvestigateable...but this song, my God.,,this is magic...smth unbelieveable! God sent Meschian people...to help us...AMEN. there is noone who is as close to Lord as Arthur Meschian!
@sourensarafyan When Arthur Meschian wrote this song , he was 16 years young and he did'n know about Myshegh Ishkhan. Mushegh Ishkhan is survivor, and he is Arthur Meschian's wif's uncle!!!!! Do not give wrong information!!!
AM is an amazing person and an amazing intellectual . His depth is not understood by many. Most people linger on a few words from a song . To understand him completely you have to set aside your personal experiences and just listen.
@forcuties don't you EVER talk about A.M. like that....you know NOTHING.....you poor minded..... swearing...........go listen to dzax harut....that is your level....and bally dansers
..This song Meschian wrote long ago-when He was 16 years young.....and whatever you'r trying to say....He already did during 40 years of his life....listen to his other songs, and hopfully you'll get it.....
@forcuties Hwo told you that Meschian does nothing????????????? He is Great Architect....and he doesn't build those building you talking about.....now he's building Matenadaran's addision......you BLAME everybody except yourself...............
@forcuties It's becouse you leasten , but Not hear what this song is really about...that's primitive way to listen the "blame" only....this song much dipper than your brein can take......becouse your taste in music=bally danseres......ha-ha-ha
@Sarinenoeme anyone who has moderate amount of brain cells will make conclusion that you are unable to discuss the subject but keep talking the same "great song" nonsense. Where do you see I criticize the melody? What's the title of this song? "Where were you God", right? What are the lyrics? - Same BULLSHIT. Why do you think it may not have great melody, good quality lyrics, but content will be GARBAGE?
@forcuties because some things must happen!!! Genocide has to be recognized !!! and don't tell me that some time even u didn't blame God for things that happened to u!
I am not saying that it is right but that's the way it is!!! And this song is just ARISTOURGIMA ! ! !
@shineuptome nothing wrong going back to history, analyzing, demanding recognition of Genocide, but it's ABSURD to blame God in that, or blame for earthquakes. God didn't make Turks to kill us, same way God didn't force our ancestors to live in the lands of SOB turk animals. They could leave like Slavon nations leaved to safer places in Europe when animal Megyars invaded present day Hungary. God didn't force STUPID PEOPLE built fucked up building in earthquake zone which could fall any time.
Our world is hostage to the insatiable rampaging of the ruling class private gain and greed, dominating,dehumanising,devaluing everyone and everything in the midst. We can and must change the wage slavery of immense humanity in a market system of artificial scarcity . We can share the world for our common needs and well being in harmony within and without.
Bravooo, very nice music...God Bless You Arthur..We love you...Mernem ko sirtin axperes...Nazareth Shahinian 298 PAlisade Ave, Cliffside Park, New Jersey, USA. 07010 cell: 551-4045282 work 201-840-7004...zangi.. wwwcashArmenikingcom
The evolution of recent human history has been dominated by minority control over the majority, the rulers have come up with nessesary illusion for compliance and servitude of the many, Science and technology has created a world of plenty, but the market mechanism is about artificial scarcity to perpetuate poverty and exploitation in a modality of war,enviornmental destructions,animal cruelty and so on . The new paradigm is sharing the Earth for our collective needs and wellbeing.
fuck jesus, the fake god that led us to believe humans are more humane than animals, hence the destiny of the Armenian people. Whom almost perished in the name of this sorried excuse of a god. Wake up Armenians! Your destiny is in you own hands, not in the hands of a dead jewish god.
An attempt at translation, so our English speaking world could get an idea of what Meschian is singing about. [1] Where were you God? When an abandoned people maddened Where were you God? When our plea died unanswered Where were you God? When they were destroying a glorious nation Where were you God? When from the maddened pain we were praying amen Aaaaaaamen aamen
Thanks a lot dear Arthur for this song/ complaint....I think will be a good idea for Mr.S. Sarksyan( Pres) to listen to this song twice a day!! and let's see if he has any Armenian blood left in him?
Ays erge Artur Meschyane shat lav e katrarum, isk erg@ grel e Gyumreci mi invalid eritasard kompozitor vor@ etpes el anhayt mnac ev minch aysor voch mek chgiti te vortex e ev kam ardioq voxj e na. Nra anune Aleqsandr e. Artur Meschyani ergarvest@ bacardzakapes tarber ev xorimast e shat. Na naev hoyakap chartarapet e. ir himnakan masnagitutyun e.
Some people confuse Arthur's lyrics for RAP this is not RAP this is something way DEEP, this is something spiritual... I personally this his music is spiritual & every word makes scenes... Some people get his lyrics in the wrong way, but that's too bad for them, because they don't understand where his coming from and what his message is...
dont blame GOD thank him that u r still alive that we armenians still exist GOD cant be blamed for everything its just ssin wen adam and eve sinned the world was coursed alot of bad stuff will still happen jews are gods ppl how come 5 mill died its not gods fault dont blame him thank him that ur still alive
kunem obama kunem kes you filty lair pig you breake your promise we all know the true he reapet the genocid eword 1000 times and say it is a fact and know he lie how much did turky gave you or only hope is god barbaros turkey this is way there are some peapol become terror fight for the right!!!
oh... 'tHIS IS WHY SOME PEOPLE BECOME TERRORISTS'...IS THAT WHAT YOU R TRYING TO SAY?? So if people do not believe your allegations, or deny them or dispute them or debate them, then they should become terrorists according to u! No, Obama is not a kunem. He is sensible and smart and knows the truth. Right now, he is playing both sides of the fence. Vewry clever man.
God was probably watching in horror......He could not believe that some of His "creatures" would carry out the most atrocious and sacrilegious barbarity against the noble nation of Armenians who were the first to accepted His son as their saviour.........Maybe God has not yet recovered when he witnessed that unspeakable savagery....
His question was rhetorical, and as such needed no answer.
And do not involve Jesus, especially as a "son of god"... His song is addressed to a single deity some tend to believe in, not necessarily the Christian god.
shat lavna !:)
talarouu 1 month ago
this is just from the heart! God's ways are uninvestigateable...but this song, my God.,,this is magic...smth unbelieveable! God sent Meschian people...to help us...AMEN. there is noone who is as close to Lord as Arthur Meschian!
HasmikM 2 months ago
AM did not "write the song", the words are by Moushegh Iskhan Մուշեղ Իշխան himself a survivor of the genocide hence the resonance of the words
sourensarafyan 3 months ago
@sourensarafyan When Arthur Meschian wrote this song , he was 16 years young and he did'n know about Myshegh Ishkhan. Mushegh Ishkhan is survivor, and he is Arthur Meschian's wif's uncle!!!!! Do not give wrong information!!!
Sarinenoeme 3 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Arthur Meschian
AM is an amazing person and an amazing intellectual . His depth is not understood by many. Most people linger on a few words from a song . To understand him completely you have to set aside your personal experiences and just listen.
argishti01 9 months ago 5
Amen
azerbaran1 10 months ago
Comment removed
armenianspirit 1 year ago
Comment removed
armenianspirit 1 year ago
@forcuties don't you EVER talk about A.M. like that....you know NOTHING.....you poor minded..... swearing...........go listen to dzax harut....that is your level....and bally dansers
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago 3
..This song Meschian wrote long ago-when He was 16 years young.....and whatever you'r trying to say....He already did during 40 years of his life....listen to his other songs, and hopfully you'll get it.....
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago
Comment removed
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago
@forcuties Hwo told you that Meschian does nothing????????????? He is Great Architect....and he doesn't build those building you talking about.....now he's building Matenadaran's addision......you BLAME everybody except yourself...............
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago
@Sarinenoeme do you know Armenian, if yes, let's discuss this in Armenian instead of exposing our garbage to others.
forcuties 1 year ago
@forcuties it's only your garbage...
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago
@forcuties It's becouse you leasten , but Not hear what this song is really about...that's primitive way to listen the "blame" only....this song much dipper than your brein can take......becouse your taste in music=bally danseres......ha-ha-ha
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago
@Sarinenoeme anyone who has moderate amount of brain cells will make conclusion that you are unable to discuss the subject but keep talking the same "great song" nonsense. Where do you see I criticize the melody? What's the title of this song? "Where were you God", right? What are the lyrics? - Same BULLSHIT. Why do you think it may not have great melody, good quality lyrics, but content will be GARBAGE?
forcuties 1 year ago
Comment removed
armenianspirit 1 year ago
Comment removed
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago
@forcuties Haven't you wondered why any Genocide that have been done by Turkeys isn't recognise? Armenias, Greeks Pontians?
shineuptome 1 year ago
@forcuties because some things must happen!!! Genocide has to be recognized !!! and don't tell me that some time even u didn't blame God for things that happened to u!
I am not saying that it is right but that's the way it is!!! And this song is just ARISTOURGIMA ! ! !
shineuptome 1 year ago
Comment removed
Sarinenoeme 1 year ago
@forcuties to go further , u have to return to ur history first!
shineuptome 1 year ago
@shineuptome nothing wrong going back to history, analyzing, demanding recognition of Genocide, but it's ABSURD to blame God in that, or blame for earthquakes. God didn't make Turks to kill us, same way God didn't force our ancestors to live in the lands of SOB turk animals. They could leave like Slavon nations leaved to safer places in Europe when animal Megyars invaded present day Hungary. God didn't force STUPID PEOPLE built fucked up building in earthquake zone which could fall any time.
forcuties 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Our world is hostage to the insatiable rampaging of the ruling class private gain and greed, dominating,dehumanising,devaluing everyone and everything in the midst. We can and must change the wage slavery of immense humanity in a market system of artificial scarcity . We can share the world for our common needs and well being in harmony within and without.
arzoyan 1 year ago
khentanalik!
guitaram4 1 year ago
HIANALI BARER
avo55555 1 year ago
Bravooo, call me New Jersey NY 551-4045282 Nazareth Shahinian
ArmeniKing1 1 year ago
no commments....
sevak601 1 year ago
wax shat sirechi ira ergere shat sirechi
kindnace 1 year ago
Bravooo, very nice music...God Bless You Arthur..We love you...Mernem ko sirtin axperes...Nazareth Shahinian 298 PAlisade Ave, Cliffside Park, New Jersey, USA. 07010 cell: 551-4045282 work 201-840-7004...zangi.. wwwcashArmenikingcom
ArmeniKing1 1 year ago
Сумашедшая энергетика!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! нет слов!!!!!!гениальное исполнение!!!!
costaav 1 year ago
@costaav А ты кто по нации?
77Gors 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The evolution of recent human history has been dominated by minority control over the majority, the rulers have come up with nessesary illusion for compliance and servitude of the many, Science and technology has created a world of plenty, but the market mechanism is about artificial scarcity to perpetuate poverty and exploitation in a modality of war,enviornmental destructions,animal cruelty and so on . The new paradigm is sharing the Earth for our collective needs and wellbeing.
arzoyan 1 year ago
hraaaaaaaaaaaaaaaashq erg a
hayeritasardutyun 1 year ago
fuck jesus, the fake god that led us to believe humans are more humane than animals, hence the destiny of the Armenian people. Whom almost perished in the name of this sorried excuse of a god. Wake up Armenians! Your destiny is in you own hands, not in the hands of a dead jewish god.
sarkisnick 1 year ago
...Es qez havatum yev akhersum ey inchpes mi ankhelq... AMEN
bloodhoundtg 1 year ago
beter be crossed with this song, than live with rabiz
AMEN
poposjok 1 year ago
I often ask where God was!!!!!!!!!!!!
Arthur, your song brings sanity to me. thank you--anjell
asoophie 1 year ago
a song that touches the heart and soul.
Arthur feels everyword he is saying. He is the best
garmess1 1 year ago
Thanks for sharing ! He's also great philosopher, architecture, composer, song writer & singer. Bravo ARTHUR MESCHYAN
gevorgr 2 years ago 8
Tout est dit !
Fantastique et Beau, Bravo !
mannik429 2 years ago 10
Abres..shad sirun yerkaaa,jaaaan
themrchrist1 2 years ago
"Aha ev Verj" - Arthur Meschian in LA, Nov 09
visit this link...
donidoni99 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
hunan131 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
[2]
Where were you God?
When the eyes of justice got blinded
Where were you God?
When on the lips of my nation the prayer froze to death
Where were you God?
When the skies trembled, asking for help
Silent were you God
When tied to crosses we were praying amen
Aaaaaaamen aamen
hunan131 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
hunan131 2 years ago
Comment removed
hunan131 2 years ago
[3]
In my craving soul
There was no other faith or love, my lord
I was believing in
and pleaing to you like a fool
Where were you God?
When they were dismantling a glorious nation
Where were you God?
When hopeless we were praying amen
Aaaaaaamen aamen
hunan131 2 years ago 7
[4]
Give us strength, lord
So we don't get lost in the deep sea of life
Give us heart, lord
So we can erase the lips of suffering
Give us light, lord
So in this dreary darkness we can spot a road
Give us hope, lord
So with dried lips we find you again, amen
Aaaaaaamen aamen
hunan131 2 years ago 5
axr shaaaaat lavneee, uxaki hiasqanch erg e ev miyevnuyn jamanak shat txur=(((
ArMeNiAnDeStInY 2 years ago 10
Thanks a lot dear Arthur for this song/ complaint....I think will be a good idea for Mr.S. Sarksyan( Pres) to listen to this song twice a day!! and let's see if he has any Armenian blood left in him?
tadaha11 2 years ago 7
Erg@ grvel e 1970-akaneri skzbnerin.
Beazt187 2 years ago 3
Ays erge Artur Meschyane shat lav e katrarum, isk erg@ grel e Gyumreci mi invalid eritasard kompozitor vor@ etpes el anhayt mnac ev minch aysor voch mek chgiti te vortex e ev kam ardioq voxj e na. Nra anune Aleqsandr e. Artur Meschyani ergarvest@ bacardzakapes tarber ev xorimast e shat. Na naev hoyakap chartarapet e. ir himnakan masnagitutyun e.
Beazt187 2 years ago 2
@Beazt187 Amen inch lseci verjers baic senc vercia der chei lsel - ergi hexinaki masin em xosum...
Sa Meschiani ergn e, grvac 17 tarekanum - verjaket.
nkaramya 11 months ago 2
I was wondering if anybody had this song in the original, by ARAKYALNER. I like the original version better.
Anahita19940405 2 years ago
very sad and emotional song... makes me cry everytime i listen to it :(
HamestAxchik 2 years ago 5
Comment removed
MrRon33 2 years ago
Comment removed
MrRon33 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sick song !!!
cts27 2 years ago
Вы гений .Я обожаю Вас.Вы наша гордость................
ooookkkrr 2 years ago 12
Arthur Meschian is the best! man! this is the best lol!!! can't stop listening to it!
diamond9i 2 years ago 13
BRAVO !!!!!!!!!!
tigran93 2 years ago 7
not everyone can criticize the almighty God in a song so well!!!
samveljan7 2 years ago 39
THE BEST SONG EVER !!!!!!
shat shat lav jekra
iskaganHAY 2 years ago 15
Oh god ,
I just love it <3
Long live Armenia..!!
x0BurnInHell0x 2 years ago 15
Beautiful song, thank you for uploading.
Long Live Armenia!
Fedayi01 2 years ago 12
Some people confuse Arthur's lyrics for RAP this is not RAP this is something way DEEP, this is something spiritual... I personally this his music is spiritual & every word makes scenes... Some people get his lyrics in the wrong way, but that's too bad for them, because they don't understand where his coming from and what his message is...
God Bless ARMENIA!!!
DJMiranG 2 years ago 17
It's pure poetry. RAP = retarded attempt at poetry. He is the Bob Dylan of Armenia, only with lyrics 20 times more deep.
sarkisnick 2 years ago 9
dont blame GOD thank him that u r still alive that we armenians still exist GOD cant be blamed for everything its just ssin wen adam and eve sinned the world was coursed alot of bad stuff will still happen jews are gods ppl how come 5 mill died its not gods fault dont blame him thank him that ur still alive
MPw3r 2 years ago 6
kunem obama kunem kes you filty lair pig you breake your promise we all know the true he reapet the genocid eword 1000 times and say it is a fact and know he lie how much did turky gave you or only hope is god barbaros turkey this is way there are some peapol become terror fight for the right!!!
AllochGs 2 years ago 13
This has been flagged as spam show
oh... 'tHIS IS WHY SOME PEOPLE BECOME TERRORISTS'...IS THAT WHAT YOU R TRYING TO SAY?? So if people do not believe your allegations, or deny them or dispute them or debate them, then they should become terrorists according to u! No, Obama is not a kunem. He is sensible and smart and knows the truth. Right now, he is playing both sides of the fence. Vewry clever man.
tmoda61 2 years ago
great!!!
HaykOrion 2 years ago 9
ARTAROUTYOUN
apo443 2 years ago 13
God was probably watching in horror......He could not believe that some of His "creatures" would carry out the most atrocious and sacrilegious barbarity against the noble nation of Armenians who were the first to accepted His son as their saviour.........Maybe God has not yet recovered when he witnessed that unspeakable savagery....
Gregory10000000000 2 years ago 47
@Gregory10000000000
His question was rhetorical, and as such needed no answer.
And do not involve Jesus, especially as a "son of god"... His song is addressed to a single deity some tend to believe in, not necessarily the Christian god.
TheNuclearpolitics 1 year ago
@Gregory10000000000 thank u for ur words.
HasmikM 2 months ago
A masterpiece of poetry/prayer calling on God for explanation.
Thanks to the person who posted this video.
Meschyan's performance is simply the best.
Urartu1 2 years ago 15