I doubt Searle can say anymore about pain and color than someone describing the phenomenon from a third person perspective. Searle doesn't know anything about pain and color, he just detects it.
LennyBound, excellent video. I thoroughly enjoy your posts. Can you tell me what show this clip is from, please? I'm sure I recognize the interviewer, but I just can't place him. Thanks, and keep up the good work!
If Mary would know every physical fact there is about the brain, then she could probably also construct a technical instrument, a sort of brain enhancer, which would enable her to experience color. Thereby objective observation would be enough to learn also this "subjective" fact, because she could simply use this instrument, just like astronomers use telescopes to learn new facts about the stars.
The brain is an organism, the mind is intangible and unlimted accept by the measures to intelligence, conscience is factual Con~science, science is explanation, which relates to consciousness be an interpretation of factual information, the more we dream of knowing rather than actual knowing limits the awareness process, processing reality is through logic knowing what we know builds the foundation of knowledge, awareness is our intelligence.
Colour Vision - if defined as "wavelength discrimination" would be a beneficial survival trait - for identifying food. I'd also argue that the brain has evolved to represent the different wavelengths as colours.
David Chalmers looked SO young...Dennett didn't...The good news is though that he hasn't changed in the 13 years since this was made. His ideas don't change either, so his comments didn't seem dated...It was interesting to see the Mary's room paradox covered yet AGAIN!
I doubt Searle can say anymore about pain and color than someone describing the phenomenon from a third person perspective. Searle doesn't know anything about pain and color, he just detects it.
SciTechExplained 2 months ago
Dennet looks practically unaged... lol!
Ermal8711 5 months ago
Chalmers yay!! Dennet boo!!!
kornbelt 11 months ago
Daniel Dennet is a p-zombie! watch?v=ags_M3ILszo
JohananRaatz 1 year ago
LennyBound, excellent video. I thoroughly enjoy your posts. Can you tell me what show this clip is from, please? I'm sure I recognize the interviewer, but I just can't place him. Thanks, and keep up the good work!
denawerner7 1 year ago
@denawerner7 To be honest, I actually can't remember where I found it, and I no longer have the original file. :-/
In any case, glad to hear you liked the video, and sorry I couldn't be of more assistance. :-)
LennyBound 1 year ago
If Mary would know every physical fact there is about the brain, then she could probably also construct a technical instrument, a sort of brain enhancer, which would enable her to experience color. Thereby objective observation would be enough to learn also this "subjective" fact, because she could simply use this instrument, just like astronomers use telescopes to learn new facts about the stars.
exfalsoquodlibet 2 years ago
The brain is an organism, the mind is intangible and unlimted accept by the measures to intelligence, conscience is factual Con~science, science is explanation, which relates to consciousness be an interpretation of factual information, the more we dream of knowing rather than actual knowing limits the awareness process, processing reality is through logic knowing what we know builds the foundation of knowledge, awareness is our intelligence.
NeoOneOrg 1 year ago
I wish i could go to these kinda things.. but i dont have a degree
Nades129 2 years ago
What RoboMary knows blows away the Mary argument
robotaholic 2 years ago 2
Nice Vid, Thanks Lenny
Rybot9000 2 years ago
Colour Vision - if defined as "wavelength discrimination" would be a beneficial survival trait - for identifying food. I'd also argue that the brain has evolved to represent the different wavelengths as colours.
ReeT0ric 2 years ago
David Chalmers looked SO young...Dennett didn't...The good news is though that he hasn't changed in the 13 years since this was made. His ideas don't change either, so his comments didn't seem dated...It was interesting to see the Mary's room paradox covered yet AGAIN!
2bsirius 2 years ago
Dennett is the unmoved mover; he is eternal and unchanging. :-)
My favorite part is at 2:12 where the toast is made to "problems easy and hard, wherever they may be."
LennyBound 2 years ago
lol dennett still looks like darwin
sekkingu 2 years ago
Darwin? I don't really see it. I think he looks like:
A. The bust of Socrates
B. A certain 1915 self-portrait by Matisse (the one where he's seated at his easel wearing an olive colored suit)
C. Fredrick Church Ohmstead
polymath7 2 years ago
@LennyBound Dennett says he looked like Rasputin in the 60s.
S2Cents 3 months ago
Short and excellent. Thanks!
somor98 2 years ago
Thanks for your clips. Hope you keep them coming.
safeteyvalve 2 years ago