National Anthem-Kelly Clarkson and Carly Smithson (separate)

[Sideshowspike]

Carly wins this one. Kelly tweaks it too much. Also carly is showing her flexibility as this is way different from we are the fallen

[brian4856]

they cannot be compared she sings good but does not compare to kelly.

[NYCITALIAN82]

I like Carly's voice better

[cbotten106]

Yelly isn't close on this one, I'd take Carly every time.

[TuckerLovesHimself]

Kelly only please

[musiclover872008]

KELLY CLARKSON OWNS,shes a international superstar carly isnt anything

[ksluvscs]

I LOVE these two ladies! They are both amazingly talented. I love Kelly's voice but I also love Carly's. I am undecided on this one. I will call myself a bigger Carly fan though.

[joepatrick55]

Wow i loved both. im gonna go with kelly, just because theres that certain rawness to her voice that nobody can beat. but i loved carlys as well. carly did just as good, i just perfer kellys voice i suppose

[welshjoe21]

Oh, and its this is a versus video, then Clarkson, everytime! :D

[welshjoe21]

Christ, Smithson is Irish. Shocked. Just shocked. Heh!

Then again, I suppose if she is allowed to take part in Idol then she should sing the anthem. But meh, sing it if you're from there, that's my motto...