it isnt good for horses to be worked and then allowed a drink of water. they like mentioned before can get colic or a twisted gut same thing and die. i have had a horse colic before and he almost didnt live. it is painful and they more often than not die from it. i raise horses and have used a team a time or two, no abuse happened here. boohoo if the horse is thirsty it has worked all day and after it cools down then can it have water.
It is dangerous to let a hot horse drink cold water like that. That horse needs to be walked and cooled off before its allowed cold water, otherwise it could colic and die. NO horse should be forced to pull a carriage through the streets of new york. When is this stupidity going to end.
Dude, they don't even look like they are sweating or anything. These horses just walk around, they are not that hot. How do you know the temp of the water also? These horses are fat and happy. I think the only stupidity here is you.
@blazinghot18 It requires an extremely HOT horse (like just ran the Belmont Stakes) being given cold water for it to be a problem. FWIW, the water comes from a lake in Central Park and is ambient temperature, not ice cold.
All I see is a horse having a drink... do you think that because the horse drank this means it was being mis treated? ... No problem here, horses in great condition...
from the video these horses look very well cared for. They were of good weight and had gleaming coats (a sign of a good diet and good grooming)
These are draft horses or draft crosses and were originally bred to work a hell of a lot harder than they are working in NYC pulling carriages. These PETA people and people who shout abuse need to get a litetle more orse knowledge than they currently have!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
some video footage of a horse drinking water and suddenly that is instant proof that he/she is "well taken care of"?
possibly some further footage would be proof to me. i like how someone wrote "let's keep the horses in the city!"
......really? seriously? let's keep these magnificent animals enslaved in the dirty, rough streets of manhattan? all i can ask is WHY. profit, i assume. that awful word that spurs all greed...
interesting demographic of animal lovers. you seem to enjoy the image of me in a nazi suit or drinking "krazy koolaid" with my freak friends.
if it will make you calm down a little, i am really just a normal person. i love and care a lot about those i share this planet with (including you) and raise my voice for those i believe could use a little more awareness.
i have no criticism of you personally, and i'd prefer not to be personally criticized.
Good to see proof that the animals have water available and are allowed to have water during their work day. That is a beautiful, well-cared for animal.
Cool, these carriage horses are beautiful and obviously well cared for. Thanks for showing that they get to stop and satisfy their thirst. It shows how their needs are met. Pretty cool.
any horse will drink after a long days walk .. my horse does the same after a 4 hr hike through the mountains. it's normal.. shit wild horses trail countless miles everyday.. a stroll around the park a few hours aday isn't going to kill them.
In the wild it has been reported that horses walk anywhere from 15-25 miles a day.
There is no little paddock on a farm where horses naturally come close to approximating that.
Carriage horses, however, get a lot of easy exercize (pulling the carriage is not hard for them), strolling through the Park.
Perhaps that's why (at least where I work in Philly) our horses live to ripe old ages (usually near 30) and remain healthy and fit well into their senior years.
Abigail, I am not Felix and I don't take heroin. Would a heroin user even post comments on youtube? A heroin user is too busy trying to score. I am a carriage driver like you and I am tired of these animal activists who complain. Our horses don't complain working over 9 hours with no food or water. These horses don't mind standing for hours with exhaust blowing in the mouths. Only these stupid people. I wish I could whip them like I whip my horse.
well its all true but there are some i mean they do take care of them but somtimes its not good enoufgh to the public i guess its pretty hard to take care of so many big animals and the stalls are pretty high up keep i guess ita the publics fault not understanding i mean i sortof dont but then i do i guess its the fact that somtimes it hard to build stables and keep so many horses well cared for speacily if u dont have the staff but the horses are happy not complaning =] ive seen much worse
Actually, we have 5 stables...all have box stalls. 2 of the newest are state of the art with sutomatic waterers, ventilation systems, drainage, etc. All the stables have at least 2 stable men on duty at all times. When you look at the truth there is nothing wrong with the way our horses are cared ofr. The animal rights people lie about us a lot. peeba76 has many videos showing their outright lies. I think peeba is going to do a video on the stables, too.
im not responding to that ur not caring just that its hard to do it perfectly like u would to a show horse
and alot of peaple think that keeping them in the city isnt a life a horse should have horses now get way mroe care being wormed shoed propley groomed propley then they ever did
alot of peaple thnk wer i ride is a bbit yukky well it gets cleaned and sorted the food is protective just theres so many but there healthy and happy its just not sparkly clean1
well they live in a large field not really stables beacuse i cost to much for them to live in stables
im not talking about owners like u who have payed for a farm and gives ur horses breaks i mean some of the bigger company i dont always belive wat i read i belive wat i c and i give u thumbs up its great u invested in a farm and give ur horses a holiday =]
walking on pavement, pulling a carriage, socialized, or knowing what they are doing most of the time. Abuse is withholding food, gross neglegence, beating, and we all have to breath the same air. These folks are
sharing their god-given talents of horses.
I think it is wonderful that people use their
talents in their livlihood. I'm glad they prosper at it. That is how it is suppose to work. from where do you get your income?
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
There are not horrible owner. How can you make such a statement? How do you know what happens to these animals.
Ok, One example. There was a special with the aspca police that horse carriage riders were falsifying tickets showing how long a horse had been out pulling a carriage.
I am not gaining anything being against horse carriages. I don't need to lie. I don't read propaganda. I just need to walk down the streets of NYC, especially at night time. on the other hand, the riders do.
When there were no cars, there were no CAR fumes for the horse to breath in, no CAR accidents killing horses, no CAR's honking on horns to scare them.
it is such a poor opinion to say the city in the old days was more polluted and dirty.??
How I feel is necessary, I'm sorry you don't see it that way, and as far as being extreme.. Well then, yes, I am EXTREMELY against animals being abused.
My ignorance, How ignorant is it to say, you don't like seeing horses being worked in such unnatural conditions..but they should be criticized!!!!!???
I don't care if they massage there ass every night before going home. They are putting the horse in harms way of a car accident. Hot whether, and horrific car emissions. Not to mention the fun of pulling stuff all day or standing still, or better yet the Horn HONKING.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Needing to make a living is no excuse for exploting an animal. I saw 2 horses last week and it was horrific. I was so angry how they looked and were treated. It shold be banned.
Anyone ever near pro horse carriages, would DRASTICLY change if they saw what they looked like after a car accident or how much smg goes in there face. Ever breath down the back of a car muffler. It's not right.
sporeismylife You are the one who doesn't care. You probably have no choice in dumping bitches...they probably run screaning at the thought of a second date with you.
sporeismylife You can make a kid go to school but you cannot make him learn. Your lack of education is showing. Learn from this that a sentence starts with a capital and ends with a period.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
who are you to invite anyone to the troughs when you did not even pay for it. THE ASPCA donate to troughs for the horses. You don't buy them any shading to protect them from the summer heat.
it isnt good for horses to be worked and then allowed a drink of water. they like mentioned before can get colic or a twisted gut same thing and die. i have had a horse colic before and he almost didnt live. it is painful and they more often than not die from it. i raise horses and have used a team a time or two, no abuse happened here. boohoo if the horse is thirsty it has worked all day and after it cools down then can it have water.
jayrichards23ok 5 months ago
It is dangerous to let a hot horse drink cold water like that. That horse needs to be walked and cooled off before its allowed cold water, otherwise it could colic and die. NO horse should be forced to pull a carriage through the streets of new york. When is this stupidity going to end.
blazinghot18 1 year ago
@blazinghot18
Dude, they don't even look like they are sweating or anything. These horses just walk around, they are not that hot. How do you know the temp of the water also? These horses are fat and happy. I think the only stupidity here is you.
BLiSSFULxFiLLY 1 year ago
@blazinghot18 It requires an extremely HOT horse (like just ran the Belmont Stakes) being given cold water for it to be a problem. FWIW, the water comes from a lake in Central Park and is ambient temperature, not ice cold.
thedrafthorse 5 months ago
I don't like to see a horse ever get THAT thirsty, and I've handled horses for 40 years. they are not allowed to dawdle either -this is a concern.
theodorodepangrazia 2 years ago
Hmn, proof that the horses are healthy, well fleshed, working at an easy pace and are getting watered. Thanks for clarifying those facts. ;-)
mtardiff 2 years ago
The HUMANIACS must keep accusing people of abuse, or the donations STOP.
animalwrongs 2 years ago 2
The only thing i see here are a few harnesses that dont fit quite right, but that is certainly NOT abuse!
pinkfeathers2006 2 years ago
All I see is a horse having a drink... do you think that because the horse drank this means it was being mis treated? ... No problem here, horses in great condition...
laranic1 2 years ago
from the video these horses look very well cared for. They were of good weight and had gleaming coats (a sign of a good diet and good grooming)
These are draft horses or draft crosses and were originally bred to work a hell of a lot harder than they are working in NYC pulling carriages. These PETA people and people who shout abuse need to get a litetle more orse knowledge than they currently have!
520emerald 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
some video footage of a horse drinking water and suddenly that is instant proof that he/she is "well taken care of"?
possibly some further footage would be proof to me. i like how someone wrote "let's keep the horses in the city!"
......really? seriously? let's keep these magnificent animals enslaved in the dirty, rough streets of manhattan? all i can ask is WHY. profit, i assume. that awful word that spurs all greed...
LARAMONExALFNOWx 2 years ago
You want instant proof, go to my channel and watch my vids, on stables, the farm for rotation breaks, training etc, etc.
It will set you straight, you'll enjoy them.
Thanks
StopLiesSeeTruth 2 years ago 2
unless every single horse in NYC belongs to you, that is not instant proof. it's proof that only one person takes care of their horses.
LARAMONExALFNOWx 2 years ago
oh brother.
StopLiesSeeTruth 2 years ago
Listen, where is YOUR PROOF of abuse !!!
You are a biased PETArd.
No one expects you to stop drinking the kool aid. YOU ARE BIASED.
You scream abuse, I show carriage horses, mine and others to be healthy and happy, with all the things YOU SAY they don't have.
Still you worm your argument right passed the facts.
You are a lying FACSIST, who wants to make good look EVIL.
In a way you deserve pity, but not from me, I have read you arguments, they are based on hate and lies.
Sick ,twisted
StopLiesSeeTruth 2 years ago
interesting demographic of animal lovers. you seem to enjoy the image of me in a nazi suit or drinking "krazy koolaid" with my freak friends.
if it will make you calm down a little, i am really just a normal person. i love and care a lot about those i share this planet with (including you) and raise my voice for those i believe could use a little more awareness.
i have no criticism of you personally, and i'd prefer not to be personally criticized.
thanks!
LARAMONExALFNOWx 2 years ago
Good to see proof that the animals have water available and are allowed to have water during their work day. That is a beautiful, well-cared for animal.
userunavailable3095 3 years ago 6
For more proof on how well the Horses of NYC are cared for , please view some of my vids.
Thank you.
StopLiesSeeTruth 2 years ago
Cool, these carriage horses are beautiful and obviously well cared for. Thanks for showing that they get to stop and satisfy their thirst. It shows how their needs are met. Pretty cool.
Let's keep these beautiful horses in the city.
2bejou 3 years ago 6
any horse will drink after a long days walk .. my horse does the same after a 4 hr hike through the mountains. it's normal.. shit wild horses trail countless miles everyday.. a stroll around the park a few hours aday isn't going to kill them.
SassyMustang1980 3 years ago 13
Yes!
In the wild it has been reported that horses walk anywhere from 15-25 miles a day.
There is no little paddock on a farm where horses naturally come close to approximating that.
Carriage horses, however, get a lot of easy exercize (pulling the carriage is not hard for them), strolling through the Park.
Perhaps that's why (at least where I work in Philly) our horses live to ripe old ages (usually near 30) and remain healthy and fit well into their senior years.
thedrafthorse 3 years ago 7
This has been flagged as spam show
see my videos on the cruelty of NYC carriage horses
horsesinnyc 3 years ago
This guy is INSANE!
nyccarriagehorses 3 years ago 3
Those are some beautiful horses. I could tell that they're well taken care of. =)
ereyes312 3 years ago 15
I have been taking videos of the horses in Central Park for more than a year now and I noticed that all the horses are very healthy and
well taken care of.Never saw any cruelty to horses too.Thanks for subscribing.Have a nice day!
lagalagny 3 years ago
@lagalagny thats all your capable of doing SPREADING LIES!
vivienleigh1097 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
oh bullshit
RadioReporter01 3 years ago
@ereyes312 They actually are not. Please watch the movie "Blinders"
dogshenry 1 year ago
@dogshenry Watch Blinders if you want propaganda. Also, what you see is the truth - well cared for horses in good health, moseying through the park.
thedrafthorse 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Abigail, I am not Felix and I don't take heroin. Would a heroin user even post comments on youtube? A heroin user is too busy trying to score. I am a carriage driver like you and I am tired of these animal activists who complain. Our horses don't complain working over 9 hours with no food or water. These horses don't mind standing for hours with exhaust blowing in the mouths. Only these stupid people. I wish I could whip them like I whip my horse.
notmybutt 3 years ago
well its all true but there are some i mean they do take care of them but somtimes its not good enoufgh to the public i guess its pretty hard to take care of so many big animals and the stalls are pretty high up keep i guess ita the publics fault not understanding i mean i sortof dont but then i do i guess its the fact that somtimes it hard to build stables and keep so many horses well cared for speacily if u dont have the staff but the horses are happy not complaning =] ive seen much worse
TamTamHorsey 3 years ago
Actually, we have 5 stables...all have box stalls. 2 of the newest are state of the art with sutomatic waterers, ventilation systems, drainage, etc. All the stables have at least 2 stable men on duty at all times. When you look at the truth there is nothing wrong with the way our horses are cared ofr. The animal rights people lie about us a lot. peeba76 has many videos showing their outright lies. I think peeba is going to do a video on the stables, too.
nyccarriagehorses 3 years ago 3
im not responding to that ur not caring just that its hard to do it perfectly like u would to a show horse
and alot of peaple think that keeping them in the city isnt a life a horse should have horses now get way mroe care being wormed shoed propley groomed propley then they ever did
alot of peaple thnk wer i ride is a bbit yukky well it gets cleaned and sorted the food is protective just theres so many but there healthy and happy its just not sparkly clean1
TamTamHorsey 3 years ago
peeba76 has been suspended, probably one step ahead of the law. Possibly wanted for assault and terroristic threats.
You stable has bars like HORSE JAIL?
RadioReporter01 3 years ago
Every stable has bars, moron. Go read a book about horses or do some actual research. UGH.
nyccarriagehorses 3 years ago 4
but im not replying to all the companys just the ones who thinck about money wich is only a few
TamTamHorsey 3 years ago 2
well they live in a large field not really stables beacuse i cost to much for them to live in stables
im not talking about owners like u who have payed for a farm and gives ur horses breaks i mean some of the bigger company i dont always belive wat i read i belive wat i c and i give u thumbs up its great u invested in a farm and give ur horses a holiday =]
TamTamHorsey 3 years ago 2
its defently not the drivers who lay the abuse its the way they live
the drivers are porbley the only peaple who care about them the owners dont do they job and mange the horses probleuy
TamTamHorsey 3 years ago
Thanks Pika. It serves me well. Helps to consentrate on things that are really serious.
rwoold2247 3 years ago
trixiebella, Horses are not abused bc they are
walking on pavement, pulling a carriage, socialized, or knowing what they are doing most of the time. Abuse is withholding food, gross neglegence, beating, and we all have to breath the same air. These folks are
sharing their god-given talents of horses.
I think it is wonderful that people use their
talents in their livlihood. I'm glad they prosper at it. That is how it is suppose to work. from where do you get your income?
rwoold2247 3 years ago 2
rwold - I really like your perspective on things.
pikapika9090 3 years ago
I've alway enjoyed watching a horse get his
thirst quenched. Something would be wrong if
he didn't do that.
rwoold2247 3 years ago 5
Horse lovers are welcome.Thanks for watching.
lagalagny 3 years ago
I guess these horses are thirsty no more!
penumbrat 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
again, peeba76, stop making this an attack about you personally.
There is a show with the ASPCA showing the abuse. Does that mean to your standards that the ASPCA are terrorists?
Honestly, I'm curious how the FACT of how you would react to the horses you love so much watching them lie in a pool of blood from being hit by a car.
Like I said before, I do not need to look up things you would call "propaganda". I use my eyes.
You still havent answered my previous question about abuse.
trixiebella1111 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
There are not horrible owner. How can you make such a statement? How do you know what happens to these animals.
Ok, One example. There was a special with the aspca police that horse carriage riders were falsifying tickets showing how long a horse had been out pulling a carriage.
I am not gaining anything being against horse carriages. I don't need to lie. I don't read propaganda. I just need to walk down the streets of NYC, especially at night time. on the other hand, the riders do.
trixiebella1111 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's funny to me how you keep making this issue of the horses so personal to yourself.
IF you claim to love horses, it's pretty sad you are not the first one wanting them away from horrible owners and conditions.
trixiebella1111 3 years ago
When there were no cars, there were no CAR fumes for the horse to breath in, no CAR accidents killing horses, no CAR's honking on horns to scare them.
it is such a poor opinion to say the city in the old days was more polluted and dirty.??
How I feel is necessary, I'm sorry you don't see it that way, and as far as being extreme.. Well then, yes, I am EXTREMELY against animals being abused.
trixiebella1111 3 years ago
My ignorance, How ignorant is it to say, you don't like seeing horses being worked in such unnatural conditions..but they should be criticized!!!!!???
I don't care if they massage there ass every night before going home. They are putting the horse in harms way of a car accident. Hot whether, and horrific car emissions. Not to mention the fun of pulling stuff all day or standing still, or better yet the Horn HONKING.
Now how ignorant do you sound.
trixiebella1111 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Needing to make a living is no excuse for exploting an animal. I saw 2 horses last week and it was horrific. I was so angry how they looked and were treated. It shold be banned.
Anyone ever near pro horse carriages, would DRASTICLY change if they saw what they looked like after a car accident or how much smg goes in there face. Ever breath down the back of a car muffler. It's not right.
trixiebella1111 3 years ago
This farm of yours. Prove it.
bigkahunaguy 3 years ago
sporeismylife You are the one who doesn't care. You probably have no choice in dumping bitches...they probably run screaning at the thought of a second date with you.
thekenniewitch 3 years ago
sporeismylife You can make a kid go to school but you cannot make him learn. Your lack of education is showing. Learn from this that a sentence starts with a capital and ends with a period.
thekenniewitch 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
who are you to invite anyone to the troughs when you did not even pay for it. THE ASPCA donate to troughs for the horses. You don't buy them any shading to protect them from the summer heat.
horsesinnyc 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
see my videos on nyc horse drawn carriages
horsesinnyc 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
yes one horse out of hundred is given water. Usually that trough is filled with starbucks garbage
moremenrodepeebathan 3 years ago
What a fun thing to do!
banknownothings 3 years ago 8
This video is great. Im sick of hearing lies about how they dont have any water or we dont let them drink. The proof is in the pudding here!
nyccarriagehorses 3 years ago 6