Added: 4 years ago
From: GX6763
Views: 287,758
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (215)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 我看的只有粉丝盲目的维护

    好让自己的偶像免受任何负面评语

    无论是对或错,一律隔绝~强!

  • 超感動>_<

  • 聽歌就聽歌廢話一堆 日本統治台灣那麼久你怎不把A片給燒了!

  • why are they yelling??? fking annoying

  • 周杰倫.

    永遠都有一堆支持你的偶像.

    不管以前或是以後.

    我們都支持你.

  • this is terrible to listen...

  • 他的廣東話蠻正的!

  • 不要吵,专心听音乐,不要鬼扯政治

  • 說真的 我很討厭那些字以為講廣東話很了不起的人

    吵歸吵 你會廣東話又怎樣??台灣人也會台語

    少在這自以為是

  • 195人都喜歡 , 證明聽音樂的都是講感覺 !!

    而且他唱出來的 感情 有些人肯定是聽不出 !!

    聽音樂 聽不出感情 , 那是高級 還是 新手

    就自己 答吧 !!

  • He should stick to his own songs. A little moderation on the keys and it's another version? I think not. His voice is mediocre so he should sing his own songs which have some credit since he composes them.

  • 喜歡聽他唱別人的歌

    因為感覺完全不同

  • 確實平均來說國外質感好的音樂較多

    但Jay是台灣的TOP了,他的價值在於音樂富多元內涵(在華人­圈)

    因此才得以席捲華人世界甚至引起國外注意

    台灣的音樂界發展本來歷史就沒國外那麼悠久

    所以無論如何Jay 帶動的革命才意義重大阿

    其實我最欣賞的是Jay 早期專輯異國元素很多

    雖然現在比較少看到了~~

  • 其實 為什麼每次聽他唱一些前輩的歌都要拿來比較? 他也是聽張學友跟郭富城的歌"長大"的阿 他也有說過他的願望是跟張學友在台上一起唱"你最珍貴" 還是說 現在我們聽杰倫的歌去ktv也不能唱他的歌嗎...??  之前我還看過他跟陶子唱王菲的我願意 沒什麼奇怪吧 就是一種對老歌跟那個時代的懷念 有什麼好批評的呢 ?

  • 音樂無國界.妳們不要吵.中國唱忐忑我們有說什麼嗎??

    我們台彎有尊重妳們ㄟ

  • 這些批評很可怕...批評的很難聽的人 你知道她一年賺多少錢? 連你們中國也很多人喜歡他 你們這樣罵自己的"同胞"不好吧 說台灣人的音樂爛 妳全部都聽過了嗎?? 不然怎麼用台灣人? 還有我第一次聽到音樂還分高級跟低級 聽到這句話就知道你在吹噓自己 你說的那些我也會聽啊 那又怎麼樣?? 又不是只有你會聽 包括你批評的這個人一定也不會聽的比你少 聽是一回事...做不做的出來又是一回事啊老兄
  • i didnt hear it at first but he's singing in cantonese too. thats kinda cool

  • so cuteeeeeeee!!!!

  • 很有味道,特别是哭腔还有高音部分,好听~

  • 他在唱廣東話嗎?很可愛XD

  • he should learn tis song from jacky cheung~~~ spoiling people song

  • 5 years old boy singing on stage, cute

  • I do not know how Jaky cheung sings this song, but Jay Chou has his own style of vocals..his rendition is his own style..i guess he sung it nice..i may not like it if he copied the version of the original singer..thats why each one of us is unique, we express ourself by our own style..Go JAY..

  • 认真的杰伦最美丽

  • 我愛倫

  • Hahaha !! Are you Taiwanese? I think you don't !! Cuz we're so proud of him!! If you don't like him don't listen his songs that it makes you happier!! you're so pessimistic person !!! Giving a chance for other one it's a good thing that you must do!! don't selfish and live in your world lonely !!! welcome to world wide !!! don't moody be happy!!

  • @omijay1813 ok.... very nice of you.....

  • he was crying......

  • 看到周杰伦就想到我激情青涩的高中时光,好怀念啊,不经意间自己­就长大了,最近一直在听周杰伦的老歌,最爱的还是范特西和八度空­间

  • 這裡有隻狗要吠人,我覺得人是不需要跟牠鬥吠的。

  • that period Jay 's still young his singing and experience it's not much like Jacky !!! but Jay sings it with his style I think it's very nice why everyone must compare him with others Jay is Jay !!! please understand him!!!! Jay sings all his songs with his heart and soul that make his songs beautiful and fill with emotion!!!!!>.<

  • @omijay1813 yea thats right!! =)

  • 好爛的粵語喔 拜託 回家練一練再唱吧

    

  • jaychou 最吊!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 他是坨屎?! 台灣人都是有智商之人 就是有某些想猴想被砲的人說出會被砲死的言語

    也不再多談 因為台灣人不想中你的詭計 省省吧 想紅不是這樣紅 這樣只會變砲灰 我真的為台灣可憐 太可憐 可憐這些砲灰

    現實證明一切 周董有他的地位存在!!

  • @atamaitai0102 像你這種垃圾也敢上來批評? 這世界上就是多了你這些一天到晚宅在家裡的寄生蟲, 現在社會才會這麼敗壞

    你這垃圾就拜託照照鏡子, 別再丟香港人的臉了

  • @zhow5092 這十年來他的成功見證著你這說話的失敗!!!

  • jay sing as good as jacky cheung

  • 周唱這歌也很合適,當然唱法沒有張學友的那樣正路,但周較窩心。­

  • @emptinessform

    1 second ago Hahaha !! Are you Taiwanese? I think you don't !! Cuz we're so proud of him!! If you don't like him don't listen his songs that it makes you happier!! you're so pessimistic person !!! Giving a chance for other one it's a good thing that you must do!! don't selfish and live in your world lonely !!! welcome to world wide !!! don't moody be happy!!

    omijay1813 1 second ago

  • @bluegodya

    你不能說杰倫唱的不好聽 這是你個人的感覺

    不代表真的不好聽

    你只能說

    我不喜歡聽

    我覺得他唱的不好聽

    而不是

    這歌他唱的真的很不好聽阿!

    你覺得不代表大家的感覺

  • 支持,,,,so cool

  • sad, he just cannot make it... Jacky cheung is still the best.

  • 為什麼羅志祥也是唱不準廣東歌  可是他是可愛?

  • 這是他很多年前來香港開演唱會時特地練的廣東歌, 誠意可加啦!

  • =P i think aaron yan sings the best version,no offence

  • that was so freakin bad!!!

  • 周杰倫不適合唱這首歌

  • trash

  • 雖然聽不太懂,但是至少感覺還蠻好聽,其他批評的人,自己唱唱看­不會嗎?不要只會給予負面批評,讚美與批評,讚美大聲說出來就好­,批評的話至少思考過,委婉表達,先想看看人家是不是比自己厲害­吧!至少比我厲害的人,我會羨慕會佩服,卻不會惡意攻擊人。

  • @chinghao7866 一定要長得很帥才能說別長得不好看0.0?

    批評一定要委婉0.0?

    批評就是惡意攻擊0.0?

    我自己也是jay的歌迷,但這首唱得不好聽就是不好聽阿

  • @tam1234hk

    我的意思是給予一些有建設性的意見,

    且每個人的感受不一樣,觀點也不一樣,

    這個說再多也沒意義,你覺得你能夠唱得比jay更好?

    就算我有比別人好的長處,我也不會去批評人,頂多給予建設性的意­見。

    我自己知道沒人家厲害,所以沒有批評也沒有給予建議。

    而且你曲解我的話,我只是說這樣我覺得會好一點,沒有強迫人一定­要這樣做。

  • @chinghao7866

    最討厭每次在說實話批評時

    聽到別人說 阿你是唱的比xx好聽嗎?

    批評選手打球打的爛

    聽到人說 阿你是有打的比他好?

    唱歌不好聽就不能批評〝出檯面〞的人嗎?

    這歌他唱的真的很不好聽阿!

    出檯面的人本來就該比別人優秀阿!

  • @bluegodya

    那裡唱得不好聽 ??

    你聽不出那些感情來嗎 ??

  • @tam1234hk

    那你一定是剛聽他的音樂

    你感受到他的感情 一定不會有這番說話 !!

  • 不知道唱啥...可是尖叫一大堆

    = =...卡啦ok也有這版本

    上次一堆人還叫着唱這版本

    說張學友不好聽

    這什麼世界

  • i think aaron yan sings it better

  • @Shufangn er no

  • That's his style anyway... u can't criticise him because of his voice...

  • 唱得讓人聽不懂

    這就是周杰倫唱歌的風格阿=ˇ=

    雖然聽不太懂

    但還是覺得很好聽

  • 真不知道在唱什麼?

  • i love this version :-D C'mon, it's Jay Chou!!!! singing from his heart ^^

  • i am a jay fan but he doesn't sing this as good as jacky cheung

  • @boeingmaniac

    i think so.

  • this singing ...is probably one of the worst singer live performance i heard in my life..no offense to him..

  • no offense at all^^

    say wt u like,bitch

  • @atamaitai0102 你上去那個舞台 我看你一句話都講不出來

  • @wangwade123 舞台喔

    我可以講一口標準的mandarin 還有比這個閩南小孩還標準的cantonese

    至於你 可能比我還弱 什麼都不會吧

    真的很爛 明明就不會粵語 還硬要唱 他以為只有他知道 他自己不會說粵語嗎

    台灣人也算可憐 沒什麼音樂人 人家我都聽國外高級音樂的

    等級和你可不同呢 ^^

  • @atamaitai0102 樹不要皮,必死無疑。人不要臉,天下無敵

  • @D9860223 所以你字取天下無敵嗎 

  • @atamaitai0102 連字都打錯 你讀過書嗎?粵語講很好才能唱?那你怎不先整容再出門?外國人要­是知道你這種人聽他們的音樂 你確定他們不會感到難過嗎?粵語是你半個母語?真為偉大的粵語感­到委屈

  • @atamaitai0102 又是一個 以為聽外國音樂就比較屌的人

    今天要是台灣是世界第一強國 周董也會被外國人講說

    唉呦!? 我都聽人家外國周董的歌 那像妳們都聽美國的歌

    對啦 外國的月亮都比較圓啦 也不想多說甚麼

    別活在自己的世界比較好  (嘆氣)

  • @zhow5092 台灣不會是世界第一強國 是不是國 還是區 都有點點.....(不要活在自己的幻想) 周杰倫 mandairn 英語 日語 都不好 講話含顆茶葉蛋 你也會喜歡^^

    繼續活在您的異世界吧 我喜歡羅大佑 那種實實在在的音樂人

    而不是周這種 藝人

  • @atamaitai0102 (人家只是唱出自己風格.. 不像某些人整天躲在電腦後面批評人)

    (粵語唱的爛又怎樣 粵語又不是他的母語.. 拜託你唱個台語歌來聽聽 我看你唱多好...)他音樂低級?內地幾億人在聽 難道幾億人都比你低級? 你整天在網上批評人 還有人會比你低級嗎@@?? .. 出去做點公益吧 幫助社會比較有用..

  • @atamaitai0102 後... 不簡單餒 高級音樂餒 非常不簡單喔!!!

    你聽得懂嗎 整天在網路上批評人家的人 跟我說懂音樂 等級真的是夠高級@@

    你閩南語董個(爸謝謝你幹媽生出我 媽謝謝你被爸中出才生出我) 你會把這句翻譯閩南語就很厲害了辣

  • @atamaitai0102

    你懂什麼華人音樂啊 ??

    華人不好好支持 華人音樂

    就是只有你不懂聽而已 !!

    我地香港人聽得明佢d 廣東話歌詞

    聽得不知幾感動 !! 你吹9漲啊 ??

    你看得懂嗎  垃圾 ??

  • @wangwade123 台灣人可憐的地方 就是只能接受台灣的垃圾音樂

    抱歉呢 真正的音樂天才的創作 我聽過太多了 所以聽到這種歌喉

    我真的很難接受 在Inaba的歌喉或是Yoshiki的多才多藝

    這個jay還是gay的 只是坨屎

  • @atamaitai0102 No body cares about how you think or who you are; you pathetic lonely piece of carbon. By the way I'm pretty sure majority of people are happier in Taiwan than the population of where you came from ruled by communists. By the way your so called junk music is largely favored by your neighbor and friends... lol never mind about the friends part. Friendless. Don't abuse freedom of speech on here asshole.

  • @atamaitai0102 What does typing in English have to do with taste in music?

    I type it in English, because it's more convenient for me and obviously you understood. You obviously dislike people using English. You're obviously against the majority of people who enjoyed his music. All the above doesn't mean you have bad taste in music. It just means your very negative in the head.

  • @atamaitai0102 ya, just because you type in Chinese doesn't mean you have good taste in music. That made a lot of sense. By the way that was sarcastic if you ever miss the tone.

  • @atamaitai0102

    我懷疑你是沒有耳朵的吧

    有感情的人都會聽得懂 !!

  • @atamaitai0102 你他媽 你很威?  妳唱看看 貼上來阿 我看大家砲到脫肛

  • @atamaitai0102 全球下載量第3 他是坨屎 那後面的怎麼辦 你這種人真可憐 自以為聽所謂"高級音樂"人就變高級 那種音樂連路邊乞丐都聽得起 又不是你寫的 你又何必那麼得意呢?躲在電腦後面把自己說的多厲害 世界上只有一個周杰倫 像你這種垃圾滿街都是

  • i like jay. i love his songs. he can sing well but i think he is not meant for this kinda songs?

    (my flame shield: IMO btw)

  • 嗚嗚嗚~~~~

  • to jay haters,he sing tis song is at something around yr 2002 or 03,he now improve alot lot,now his current album all song lyrics aso quite clear then last time,even his rap song i aso can understand wat he sing now,he is getting better n better..leehom sing mj man in the mirror aso like shit...

  • @torresjay889, i agree with u!!

  • ,唱現場,仲要彈埋,算唔差....,當然唔好同亞神比la..­.......

  • @zzx1111 , Sing not good then called lapsap? u nvr try something before how come u will get experience to know how better are u? Dun bark at here if u dislike Jay... here almost many ppl are Jay fans!

  • ok, i admit it, i'm so crazy for him. he's great......yes, he is.

  • Jay is legend

  • poor

  • I don't understand why so many people hate Jay. Good singers like Jacky or David nobody hate them. Hmm... maybe he just isn't as good as I thought.

  • to all jay haters, if u think u can sing better than jay, why don't u sing? jay OWNED everyone!!

  • Have to disagree, I'm black and my cantonese owns his...

  • Jay hater go back and find some cock to suck on!!!Jay own everyone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 喜歡唱很標準的人就去聽很標準的阿

    幹麼勉強自己來聽

    我就是喜歡這樣的音色

  • Comment removed

  • 沒感覺...

  • ni cai gun chu qu bu yao wu ru wo de ou xiang stupid dumb

  • how can you say stupid dumb jackal

  • @wangtao1000 你不喜歡聽有必要罵成這樣?

  • 唱得还好啦,不过周杰倫唱这首歌的时候咬词不太清楚哦~

  • 他很努力了~看那些歌迷根本不在乎他唱得標不標準~

  • It is nice that he did his song half in mandarin and half in cantonese. But it distracts from the meaning of the song and makes it hard for people to understand the lyrics. It's a very emotional song to sing. It is a very limiting song because you can only sing it a certain way due to the lyrics and the melody. You can't jazz it up with beats and make a dance version of it. he does it as best as he could while maintaining his own style.

  • yes yes...i know.

    i meant that aaron yan fan1 chang4 this song before and it sounded much better than jay.

  • aaron did this song way better!

  • jacky cheung sang this song......

  • 杰倫現在唱功進步很多!

  • Haha 聽到點廣東話啊

    不過怎麼唱得好像不是太行...

  • this song is good, but he's performance is shit. I barely can understand what he said.

  • It's so funny. He sings the beginning part Cantonese to give tribute to Jacky Cheung but the language is unfamiliar with him and NO ONE here comments on that.

    Come on, this was good entertainment.

  • such an insult to jacky cheung's song!! jay, go back compose music la and take some basic singing lessons!! i don't know what the heck you're always mumbling about.

  • lolz, i cant say jays a bad singer cause hes not.. hes actually a genius to me, its just probably that hes still a newbie in here or something cause the video seeems old.. besides, jay improved alot

  • I can't understand a word that come out from jay's mouth or his sing.....If a singer can not sing the song with clear pronounciation, this person is not qualify as a professional singer in western countries...I really do prefer Jacky Cheung sing this song over Jay Chow because Jay Chow just mumbles...this kind of lost the meaning of a person listening to a professional singer singing....

  • you're right man! this dude sucks big time!!!

  • His voice sucks. I prefer Jacky 50 million times.

  • Probably not but that's not the point.  We're talking about the voice here.

  • anyone can learn to play the piano but singing with emotion is something that not everyone can't do

  • 沒字幕...

  • u guys english suck 9

  • Watever those ppl say Jay bad singer or wad else, i'm ask u all at here...u can be a singer and a write song lycris by ur ownself to be famous? Can or not? Dun simply how say Jay bad insult.

  • well, next time you are not allowed to say a movie sucks, because you can't create a better one. seriously, why most jay fans are so over-reacted when jay got criticized? show this video to any singing teacher and he/she will say this is bad also.

  • totally agree~

    wif his songs, his way of singing actually brings out the best of it~

  • i didn't hear anything....

    this song is raped. cuz of Jay....

    still Jacky sing it much better then him.

    how he singing is like he's going to die...

  • aaron yan sings better

  • who is that? can u send me a link when he is singen this song?

    ty

  • hahas! a goodness 100 times better!^^

  • maybe he is a bad singer..so???... he earn a lot and he is very famous.... u can make song? u can write a nice song?

  • haiz...

    why u guys hate Jay so much? Think before u say somethings. He is talented. Even tough many ppl comment about wat he sang, but, he is famous, right?

  • u dun even know wat hes sainging in the beginning lol

  • 好細聲...

  • any singing teacher in this world will say," jay chou, go fuck yourself if you're singing like this" if they're shown this video.

  • this was a long time ago, he couldnt sing well because he was shy, if u listen to his more recent songs like shou hao de xing fu ne, he sings alot better now

  • yeah, but this kind of performance is quite unprofessional, right? i know this is jay's worst performance and he usually can do better, but this time sounds not professional to me. this is a serious concert, okay, not karaoke session.

  • yeah, but it's a good thing Jay is known more for his composing skills rather than singing.

  • don't understand a word.........but, i love this song. i guess this is not his song?....

  • 唱得比不上原唱者

    至少唱出個人風格較重要

    重點是江山代有才人出

  • ok, jay is alot better now... this looks like when he was just starting in his career...

  • not really, he was well established at this time, its just he was trying a song that has a very different range than what jay sings in, guess he just wanted to sing it. I like hearing these songs anyway.

  • actually this was back in 2001 at his HK fantasy show concert. Only one year after he released his first album. His singing has improved much since then.

  • 嗰啲人明顯喺清楚聽到廣東話發音先嗌 周杰倫一向畀人批評發音唔標準 何況係廣東歌 所以成首歌喺廣東話部分會聽到斷斷續續亂嗌 好搞笑

  • 好難聽...

  • this is the time when he was known for better song writing than singing... but he really polished his own style of singing now.

  • c'mon, don't even compare him with jacky yet, he even can't sing better than jacky's fans this time.

  • not very good

  • sucks

  • well, i think i can sing better than him

  • lol i got the same thinking like you

  • fucking morons , if u think u can sing better then go ahead and sing , if u cant sing better then him then shut da fuck up