I may catch a lot of flack for this... but this woman's cover of this makes me believe I can go out and be a successful professional singer if that's as good as you have to be..... this is really off key , pitchy, and if not for the overbearing string section it would have been unbearable. (especially the everlasting peace section)
@MusicalMi let's be honest amanda palmer wouldn't have a career if she just did covers... her voice alone isn't that great but her songwriting is stunning... if you can write songs as good as hers i couldn't give a toss what you sang like ... in short she's not a "successful professional singer" ... she's a fucking amazing musician
Damn, what's with all the hating on Amanda? Shit, she does a great job. Illegitimate? Boring? Hides her crappy voice? That's absolutly the most ridiculous shit I've heard. She's got a great voice, she's very talented and so what, she's not on the radio...just means we won't get bored of her like we get bored of your favorite artist.
Good intentions, not good singing. Just atmospheric and a really good song that people fill with their own feelings so it covers up how bad she sings.
It looks like some people here find Amanda's voice "boring". So my question is... wtf ?
SCharlesDennicon 1 month ago
That was one of the best things I've ever seen.
QuietIndigo 6 months ago
I may catch a lot of flack for this... but this woman's cover of this makes me believe I can go out and be a successful professional singer if that's as good as you have to be..... this is really off key , pitchy, and if not for the overbearing string section it would have been unbearable. (especially the everlasting peace section)
MusicalMi 8 months ago
@MusicalMi hahahhah.
hah.
hahahahahah.
you are right, you could easily be a professional singer.
just sing poppy bullshit like kesha or something.
it is not hard.
QuietIndigo 6 months ago
@MusicalMi let's be honest amanda palmer wouldn't have a career if she just did covers... her voice alone isn't that great but her songwriting is stunning... if you can write songs as good as hers i couldn't give a toss what you sang like ... in short she's not a "successful professional singer" ... she's a fucking amazing musician
Setheth 6 months ago
I LOVE THIS WOMAN!!!
MyWORDisntGospel 1 year ago
Damn, what's with all the hating on Amanda? Shit, she does a great job. Illegitimate? Boring? Hides her crappy voice? That's absolutly the most ridiculous shit I've heard. She's got a great voice, she's very talented and so what, she's not on the radio...just means we won't get bored of her like we get bored of your favorite artist.
MyWORDisntGospel 1 year ago 4
Está demoníaca!
witket007 1 year ago
Took my breath away :0
DrunkenRussian17 1 year ago 3
im so old
never thought there would be a video in...er...utuped
amanda - im a fuckn special idiot from germany... :)
ty shoottheplayer
Severolus 1 year ago 3
I quite enjoyed the vocals, but it's far from her style. Musically it's a lovely cover.
FlyingFuckstorm 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@dpuknowme
boring comment, fuck off.
haydnroar 1 year ago
youtube trolls make me laugh.
mcfatty007 1 year ago 6
@mcfatty007
yeah. you're right. you do make me laugh.
thecynthiamachine 9 months ago in playlist Amanda Palmer
Illegitimate, underwhelming, and would surely sound like hell if she were unplugged from the mic she's molding her weak voice to.
Although, she's far from ugly. Whoever said that deserves to listen to this for the next 80 hours.
FungusMossGnosis 1 year ago
Wake from your sleep, Amanda...
genitival 1 year ago
why?!?!?!
mikeyfridgebuzz 1 year ago
This song is like a kid playing in his parents cloth.
dhfhdfhd 1 year ago
not really good, too much for her
marshmallowfra 1 year ago
Good intentions, not good singing. Just atmospheric and a really good song that people fill with their own feelings so it covers up how bad she sings.
GinoTheSinner 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
shes ugly has a boring voice........whats her purpose again?
dpuknowme 1 year ago
@dpuknowme
why are you judging her looks? this is about music, stupid!
kathleenhannah 1 year ago 4
@kathleenhannah boring voice
dpuknowme 1 year ago
that's one of the best covers of this song i've ever heard
she shud've stuck to the piano instead of using the ukulele for the other songs she covered
madhav05 1 year ago
Seems to be in the same vein of Thom Yorke, which is the highest compliment I can give a person covering Radiohead. Great job!
skyiscrape5 1 year ago
Good intentions, bad singing
kanfoosj 1 year ago
i don't even know what to say ... omg
tenebrousllama 1 year ago
Boring voice.
thenileinjune 1 year ago
God, it brought tears to my eyes. And I've listened to this song a million times in my life.
srzent 1 year ago 3
*.*
nichossss 1 year ago
i don't think she's too well-suited for this.
getbonus 1 year ago
it's not bad, however her manly voice is quite annoying on a woman.
coruptgovt 1 year ago
God, her voice is so bland and boring. Very nice string section though. And she's a good pianist.
Brown86Town 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
great radiohead song, but i could honestly do with out the emo/goth gimmick
MicahBuzan 1 year ago
there's a resemblance between her voice and amy lee's voice... try closing your eyes while listening. :D
geotaurum 1 year ago
that legitimately took my breath away. wonderful
takerdemon 1 year ago 19
god this is stunning, my fav radiohead song and she did it so well it brought tears to my eyes.
Leishkin 2 years ago 2
love this song, love this cover.
burningsands667 2 years ago
oh amanda that is absolutely magnificent.'goosebumps' as you said.
sangrealhande 2 years ago
Dear Lord... that was amazing.
FallenShards 2 years ago 3
Love it!
aurelienpodcast 2 years ago 2
God. Amazing cover. Was sending me shivers of joy.
DeMaulwurfn 2 years ago 2
My all-time favourite singer singing my second favourite song from my favourite band.
It's like birthday and xmas in one.
VonBlade 2 years ago 2
@VonBlade favourite is..?
thewirrow 1 year ago
Gorgeous. The climax gave me goosebumps.
SlowCatProductions 2 years ago
just amazing
LimboLinda 2 years ago
fucking amazing
insignifikunt 2 years ago 24