How amazing would it be to hear this live?? Unfortunatly I havent even experienced u2 live yet.. hopefully I will soon. Ahhh how great that day will be :D
I saw them 2 days ago and I really wished they played this song. This slightly slower version is actually quite good from what I can hear of it. Singing wise, I reckon he still can do it after what I heard 2 days ago. Dang...I wished they played this song...
Even if Bono's voice can't scale the highs of this song as well as he did in the early 1980s, I would still love to hear it live. There is a magical quality to this song (also shared by "The Unforgettable Fire") that I wish they would go searching for again, as musicians.
rorshakks...totally agree... also... with 'The Unforgettable Fire'.. great U2, like, they really connected with something out there...back then... and reconnecting the connection now. Magical stuff!
Hard to hear because of the audience. Hard to believe they would play this ancient but great song, live. Most fans would have no idea of it. Its a tough song to re-produce because of the many textures. One of their best songs.
@rorshakks i hope i don't get absolutely killed for this because i LOVE this band more than any other but honestly i don't know if bono's voice can handle the highs needed for this song anymore (as you can kind of hear in the video). i hope that doesn't stop them- i wouldn't even care if they played it just like this. i would cry like a baby and be able to cross one off the bucket list. definitely one of their best songs.
just figured out this was at a rehearsal. i can't remember where i read that they said they kept trying it and it never quite worked live... if i ever saw this in concert i think i (like marius) would die.
This is a song in my soul, since the first time I heard... something special to remember, since then. U2, you got to play it for us in this show in 2009. And please, come to Brazil. I can't believe I heard it alive now. Toze... tanx for it.
great song!! stupid video..really??????? i thought by description it be in audience..not somewhere else....stupid...so disappointed
24luckyspaz 5 months ago
How amazing would it be to hear this live?? Unfortunatly I havent even experienced u2 live yet.. hopefully I will soon. Ahhh how great that day will be :D
Niesha18C 8 months ago
Moving song, amazing. What would I give to hear it live...
QG089 1 year ago
I saw them 2 days ago and I really wished they played this song. This slightly slower version is actually quite good from what I can hear of it. Singing wise, I reckon he still can do it after what I heard 2 days ago. Dang...I wished they played this song...
Blacktzar 1 year ago
Even if Bono's voice can't scale the highs of this song as well as he did in the early 1980s, I would still love to hear it live. There is a magical quality to this song (also shared by "The Unforgettable Fire") that I wish they would go searching for again, as musicians.
stromssa 1 year ago
they never played this on the 360 tour ! why id have loved to hear this live
MrKrypton88 1 year ago
My father´s favourite song
derbeanchen 1 year ago
@derbeanchen My ex-girlfriend favourite song ...
karimkauak 1 year ago
rorshakks...totally agree... also... with 'The Unforgettable Fire'.. great U2, like, they really connected with something out there...back then... and reconnecting the connection now. Magical stuff!
jamespaul69 2 years ago
debthemango...I would join you in heaven too... if I ever heard this song live... words couldnt express the emotion of what i would be be feeling!
jamespaul69 2 years ago
@jamespaul69 - it might be better if they didn't. I am a huge, huge fan of U2 but I don't think Bono's voice is able to this anymore..
brainwavezzz 2 years ago
Hard to hear because of the audience. Hard to believe they would play this ancient but great song, live. Most fans would have no idea of it. Its a tough song to re-produce because of the many textures. One of their best songs.
rorshakks 2 years ago 9
@rorshakks i hope i don't get absolutely killed for this because i LOVE this band more than any other but honestly i don't know if bono's voice can handle the highs needed for this song anymore (as you can kind of hear in the video). i hope that doesn't stop them- i wouldn't even care if they played it just like this. i would cry like a baby and be able to cross one off the bucket list. definitely one of their best songs.
debthemango 2 years ago
i cannot believe this- they said they would never play this live!!! O_O
debthemango 2 years ago
just figured out this was at a rehearsal. i can't remember where i read that they said they kept trying it and it never quite worked live... if i ever saw this in concert i think i (like marius) would die.
debthemango 2 years ago
Oh mi Dios!!! no puedo creerlo... es drowning man en vivo???
El fin del mundo esta cerca..LOL
Naahh U2 es lo M-A-X-I-M-O!!!
graciu2007 2 years ago
HOLY SHIT!!! I'll probably die if they play it live! My favourite U2 song ever!!! YAY! :)))))
mariuszkrause 2 years ago 3
Please play this in Dublin, Chicago or Houston!! Please.
Amiarockstar 2 years ago
This is a song in my soul, since the first time I heard... something special to remember, since then. U2, you got to play it for us in this show in 2009. And please, come to Brazil. I can't believe I heard it alive now. Toze... tanx for it.
nolineproject 2 years ago
Mierda !!!!!
pirlouis1528 2 years ago
It's recorded from outside the stadium??? The rehearsal for the 360 tour?
Your date is wrong, we are in June (06) not in July (07)
SalsaForte 2 years ago
I love this song!! One of the most underrated and touching U2 songs.
healye7 2 years ago 15
I wonder from where this is filmed?
derdritteweg 2 years ago
Comment removed
paulie1982 2 years ago
Amazing!! thanks for posting :)
mrschaos1 2 years ago
Wow, first ever live recording of this track if I'm not mistaken.
Matkin222 2 years ago 4
It had never been played in full live. Snippets of it have been played but never the whole thing.
Zenon2006 2 years ago 2
i willl die!!!!!
pinkfreezie 2 years ago
holy balls we're listening to live drowning man in 2009!
parafish13 2 years ago 6
I never thought I would ever hear that song live. Damn right, holy balls.
skrason 2 years ago 3