Added: 4 years ago
From: mblumenthal
Views: 5,292
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (47)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow that is horrible! i'd have killed the fucking officer, heartless military bastards.

  • when this lady breathes she makes this wierd snorkling sound.

  • Where are all the chickenhawks?

    Can't click on this video?

    Maybe we should send it to each university in blumenthal's video on college repugs?

  • I was in Marine Artillery roughly when Fallujah was re-invaded and I know for certain that white phosphorous was not used. I worked as a Scout Observer and also did plenty of time in the FSCC, so I was well aware of what could and couldn't be used.

  • @SatiricalLinguist I heard & read so much to the contrary regarding White Phosphorous, nut I do know one thing for sure DU was used extensively which is much worse. So whose information do I accept as fact?

  • I'm in Marine artillery, and we don't use DP rounds?

  • Try backing up your claim..prick

  • Fine where would you like me to start you Ignorant liberal

  • what tripe

  • Most soldiers are barely in their 20's and have seen such horror that would drive grown men insane. Hey the zionist-evangelical alliance are bent on pushing for war with Iran next so we probably should right off another few thousand American kids.

    And all for the purpose of Israeli security...it was coincidence that the majority of war mongering neo cons simply happened to be zionist jews right?

  • as a former soldier i can say that i feel used by the government telling us lies to enter the war.

    i never killed a man untill i went to iraq, i killed at least 5 in 1yr after the start of the war give or take a month. this haunts me as i am now sure that it was for nothing.

    when you are in active duty you are not allowed to publicly comment against the commander and chief, unless you want to get imprisoned.

  • don't worry-- john mccain , presidential candidate has probably killed thousands of people as a pilot bombing people in Vietnam

    we're fighting al queda now.. this is not in vain, and your service is against the greatest evil-- the Islamic Caliphate that wants to take over the world and go against human rights/democracy..

  • we arn't actually fighting al-queda in Iraq, their are in afgan, only 2% of the people we have fought in iraq are actually al-queda.

    don't speak of Islamic believers as tho they are all crazy and suicidal. Most of them probally more like people you know, moderate, cool headed, and reasonable.

    lets not forget that christianity has its ugly reps KKK,Christian identity movement,and the various groups who suicide bombed abortion clinics, they are all christians and identify as christian groups

  • i appreciate the service of all our armed forces.. it's better that Sadaam is gone.

    He broke 13 U.N. resolutions. There was massive corruption and probably up to 800,000 killings under his regime.. mass graves..

    now and in the future, there's a major difference in the way societies view the world... a secular democratic republic, where people can worship as they choose and have freedom.. women are respected etc..

    versus an Islamic caliphate where freedom is stifled in all ways..theocracy

  • as a free person who has the utilities and the capasity to understand history and its progression, we as free people must know that it can not be brought with a gun.

    only the people of the land can bring freedom to themselves. we have never actually fostered the birth of anyother democratic nation. every single attempt we have failed, and we even denounce the free choices of the peoples of these nations. It was a free an independent vote that gave Hamas power, not a military take over.

  • @amazingjames311:

    "we have never actually fostered the birth of another democratic nation. every single attempt we have failed, and we even denounce the free choices of the peoples of these nations."

    The reason is because any conflict that America has been involved with since WW2 was never about "democracry". They have been about American business. This includes the "Cold War". The govermment tells you that a given war is "about democracy" because, who can be against that? Right?

  • @ jeffbrown8:

    "versus an Islamic caliphate where freedom is stifled in all ways..theocracy"

    You do realize that evangelical Christian right-wing Americans have plotted for decades to make America a Christian theocracy, don't you?

  • @bapyou And scarily bapyou, they're getting close to realizing their dream of an officially Christian America.

  • @Loejyrrab "[In the early 1980s] Dr. James Luther Adams, my ethics professor at Harvard Divinity School, told us that when we were his age--he was then close to 80--we would be fighting the "Christian fascists." ~ Chris Hedges in his book "American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on America" (Free Press 2006).

    Although five years old now, Hedges' book is still timely, urgent and valuable, as is all of his work. Read 'American Fascists' if you haven't done so already.

  • @bapyou Like Prof.Adams, it was evident to me also back then that the Christian right was finding the door to govermental power wide open.Reagan&Falwell were joined at the hip.The coup is almost complete.Every single Repub tows the Christian line.Some Dems too!The great author Sinclair Lewis said it best in the 1920's "When facism comes to America it will come wrapped in the flag and bearing the cross" Timely, yes?Yes, Chris Hedges is an important voice in these times. I admire him greatly.

  • So much for "fighting for freedom", huh? Hypocrisy at its finest, brought to you by the American gov't, esp. the GOP. Not to disparage our fighting men and women, but are the guys at the absolute top and those in the defense dept. really any more immune from criticism than all other gov't servants?

  • its actually a punishable offense to speak publiclly against the president when you are contractually bound to the military and the Uniform code of military justice in which it holds as law.

    i learned this fact after about 1 1/2 yrs of service, and it haunted me for the remaining 4 1/2 yrs.

    i only say this because from experience in some situations in the military you are specifically denied the ability to be questioned. I had a battle buddy who was apointed as a offical micro-yes man.

  • amazingjames311:

    Read William Blum's 'Killing Hope'. You will gain a new perspective on American history since WW2. Blum is an historian. He was a dedicated cold warrior working for the State Department in the 1960s, until he woke up to what our foreign policy was truly doing around the world in our name. Check him out. He has a website. Read his online essays at least. Or buy his books. You will not be dissapointed.

  • Thank you American, now you know, I am sorry it took that to find out,,,

  • @amazingjames311 thank you for your brave comment. im left wondering though .. do you personally think that there is a single marine who got deployed to iraq and who didnt kill a person? in your unit and other units you know of, did you ever encounter a soldier who hadnt killed a person at the end of his/her term? btw i will pray for you and for your victems may Allah forgive you and your victems.

  • So Cloy Richards is a WAR CRIMINAL who killed unarmed women and babies with chemical weapons.

    Thanks for clearing that up about your son Tina. I hope he does time for his crimes.

  • The only atrocities committed in Iraq were at the hands of Hussein's inbred thugs.

  • Really? You might want to google "Abu Ghraib torture and prisoner abuse". It was certainly committed by inbred thugs, only thing was they were AMERICAN inbred thugs - of the 372nd Military Police Company, to be more specific.

  • Abu Ghraib was an atrocity? So they had torture chambers and were mutilating their captives to the brink of insanity and death?

  • yes

  • I think the Lt. was using a euphemism of 2000

    but think of what would happen, say just as a matter of metal fodder, what would happen if a neighborhood were hit by a barrage of WP

    Does there seem to be some creditability then ? Also we've been there since when again?

  • GO MAX - YOU ROCK. These moron republitards that can't make a reasonable argument can only attack you. Keep up the great work.

  • Dis-information.

  • third - the canon cockers (arty guys) do not conduct BDA's - bomb damage assesment - grunts carry those out not the cannon cockers - so much of this interview is BS - Not one comment in her interview was accurate in regards to how things are handled - or even the possibilty of these things happening.

  • - when we assaulted the city of Fallujah in November 2004 there were maybe 3000 terrorists in the city tops - and this lady wants us to beleive that Camp Fallujah(which is the only place holding arty in the Fallujah AO) was being attacked by 2000 terrorists - her son has been feeding her lies - BS, sorry - second the use of willy pete or white phosphourus is used as an illumination round - not as an impacting shell -

  • Being a Marine (grunt) and having served in Fallujah in Aug04-Sept05 - there was never an incident where 2000 idividuals were shelled - an incident of that magnitude would have spread like wildfire throughout the Marine Corps not to mention the media

  • You'll be happy to know that while you were fighting, "Code Pink Women For Peace" sent the other side $665,000 in money and medical suppies that December. Now that Nineveh is the al-Qaeda stronghold, they're sending money there.

    Why is teason tax deductable?

    BTW, I spoke with an attorney who confirms that the hospital that had to be taken out first was a insurgent military depot, funded by one of those phony Islamic Charities, initial are IIRO.

  • i feel so bad for him. It's disgusting things like this are happening. I think when this ends and years down the road when things like this become mainstream heads are going to roll.

  • wow. seriously chilling account. I can't imagine what it's like to experience something like that.

  • Imagine all you like, because that is all it is, her imagination.

  • Proves what mindless idiots soldiers are. Trained killers-and we are supposed to be proud of them?! I would try to kill myself too if I had instigated such atrocities on any people.

  • F U. I am a soldier and officer, I would never do something like that and neither would my fellow soldiers. Think what you are saying. Of course we have bad apples, after all we are so streched that we actually recruit just about everyone willing.

  • Sir, just take a look at mikemugwort's profile, in particular, his favorites. It may lessen the sting of his BS when you understand, he's a stoner.

  • I thought the military insisted that phosphorus was only used for illuminating the battlefield!

  • Military truth is to be found by citizens like Maxx not Generals. Keep it streamming Maxx, your refreashing. Just stay below the radar of the supressors, we need you.

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more