Renee Fleming, Ramon Vargas - Libiamo ne'lieti calici

[reinadegrillos]

SSí, la voz de Vargas hoy en día es de las más bellas, sin duda. Su fallo, para mí, está en la actuación. Lo mismo se dice de la Fleming, pero con una pareja adecuada (Villazón), sí actúa (además de cantar bellísimamente, claro).

Yo creo que Villazón actúa mejor que Vargas y eso lo hace más popular, pero la voz más bella es la de Vargas ¿qué se piensa por acá?

[gmdilee]

@reinadegrillos De acuerdo. Vargas tiene una voz priviligiada y se le va mejorando comforme relaje los musculos y los nervios del escenario. Yo creo que Villazon es mas bueno en la dramatizacion pero Vargas tiene mas rango en la projeccion de voz. Saludos.

[MrGOPERA]

Wonderful. Vargas is a refreshing new sound but still has that familiar Pavarottiness to him. It's very focused and flexible. Outstanding

[Ebonysoprano]

pitchy

[Telltaleheart79]

He is no Alfredo Kraus to be sure.

[danbar73]

Kraus'&Vargas' voices are of comparable purity, focus and beauty but quite different tonal colors. AK's silver tones hardly changed throughout his long career. The young RV had some of AK's silvery qualities, but his voice has changed significantly. It is now a robust instrument with a very attractive tonal mix of gold and shades of bronze with some silver for brightness. AK had thrilling high notes while RV has exciting vitality over his entire vocal range,more warmth and expressiveness.

[ARReith]

fleming sounds good! Her DVD from LA is questionable, but she's accurate in this rendition!

[reinadegrillos]

@ARReith I wonder what you mean by questionable? I like it very much, but would like to contrast opinions.

[novice1959]

Very excellent!