If you sit down to play a Tool song on your acoustic guitar, you'll more than likely find yourself (a) playing a mid-80s Megadeth-style bass line or (b) alternating between two or three tedious barre chords that are right next to each other.
A bassist using a pick is a failed guitarist. Period.
Bass is meant to be played with fingers. If you want some more rude or metallic sound, hit harder on your strings, hit the wood. That's what I do on my rbx375 Yamaha, and I can play Korn, RATM and Sepultura without using any effects.
You may be a decent bassist with your pick, but whatever you do with it, if someone can do it with his or hers fingers, makes him or her way more better than you. Period again.
@Goathem The point is to get a sound, playing with a pick gets a different sound. What makes you a good bassist isn't how fast you can play, its how you think about the music, which is totally divorced from whether you use a pick or not.
People like you should really just go die, you ruin music.
@Goathem Did it occur to you that it was inane to attack picking on a tool video, where tool's actual bassist uses a pick? Think before you speak, cretin.
@hojima I'm not insane, and you are the stupid one here.
As to me, this song, all songs, sound better using fingers instead of pick. You may disagree, it's fine. But you cannot say that I have to die because my ideas ar different than yours, moreover you cannot offend me. I didn't attack personally anyone.
@saleporc123 Yes, we have humor in canada, I'm just used to douchebag tool fans who would say something like that in earnest. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
I don't know what people are talking about. I have been in bands for years and this is pretty good. Most drummers suck, guitarists can't play to a beat, and so on. Good job.
i think the same guitar sucks and itś not a really hard songyou need to practice before u upload somthing like this i'd forgive this if you were playing some other stuff but you got to play tool's songs with some respect
@bendingparabol Who the fuck are you to tell these guys whats what....this is youtube dude, and any and everybody can upload any and everything they want to.and yes you and everyone else is free to comment good or bad about the vid..You'd forgive this if they were playing some other stuff?? You'd forgive them??..WHO the fuck do you think you are. I bet these guys really give 2 wet fucks whether you forgive them or not...your a fucking idiot...these guys did a bang up job..not bad at all
All together, the pick, finger style and slap style are techniques that a good, complete bassist should basically be familiar with, because they provide differences in sound. Some bassists like pick more, some finger style, some use both. So, your opinion kinda says that you're a classic dumb ass.
@Lesstra It was a joke, but you have to be a typical internet tough guy and start talking shit, so go fuck yourself. I like the video and think that it is a good cover of TOOL's song. I prefer the challenge of playing bass without a pick because I play more than just one style. When going from gallops or tremello picking to a slap and pop groove, it makes it very difficult to use a pick. So try not to resort to douchery so quickly. Not everyone is out to get you or talk shit.
If I remember correctly, I was referring to parabolakiller's state: "only pussies use a pick"... So I really don't know what's your problem, and how come you got offended.
Singing is the soul screaming out.... Not A energy that can only be interpreted on a instrument....The vocal ability is a trip into the human mind... You convey intensions Strengths & weakness in its RAWest form.....Get a singer. I cant lie.. this is precision & sounds good to me, but i & everyone else wants you to put a select individual to put his soul interpretation in the NOW. Ok, i will 5 star, but because it deserves it.....GET A SINGER... Make it what it was meant to be.
Kinda pointless to have a whole band together & no one is singing....Whats to say i dont find a video with one guy & a drum machine singing the song. He would be the shit. I remember i did this when i was your age... & if you dont have a singer then its only kool to you & not everyone listening
Only cool to them and not everyone else listening huh? Well how would you explain the just about 5 star rating out of 739 (740 after I rate 5 stars) people and the numerous positive comments below? They are their own band and they have every right to choose how they want to play music.
Sorry i came off shitty, but been there done that... They want someone to BALLS up & sing... That is the true component to the representation... Instrumentalists are a dime a dozen... A one man show beats this out... because you are missing a profound component. It will never hit that spiritual level of creation if you dont have a vocalist putting the soul to the music. It is words of wisdom....Even if the singer sucked it would have potencially set all the others off.
Great cover, the timing between you three was pretty much solid for the whole song which is great!
The song itself though was played a bit faster than the original, might have been a bit easier if you had played at the right tempo. The drummer plays great but I don't think the snare is off like it should be. Even though he didn't do some parts the same as the song he still filled in some pretty nice stuff. Good job!
man im alot better at guitar now if i redid this i think u mite be impressed so mayb you dont kno weverything about guitar. have u hreard of yngvie malmsteen? ive been watching his videos everyday to try to get my talent much better
Um the bass and drums were good. The guitar needs a bit of work on several sections. And your timoing needs improvement, BUT other than that nice work :)
Sounded really good. One thing I noticed is that there wasn't any distortion for the guitar during the delay effect with the bass and there should have been.
the bass sounds just like justin's. excpet just alittle less gain if anything. but it sounds JUST like it. and the guitar, adam uses alittle reverb i think, but not THAT much
Probably someone told you already, but you can use VirtualDub, it's free and quite a standard among opensource tools for video editing (aplying filters to video/audio, cropping, cuting, converting, compressing etc.)
awesome cover// guitar distortion could be a little heavier or more trebly.. to counteract the bass.. well not counteract it. harmonize wiht it better.. great cover though!!!! haha"fuck, fuck fuck, fuck you camera"
as others have said, the guitar tone is lacking, and he is lacking the aggression that Adam Jones has in this song. It's not bad, but the bass player and drummer especially make up for it. Fucking drummer is good man.
If you sit down to play a Tool song on your acoustic guitar, you'll more than likely find yourself (a) playing a mid-80s Megadeth-style bass line or (b) alternating between two or three tedious barre chords that are right next to each other.
jointhemodernworld 6 months ago
you guys are actually decent, guitar need a bit of work though. other then that keep it up
TheAddictsPerish78 10 months ago
That was damn good guys!
markmartinojrE4 1 year ago
nice job
Souljacaomh 1 year ago
Im sorry but your guitarist is a moron...has he even heard the song?
tylerweber1986 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A bassist using a pick is a failed guitarist. Period.
Bass is meant to be played with fingers. If you want some more rude or metallic sound, hit harder on your strings, hit the wood. That's what I do on my rbx375 Yamaha, and I can play Korn, RATM and Sepultura without using any effects.
You may be a decent bassist with your pick, but whatever you do with it, if someone can do it with his or hers fingers, makes him or her way more better than you. Period again.
Pick is cheating.
Goathem 1 year ago
@Goathem The point is to get a sound, playing with a pick gets a different sound. What makes you a good bassist isn't how fast you can play, its how you think about the music, which is totally divorced from whether you use a pick or not.
People like you should really just go die, you ruin music.
hojima 1 year ago
@hojima First of all, you should totally die.
I was expressing my way to think; you're free to play the way you like.
I hate cheaters, but this doesn't mean I kill them as soon as I meet one. And I think that using a pick to play bass, is cheating.
I was talking about effects, and not speed. I really don't like pick sound on bass strings. That's all.
So, go die somewhere else, go ruin your life wherever you like. And don't bother my ideas.
Goathem 1 year ago
@Goathem Did it occur to you that it was inane to attack picking on a tool video, where tool's actual bassist uses a pick? Think before you speak, cretin.
hojima 1 year ago
@hojima I'm not insane, and you are the stupid one here.
As to me, this song, all songs, sound better using fingers instead of pick. You may disagree, it's fine. But you cannot say that I have to die because my ideas ar different than yours, moreover you cannot offend me. I didn't attack personally anyone.
Goathem 1 year ago
wow :) this sounds super great guys! :)
LoveBama624 1 year ago
love this song and you guys did a great job!
paulv1973 1 year ago
I-I didn't really have any problem with the guitarist? I thought it was fairly right on...
piratepantsfromhell 1 year ago
Needs vocals :D
TheTwItCh56 1 year ago
Fucking great job guys.
sjk254 1 year ago
i'm not too sure if i like the fast tempo but pretty good regardless
Lrogerz44 1 year ago
good job
rromo9 1 year ago
you need a silverburst to play a tool song ,thats not an option ;)
saleporc123 1 year ago 2
@saleporc123 Thats rediculous.
hojima 1 year ago
@hojima it's a joke,don't you have humor in your country?
saleporc123 1 year ago
@saleporc123 Yes, we have humor in canada, I'm just used to douchebag tool fans who would say something like that in earnest. Sorry for the misunderstanding.
hojima 1 year ago
damn good fellas!!!!!
tcasel38 1 year ago
ur like just a slight bit of tempo on the first just enough to notice but otherwise it was fucking awesome u rock
YouLoseTheGameOo 1 year ago
Oh. And the bassist was pretty good. You were a little fast on the intro, though. A bit slower.
MegaDysfunction 1 year ago
The guitarist could defintely use some work. Try holding down the frets longer. It sounds way too short.
MegaDysfunction 1 year ago
these guys are so cute!
fannnnntasticly 1 year ago
Bass was good. I enjoy the bass cause it was good. Maybe you should start playing bass cause it's good. That's good
XD
bluewire3333 1 year ago
sooo from what i can understand you live with your band?! thats fuckin badass..
distubedrat 1 year ago
screw that lady who doesent know crap about good music and just wants kids to shut up
drumskater337 1 year ago
wow this is badass how old were u guys when u did it
sunburst13 1 year ago
Too fast.
DISGUSTIAPATED 1 year ago
I don't know what people are talking about. I have been in bands for years and this is pretty good. Most drummers suck, guitarists can't play to a beat, and so on. Good job.
RigoKellerColas 1 year ago
Put the damn distortion On the guitar xD
Luvinhas 1 year ago
overtime !!!
DistrattoDallaLuna 1 year ago
the snare sounds....... broken like the bottom head has cracked....... anyway good job!
BassGod2271 1 year ago
Could've been better but you had a damn good go at it. Keep it up :D
ScrewNormality1 1 year ago
i think the same guitar sucks and itś not a really hard songyou need to practice before u upload somthing like this i'd forgive this if you were playing some other stuff but you got to play tool's songs with some respect
bendingparabol 1 year ago
@bendingparabol Who the fuck are you to tell these guys whats what....this is youtube dude, and any and everybody can upload any and everything they want to.and yes you and everyone else is free to comment good or bad about the vid..You'd forgive this if they were playing some other stuff?? You'd forgive them??..WHO the fuck do you think you are. I bet these guys really give 2 wet fucks whether you forgive them or not...your a fucking idiot...these guys did a bang up job..not bad at all
theenigmajjames 1 year ago
fun fun
Knux28 1 year ago
niceee cover
=)
VIDGAMZGIRL 1 year ago
it was kinda fast at the intro and u needed distortion guitar ;p
Luvinhas 1 year ago
Great drummer!
The guitar needs to be louder!
Yelowfurlamb 2 years ago
the drummers sick
LogansDrums23 1 year ago
good cover. Bassist need to slow it a bit though
ziporonto 2 years ago 2
Sick drumming
haydenf 2 years ago 3
bassist needs to slow his shit down lol
rob5000x1 2 years ago
to fast.. but very cool
Hillgaard84 2 years ago
yeahyeah good cover bro good cover
excelente cabrones
farahonx 2 years ago
hey muy buen cover !!1
puchito1x1 2 years ago
Great sound!
TheRoge43 2 years ago
only pussies use a pick....
parabolakiller 2 years ago
@parabolakiller your suppsoed to play this song with a pick or else it sounds like shit you dumb peice of shit
iDeathFromAbove 2 years ago
Well yeah if you a pussy
parabolakiller 2 years ago
The bassist from tool is a pussy? Then why listen to it?
madderdaddy2 2 years ago 7
.................. ur gay
Suffication94 2 years ago
Picks are for afros not basses.
OliverAnderson420 2 years ago 2
agreed
jshow420 2 years ago
All together, the pick, finger style and slap style are techniques that a good, complete bassist should basically be familiar with, because they provide differences in sound. Some bassists like pick more, some finger style, some use both. So, your opinion kinda says that you're a classic dumb ass.
Lesstra 2 years ago 8
@Lesstra It was a joke, but you have to be a typical internet tough guy and start talking shit, so go fuck yourself. I like the video and think that it is a good cover of TOOL's song. I prefer the challenge of playing bass without a pick because I play more than just one style. When going from gallops or tremello picking to a slap and pop groove, it makes it very difficult to use a pick. So try not to resort to douchery so quickly. Not everyone is out to get you or talk shit.
OliverAnderson420 2 years ago
If I remember correctly, I was referring to parabolakiller's state: "only pussies use a pick"... So I really don't know what's your problem, and how come you got offended.
Lesstra 2 years ago
@Lesstra
FIngerstyle with the occasion slap for emphasis is all i need, you have TONS more options when you play fingerstyle, pick your limited like crazy
KreatorOfDeath1985 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Lesstra
FIngerstyle with the occasion slap for emphasis is all i need, you have TONS more options when you play fingerstyle, pick your limited like crazy
KreatorOfDeath1985 1 year ago
Comment removed
Goathem 1 year ago
@Goathem Your comment is retarded, all you did in your comment, was fail at grammer and prove your not a musician.
dtab321 1 year ago
Comment removed
Goathem 1 year ago
Comment removed
Goathem 1 year ago
depends on what sound you are trying to get
MRpoopsniff 2 years ago
Singing is the soul screaming out.... Not A energy that can only be interpreted on a instrument....The vocal ability is a trip into the human mind... You convey intensions Strengths & weakness in its RAWest form.....Get a singer. I cant lie.. this is precision & sounds good to me, but i & everyone else wants you to put a select individual to put his soul interpretation in the NOW. Ok, i will 5 star, but because it deserves it.....GET A SINGER... Make it what it was meant to be.
LendMeYourHand 2 years ago
Kinda pointless to have a whole band together & no one is singing....Whats to say i dont find a video with one guy & a drum machine singing the song. He would be the shit. I remember i did this when i was your age... & if you dont have a singer then its only kool to you & not everyone listening
LendMeYourHand 2 years ago
Only cool to them and not everyone else listening huh? Well how would you explain the just about 5 star rating out of 739 (740 after I rate 5 stars) people and the numerous positive comments below? They are their own band and they have every right to choose how they want to play music.
craig6944 2 years ago
Sorry i came off shitty, but been there done that... They want someone to BALLS up & sing... That is the true component to the representation... Instrumentalists are a dime a dozen... A one man show beats this out... because you are missing a profound component. It will never hit that spiritual level of creation if you dont have a vocalist putting the soul to the music. It is words of wisdom....Even if the singer sucked it would have potencially set all the others off.
LendMeYourHand 2 years ago
i got the chills during the breakdown... great job
abowlofsoda 2 years ago
Great! Thanks from Russia!
vampinside 2 years ago
the very begining with the bass is just a tad bit too fast, but you fixed yourself. good job
nollidazar 2 years ago
well wmv and pc is the problem go MAC thats your solution..
rexfollett 2 years ago
FUCKING A!!!
hermald18 2 years ago
Great cover, the timing between you three was pretty much solid for the whole song which is great!
The song itself though was played a bit faster than the original, might have been a bit easier if you had played at the right tempo. The drummer plays great but I don't think the snare is off like it should be. Even though he didn't do some parts the same as the song he still filled in some pretty nice stuff. Good job!
madmax336 2 years ago
I take that back, guitar needs alot of work. Drumming was great!
Calbad3112 2 years ago
man im alot better at guitar now if i redid this i think u mite be impressed so mayb you dont kno weverything about guitar. have u hreard of yngvie malmsteen? ive been watching his videos everyday to try to get my talent much better
thumphrey05 2 years ago
@thumphrey05 bro need learn the timing and shit there isnt any rythm in your playing either sounds real bland and boring
Tibnips 1 year ago
@Tibnips Their timing is fine.
hojima 1 year ago
@hojima you serious? drumming is but the strumming is out farr as any way guy said hes improved so yea who really cares
Tibnips 1 year ago
Um the bass and drums were good. The guitar needs a bit of work on several sections. And your timoing needs improvement, BUT other than that nice work :)
Calbad3112 2 years ago
that was a good cover..
bama4720 2 years ago
good cover boys
mosheskimo 2 years ago
Comment removed
theTOOLshed1 2 years ago
really well done .. i play bass aswell as guitar and drums, and i know how extremely hard this song is to play..
zataan 2 years ago
Good job, gitar, more gain ?
Banjovince 2 years ago
great cover (: you guys need a singer though, i know they're fuckin hard to find X.X but still
SvenIsHere 2 years ago
great bassist !!
fwtovolidas 2 years ago
what a sick drummer
hoodratts 2 years ago
yeah! and he seems to have pretty fast feet (at the end)...
MorandRuler 2 years ago
i'm getting a guitar like that one
aaws95 2 years ago
Yes !!!
Great !!!!
Good job !
aurelalto 2 years ago
les falta la voz lo demas its great!!
sebasztian1 2 years ago
tha was pretty fuckin awsome
twistedkatana1 2 years ago
Sounded really good. One thing I noticed is that there wasn't any distortion for the guitar during the delay effect with the bass and there should have been.
zakorkaz 2 years ago
good job :)
aerfdd 2 years ago
guitar needs more practice
elsalvador702 2 years ago
that was awesome, good job
mum3hai 2 years ago
slow down a tiny bit. it's deceiving how fast it sounds. but it's actually a bit slower
rldjsegura 2 years ago 2
its goo but you dont have voacalist
panicrevenger 2 years ago
no singer? ah well still awesome. schisms good but parabola is even better!
ShulerStudios3211 2 years ago
schism is so bad asssss!!!!!
TheMightyRAMBO5 2 years ago
thats great guys. i can play this on guitar and bass but the drums always fuck me up.idk why. its prolly the time signature. great job anyway
superdude1452 2 years ago
the drummer was full of sketch but it was still awesome.
rcfreak2493 2 years ago
you guys need a vocalist
Bluntangel831 2 years ago
ASAP
kevarm23 2 years ago
woow!!!... increible!!!
1000/5
7ArtangeL 2 years ago
slow down and play the hammer ons at the beginning right
clevelandtyler2 2 years ago 2
you guys did a really great job. im impressed somebody could even get close to danney carey on the drums. you guys are really talented for your age
WorldofFood 2 years ago
Dang that drummer was gettin down, the bass player too.
brianwurst1234 2 years ago 2
the guitar is a bit sloppy but other than that its a really good cover :]
metalgeartiernan 2 years ago
..good job
mki1 2 years ago
fucking great
nddurana 2 years ago
Um sony vegas is pretty good for editing
grimchain 2 years ago
Movie Maker
Kreigshundun2 2 years ago
haha the bass player looks alot like me, what is he like 5'6 5'7? cuz if he is thats my damn twin lol
21021011 2 years ago
What equipment are the bassist using? A pedal or something? And how is the amp equalized?
mitnavnerchristian 2 years ago
very good cover, of difficult song. 5 stars from me!
serhgoch 2 years ago
the bass sounds just like justin's. excpet just alittle less gain if anything. but it sounds JUST like it. and the guitar, adam uses alittle reverb i think, but not THAT much
azombiestool 2 years ago
tht was great...good job guys!!!
fingerboardgod345 2 years ago
More sustain to guitar
And chorus to bass will be perfect
AkademikPotapov 2 years ago
ya yall got a good thing goin especially wit dat drummer, it was ok drumming but no1 can blame u because danny carey's drumming is really complicated
xxxbulldog44xxx 2 years ago
larned this the other day, brill cover , great song by a great band!
ceetothecee 2 years ago
im pretty sure the snare is supposed to be turned on.
urdumb7 2 years ago
I'm fairly certain the snare's off for most of the album, definitely off for this song.
fuktnees 2 years ago
hahaha, you don´t know nothing about TOOL my friend
underwaterladys3 2 years ago
who said i did know anything about tool in the first place? i only said that cuz it sorit of sounded like the snare was turned on for the album.
urdumb7 2 years ago
all-together a 10/10
except no vocals!!
holycross23 2 years ago
agreed! i'd wail for ya if you need some vocals :)
crimsontearz24 2 years ago
Probably someone told you already, but you can use VirtualDub, it's free and quite a standard among opensource tools for video editing (aplying filters to video/audio, cropping, cuting, converting, compressing etc.)
vladk2k 2 years ago
u nailed the bass but u need a vocal
kingdan356 2 years ago
great cover all you need is vocals
DespisedAdvocate1 2 years ago
awesome cover
pooploser911 2 years ago
keep on drummer!!!
shuckuma 2 years ago
Fuckin' nice!
PowerSlaveN 2 years ago
ugh i dont like the sound of those drums..
Thusyanthan 2 years ago
the bass and drums sound amazing, the guitar was a little iffy but good nonetheless
mattconna 2 years ago
nice cover, would suggest a better distortion pedal though but still very good. hella good drumming tool is not easy to play at all.
lightning2021 3 years ago
I love the song and you guys are prety good. But I found the overall picture prety weak. Especialy the guitar. And buy your drummer a metronome.
brigdetosomewhere 3 years ago
Comment removed
CJBassett86 2 years ago
"the woman down the street called the cops on us. apparently she's not a tool fan" :)))))
great cover
andr3yr4du 3 years ago 4
coool !!
antesrock 3 years ago
this is amazing! one of my favorite songs
jenniereynnie 3 years ago
wud love too see u all do dat cover live
livetotrip 3 years ago
Final Cut Pro and Avid are always good editing programs, they might not be simple though.
grEEnfan8880 3 years ago
very good bass player!
which bass do yo own?
cheers from Chile!
Kudell46and2 3 years ago
awesome, add a vocalist and you can make 400+ a night :D
CannibalKlok 3 years ago
That was tight guys, keep it up. Guitar dude should've been in view more though.
elephantlawst 3 years ago
love the sound of your bass
what brand you got?
or what strings you use?
darkworldteen91 3 years ago
Excellent cover! Undoubtedly one of the best covers I have yet to see on YouTube.
JWBassNDrums86 3 years ago
awesome cover// guitar distortion could be a little heavier or more trebly.. to counteract the bass.. well not counteract it. harmonize wiht it better.. great cover though!!!! haha"fuck, fuck fuck, fuck you camera"
sovietrocker89 3 years ago
ownage.
slowrider91 3 years ago
that's a pretty near perfect cover right there. The lead guitar (or whoever is on the left side of the screen) Seems a bit choppy though
xXbunnyluvXx 3 years ago
That'll do quite nicely.
mastermynal 3 years ago
u guys are killer
matthewflemin12 3 years ago
its a little fast
sappypesticide 3 years ago 2
no ..the time is right,but what about the voice????????
Ruben8275 3 years ago
man I wish I had a bass whammy :C
drkmonkey7 3 years ago
i had a kareoke time as well in my studio...lol
theshit1980 3 years ago
Had myself a little karaoke moment there. Thanks guys.
worldismyashtray 3 years ago
lol "fuck u camera" XD. great cover!
pyrodb 3 years ago
as others have said, the guitar tone is lacking, and he is lacking the aggression that Adam Jones has in this song. It's not bad, but the bass player and drummer especially make up for it. Fucking drummer is good man.
martinlutherkingIII 3 years ago
That shit brought a tear to my eye.
nocreal 3 years ago
is that a slash signature epiphone?
joaozinhomaria 3 years ago
i think so it looks like the goldtop
mikegawne 3 years ago
nice, u guys are good, get a singer and ur band would be perfect.
heavymetal988 3 years ago 2
Awesome job.....
TheeManThatCan 3 years ago 2
definitly not an easy song...took me a bit to get it down(on guitar).....great performance though
xsamanthax1691 3 years ago
nicely done
HardRocker766 3 years ago
yeah this is phat lads.
metalasfuck123456789 3 years ago
KiCk AsZ!!!!! sound good
jp246810 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i think some where in that song there were words
Turncoatrb 3 years ago
Wow the intro was waayyyyyy too fast.
Altered6Chicken 3 years ago
jajaja, re bien!!!! felicitaciones, Tool lo mejor!!
oliveira830724 3 years ago