Girls Aloud - 10 - Whole Lotta History (Live at O2)

[TheFinishable]

This is such a clever performance.. I love it!

[TheUberErin]

Kimberley's part in the beginning <3

[HannahTurnbullx]

cheryl has an amazing voice in this song! well she does all the time, but particularly in this song, some of yous are saying that they're rubbish, or one of them cant sing or something, how did they get so far if they 'cant sing', they can sing better than you anyday. 

[yuvush2]

@HannahTurnbullx she is amazing !! how can people say she can't sing ? O.o

[HannahTurnbullx]

@yuvush2 exactly!

[yuvush2]

@HannahTurnbullx they are deffo jelouse of her LOL so talented and amazing woman !

[HannahTurnbullx]

@yuvush2 anoo haha! if they come on her just to criticize its just cos they're all jelous.

[13converserock]

This proves Girls Aloud could sing AMAZING

[chiklua]

they are gorgeus but they can't really sing. they have normal voices nothing special or very artistic. but its ok

they seam to be pretty famous in england though

[etreduardo]

@chiklua Uhum, in the very end, that's true. However, Nadine (the third) and Nicola (the ginger) do sing very well, specially nowadays, some years after this tour. The others are just OK.

[ldi321]

@chiklua they sing amazing live if you are there. they are huge in england they are the most successful girl group ever in UK bigger than spice girls. you dont need to have amazing voices at all you need to be ale to perform. and they are amazing. most artists dont have amazing voices.

[gosiaduch]

nadine is absolutely the best singer and so beautiful, cheryl is hopeless singing live like always nicola is totally unerrated

[ldi321]

@gosiaduch what cheryl was amazing here? and all the tour she was good. on the OOC tour she was amazing i was there and she was incredile they all were. nicola was amazing. they all were

[pastcineo]

this was also called "The Waving Number", right?

[grzesmol]

Cheryl is the most beautiful girl in the group but has very weak vocal. The best singer is NADINE

[ldi321]

@grzesmol what broken strings live from out of control tour and then tell me she cant sing. or watch set fire to the third bar with snow patrol. she can bloody well sing

[grzesmol]

@ldi321

listen FIREFLIES live you changed your opinion

[ldi321]

@grzesmol that was one performance shed been ill and she was hungover. 1 perfromance. if you listen to her sing it at other events then its better. id 90% of the time she gets it right. give over dont be jealous.

[ldi321]

actually watch broken strings live you cant say that isnt good

[xR0cKabiLLYPriNcEsSx]

@grzesmol No!!!!!!! Cheryl is not the most beautiful girl in the group!!!! Sarah is also beautiful and the others too :P

[grzesmol]

@xR0cKabiLLYPriNcEsSx

of course not NADINE is the most beautiful

[shoko131313]

like their mikes

[chamexguy]

Sarah's vocals are amazing in this version.

[Cabess12]

Cheryl owns this song,

Nicola's bit gives me goosebumps

[ldi321]

oh my god that harmony at the end was amazing

girls aloud need to come back right now!

[Giorgia13x]

get back together please :'(

[meganlouise94x]

i miss these so much they were the best girl group ever i love kimberly and cheryl

[caoimhelovesmehall]

the gooosebumps mss cheryl gives me are unbeliveable! xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

[campalamp1212]

GA fuck yes!!! I want a new GA album!!

[SpoonsRLikForks]

this is the first time I liked Kimberley's voice.

[KittyLovesMusic]

i love cheryl so much<3

[belen7]

this song :(

[empress8skywalker]

those dresses look AMAZING on the girls not to mention that they are already so GORGEOUS!

[empress8skywalker]

this song gives me the chills, it's gorgeous

[gunnerpetters]

I have to say this. After seeing them live and watching the videos here, all the girls APART from NADINE really struggle singing live!

Not only is Nadine the best voice, but the most stunning, beautiful woman ever! Why is Cheryl so much more famous and liked??

[CherylColeAMAZING]

@gunnerpetters People relate to her more.people have different oppinions I like nadine & cheryl, but i prefair cheryl

[tourous4life]

this is a pre recorded live... as you can always tell when nadine is singling live....

[KatieGASatsGCCFan]

i miss them so much its unreal :'(

[hesterftw]

Seriously they totally ruined this by dubbing over Nadine with the studio version of her part :s

[MissNicoleSteele]

I love this song and i think there great especially Nadine cheryl and kimberly was greatb at the start x

xxLove Girls Aloud!!!x

[hesterftw]

Why is Nadine dubbed over? :|

[chuckyager1]

Nadine is Irish....can really tell when she raises her voice and says words ending with R's

[kinkykara010]

is Nadine Irish or is she from Newcastle like Cheryl is

[TweanCoyle]

@kinkykara010 nadine is irish

[jdanbridge]

They all sound awesome on this..

ANyone that says Cheryl can't sing should watch this

[yenoshsu]

this is better than the recording! love it.

[usvryzas]

love Cheryl on that! beautiful voice.

[foxxxdiee]

nadine sounds waaayyy too much like the actual album track. wtf?

[JerryHearts]

it's not even that :/ the first bit she sings straight after cheryl sounds like nicola? x

[animalelementpowers]

@JerryHearts I don't think it's sounds like Nicola... I really hear Nadine (Even when I don't look, wich I did the first time...)

[meshukorina]

best ive heard from nicola. stunning girls.

[tourous4life]

wtf is up with sarah's vocals... gzzz; thought she would of consulted 2 a vocal coach b4 a tour!

[adamcrookedsmile]

Sarah's part is good, starts 3:24, she does some technical stuff with belt/wail on the high notes (3:58) and it sounds fine.

[dancinape]

i absolutly love GA and i think that Cheryl and Nadine are gorgeous!! xxxx

[LoVeStoned2424]

Prettiest girl group ever!

[jhwb256]

Great singing in this song. They all brought it!

[ArtemisAnahi]

Nicola is awsome here ^^

<3

[hotclippings]

roit on to to moddle of tho croooid

[GemDerbyRam]

Cheryl looks amazing in this!! She does always but especially good in this! lol

[thiagodelsole]

kimberley is so cuteee

[danimaryx]

i love this song one of my fave girls aloud songs to datee :D

its so beautiful :D

x

[aliice23xGAfanx]

<3 this song is gorgeous it sends me to sleep at night :)

[GirlsAloudForever100]

to me as long as they are them and they sing im happy. dubbing, costumes, timing, voices, songs dont matter. i love em

[aliice23xGAfanx]

i love this song <3 its gorgeous :)

GA 4 EVAA :D XXXXX

[marcusmooney23]

good but nothing compared to the wembley performance on chemistry the dubbing is crap on this dvd

[Scotsgal96]

its not dubbed, it doesnt sound like anyothers they've done, jeez

[cheergurl1017]

Nadine's vocals are dubbed!

[Scotsgal96]

no they're not, you can tell when something sounds live and this does

[Leppicon77]

haha no offense lass, listen to the entire tangled up dvd and nadine sounds so fake

[Scotsgal96]

@Leppicon77 please don't call me lass and she doesn't sound fake, she sounds fine, even if it was dubbed, she's an amazing singer anyway so it doesn't matter

[Leppicon77]

woah calm down love? can i call you that? lol calm down geeesh ....

[Scotsgal96]

@Leppicon77 its nothing pesonal i just really don't like being called lass lol

[Leppicon77]

shame huh?

[allsoironic]

wow. sarah sounds deep lol, shes still good though

[depjojo]

i love nicola!!!

[hanafunnibunni]

its a shame theyve dubbed nadines voice at 1.19 x

[xhxexlx]

y did they do that??

[hanafunnibunni]

Dont know, to make her sound better i suppose, even though she sounds great without it :S ?

[megawwefan99]

Im not sure, i think she was ill?

[danny2812]

I just looooove how Cheryl sounds in the "I'd give myself the blame" part... probably not their best performance of this song, but still really good... :)

[nikolefilan]

i love it

[Ipitombi05]

i love these outfits!

[howmart]

Actually, Nadine did badly in quite alot of the songs when this was filmed.

So she was given the chance to sing her parts again and dub over her parts.

abit unfair on the others though =/

[gingerhunter55]

Wow, she's usually the most consistant of the group. Still everyone has off days I guess =/

[kaydubby]

this song at wembley a couple of years ago > than this crap live version.

[supergrice]

Damn right!

[kaydubby]

to those of you who gave me a thumbs down: do you honestly believe that this version was a better live performance than the one they did at wembely in '06? there's absolutely no way this was better; FAR from being their best. it's almost as if sarah's on steroids now because her voice is two octave lower...

[Tayuyaxxx]

How low or high someone's voice is doesn't show how good they sound...

[kaydubby]

i was simply saying that because her voice is so much lower in this version, it doesn't fit well with the rest of the song. i honestly believe that it ruins how the song sounds because she's not singing within the same range. it's not a bad performance, just shakier than others...

[mojitoXroyalty]

NICOLA IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING.

i love her<3

[elaineyank13]

nicola's voice is great!!

[Scotsgal96]

i only just realised, they do all da slow 1s together, how amazin is cheryl in this???? luv her

[ldi321]

heyyy yehh i watched it on tmf aswell

and i havent seen half of this .

dont know why they didnt show it.

i love the dresses in this part and the way they sing as the go across the bridge,,

i love them!

[Geebob09]

Nadine's voise is dubbed throughout each and every song for the dvd as she didnt sing very well live at the concert!

Nicola was amazing!!

[walkaway221]

no its just here! she is the voice of GA lets be honest.

[darwinwmu]

Actually no honey, I agree with Geebobo9, she didn't sing that well in the acutally tour that's why Xenomania went nuts when editing this DVD.

Nicola sings a lot better than her

[walkaway221]

why wld Xenomaina go mad at her?? see her on popstars the rivals live shows she is the best live and note perfect!

[darwinwmu]

I never said Xenomania was mad, i said they went nuts trying to make her sound better on the DVD

[walkaway221]

nuts? dunno what you on about. Xenomainia had nothing todo with dubing or anything todo with this dvd

[darwinwmu]

Hmmmm isnt Xenomania their recording team? They HAD to do something about the dubbing honey

[Geebob09]

Exactly ;) i was there i should know HAHAA

[cherylcolex]

fab song

[chelc4eva]

wooww....whether this is live or not...nicola sounds sensationallll

[darwinwmu]

Yep she does

[marcusmooney23]

leave sarah alone shes just trying to enjoy herself and plus she probably chanfes it each time to make it feel different cos they have perform this everday for each tour

[ParisienneGirl]

I hate that Sarah tries to turn all her parts into "rock chick" parts,even in slow songs. This is a ballad,not a bloody drunken piss-up.

[Geebob09]

Ahaaaaaaaa Good one !

[kahraba]

its obcious that its isnt live.. some parts are, on kim and nicola but not on nadine for sum reason...

[chococat88888]

it's just nadine. I'm sure they have their reasons, like she probably had to rest her voice.

[TomEd171]

if they didnt sing live it would be all over the papers, like when britteny mimed on the x factor, i can asure you they ARE singing live, the dvd has been dubed but that doesnt do anything to the voices, it just lowers the sound of the audience, so you can hear them sing.

[hellu882]

hehe , in original video and song sarah did not sing her part two times ! and u can heard that its live !

[TomEd171]

lol u replied to me on this vid, but i didnt even post a comment ?

[hellu882]

yes u did

[TomEd171]

lol where?

[TomEd171]

sorrry yes i did :p i forgot

[hellu882]

it is live !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!

[eastendersroxyrules]

do they smoke ???

[nancey08]

yup i think all them do...? x

[hellu882]

yes , unfortunally , but kim and nic dont , and chez leave it to

[abbylou214]

1:58 to 2:05

how cute is kimberly!

[beci431]

they are if you look closely at the bottom of the mic the red lights on and it mean he mics on

[cartoonhero07]

they not lipsynining they are all siging live but beofre they relased the dvd they eddited it and dubbed there voices a bit mostly nadines for sum reason ! wich is soooo anoying cs they are amazimg !!!!

[blackwaterboy]

I wonder why they do that, it's so annoying and pointless. I remember they did that with Spice Girls concerts too, one I taped live on Sky but when it came out on video (lol) it was completely dubbed.

[kahraba]

kimberley is so great live, always! she sings in soo much harmony..

i relly wish that cheryl and nadine stops the smoking, cuz it affects the voice so much.

im a singer and i used to smoke and it does affect, thats why i quiet..

[20tartley09]

there allllllllllll live

[kahraba]

what, why is nadine not singing live, it sounds like it, nicola and kimberley were awesome!

[linacurre]

I know Nadine isnt, Sarah and Nicola are for sure.

I dont know about Cheryl and Kimberley.

[SClubRoxs]

How do you know?... Because they do not sounds like they are lip synching

[linacurre]

they sang live there,

but a lot of it was dubbed over in the editing process.

you can tell.

[videowhizzkid]

I REALLLLYYY hope that they have a bridge at the out of control tour as i'm block A2, and imagine the view if that came over :o

[Strapsenkoenig]

The best song on the DVD I think.

Nicola sounds exactly like at Wembley.

Sarahs part is very good.

And I like the Idea with the bridge.

[Squirrelunderabus]

I was expecting this dvd with all my heart, then I saw the amazing cover art and I was like "YES, the first ever thing I'm going to get myself from 'international internet shops'" (don't live in UK and I've always been very wary about eBay's and Amazon's...) But this dub (and overall sound quality) is such... a huge let down =((( I kind of don't want to buy it anymore, I'm kinda tight on money and... It's still great to see the Girls, but it reeks of disappointment.

[webby686]

im totally with you. i live in the US and bought it online. since i cant make it to the UK for a show, i was excited for this dvd. but so much of it is overdubbed with the original album tracks it was really depressing. and then the live performances were recorded poorly. its still a great show to watch and i love the girls, but seriously....

[Squirrelunderabus]

Nadine sang live at the venue, but it's been dubbed over in the post-production. The dub doesn't match her lip movement.

[j3ss1grl]

i liked the version from the chemistry tour better, but they're still great.

[snubblebunny]

flip sake i appreciate that they wanted to release this with dubbed vocals of nadine but the leastg they could have done was include the vocals from the other girls, she practically had the second chorus to her self, they did such a bad job fading the real with the synch that it sounded like sarah forgot to sing her piece!!

[missdeluxe]

god i love nadine's accent!

[jess0300]

omg luv cheryl so so much

[hellu882]

omg , how good is sarah !!!!!

love this ,.

[ILOVEGA959]

did they cut out the video of them backstage in between biology and whole lotta history?

[linacurre]

Yep.

[ILOVEGA959]

WHAT I LOVED THAT!!

[linacurre]

I know, me too :(

[katielainespicer2]

is that video on youtube anywhere

[ILOVEGA959]

i think somewhere. it's not in good quality tho

[doctorwho35]

Hey what's the video called??

Maybe I can find it 2 watch. I wuz good!!

[ILOVEGA959]

idk

[doctorwho35]

Do u ave 2 type summit more. Cuz I typed tha nd I couldnt find it. Lol!

[KerryPanda]

whole lotta history

[doctorwho35]

I was on about the video of them backstage in between biology and whole lotta history.

What's that called, so I can find it on Youtube?? Please x

[KerryPanda]

There isn't one! I just checked on my copy of the dvd for you. It goes from when they stop moving on the turntable, to shots of the audience, then they start walking up onto the bridge. You see them backstage after Jump, and in the behind the scenes documentary on the dvd.

[doctorwho35]

Is there one actually on YouTube??

I not then can u put it on (if u know how 2 plz)?