Yup, first Tan Sau was missing, you went straight for the Guan Sau, and couple other minor mistakes for what my Si-Hing would make noise about, but otherwise good job, you helped me to remember couple of parts ;) ...
To all the haters and bad intended commentators: This place( You Tube) in its origin was a site to share experienced memories and events. When someone exposes his/hers activities, their main purpose with rare exceptions, is to share any aspect of their life, to celebrated, to commemorate. I have almost 35 years in the Martial Artsand during that time I 've learned to recognize that any step or achievement counts. If you don't have anything good to say, don't say anything.
I have done wing chun for years and taught it. I am glad to see people come on here and show there journey. people forget what martial arts are about. we should support our fellow martial artist not tear them down. there are many different lineages meaning many different ways to do things. i thought this video is fine. if you lineage teaches different doesn't mean he is wrong just he does it a different way. don't let people get you down and keep the heart of the warrior.
good form. alot of people on you tube are alittle more sloppy lol! hope you do some more videos and do let bad comments on here get you down. i love wing chun
Thanks for your greetings. appreciate for that. I ve better things to do in life than to take childish judgement of bad comments, lol. I ve respect for the word of real warriors not for the ppl that just like to show up.
look in this way.I respect the opinion tht anyone can have about this as long as they a have respectful way to express their self.I thanks for that and I learn if it s a quality information.You really can tell ' this is correct, this is incorrect ' and give me your why.At the end It s just about a form. Simple as that. But If you just have a childlike mind and try to sound cool to say that, I seriously recommend not to underestimate somebody just for a body movement.You can get a surprise
well performed Siu Nim Tao. Looks a lot like Leung Ting lineage. But I really study a lot Siu Nim taos on youtube. From Hongkong, mainland Wing Chun branches and so on. I dont understand why so much people think they know the only truth. But you can say that these guys with such mindset understand not a little about Wing Chun. The form always reminds you on little ideas. Wing Chun internal and external is simple and pure. There is nothing wrong with this view. Just open your minds.
Wow! That's oldscool Leung Ting SNT form for me. thanx for posting. I started wing chun training in 2002 and with these techniques and form, applications worked well.
Nowadays I train in the Practical Wing Chun from Wan Kam Leung.*check the difference in angles of the SNT on youtube ;)
One tip though: keep your shoulder low when you perform the wu-sao backwards..
Wish you lots of fun in training at your Wing Chun school.
I am really getting tired of all the martial arts "experts" telling others how to do it. Most of the time they think their way is the right way. The important thing is that you understand what you are doing and why! You have to know what you want to achieve with all you learn. So be critical , but don't talk about wrong or right so fast, because that shows you are a mindless follower...
even the very beginning when you do garn sao an when go into tan sao, you do it as chum kiu way!!! and the third section... has some other parts, who tought you that? :O
When you go from lower kang sau to upper kang sau.. You make a very nice spiral motion but when you do that , one pak sau and you arms are both locked up... I see a lot of Wing Chun video's about Siu Nim Tao but the are powerless and more stylised then usefull..
It seems very common nowadays to train Wing Chun, VingTsun etc. in a soft way. It should never be forgotten that your training is your preparation for self defence, and if you think that you will survive with soft movements you are mistaken.
This is the only form of fung fu were it looks like his feet are nailed to the ground. Obviously this style is only used in a very confined space. But in open spaces like the beautiful park he is in, this style would be no good if the attacker knows Chen style Tai Chi, or Akido. Remember, Wing Chun was invented by a woman, i am not knocking this fact, but i must say that back in the day woman were only found in confined spaces, like kichens and bedrooms, houses, were this style works best.
ich stimme allen zu die schriebn das der erste falsch ist und er beim 4. das ende vergaß und guckt euch mal den 6. satz and das sind i-wie recht unförmig aus (also ich hab das zumindest anders gelernt^^)
There are many different ways of practicing siu nim tao. You are missing out on alot of key parts in the form that are essential for your qi gong. FIngers especially and your bong is slightly off....not loose enough. I will attempt to put up a demo.
I have studied traditional ving tsu under the moy yat lineage. GOod work keep it going!
@Tuxre there is wrong he locked his arms up when doing going from lower kang sau to uper kang sau he made a very stylized motion which made his arm crossed before his chest..it take time and have no function but to put your self in danger..One pak sau on his arms and one hit in the face...
che lineaggio è ?? anche se siamo quasi tutti figli di leung ting ad ogni modo manca il doppio toi sao prima dei doppi pugni alla fine della parte doppia .... ciao
sorry, but this is a poor excuse for a sil lim tao. it lacks relaxation, it's too quick and i wonder whether this guy could stop a newbie in a proper lineage.
This is prob the best Sil Nim Tao I've seen on youtube, Fook Sao does'nt drop, Pak Sao extends to the shoulder, Tan and punches are dead center with elbows right in. Great stuff!
Yup, first Tan Sau was missing, you went straight for the Guan Sau, and couple other minor mistakes for what my Si-Hing would make noise about, but otherwise good job, you helped me to remember couple of parts ;) ...
Sauerules 2 months ago
To all the haters and bad intended commentators: This place( You Tube) in its origin was a site to share experienced memories and events. When someone exposes his/hers activities, their main purpose with rare exceptions, is to share any aspect of their life, to celebrated, to commemorate. I have almost 35 years in the Martial Artsand during that time I 've learned to recognize that any step or achievement counts. If you don't have anything good to say, don't say anything.
aeortiz2004 3 months ago
I have done wing chun for years and taught it. I am glad to see people come on here and show there journey. people forget what martial arts are about. we should support our fellow martial artist not tear them down. there are many different lineages meaning many different ways to do things. i thought this video is fine. if you lineage teaches different doesn't mean he is wrong just he does it a different way. don't let people get you down and keep the heart of the warrior.
nico27004 4 months ago
good form. alot of people on you tube are alittle more sloppy lol! hope you do some more videos and do let bad comments on here get you down. i love wing chun
nico27004 4 months ago 2
Thanks for your greetings. appreciate for that. I ve better things to do in life than to take childish judgement of bad comments, lol. I ve respect for the word of real warriors not for the ppl that just like to show up.
bushidodharma 4 months ago
your technique is horrible have you ever used this nonsense in a real fight?
evilasian33 4 months ago
your style is weak and a form is not "just a form".
evilasian33 4 months ago
this guy obviously cannot fight in real life! hahaaha
evilasian33 4 months ago
look in this way.I respect the opinion tht anyone can have about this as long as they a have respectful way to express their self.I thanks for that and I learn if it s a quality information.You really can tell ' this is correct, this is incorrect ' and give me your why.At the end It s just about a form. Simple as that. But If you just have a childlike mind and try to sound cool to say that, I seriously recommend not to underestimate somebody just for a body movement.You can get a surprise
bushidodharma 4 months ago
Wish that was my back garden!
wingchunguru 6 months ago
well performed Siu Nim Tao. Looks a lot like Leung Ting lineage. But I really study a lot Siu Nim taos on youtube. From Hongkong, mainland Wing Chun branches and so on. I dont understand why so much people think they know the only truth. But you can say that these guys with such mindset understand not a little about Wing Chun. The form always reminds you on little ideas. Wing Chun internal and external is simple and pure. There is nothing wrong with this view. Just open your minds.
jomushin7 8 months ago
You forgot very many movmends!!!
2ReAce 9 months ago 2
incomplete Siu Nim Tao
00Ghz 10 months ago
Not sure if it's me, But you're hyper-exstending your arms at the start.
KingersXD 10 months ago
Wow! That's oldscool Leung Ting SNT form for me. thanx for posting. I started wing chun training in 2002 and with these techniques and form, applications worked well.
Nowadays I train in the Practical Wing Chun from Wan Kam Leung.*check the difference in angles of the SNT on youtube ;)
One tip though: keep your shoulder low when you perform the wu-sao backwards..
Wish you lots of fun in training at your Wing Chun school.
Kind kungfu regards from the Netherlands
maekelon8 10 months ago
I am really getting tired of all the martial arts "experts" telling others how to do it. Most of the time they think their way is the right way. The important thing is that you understand what you are doing and why! You have to know what you want to achieve with all you learn. So be critical , but don't talk about wrong or right so fast, because that shows you are a mindless follower...
ruud132 11 months ago 2
He forgot to pay his respects at the end
1stBANO 11 months ago
different from the way I know it, but still interesting.
do you train wing chun in Norway?
thekimjoa 11 months ago
even the very beginning when you do garn sao an when go into tan sao, you do it as chum kiu way!!! and the third section... has some other parts, who tought you that? :O
Eugealivingwarrior 11 months ago
you need to press the ellbows together behind your back..
asdErasdom 1 year ago
good, but some mistakes!
peaveyman212 1 year ago
When you go from lower kang sau to upper kang sau.. You make a very nice spiral motion but when you do that , one pak sau and you arms are both locked up... I see a lot of Wing Chun video's about Siu Nim Tao but the are powerless and more stylised then usefull..
Ben1987X 1 year ago
It seems very common nowadays to train Wing Chun, VingTsun etc. in a soft way. It should never be forgotten that your training is your preparation for self defence, and if you think that you will survive with soft movements you are mistaken.
MichaelBaker1100 1 year ago
Wing Tchun? it isn't Wing Chun or Ving/Vin Tsun ?
plgzao 1 year ago
fuckin norway :( im jealous. looks liek a beautiful place to practice
NexeusPariah 1 year ago
looks robotic
ForwardIntent 1 year ago
@ForwardIntent
it just the basic form of wing chun which let you to practice and to get use to the motion
klsuperman 1 year ago
where is work bady that is bad and your end is max bad WT is no onli hand job
Icebrus 1 year ago
i can play it better then u
Kazey0 1 year ago
Maybe, but this is still one of the best examples on youtube of sil nim tao.
SwedishHelicopter 1 year ago
Maybe, but this is still one of the best examples on youtube of sil nim tao.
SwedishHelicopter 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This is the only form of fung fu were it looks like his feet are nailed to the ground. Obviously this style is only used in a very confined space. But in open spaces like the beautiful park he is in, this style would be no good if the attacker knows Chen style Tai Chi, or Akido. Remember, Wing Chun was invented by a woman, i am not knocking this fact, but i must say that back in the day woman were only found in confined spaces, like kichens and bedrooms, houses, were this style works best.
macktheknife888 1 year ago
manca il doppio tanzao!!!
dvfcmsdi 1 year ago
ich stimme allen zu die schriebn das der erste falsch ist und er beim 4. das ende vergaß und guckt euch mal den 6. satz and das sind i-wie recht unförmig aus (also ich hab das zumindest anders gelernt^^)
xBooMSchakAx 1 year ago
in form 4 is one part missing... the hitting up move with the back of your hands...
bimbamo 2 years ago
There are many different ways of practicing siu nim tao. You are missing out on alot of key parts in the form that are essential for your qi gong. FIngers especially and your bong is slightly off....not loose enough. I will attempt to put up a demo.
I have studied traditional ving tsu under the moy yat lineage. GOod work keep it going!
sifumg 2 years ago
Nice me Pete Paijil (Moy Bagh Hugh) for a little while...
DistantSoul13 2 years ago
You missed the very end of part 4 ans you seem to have a tightened right shoulder...
Zazquatch1 2 years ago
Why the extra fist rings, no use i can think for them? and opponent shouldn't see your palm when going from offer to prayer.
rahvavaenlane 2 years ago
stimmt, der erste Satz is falsch und beim vierten Satz vergisst er den Schluss...
Tchika 2 years ago
Sein Stand ist falsch und er beginnt den ersten Satz nicht richtig.
bumshack007 2 years ago
Is the back ground real? Its bothering me so much I couldn't pay attention to the form
LittleJ922 2 years ago
dont think so, clouds arent moving
wingstoflie 2 years ago
lol, look one more time
misiekbtk 2 years ago
look faster , cloud are moving... lol...
peymey 2 years ago 7
He starts if off wrong... Arms are crossed above first, and then crossed downwards again - then back up, and then fisted and placed by the ribs...
joselimai 2 years ago 15
@joselimai
There is no "wrong", there is only "different"
Tuxre 1 year ago 2
@Tuxre there is wrong he locked his arms up when doing going from lower kang sau to uper kang sau he made a very stylized motion which made his arm crossed before his chest..it take time and have no function but to put your self in danger..One pak sau on his arms and one hit in the face...
Ben1987X 1 year ago
@joselimai
No. You retard. Not in Yip Man or WSL lineage.
Don't comment on something that you don't know shit about.
Shaolinkungfucat 9 months ago
@joselimai ip man did it the same way as he did in a video so i think he did it right
whoooohaaaa 6 months ago
he looks like me
physikphilosoph 2 years ago
che lineaggio è ?? anche se siamo quasi tutti figli di leung ting ad ogni modo manca il doppio toi sao prima dei doppi pugni alla fine della parte doppia .... ciao
natharaja 2 years ago
sorry, but this is a poor excuse for a sil lim tao. it lacks relaxation, it's too quick and i wonder whether this guy could stop a newbie in a proper lineage.
intirayami 2 years ago
way too fast!!! try it for 20 min w a block in between ur knees
greglewis26 2 years ago
non so dove stavi ma fa molto wutang..vero?
xD
5/5 bravo
suriken94 2 years ago
This is prob the best Sil Nim Tao I've seen on youtube, Fook Sao does'nt drop, Pak Sao extends to the shoulder, Tan and punches are dead center with elbows right in. Great stuff!
UniversalExpert 2 years ago
why no final upwards movement in the 4th set?
0ffh 2 years ago
thank you for uploading the video, it helped a lot. is it EWTO wing tsun form?
Overcrook65 3 years ago
wow, nice background.... where's this at
hgamer 3 years ago
The place s name is Geiranger, in Norway. It s a very beautiful scenario.
bushidodharma 3 years ago
@bushidodharma
i love this place
klsuperman 1 year ago