Why did you neg yourself? Now people are pretending to be nice and pity you. Yeah your not attractive. The video clip seems to somewhat grasp the songs message. Good work
The chorus doesn't sound like a complete rip off. It sounds like the "I want" and "him" in the chorus's lyrical content may be an homage to Elliot. The music isn't the same. Really all you have to do is listen to any other song in Sufjan's catalog to realize he doesn't have to rip people off.
ALRIGHT IM A HUGE ELLIOTT SMITH AND IVE NEVER REALLY HEARD OF THIS GUY BUT YES THE CHORUS DOES SOUND LIKKE A COMPLETE RIPOFF OF ROMAN CANDLE BUT BESIDES THAT IT DOESNT SOUND LIKE ELLIOTT SO LETS QUIT FIGHTING ABOUT IT
wow after reading all the comments on roman candle i thought this song would be the same but it's completely different, a few lines seem similar. anyone who think's it's a complete ripoff obviously hasn't written a song before.
wow after reading all the comments on roman candle i thought this song would be the same but it's completely different, a few lines seem similar. anyone who think's it's a complete ripoff obviously hasn't written a song before.
You guys should check out The Perennials, they play really beautiful music. You can find them by searching "theperennialsarewe" on youtube. They are also on facebook, myspace and itunes.
I actually thought it was very artistic. The black & white went really good with this song. It looks like something I'd actually seen on Mtv. (If Mtv ever became cool enough to play Sufjan Stevens.) ;]
oh look. another low quality home recorded video with no direction and completely irrelevant footage set to an indie song. your so artistic... fucking hipsters. why did you even make this?
@TremulantMannequin Thank you so much. And I'm really not a hipster, to be honest, Sufjan Stevens is the only "alternative" artist I listen to. Oh, and if you read the description you'd have noticed I did it because I hadn't anything interesting to do and I wanted to try Windows Movie Maker. And so what if I did? Does it bother you? Can't you sleep at night?
@CoobyMX you can just stop with the whole "i did this because i was bored" routine. it's obvious you spent quite a bit of time on this. oh yeah you're not a hipster, you just own a fedora and wear a beanie in the middle of the day. you should just delete this piece of shit.
@TremulantMannequin Oh EXCUSE me, even better you said "INDIE" that's even further away from this man's style. Congrats. :l
What you said: oh look. another low quality home recorded video with no direction and completely irrelevant footage set to an indie song. your so artistic... fucking hipsters. why did you even make this?
@TremulantMannequin wow another troll posting on something so stupid. "If" its so irrelevant why would they (you the most important person in the world) waste your time watching it? Let alone comment on it?
(filterguy2525) I was thinking exactly the same thing.....they are sung the same at those parts.....an the only word he changed was Kill instead of Hurt.
i wanna hurt him, i wanna give him pain, i'm a roman cande, my head is fu of fames.
i wanna ki him. i wanna cut his brain, and when it's over, i swear i' fee no pain.
i'd say it's a huge stretch to ca that a rip off. totay different. and even if they were more simiar, everyone has fet that way about someone at some time. that's just being human, not so crazy. by the way, sorry one of my keys is busted.
I think this style is much better then Roman Candle can ever be. Yeah Elliot Smith is really really really good but this song is better then the one being compared. This song makes me wanna read the short story/book based on this. It sounds weird but intresting the(shortstory/book)
not sure, but I'm guessing its about 2 soldiers in a guerilla force, one recruited him then left him in the line of fire. or it could be biblical, I wouldnt know
He stole the cargo,Took every chance to leave. There's no permanence
When you never leave the stall. He ran to other wars, Won't write me at all. I want to kill him, I want to cut his brain, And when it's over, I know I'll feel okay. I want to kill him, I want to cut his face, And when it's over, I know I'll feel okay. I want,I want, I want, I want.
To tell you the truth, I have no idea. I guess it has a different meaning for each person. But I've heard it's inspired in a short story written by Sherwood Anderson "The Man Who Became a Woman" ... or something like that.
Sufjan Stevens was a student in a grade above me. He was so handsome. I had a crush on him as did probably everyone else. Alanson High School is where he attended. Sufjan has another brother who I think was older and some sisters. They all had odd names since most other kids were named Tom, Dick and Harry. lol. Nice to see he made something of his life. Hope all the best for him.
This song is about a story, The Man Who Became a Woman by Sherwood Anderson. It has some similarities to Roman Candle, but has a completely different meaning and it is written in character.
I think that Roman Candle and Kill are completely different songs with completely different meanings....I can't really judge either together because it just isn't fair.
Both Sufjan and Elliott are/were brilliant artists, and you simply cannot justly compare the two.
What kind of camera did you use?
snjmom 1 month ago
The black and white cinematography really goes with the song! Good job!
tooskyblue 2 months ago
Great video better song! =) Thanks !! ^^
ToRReNyO 4 months ago
Why did you neg yourself? Now people are pretending to be nice and pity you. Yeah your not attractive. The video clip seems to somewhat grasp the songs message. Good work
KastDND 5 months ago
You're definitely not ugly. Actually, I think you're kinda cute :)
abadee8 7 months ago
Good service!
osvaldocelso 8 months ago
You made great things when you are mading nothing!
osvaldocelso 8 months ago
Actually.. you are ugly. And you might need some lexapro.
MrOscarIsYourFriend 8 months ago
@MrOscarIsYourFriend dude, stop trollin, im pretty sure you are uglier
cheponchocho2 8 months ago 3
The chorus doesn't sound like a complete rip off. It sounds like the "I want" and "him" in the chorus's lyrical content may be an homage to Elliot. The music isn't the same. Really all you have to do is listen to any other song in Sufjan's catalog to realize he doesn't have to rip people off.
jordansparrow 8 months ago 3
Comment removed
Srbabiruso 8 months ago
This song refers to Sherwood Anderson's, "The Man Who became a Woman."
Srbabiruso 8 months ago
are you depressed?
frizzybob 9 months ago
Both an Elliott and Sufjan fan.
Even if it was derived from Elliott who cares? Because Elliott might be inspirational to Sufjan.
shhmellshlikeasshhhh 10 months ago 3
ALRIGHT IM A HUGE ELLIOTT SMITH AND IVE NEVER REALLY HEARD OF THIS GUY BUT YES THE CHORUS DOES SOUND LIKKE A COMPLETE RIPOFF OF ROMAN CANDLE BUT BESIDES THAT IT DOESNT SOUND LIKE ELLIOTT SO LETS QUIT FIGHTING ABOUT IT
peacelovemusic2461 10 months ago
...slices to the heart, with a precision that is silky, while dancing along a razor's edge...
TheHermeticHermit 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
wow after reading all the comments on roman candle i thought this song would be the same but it's completely different, a few lines seem similar. anyone who think's it's a complete ripoff obviously hasn't written a song before.
donjezza 11 months ago
wow after reading all the comments on roman candle i thought this song would be the same but it's completely different, a few lines seem similar. anyone who think's it's a complete ripoff obviously hasn't written a song before.
donjezza 11 months ago 2
You guys should check out The Perennials, they play really beautiful music. You can find them by searching "theperennialsarewe" on youtube. They are also on facebook, myspace and itunes.
1thing2do 1 year ago
I really like this. Thanks for making/posting it.
cloudylissa 1 year ago
I want to kill him
-I want to hurt him
I want to cut his brain
-I want to give him pain
Wow, fuck this guy.
JizzOrDie 1 year ago
@JizzOrDie You have a problem then my crazy sir. You should figure them out, or just listen to moar Sufjan and that should solve it.
Anders898Avey 1 year ago 2
@Anders898Avey Nah, this ripoff can suck my dick.
JizzOrDie 1 year ago
@JizzOrDie Ripoff? What the Jizz are you talking about?
Anders898Avey 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@JizzOrDie You're one fucked up individual.
Kent1261 6 months ago
this was beautiful! i hope you do another edit like this one :)
sheppy1994 1 year ago
this was beautiful! i hope you do another edit like this one :)
sheppy1994 1 year ago
This song takes me to a place I can never replace.
wigwomwill 1 year ago
hey man great vid, dont ever let anyone stop you from doing what makes you happy. thats the truth of life right there!
lachance1111 1 year ago
This is mexico! I love the song
niithaiiziithah1 1 year ago
sufjan just makes the most haunting music...great job man :)
shisksjis 1 year ago
Goodjob on the video I liked it a lot.
banshek7 1 year ago
This is beautiful.
LilyCraven1 1 year ago
I actually thought it was very artistic. The black & white went really good with this song. It looks like something I'd actually seen on Mtv. (If Mtv ever became cool enough to play Sufjan Stevens.) ;]
lazyemo333 1 year ago
at 0:56 is that dot on your face a chicken pox scar?
xxvietbebe 1 year ago 2
How can anybody even say the song is good when he fucking ripped this off of Elliott Smith?
gotf 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
oh look. another low quality home recorded video with no direction and completely irrelevant footage set to an indie song. your so artistic... fucking hipsters. why did you even make this?
TremulantMannequin 1 year ago
@TremulantMannequin Thank you so much. And I'm really not a hipster, to be honest, Sufjan Stevens is the only "alternative" artist I listen to. Oh, and if you read the description you'd have noticed I did it because I hadn't anything interesting to do and I wanted to try Windows Movie Maker. And so what if I did? Does it bother you? Can't you sleep at night?
"Your" so smart.
CoobyMX 1 year ago 57
@CoobyMX
Owned.
Prouda you. c:
Skiz0id 1 year ago
@CoobyMX you can just stop with the whole "i did this because i was bored" routine. it's obvious you spent quite a bit of time on this. oh yeah you're not a hipster, you just own a fedora and wear a beanie in the middle of the day. you should just delete this piece of shit.
TremulantMannequin 1 year ago
@TremulantMannequin What the fuck is your problem? He wears what he wants. Go fuck yourself. Seriously dude, kill yourself. You suck
LotusElf1 1 year ago
@LotusElf1 HAhahahahahaha that's awesome.
cloudylissa 1 year ago
@cloudylissa ^^
LotusElf1 1 year ago
@CoobyMX like your answer. these people are exhausting. always something negative on their lips. don't let it bother you.
Zahnbuersteundpasta 1 year ago
@CoobyMX hahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahhahahahahaha
Tibbert67 1 year ago
@TremulantMannequin Sufjan Stevens isn't even alternative he's folk. Listen to his other works and you'd know.
blackluckycharms 1 year ago
@blackluckycharms you show me where i said sufjan stevens was alternative.
TremulantMannequin 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@TremulantMannequin Oh EXCUSE me, even better you said "INDIE" that's even further away from this man's style. Congrats. :l
What you said: oh look. another low quality home recorded video with no direction and completely irrelevant footage set to an indie song. your so artistic... fucking hipsters. why did you even make this?
blackluckycharms 1 year ago
@TremulantMannequin
Some people feel like they have to tear others down to build themselves up. I hope you stop feeling this way. It's sad.
@CoobyMX
Thank you for sharing your vid!
jzgs423 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TremulantMannequin
Some people feel like they have to tear others down to build themselves up. I hope you stop feeling this way. It's sad.
@CoobyMX
Thank you for sharing your vid!
jzgs423 1 year ago
@TremulantMannequin
Some people feel like they have to tear others down to build themselves up. I hope you stop feeling this way. It's sad.
@CoobyMX
Thank you for sharing your vid!
jzgs423 1 year ago
@TremulantMannequin
Some people feel like they have to tear others down to build themselves up. I hope you stop feeling this way. It's sad.
@CoobyMX
Thank you for sharing your vid!
jzgs423 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@TremulantMannequin
Some people feel like they have to tear others down to build themselves up. I hope you stop feeling this way. It's sad.
@CoobyMX
Thank you for sharing your vid!
jzgs423 1 year ago
@TremulantMannequin wow another troll posting on something so stupid. "If" its so irrelevant why would they (you the most important person in the world) waste your time watching it? Let alone comment on it?
good job bub
netforce0 1 year ago 3
this guy is really good. i like the darkness of his music
MatterMadeMusic 1 year ago
Fabulous clip and acting too. I can't believe you're not a professional.
notcrumb 1 year ago
i hope you will often have nothing to do in future because this videoclip really is great!! Thanx
lukasrosenbauer 1 year ago
I like Elliot Smith, but his Roman Candle is not even close to as good as this track. Elliot Smith is still awesome dont get me wrong.
AustinJohnson07 1 year ago
I like this .
jordanariel1hikaru 1 year ago
I just noticed the chorus is a lot like roman candle by Elliott smith
heffaface 1 year ago
nice video
loulou443 1 year ago
its amazing that even something that sounds so sad, can make a sad person so happy. im in love.
sunsetoverflowing 1 year ago
It's so nice to realize this kind of music touches so many different kinds of people. Good video. : )
Moththemotti 2 years ago 7
Dramatica.
TheFoucaultDude 2 years ago
Chill....CoobyMX gets pussy!
BlackedOutBoy 2 years ago
@BlackedOutBoy i don't think having sex really relieves the guilt of killing a man.
MidGroundInertia 2 years ago 2
oh sure it does..
shanexscene 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you are an ugly man..
but that is all right.
TheAllyamc 2 years ago
wow what a nice person you are, why don't you post some pics of yourself so we can judge you on here?
mellowtonen 2 years ago
it was a joke, but okay..
TheAllyamc 2 years ago
Awesome song!! I just love this!
FlyLaika 2 years ago
Those horses always want to take revenge when their riders don't write.
thatcherpoe 2 years ago
anyone know where to get a copy of this album? cus i tried to order it from a local CD store and they said it was discontinued.
sk8cre8 2 years ago
iTunes has it.
ClassicDisaster667 2 years ago
This is a weird song but a great video !! :] I love Sufjan Stevens
scrubsfan244 2 years ago
haha i was thinking the opposite. it's so random. the beanie is funny though. lol
bryankalen 2 years ago
its about a horse! like mare?!! "theresno permanence when you never leave the stall." look up the lyrics and youll agree!
hameater554 2 years ago
there's some potential! and stop calling yourself ugly :P
lukeisastalker 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
ugly
especiallynow 2 years ago
The chorus of this song is a total ripoff of Elliott Smith's Roman Candle. It's crazy.
filterguy2525 2 years ago 33
(filterguy2525) I was thinking exactly the same thing.....they are sung the same at those parts.....an the only word he changed was Kill instead of Hurt.
mellowtonen 2 years ago
i wanna hurt him, i wanna give him pain, i'm a roman cande, my head is fu of fames.
i wanna ki him. i wanna cut his brain, and when it's over, i swear i' fee no pain.
i'd say it's a huge stretch to ca that a rip off. totay different. and even if they were more simiar, everyone has fet that way about someone at some time. that's just being human, not so crazy. by the way, sorry one of my keys is busted.
wackydelly84 1 year ago
@filterguy2525 lol I thought the same thing at first xD
XxKaoticFatexX 1 year ago
@filterguy2525
i actually htought he was singing roman candle when i first listened
preyaswolves 1 year ago
@filterguy2525 everything is a ripoff lol
looneYeah 1 year ago
@filterguy2525 It's more a tribute than anything else. Sufjan is very conscious of his similarities to Elliot.
rockon6191 1 year ago
@filterguy2525 Yeah, is that intentional? Never heard of this dude before today, but I'm a big E. Smith fan. Total Rip off.
TheHappyNewYears 11 months ago
would make me crack up if he cut himself.
omg that'd be hilarious.
but really nice video mate, kudos to you :D
itsmealice 2 years ago 3
really liked it.
and indeed, you are NOT ugly:)
RemiFrance 2 years ago
nice video :) & you're NOT UGLY!! :)
TheWayToWonderland 2 years ago
really nice video, sir<3
hollypsychedelic 2 years ago
nice video :) and youre NOT ugly haha.
falastinicoor 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
awesome song how does he sing at the same time as playing tht its soo hard
jakestupidme 2 years ago
his first album is my favorite
robs70986987 2 years ago
i love this song! and i liked your video. it was interesting.
& you're not ugly!! (:
thousandxtears 2 years ago 19
Haha, thank you :)
CoobyMX 2 years ago 7
@CoobyMX you're beautiful :)
wotsherface 1 year ago
well that was awkward
drunkfunkmonkey 2 years ago 3
I think this style is much better then Roman Candle can ever be. Yeah Elliot Smith is really really really good but this song is better then the one being compared. This song makes me wanna read the short story/book based on this. It sounds weird but intresting the(shortstory/book)
AustinJohnson07 2 years ago
this song sounds just like roman candle
wowandrew5243 2 years ago 4
it is cool, that you make an own video !
LovelyMarilea 2 years ago 2
Song- good.
Video- bad (obviously because you didn't really spend much time on it) but not horrible.
rickman33 2 years ago
well done...thank's a lot
Weibsvoice 2 years ago
keys to an artsy video
1 set it to a slow acoustic song
2 close up on a face
3 shaky camera or childhood videos shown in reverse
4 nature contrasted by a town
5 some sad or glazed looking kid...
and there you have it you are an artist
twizelby 2 years ago 9
Haha great comment :P
melonbandit 2 years ago
thanks im a giver ya know its just...who I am
twizelby 2 years ago
he's bashing jesus damn thast all the songs about
kazlaz 2 years ago
Comment removed
WillyMackProductions 2 years ago
ok whats this song about? lol respond if you know lol great song and video by tha way
hameater554 2 years ago
Maybe Cain & Able?
dresssexyatmyfuneral 2 years ago
I think, that the song is about Unicorns, and how one of the Unicorns was not bred to realize his full corniness and now he has murderous tendencies.
Shokk1234567 2 years ago 3
I misread that as tentacles at first, which is also funny/
npc223 2 years ago
not sure, but I'm guessing its about 2 soldiers in a guerilla force, one recruited him then left him in the line of fire. or it could be biblical, I wouldnt know
npc223 2 years ago
sylar perhaps lol
harrytheblurfan 2 years ago
OMG haha
Actually this is my Sylar song. :) I always play it when I daydream about that character :D
Tahaji 2 years ago
Sylar rules. Sufjan rules. And so does Blur! So much win going on here, it's out of control.
pollyethylene 2 years ago 2
good song. very calming.
perfumeelisabet 2 years ago 2
We were riding side by side.
Into the frontier.
He left me without a ride.
Where did the hour go
When the champions intercede?
He stole the cargo,Took every chance to leave. There's no permanence
When you never leave the stall. He ran to other wars, Won't write me at all. I want to kill him, I want to cut his brain, And when it's over, I know I'll feel okay. I want to kill him, I want to cut his face, And when it's over, I know I'll feel okay. I want,I want, I want, I want.
mishmo 2 years ago
He ran to other wars,
Won't write me at all.
I want to kill him,
I want to cut his brain,
And when it's over,
I know I'll feel okay.
He was a champion;
mishmo 2 years ago
He took the stable, Bred me to be a mare.
Made the bretheren able, Gave me a room. I never asked him. I never meant meant to stay. He dressed the table,
Wore a dress to be my mare. There's no permanence When you never leave the stall.
mishmo 2 years ago
hatking you're right
flattermanntheripper 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Be honest
If u really like someone right now,
or miss them right at this moment,
or can't get them out of your head,
Then copy and paste this on 10 vids within 5 minutes,
And whoever you are missing,
Will surprise you tomorow
ipLelouch 2 years ago
Wouldn't a rock cover of this song just be amazing.
HatKing 2 years ago 9
This has been flagged as spam show
Be honest
If u really like someone right now,
or miss them right at this moment,
or can't get them out of your head,
Then copy and paste this on 10 vids within 5 minutes,
And whoever you are missing,
Will surprise you tomorow
crazydrunkendriver 2 years ago
you´re super cute
jessaonfire 2 years ago 7
this sounds alot like elliott smiths roman candle
geck0788 2 years ago 8
I like your vid, it goes really well for the song
piemorgan 3 years ago 6
Hm, I hear your point. Both amazing artists.
pollyethylene 2 years ago 4
i thought reactions where to say that you liked/ unliked the video and give your opinion, but still behave..
xDieD777 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
tagg125 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this guy is such a tool, who listens to this crap, STOP TALKING ABOUT CHICAGO U PIECE OF GARBAGE DOUCHE, I FEEL LIKE I AM IN A N ELEVATOR
stvmb482 3 years ago
then don't listen. stop being bitter
sereneking 3 years ago 8
You have no taste
tagg125 3 years ago
What do the lyrics mean?
AustinJohnson07 3 years ago
To tell you the truth, I have no idea. I guess it has a different meaning for each person. But I've heard it's inspired in a short story written by Sherwood Anderson "The Man Who Became a Woman" ... or something like that.
CoobyMX 3 years ago
Sufjan Stevens was a student in a grade above me. He was so handsome. I had a crush on him as did probably everyone else. Alanson High School is where he attended. Sufjan has another brother who I think was older and some sisters. They all had odd names since most other kids were named Tom, Dick and Harry. lol. Nice to see he made something of his life. Hope all the best for him.
feelzthelove 3 years ago 6
Oh, lucky you!! :)
CoobyMX 3 years ago
Please explain these lyrics. Im intrested in the music of Sufjan Stevens.
AustinJohnson07 3 years ago
OH MY GOD. youre so lucky. he is indeed a handsome fellow.
shazam15 3 years ago
1:36 That's a cute hat...where'd you buy it orrrr did you make it...nvm I'll probably make it one day.
healingv1sion 3 years ago 3
Hehe, thanks! My grandma made it for me.
CoobyMX 3 years ago
When I first heard this song,I found it sounded so much like Roman Candle, well the obvious part anyways. But its so Sufjan still.
Clearly he didn't nor does he have to rip off other artists.
Heateanapple 3 years ago 4
this is exactly my first reaction
dancetoska 3 years ago
Just caught that about Roman Candle.
Sufjan is killer.
cloakofthenight 3 years ago
Did he mean to rip off the lyrics of Roman Candle, there not exactly the same nor does the song sound exactly the same but damn seems like a rip off.
davidj209 3 years ago
Homage, not rip-off.
andkevinsaidFTW 3 years ago 6
Oh, I caught that.. when I read this.
Lorsbloodytask 3 years ago
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ i love it !!
ilovemyswallow 3 years ago 3
This song is about a story, The Man Who Became a Woman by Sherwood Anderson. It has some similarities to Roman Candle, but has a completely different meaning and it is written in character.
ruthg10 3 years ago 3
Comment removed
almostbluevision 3 years ago
Does the shaky cam hurt the video, or does it amplify the mood of the song?
I'll think on this.
NelsonClay 3 years ago 4
I think that Roman Candle and Kill are completely different songs with completely different meanings....I can't really judge either together because it just isn't fair.
Both Sufjan and Elliott are/were brilliant artists, and you simply cannot justly compare the two.
Zeldreaisme 3 years ago 5
Great song. awesome video kid- got the vibe of the song down
dbeneath 3 years ago 6
amee el gorritoooo !! *-*
xbitterpillxX 3 years ago
Yeah, Roman Candle is 100 times better considering this is simply the same.
ColbyVid 3 years ago
hahaha no habia visto este video tuyooo con tu gorrito para la nieve sales bien ehhh tkkmm
ilovenellyfurtado 3 years ago
qe lindo eres :) me gustaria conocerte
taniaamm 3 years ago
Sufjan is amazing X]
thnx 4 vid
TheCama 4 years ago