Anton Bruckner Symphony 6 - First Mov. Part 3

[yale1167]

Caro Pingo,penso si tratti di una consuetudine ormai purtroppo consolidata nel tempo quella di sentire sempre un certo tipo di esecuzione. In un certo senso si tratta di una globalizzazione del gusto di direttori che "impongono" come va eseguito un certo compositore piuttosto che un'altro mascherandosi poi dietro la veste dell'interpretazione. Una considerazione: perchè un compositore deve impiegare anni x scrivere una sinfonia con migliaia di note per tutti gli strumenti e nn farle sentire?

[iLoveCheerLL]

It's great but WAY better to listen to it live.

[LuisFredTrombon]

That last exposition by the brass is just hair raising!

[iduefoscari]

This is the finest of all Bruckners Chorales.I dont know how many modulations there are but I gave up after counting thirty.The more I hear Bruckner the more I believe that perhaps with Beethoven he was the greatest of  all symphonists.

[belianis]

@iduefoscari I wonder what the wild and rebellious Herr Beethoven would have made of music so powerful and majestic coming out of a man as meek and humble as Herr Bruckner.

[lewars1912]

@iduefoscari Beethoven, Bruckner, Sibelius, especially his 3rd, 5th and 7th. There are so many great symphonies. Carl Nielson's 5th, Vaughan Williams' 5th, etc.

[ultradmann]

This first movement is incredible!!! Its has its innocent and sweet moments but when its time to get serious the brass do play around. For that moment at 5:23 to the end I want to be a trumpet player I swear. You can just hear them calling out to you even till that rit comes in on the last note.!!! Amazing!!!! (Still clarinet player for life though lol)

[301250]

A conductor who can rank alongside the famed Brucknerians like Jochum, Karajan, Tintner et al.in this sublime repertoire. Danke Pingopalla. sd goh (malaysia)

[bruckner4444]

De los más bellos pasajes brucknerianos.

[lewars1912]

The bit beginning at 3:23 is Bruckner at his most sublime.

[iduefoscari]

@lewars1912 You are so right.This chorale is the essence of Bruckner.

[CoulterOrganbuilder]

the height of the sticks of the timpanist at the end is stunning.... what a sound

[DoctorClarinet]

You're right. Wow.

[magdluke]

Yeah, he does it perfectly - a real "all or nothing" moment, I think!

[MahlerTitan]

actually, there is a recording of Sinopoli conducting Bruckner 6th with philharmonia.

[benzylalk]

War Manuel Neuer(Torwart bei Schalke) mal Paukist der Münchner Philharmoniker?

Quatsch, natürlich nicht, aber eine Ähnlichkeit besteht schon.

[otterhouse]

Thanks, I had a very nice breakfast with Bruckner this morning... :)

-----------------------------

Rolf, Netherlands.

I am a collector of classical 78's and lp's

Click "otterhouse" above to see some of

my collection.

[DumboTheJumbo]

Veramente bella!

la musica classica rappresenta l'apice della tecnica di esecuzione

[sabadabaduz]

upload movement 2 - NOW! for me, celi is barely ever too slow. Especially the 2nd movement - gosh, I actually thought I had already conquered Bruckner, but it was not until listening to this version of the 6th. Nowadays, this sencond movement is among my very favourite pieces, maybe THE favourite (even above 2nd movement of the 8th)

[hung30306guy]

wow

[Pingopalla]

do u like Celibidache interpretation?

I think that's too slow! In part two there is a beautiful "crescendo", but in Celibidache version this is really slow. My favorite directions of Six Symphony of Anton Bruckner are surely those Jochum or Sinopoli, both Staatskapelle Dresden. I dont know Abbados direction..and u? Bye

[hung30306guy]

slow or not, the playing by the orchestra is phenomenal

[Pingopalla]

i agree! but this symphony, with the same orchestra with another conductor (like Abbado or Sinopoli) is supreme!^^

[osumb17]

celi has fast and slow versions of bruckner symphonys. take a listen to bruckner 9 by cheli under EMI. The 1st mov. alone is 32 mins 10 mins slower then some. BUT THE POWER IS MASSIVE

[Pingopalla]

I dont Know 9 Symphony with Celibidache...My favorite interpretation of 9 Symphony is with Abbado and Furtwangler!

[MahlerTitan]

uuhh, Sinopoli never recorded 6th symphony with Staatskapelle Dresden!

[yale1167]

Quella di Jochum ok. Sinopoli troppo libera nell'interpretazione, nn è più il mondo di Bruckner. Abbado nn va bene: tropo veloce e troppo superficiale. Ok Karajan ma Celibidache è due gradini in più.ciao.