It's hard to do a note-perfect Floyd cover, but you at least need to get the feel right, which these guys don't do, particularly the timing. Sounds like an opera singer trying to sing the blues, as they decide to do now and then.
@southerner66 I have to agree with you, there's just a certain something missing. The notes are note-for-note correct, but the classic English soul isn't there. The lady-vocalist is certainly talented, but ain't nothing sound like a couple fat Black ladies belting it out with a huge serving of soul. That singer has vast dynamic but I'm not feeling the soul.
Ya, and apparently Clare Torry's was a brilliant one-take improvisation in the studio for like 50 bucks (so years later she had to sue PF to force them to pay her fairly for profiting off what was largely her idea).
those notes will never be perfomed be any singer ....we have to applaud those who will...and those that are afraid to try...to clare torry never again !
I think that if she could have felt she was a daughter that just came home from her fathers funeral and looked at his empty chair... I had heard the song dozens and dozens of times before I heard it for the first time with my heart . I was sure that Clare Torry sang this with tears streaming down her cheeks for the memory of a loved one gone, but that's not it either
she did a great performance, do you know how difficult it is to reach those notes, hearing the origional, then hearing her, she did a pretty good job.
who the fuck do you think you are,to be crtitic about some one paying a tribute, if you want the real thing search for the real thing you moron!!!! I 'm a Pink Floyd fan since the 1970, and every time a hear some tribute bands i apreciate the effort rather than be negative about it .........
Have to admit she's brave enough to attempt this song in front of so many people. A little more reverb may help. Giving her an a for the effort though.
Gorgeous girl....
shadyalan1 2 weeks ago
I guess its her interpretation of the song itself, but in my humble opinion the from-the-gut performance of Clare Torry will never be matched.
sheklikak 1 month ago 3
woa... the keyboard sound very aggressive...
Beaujolois 1 month ago
2:11 , what is he doing ?? looking the great gig in the sky right ??
yinyinkong2559 1 month ago
It's hard to do a note-perfect Floyd cover, but you at least need to get the feel right, which these guys don't do, particularly the timing. Sounds like an opera singer trying to sing the blues, as they decide to do now and then.
southerner66 2 months ago
@southerner66 I have to agree with you, there's just a certain something missing. The notes are note-for-note correct, but the classic English soul isn't there. The lady-vocalist is certainly talented, but ain't nothing sound like a couple fat Black ladies belting it out with a huge serving of soul. That singer has vast dynamic but I'm not feeling the soul.
BikeSwimLaugh 1 month ago
I finally do understand what they mean by "FAUX PAS".
inbox314 3 months ago
only a compliment to the courage .. and just ...!!
satsat57 3 months ago
whats going on with the left arm?
noxidnala 3 months ago
ONE WORD....YUCK!
xxSeAwEeDxxCoOpSxx 4 months ago
She is smokin "HOT"
kennyufc09 4 months ago
Sorry love but you just cant do it!!!
exrn13 4 months ago
She is still hot but what happened to her voice?
karloney 4 months ago
Once you listen to Clare Torry's original singing, you cannot handle hearing the rest.
plumeria66 5 months ago 32
@plumeria66
Ya, and apparently Clare Torry's was a brilliant one-take improvisation in the studio for like 50 bucks (so years later she had to sue PF to force them to pay her fairly for profiting off what was largely her idea).
markus777 1 month ago
CO TO MA BYĆ?! PROFANACJA UTWORU MUZYCZNEGO!
Mr3carter33 5 months ago
those notes will never be perfomed be any singer ....we have to applaud those who will...and those that are afraid to try...to clare torry never again !
pshphx 5 months ago
Stop....Stop.....Stop....Just stop! Please! Stop trying to sing this song because you can't. Your voice just simply isn't strong enough.
TheLegend313 5 months ago 6
Most Excellent. But I do understand the critical comments about a bit more feeling. But honestly how many people can even come close to that?
DougZawacki 6 months ago
not even the band comes close to instrumental...
calateroman 6 months ago 3
don't fell it...
THEGREATATZUMI 6 months ago
@THEGREATATZUMI ye it was not the best version, didnt reach me
FinalSh0ts3 6 months ago
Fa gli acuti in falsetto!
Non sono riuscito a trovare una riproduzione live che mi faccia venire i brividi come la versione di Clare Torry.
Thekaisersoze71 7 months ago
I think that if she could have felt she was a daughter that just came home from her fathers funeral and looked at his empty chair... I had heard the song dozens and dozens of times before I heard it for the first time with my heart . I was sure that Clare Torry sang this with tears streaming down her cheeks for the memory of a loved one gone, but that's not it either
scottinthepeg 7 months ago
wheres clare torry?
mandelcorny 7 months ago
That was a very nice try. She has a lovely voice.
KiddVid 7 months ago
clare torry is the one and only greatest gig in the universe! full stop
pilahdelphia 7 months ago 5
she cant go more up with voice. but respect she try it..
msvobi 8 months ago
L'ORIGINALE è 1 ALTRA STORIA.......... COMMOVENTE!
atirars86 9 months ago
she did a great performance, do you know how difficult it is to reach those notes, hearing the origional, then hearing her, she did a pretty good job.
uradoochbag 10 months ago 11
Apparently, Clare Torry has drawn too difficult a schematic to follow.
blipco5 10 months ago 2
lacks feeling...
vZamfir 10 months ago 2
who the fuck do you think you are,to be crtitic about some one paying a tribute, if you want the real thing search for the real thing you moron!!!! I 'm a Pink Floyd fan since the 1970, and every time a hear some tribute bands i apreciate the effort rather than be negative about it .........
Payatix 10 months ago 3
Not even close..
91hybrid 11 months ago 73
@91hybrid it actually is a bit like it.....it just doesn't have that 'crackle' in the voice. thats not the word to describe it.
bgborngorgeous 10 months ago
Wow - she's beautiful!
taynuilt1 11 months ago
Have to admit she's brave enough to attempt this song in front of so many people. A little more reverb may help. Giving her an a for the effort though.
optimumexterminator 1 year ago
this is a great song. if you like floyd then you might enjoy our tunes as well, check out our page!
SophistOfficial 1 year ago
es gibt nicht viele bands,wo dieser part fast wie das original rüberkommt!phänomenal!!!
rolandtischer 1 year ago
Super performt!! Tolle Sängerin!! Gänsehaut pur!!!
63vegas 1 year ago
Das klingt sooo Phantastisch!! Eure Sängerin singt Göttlich!!!! Hoffe Euch bald mal Live zu sehen!!!!
Hopesmily 1 year ago
Super Performance, Klasse Sängerin!!!
63vegas 1 year ago