Added: 3 years ago
From: Onegin65
Views: 133,025
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (109)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Agree

  • Oh come on you people! Blonde hair, blue eyes! She's singing in a concert and not in the setting of the opera. This is pure production and technique.  No jumping around, no flailing arms. Very good indeed. Excellent!

  • callas sang far much better than her

  • Best Carmen!

  • Ann 'that's how it's done boys..

  • She is so naughty doing this on stage ...she can't do it in concert ....

  • There are blonde gypsies , especially north in Spain ....

  • Agnes Baltsa was THE BEST Carmen ever. Elina is good but new performance in Met are not so good as in age of Levine, Baltsa and Carreras.

    PS: Garanca with her blue eyes and blond hair is not very creditable gipsy. :P

  • I love the bit when she sings

  • .....

  • formidabile immensa

  • One of my 3 favorit female voices with Anna Netrebko and Elisabete Matos.

  • Absolute supurb voice and a beautful woman  she is the finest mezzo suprano in the world

  • beatiful ending 

  • ta bien de a huevo

  • tempo = holy shit XD

  • Amazing perfromace!

  • Semplice Perfetto!!!!!

  • very good diction, some singers you don"t even hear they"re singing in french

  • I have the DVD...BEAUTIFUL!!!!

  • I have the DVD of the Garanca production. AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!

  • the best mezzosopran ever!!!

  • @cedarjolt You have not heard Irma Pavare, if You say so ;) Irma is much better and more talanted. Anita Garanca was a teacher for both of them, bu, of course, she made a carriere for her beloved daughter and derogated Irma... but Irma was strong enough and made her own progress :)

  • Comment removed

  • very nice!

  • definitly not as good as angela gheorghiu, she lacks the strength

  • @warprodigis But she has the low register...

  • @warprodigis You are kidding right? Carmen is for the mezzo. Elina is a mezzo... I'd take Garanca as Carmen over Gheorghiu any day. As to the strength, heard her in November at the Met as Carmen. Had rear orchestra seats which are supposedly the worst acoustically. Her voice is sufficiently strong for Carmen, and as LordHettrick said, she has the low register, and her voice is beautiful, and she can act.

  • @jewelmarkess Yes - the rear orch are the worst accoustically and you pay a lot to sit there.

  • @cantorandopera Not if you win the ticket raffle... Three times last season that I had a rear orchestra seat I paid $25. But yes, full price rear orchestra seats are overpriced relative to what you get.

  • awesome, who cares for anything else yet ?

  • elina es una talentosa y bella mujer, en esta interpretacion de carmen me deja boquiabierto con tanto arte, en fin .., vivan las carmenes rubias!

  • Oh wow, she is really blond! She looks so sexy as a brunette Carmen. Beautiful voice and fantastic actress. Hubba hubba =)

  • she's awesome

  • Who's the conductor and the orchestra?

  • @soundadvise I saw her standing there

  • @ Bunty1962- Actually, i think his name is Karel Mark Chigon, or something like that. I think Elina kept her maiden name :)

  • @123kooful Chichon would be better ;)

  • @123kooful Karel Mark Chichon, according to Wikipedia.

  • Does anyone know who the conductor is? I know Elina's husband is a conductor and i am wondering is that him? I love this, by the way!

  • @123kooful Yes that's him alright Mr Garanca.

  • @123kooful Yes that's him ok. Mr Garanca in the flesh, he puts his heart and soul into that performance

  • Sanger high school marching band and color gard played this for their fild show GO SANGER APACHES

  • I am truly smitten.

  • saw her at Met. dark hair. delicious , sexy , naughty, she cannot use this stage how she did at the met., the water , washing , putting her foot in the bucket , she was divine....

  • i like her more with curly, brown hair which she had in carmen. she looked better:) saw her live 2day at the met... had front row seats:)

  • Debout et la perfection est atteinte.

  • My favorite Carmem and one of the bests mezzos^^

  • This was fantastic! JayChicagoUSA's description of "luscious" is the only word that really does it justice. Amazing.

  • Surely the finest Carmen of our time. And one of the finest mezzos of our time...or any!

  • @arpeggio1358 You found the magical words!!! :-)

  • @AlcidesConstante She certainly is one of a kind. A brilliant mezzo.

  • @arpeggio1358 I love her voice, her absolute mastery of the scene, her beauty!

  • Não é possível que ela não tenha pelo menos uma frierinha? risos ... Perfect!

  • I saw the MET HD Carmen too and she was just awesome!

  • I never thought I'd be yelling Brava at a computer screen or clapping until my hands hurt, but Elina Granaca is one of the most exciting singers I've ever heard!

  • Elina's singing is luscious and delicious

  • Incredibly vibrant, rich, lusty, sensual performance.

  • much better than Katherine Jenkins' version.....Elina is now my favorite mezzo os all time :]

  • cuanto mas la oigo cantar a Garanca, más la admiro!!! I love her voice so much!!! She is amazing!!!!!

  • she is an amazing!!!!!!!!!

  • que raro...canta sentada!! no es habitual eso en un concierto!

  • @AminaBellini , tienes razón, pero hasta las divas son humanas, jaja

  • @wolfgangtheophilus ...si por supuesto, alguna falla tiene que tener, pero realmente parece perfecta...canta bien, tiene una bella voz y excelente tecnica (mi opinion como cantante) y además es una bella mujer y tiene muy buena presencia escénica, y para completarla sabe varios idiomas! jeje es excelente!!!

  • this woman made carmen the sexiest opera ever when she played at the met.

  • @MsPickleperson-Same here. I olny saw her with dark hair. I had not idea she was a blonde:)

  • wow, she's a natural blonde? I've only seen her as the black-haired carmen.

  • She is just... wonderful, amazing!!!

  • I will perform this aria and Euridice Aria with the Portuguese Symphonic Orchester on next June!!! It's amazing & You have a very nice spirit when you sing it!!! :)))

  • @1977aM1 ...how was the concert??

  • I saw her in Athens. She was awsome. And I think that she loves this song...

  • go to google and type in met opera it should give u the sight

  • does anyone know when the metHD DVD will be out? I saw it in theaters, but I'd love to own it.

  • me too, please write me if the DVD is on musicstores

  • Brava! Incidentally, is that hubby at the helm?

  • Send me a message on youtube when this comes out, I want to buy it as well

  • @soundadvise I'm only 17 and couldn't agree with you more. I had to leave when there was about 40 min left. I got so mad at myself for having to leave. Does anyone know if the DVD is going to come out in Iceland? ;P

  • story of my life for the past two months. except gheorghiu and vargas and villazon helped too :)

  • Saw her today, she is WONDERFUL!

  • I just saw her in metHD she was absolutely spectacular, she was great in la cenerentola but she really brought carmen to life today

  • I liked her in this clip. But, she really brings the role of Carmen to life with her dancing and acting in the Met production. I even think she looks more 'natural' with the black hair.

    I think the encore performance is in theaters mid March. In my opinion it's worth the money

  • its actually Feb 6 so if you missed todays performance be sure to catch the encore

  • She will be singing in the Met Carmen January 6, 2010 which will be simulcast in HD to theaters around the world.

  • good but no one will ever achieve GRACE BUMBRY'S level in my humble opinion.

  • Move over Marilyn Horne!

  • She's a revelation...

  • That´s a real Carmen! Wished I could hear her at the met! GREAT SINGING ELINA!

  • She's scheduled to replace Angela Ghorghieu at the Met this year. Thank God.

  • Comment removed

  • Wonderful! Has she done any staged Carmens yet?

  • i think 2007 in riga

  • She sings Carmen in Italy during summer festival and from 6 October at Coventgarden, though tickets are almost gone already

  • She is scheduled to perform at the Met this season.

  • she will be performing carmen at both the Royal Opera House ANDDDDD,,,,,, JUST ANNOUNCED THIS WEEK, the Met's new productiin, replacing Angela Gherghiu (including the HD broadcast to movie theaters around the world). don't miss it!

  • Elina is wonderful! And she gave me already many magical moments...Thx Onegin and ELINA!

  • WOw........what a wonderful voice!!

    I am in love !!!

    She is brilliant ........thank you so much for posting !!

    Pace and voice is wonderful ......very CALLASesque !!

  • LUMINEUSE!!!!!

  • technically incredible

  • great finale!

  • She is my Carmen!

  • She seems to be one the rising mezzo stars

  • ♡

  • This concert has ALREADY been posted - by me! Come to my channel and watch all of Elina's singing in a playlist.

  • love it!!!!!!!!!!! although see would a sing it higher!

  • I really liked this!

    chris

  • Brava!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more