Added: 4 years ago
From: harry180702
Views: 135,473
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (90)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I love Echo and The Bunnymen and Ian is so charming!!!

  • He almost has no voice and smokes while singing. Clever Ian.

  • The singer was a queen and now he's a good-looking mature man. C'est incroyable.

  • does he have a right to wreak himself with fags and booze! You bet!!

  • nowt wrong with his voice what ya all on about, i saw them live at least 10 times from 80 -85 and his voice hasnt changed.you have to remember that on recording voices always sound better/stronger and live there is always a difference. the tone and quality is still there, no change at all

  • It's almost as if the smoking on stage is just part of the act. Notice how often he's smoking on stage during recent (past decade) gigs. If he smoked that much all the time he would of died from nicotine posioning by now. As for the voice, it's kinda sounded like that since the electrafixion days.

  • Awesome, great sounding recording. Love the twelve string sound!

  • Nice

  • Wow, Ians voice is pretty much gone :-(

  • Awesome love there stuff !

    You guys should check out Spiders Where does this leave us now reminds me of these guys so much.

  • Agree. Still happening. (not a Gallagher brother, right?)

  • Their first 5 albums are classics :) This is probably my favourite tune on 'Ocean Rain', next to 'Killing Moon', 'Nocturnal' and 'Silver'

  • I saw them as Bunnymen and Electrafixion...they ALWAYS ROCK !!!(caps)

  • I loved his voice, so sad to hear it destroyed by cigarettes...

  • @deweypug what??? he still rocks i acmit that hes voice was fantastic however its a chance from the 80's ayy

  • @deweypug his voice is not destroyed by cigs

    bet you don't smoke right?

  • I think he should smoke another one!

  • such a bad ass!!!!!!!!!!!

  • U2 ??? Bunnymen best band in the 80s

  • U2 ??? The Bunnymen best band by far in the 80s

  • Bass guitar is way out of tune

  • is there any echo video not so recent...?

  • Keep smoking Ian.  Like your voice really needs some more damage.

  • @bearmedicinemusic , I was going to write exactly the same thing. Is there anything much stupid than a singer smoking????

  • @debyk1 i dont smoke but he rocks hard

  • @bearmedicinemusic I know, what the hell is he thinking by ruining such a gift?

  • E&B... since those times... no more beautiful songs to learn and sing...

  • kirkwallboy - don't forget the voice, the singer who also writes the lyrics. I don't agree that Sergeant has the skill i.e. the chord depth as S.C.N or the great Neil Young, I will say that his timing is melodic and tight.

  • Will Sergeant is up there with Crosby Stills Nash and Young. He is the reason Echo and the Bunnymen exist. Along with his pouting pal. Who, as it happens, is maybe one of the most original singers ever. Who seems to sing better the older he gets.

  • @kirkwallboy

    Nice post, have your listened to their latest?

    Not bad...

  • @kirkwallboy

    Will Sergent indeed,niece comments.

  • you're mistaken. that's not jonathan ross. it's a resurrected oscar wilde.

  • @vindaloo5000 ermm no its gordie goudie

  • Just beautiful and sublime.

  • wow, Jonathan Ross is great on guitar.

  • @nobrakesukspeedway

    hahahahlololol

  • So brilliant ya mean, best band that eva came outa liverpool, I will give Gerry n the pacemakers a mention, but I cannot think of anyone else, Zutons ok, Pete mighty Wha, , the other band band I refuse to mention with quantity not quality, HELP I need somebody, why does all there songs nearly start with the title, I reckons its a Frogs Chorus,

  • so great, so humble, only from liverpool. long may they be -

  • Any one know where to get decent footage of the Carlu, 2006 or 2007? I tried to film it but they took my cam, it was an amazing show. Me and my dad would be so grateful to get some footage of that concert.

  • Sorry it maybe Nov 2005, I don't remember that area of time too well lol.

  • Where was this filmed? It reminds me of when I saw them at the Carlu, but that can't be...

  • V Festival, Chelmsford, August 2006

  • Ian McCulloch still rocks!!!

    woooooo!!!

  • Maybe he should try cuttin'down on the fags a little (I'm A fully fledged smoker my'self-particularly whem i'm drinking1)) but if he would be unhappy doin' that then leave it!--That said AGEING (ask Elton John) means you can't reach those higher notes you used to be able to!!!!!

  • will is a fucking surgeon on the guitar, ...

  • This songs twenty five years old, i think his voice sounds amazing considering that. The Bunnymen are still brilliant

  • Ian should have quitted smoking long ago or at least minimize it. His voice has changed a lot over the years and this video is evidence.

  • yeah, and maybe he should consider a healthy, macrobiotic diet, do a bit of jogging, maybe get into yoga. FUCK OFF!

  • they are the best more of talking heads!!!

  • FUCK the tALKING hEADS!

  • J'aime cette bande, aime ce son

  • echo and the bunnymen/ ian mcculloch damn great!! thanks for this brings back great memories

  • when was this? recently, yea?

  • One of my favourite songs from Echo and the Bunnymen. Good live version. But I really think Ian should quit smoking.

  • love,love,love them. There is none cooler than Ian!

  • ace ace ace effin ace

  • its a still cool band ..

  • I just heard a live song from 8. Hearing his voice now is like night and day.

  • he smokes?

  • thats why he doesn't sound like he did in 84 anymore

  • thanx 4 the info.

  • Only when he talks. Singing sounds the same, and after 25 years, how much closer can you get.

  • love their music, always have. Echo and the Bunnymen should keep writing and performing great music!

  • I love Echo and the Bunnymen. Seen them several times and always a great show.

  • put the fag out numb nuts...........!

  • sounds like he got throat cancer already ..his voice used to be so strong ..now more like a tribute cabaret act

  • Hope the bunnymen are heading for Bangkok one day... I'd make sure the venue is PACKED!

  • poo!

  • His voice sounds as good as ever. The energy level might be down a notch but the music still sounds great.

  • guys , just understand they have been around for a long time.... it is very awesome that they are getting together and playing this show.. so appreciate it believe me.

  • i like them

  • zach braff !!!!!!!!!!!!

  • qua?

  • scrubs actor !!!!!!!!!!

  • i know i love j.d., but what does he have to do with eatb?

  • It is funny but smoking used to be so hip and cool to do back in 80's/90's and Ian isn't giving it up to be PC as he always smoked and smoked joints too live back in 80's on tours!!

  • ENOUGH WITH THE IAN SMOKING CRAP!! Deal with it, I think it sounds fine, keep touring Echo! I have not seen you yet!

  • 'B.S.' ruudlang.

  • always and forever the best band on the planet!!

  • My old man used to take Seven Seas cod liver oil pills. Good for the bones and skin he used to say.

  • Jesus, is Ian ever not smoking?

  • lol at Will with a Led Zep guitar. pleae give up the lungers mac

  • Is this Ian McCulloch? It sounds like his successor. Either that or he's much older and lost some of his range.

  • chrisperrons- no, don't think he's losing range at all-saw 1 live show 'bout tear & 1/2 ago where his voice did sound kinda'a more ravaged (concerned me some - still sounded great though)-but,saw them again like 6 months later & his voice,range sounded as great as ever- was amazed actually)-think he may occasionally smoke few too many marlboros - D.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more