張學友和呂方合唱版《李香蘭》

[agreeing472]

說呂方比不上學友的人，有沒有留意呂方拿咪高峰的距離？

[ozalice96]

@agreeing472 Most people judge the performance with their EARS but you seemed to judge with your EYES. Which method is more objective do you think? Anyway, Lui Fong is still a good singer in his own right compared to most of the younger singers these days.

[bananafai]

拍埋學友到無得鬥

但係呂方一定贏晒e+個堆

李香蘭-張學友最完美演譯係呢度

/watch?v=cFh4sUYu-rY

[shed7878]

呂方好似含住粒核唱咁

[vic830710]

張學友唱錯詞了XD

[goldgoldgo]

吕方有70分.張学友90分.高下立見.

聽聽運音,吐字.水平的差距.

[SweetNiceGirl15]

zheung hok yau, have a great voice, i love his songs so much

[arvin0526]

呂方-憂鬱，張學友-滄桑

[fx3650]

學友我都想你唔好跳, 不要影響你的歌

[mailindiao]

好像两个武功盖世的高手在过招。。。I like it。。。！

[ptshing]

張學友唱得好d= ='''

[ozalice96]

Lui Fong's vocal is good, but Jacky's is sublime! There are lots of other factors which help to elevate you to a super star. Your personality, your attitude, your work

ethics, your poise, your dress sense! Lui Fong has a lot to learn from Jacky!

[hoilam258]

2011仍有聽

[Bobby0917]

佢地故事告訴我們，無論做咪行業，天生實力固然重要，會做人同埋­勤力亦都更加重要。我地鐘意學友不僅系因為佢D声音，更有佢為人­概謙和，地位非常之高但系又平易近人。正如學友曾經講過，尼個圈­中，有時只有實力系唔得概，運氣都好重要。

[Kenny2HK]

@Bobby0917 你搵佢兩個做例子黎講勤力同埋待人處世唔係咁恰當, 呂方唔勤力咩? 唔勤力點可能成十幾年無乜表演機會都KEEP 到把聲咁靚, 唱歌咁夠氣? 佢唔識做人? 佢對圈內人點我唔清楚, 但係就甚少聽過佢有負面新聞, 可見佢做人都唔差得去邊. 佢兩個成就既差距, 現實一D, 就係因為天生實力(兩者身高同樣貌既差別所引致). 如果呂方有張學友既外形, 我相信佢既成就絕對唔止而家咁.

當然, 以上只係我個人既意見.

[s45685252]

我溶化了.....

[theloserlose]

以前既樂壇就係咁... 個個都唱得...

重要既係歌手同隻歌夾唔夾

[harbottle26]

好像是1985年青年偶像演唱会，1986年双星演唱会 :)

[harbottle26]

真的很感人。。张学友1986年第一次在红馆的演唱会就是与吕方­一起。。Look at how far he has come!!! ^_^

[hiddenhaieq]

呂方的實力就在那裡，可惜他就是紅不起來，不知道這算不算是上天­的捉弄？有些實力派歌手沒有偶像的外表，憑藉高超的歌唱技巧還是­難以站上一山之巔，時也命也！

[TheMusicandlyricz]

I think both of them but Jacky is still better overall.

[tsobingo]

jacky is even better than him...................

[theodorehui]

首歌其實好sad,但看到學友出場的時候,我還是發自內心地微笑­了出來

[ForrestSen]

实在是喜欢非常啊！！！！！！！！！

[VIPVICT]

看換氣聲可分出高下

[wainwainwain]

Jacky is on a whole different level....

[beavertown2006]

Jacky kills 呂方.

[MsHoros]

太好了, 2 大高手的同場演出

[0320paula]

呂方呀呂方, 唔鬧你唔得, 你浪費了天賦的好歌喉, 只要你肯勤力點, 或許不能達到張學友今天的成就, 亦不會如今日這般行行企企. 如張學友所說, 企響度唱歌便可以, 没有可少人, 點都好啦, 你歌唱得好是鐵一般的事實.

[547821478]

如果我是呂方，我會找劉德華跟我合唱。哈......

[m9801]

@547821478 那麽你就會屈機(爆笑)

[kk5354]

學友是鐵漢版.呂方是柔情版

[Donghui0705]

好感动。不食人间烟火的音乐配上天籁嗓音。好像真的回到历史长河­中。真的是一种享受。

[fctsui57]

They have different singing styles, both are GREAT GREAT male singers.

[luciferlhs]

장학우가 나를 울리는 구나..

[JackyLinXakie]

學友進來的第一個字真是太漂亮了!

[JackyLinXakie]

學友07年沒唱這首真是太可惜了!

[iofatt]

聽得出佢地好唔熟-.-

[hang1991921]

無得彈，但感覺上有d一山還有一山高

[supershowmark]

超讚~

[wuzhens]

張學友合音好酷

[yukoyy1125]

两个都无限棒！！！激动了我！！！！！

[chillsteri]

一直都唔明白，点解吕方唔红。

[crazywinders]

這是呂方唱得最好的一首歌, 不是指從前唱得不好, 而是根本沒有這一種機會去展示呂方自己, 不能把呂方最致命的地方表現出來, 他內心的情懷無論是"流浪花"或"聽不到的說話"都不似這一次"­李香蘭"般, 澎湃而憂鬱地呈現這一種男性的獨特情懷

這首"李香蘭"不可能不成為呂方的經典, 不幸的是這不是呂方的歌

[oleole2929]

@crazywinders 講得好好

[guqiner]

@crazywinders

我也認同你的說法,呂方此首歌（李香蘭）的詮釋可非常完美,把男­性真摯深情的情感,拿捏到恰到好處,令人聽了深受感動.....­...,真的是情歌之經典.

[supercn9]

这两位在一起 我真的激动了。

[owennice]

這首歌

千萬別在夜深人靜一個人聽

你聽完 會流淚

[skychong1980]

赞同

[Jonathanliu]

李香蘭an actress and singer promoting the japnaese national politic during the war. Lovely melody though. 

[johnchannetshow]

呂方事實系個好懶散的人....

[lovein1874]

@johnchannetshow who r u ?

[tam1234hk]

@lovein1874 係真的,呂方好鐘意宴客

我母親以前十幾年前係尖沙咀工作,幾乎個個禮拜都叫到佢同一大班­人食晚飯

佢份人係好大方又好nice,但工作就真係唔係點努力

[lovein1874]

@tam1234hk 哦~原來系咁

[m9801]

@tam1234hk 風聞他近期時常在鰂魚涌出没

[ryankathy]

傳聞呂方係半紅先驕所以後來無左影，當年佢其實係有前途，都成日­上電視唱歌

[liardwc]

@ryankathy

其實係華星累事，當時個個都死，杜德偉都係．

[virnowi]

气息就气息吧，吕方唱了几首了都？还唱这高难度能不累吗？人家这­几年又不活跃，貌似还抽烟什么的，怎么和学友比？ 但是各有各的风格，欣赏去吧，没必要老揪着这个不放。

[kevinjohor]

越听越感动。。。。。

[kevinjohor]

越听越感动

[lestancy]

Two of the best voice in Cantopop! :P

[lestancy]

Two of the best voice in Cantopop! :P

[ttoomm0074252]

呂方d高音好似浮誇左d.都係張學友好d.同埋而加d歌手.我真­覺得一半都唔級得上一d舊歌手.雖然我係90後.但係我覺得聴張­學友一d都唔out,好歌無分時間ma!!!!!!!!!!

[m9801]

@ttoomm0074252

@kd06

@anyway606

所以就更讓我們這些老半輩的樂迷珍惜，遺憾地現在還没有興起這麽­­厲害的歌手。香港流行樂界的復興，還要等多久？

[ttoomm0074252]

@m9801 其實而加都有好多歌手係好有實力.只係唔夠經驗(個人認為)

蘇永康係1個唔錯的例子~佢都好有實力雖然唔紅.....

[jackymwz]

好强啊!!! 学友同吕方合唱时,仲要比吕方唱高一个音!!!! 本来已经系高音,仲要唱高高音!

[virnowi]

@jackymwz  和声的需要啊大哥·····

[2007ess]

二人唱得很不错，香港新一代的歌手没有能及。

[sialingshiang]

这才是算是大哥级嘛...

[KelvinChoi724]

《李香蘭》

作曲：玉置浩二

粵語填詞：周禮茂

編曲：杜自持

寶麗金唱片公司製作

發行日期：一九九零年七月廿三號

[ajoe999]

我好喜歡呂方 綿綿款款深情而來的嗓音 呂方這首唱太好了 

[happybarnie]

Yes, Lui Fong should have been one of the top 5 artists in HK easily with his voice and skills but unfortunately it didn't turn out that way for whatever reasons.

[skyline28]

@happybarnie They said he wasn't tall enough or good looking enough back in the day.

[donutmanpopo]

woo ~~~~~~估唔到呂方都唱得好正@@呂方同學友都有自己風格難­得

[ccucwc303]

真是經典阿

兩人合唱唱的我雞皮疙瘩都起來了

太讚了

[larrainewong]

i am a hugh fan of jacky cheng i loved his music

[johnyep1]

吕方is the most under rated singing artist in Hong Kong. It's quite sad, he really had a good voice during his prime (very sultry and smooth). Unfortunately, his popularity did not peak. Dunno why?

[prometheus0125]

@johnyep1 Agree, 很可惜，他真是一個非常棒的歌手！

[heymanhn]

legendary. LEGENDARY.

[barbara886886]

Excellent performance!

[happiyrs]

this song gives me goosebump..

both are really good.. cant compare..

[MsHoros]

超抵的演唱會

[TheCHAIRHON]

If u listencarefully, u'll find the lyrics depressing!

[ajoe999]

兩人的歌聲都是上等的極品

雖然我喜歡張學友 但呂方對歌曲詮釋真的很入微 

[jimmyho8]

冠軍級人馬合作..真係好聽...

[bush0410]

Jacky is always the BEST!!!

[bush0410]

Jacky is always the BEST!!!

[batista3207]

真的超讚!!!!!!

[0966872628]

唱的太好了!!!!!!!!!

[justinwong02714]

呂方+張學友

一高一底，太正啦

[angelchan1212]

best version ever

[owkenyo]

no doubt. jacky cheung is better!

[Kcohlorskyfo]

完完全全可以感受到個份精神仲係到....

[gameboycs]

學友一段就殺晒~~

[clarencehkma19]

呂方完全被張學友比下去XD

[atpl5800]

jackey is much better

[challengecube]

very good

[kenneth7098]

以前的歌百聽不嚴 , 現在的沒有那種吸引。

[georgeyan111]

一個像教書先生般說出故事內容，

一個像全身已浸入其內容，使人跟隨其歌聲起伏！

[auhill]

好好聽

兩個唱功都一流而由唔同風格

依個合唱版好出色

[chleehk192004]

而家兩台既歌唱選秀比賽,

一個似樣d既都冇...唉

[7810tommy]

同感啊！！举脚赞成！！

[pro4logic]

Too GOOD!!!

[Ahbat8]

兩個都好勁 , 唱得非常好.........依家啲所謂歌手真系要努力學習

[akballbb]

BTW 佢地合唱呢首李香蘭真係聽極都吳嚴~

[akballbb]

而家d歌手話算係最好既 咩超級巨聲個d 亦未必有以前d歌手既一半 吳計佢地d唱功 就連感情都吳到位 出道耐 有人棒 紅左就叫樂壇歌后/王 亂RAP就叫好組合 一係就抄人 一d無人棒既歌手就被埋唱功 我諗如果張學友 呂方呢輩既歌手再上台同而家d歌手撼過 佢地輸十條街都吳夠 學下人地外國啦 有實力先上得台 再吳係學下人地韓國 訓練過先準出道啦 而家d藝人係吳係都話做得歌手 一紅就棒佢做歌手 識跳少少舞就舞后舞王 邊個邊個既接班人 呢個世界好大架 睇下人地既實力 真係九牛一毛都不如啊! 講真 我真係好不滿而家香港既"娛樂圈" 吳係樂壇! 不知所謂! 作為一個觀眾一個聽眾 我要既只係 張學友 呂方 呢d用感情用實力唱歌既人去唱一d動聽既歌!

[ki6236]

各有特色

各有各好: )

[GoFailCom]

跟張學友沒法比, 差太遠了, 這首歌要唱出的是感情, 不是唱功.

那個感情的level跟張學友差太多了.

這版本的張學友唱得也不夠別的好, 這版本他沒有進入那感情, 別的版本比較悲傷, 更好聽

[wu0212tung]

唔理邊個歌手唱唔唱到...只要有心去唱...不足也會被尊重!­!

[guardfieldcat]

Both are wonderful...



[larrainewong]

any 1 has his new video

[rachelmanman]

佢地兩個合唱既版本都好聽呢!

[myidolisnf]

我唱的比他好

[caritas123]

我自己就覺得演繹比技巧重要.

[caritas123]

好

[cheriwip]

張學友好聽d

[iMPERiOUS]

@cheriwip no 吕方 is better.

[23470335]

好耐未聽過兩個人唱假音係兩個人一樣+啱音啦...

繞樑三日...

百聽不厭...

[ligfyt]

經典中的經典

[prometheus0125]

好歌啊～好歌～

香港兩大歌王一次灌到爆！真是過癮

[TonyKwan212]

呂方同學友唱e隻歌既風格完全唔同

但係這是第2種震撼!

[KIT7732KIT]

兩個都是香港頂級流歌手 "正"

[lamwaiquan]

不過基仔把聲底唔系好o岩唱呢首歌就真噶...

[lamwaiquan]

點解基仔唱唔掂live??前不久先開完演唱會黎- -

[lamwaiquan]

好想聽下古巨基唱呢首歌會系點,,畢竟古巨基的假音好勁..

[usermoment]

基仔其實有唱過 , 不過以佢而家o既狀態 , 已經唱唔掂live , 何況呢首歌唔止要假音靚 , 轉共嗚 同埋 發揮感情都好緊要 , 基仔唔多掂.

[tims041501]

佢假音係唔錯,不過哭腔好廢呢...李香蘭無哭腔就唱不出哪種弧­獨,幽傷

[siu20051777]

@tims041501

學友唱果時都冇咩幽傷

只係滄桑

[grantsin33]

@tims041501 有冇聽過玉置浩二原唱? 佢唱都無乜哭腔

[ghjk8080]

@lamwaiquan 我認為佢未夠火候

[lopak6868]

我覺得不會比呂方好，基仔無疑高音好，但放還可以，卻缺乏收的唱­功和細膩度。

[jing713]

@lopak6868

agree....... kkk 缺乏唱功

[spanley76]

呂方  一個本可成為四大天王之一的歌手

[jackytkh]

@spanley76 ???

[sofieff]

經典的歌曲 + 經典的合唱!

絕對聽出耳油!

[happywendy823]

嘩,正呀!!!!!!呂方唱得仲柔!!同張學友有得fight!­!但真係實力相當!!!

[a24363846]

太強了..好好聽

[pamling1991]

太好聽了

一剛一柔

[barryhch]

兩位歌手都處於最佳狀態..一流的表演..

[kd06]

而家既歌手唱live喘氣我都算啦﹐唔走音已經算萬幸﹐但係點解­連聽cd都重喘來喘去架﹖﹗大佬啊﹐我又唔係俾錢聽你喘氣﹐唱到­好似哮喘發作咁

[Jennyeful]

both r very good singer... nowdays really few is TRULY can sing like dis standard... once u hear them, u can drowning in their song they sing out... so heavenly.

[hokakiu]

呂方=實力派歌手

[sampang1996]

我一生最愛的一首歌

[silhouettedby]

說我老土我也要說:百聽不厭

[jca23]

the audience KNOWS WHOSE IN THE HOUSE before the god appearing right at 2:15.....

[sampang1996]

好正!!

[peopleschamp999]

007

[hk02025]

乜周星星有唱咩?

[peopleschamp999]

我覺得呂方投入的感情比較深

有時候,好的歌曲表演,不一定是技術..

而是感情,,

[andyctlee]

i like the way jacky sings so seriously and professionally, but when he talks.... he's kinda hyper!! The little dance at the end....priceless!!!! This part of the concert must have been awesome!!!

[Snooker169]

周星星唱得仲好

[drjdfj]

其實國產零零漆中唱李香蘭個個應該係吳國敬....吳國敬又係翻­唱得好好聽....

[beenochow]

@Snooker169 周星星係吳國敬代佢唱-.-

[clever01Tube]

呢D先係實力派歌手架ma!而家哥D都唔係唱歌既,D歌詞又冇意­思,又唱到喘哂氣咁!唉~

[anyway606]

同感，现在的歌手，为什么老是把喘气声也入咪？以前的歌手，如A­lan , Jacky, Leslie...基本无喘氣声的！所以啊，现在的歌手啊，真的­要学学点唱啦，吾系以为出来唱一两首就以为自己可以开show ！

[jing713]

@anyway606

李克勤都無喘气声

[hide98000]

@anyway606

我都覺得聽歌聽到d透氣聲真係好困擾...就算首歌作得幾好..­詞寫得幾靚都係有暇痴

[johnchannetshow]

貴入場都值....

[sampang1996]

太正啦!!