Added: 3 years ago
From: elangelJESUS
Views: 627,220
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (809)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • qué te pasó AMY LEE!??! que pasó que dejaste de cantar bien?! =(

  • Amazing eyes. gazes and hypnotizes my whole self !

  • amy sounds amazing but look BAD in this video... I'm so glad she's so over that look...

  • Okay so , im just getting into Evanescence and there fucking AWESOME!

  • I would please this women until dawns end.

  • muy bueno

  • Damn the guys voice ruins this song so bad. A masterpiece without it, just another piece of modern day trash with it

  • Einfach nur geil!

  • love her

  • Beautiful stuff! Prefer it to the orginal :)

  • she a sexy chick.. yeah she a sexy chick

  • Perfect voice and a drop dead hottie too bad shes married already

  • HOLY MOTHER OF GOD. Thats amazing <3

  • f'n awesome!!!

  • did u hear any note she missed?

    i didnt o.O

    just perfect

  • live acoustic is very hard...and all the haters are just jealous

    

  • fucking buitfull

  • Just Shut up .l.!!!!! And Hear the Song .l.

  • She gives me shivers...

  • Ahhhhhh Ben! <3

  • Yup Yup....MrNakhurl IS a fucking moron. I agree with Ireil94. What a tool

  • Dont care about these music snobs talking about her voice. It sounds good to my ears, thats all that matters.

  • I always liked Evanescence and this song is a favorite of mine.

    However, people considering Amy Lee as a "great singer" should listen to more quality music.

    She composed this song and performed it for years, hundreds of times.

    Yet her voice is all over the place, is out of tune, misses note after note. Strains and screeches on such an easy piece.

    And no, "singing with passion" is not an excuse for singing poorly.

    .

    Lady Gaga which wannabe "goths" hate so much is a way better performer.

  • @MrNakhrul you sir, are a fucking moron. dont listen to her then. her voice is unbelievable.

  • @lreil94

    Most people here don't understand that an insult, coming from a nickname on a public forum cannot have any effect on someone right in the head.

    As I said, I like the song but am disappointed that artists so famous and well paid are nothing more than media products.

    The only difference I see between Evanescence, Metallica (nowadays) and Justin Bieber is the targeted audience.

    At base I find the same commercialism and poor artistic value.

  • @MrNakhrul alright fair enough. but cant you hear how her voice is essentially the same live and in the studio? whereas many singers cant hit the high notes live..like watch adele sing someone like you live, she doesnt go for the highest notes. and im not even going to mention bieber, please dont get me started. this girl is gooood. Evanescence does everything themselves. songwriting i mean. but yea, i think her voice is amazing

  • @lreil94

    Amy Lee is ok musically and Evanescence is respectable because of a fair amount of creativity in their debut albums, I agree on that. I even liked them as I have said.

    But seeing the incredible amount of popularity they have - especially in USA makes me feel sad about USA listeners.

    Of course you consider them top notch, if you use as comparison Adelle.. or Bieber, Rihanna. Almost everything in american showbusiness today is extremely low value.

    ->following on next reply->

  • @lreil94

    ->

    However my sincere advice is: improve and extend your tastes. Experiment. You will be stunned of what incredible bands and singers are in countries like Finland, Russia, Brazil.. everywhere. Huge bands with millions of loyal fans. Bands most people in USA don't even know they exist.

    BTW: BMTL is very easy mode.

    Here's a flawless live (not "acoustic" studio) performance of an inhumanly difficult song Sry for the bad quality

    /watch?v=bHIO8xTzTF0&feature=r­elated

  • @MrNakhrul

    Hehe, Tarja :) Best of the best but no need to go that far.

    For true gothic metal I suggest The Gathering, Tiamat, Theater of tragedy, Sirenia, Tristania. Or more commercial goth like Within temptation or HIM.

  • @MrNakhrul i agree, modern american music sucks ass. it sad. im waiting for the next british invasion

  • @MrNakhrul

    I'll stick with Amy Lee, Grace Potter, Martina McBride, and all the rest of America's top notch talent.

  • @BadWolf762

    I saw at least 20 better singers at the last X Factor.

    It's a matter of taste what can I say. Which depends a lot on what music we heard while growing up. If you grow up listening garbage, same garbage will appeal to you afterwards.

    I don't see people listening Bach in their iPods for eg, and on radio I don't hear Puccini but Justin Bieber.

    ->

  • @MrNakhrul

    The X Factor is recorded in a studio and all live performances are lip sync'ed as well as enhanced. Also, Justin Bieber isn't really played much. He's never on the radio, and its a rare thing to find his songs playing in a public place.

    Sorry for my unorganized reponses :( Kind of don't feel like replying that much. Also, I'm getting a vibe that you're one of the people who's convinced all Americans are fat and brainwashed into buying everything they see.

  • @BadWolf762

    -> Subjectivity aside though, I wonder where is that talent people are talking about.

    Bring me to life is Evenescence's very first single and is nearing 10 years of age.

    Yet it's by far their greatest work and the most listened song.

    So again: where is that talent and creativity?

  • @MrNakhrul

    Talent and creativity is different to different people. I think the acoustic version are very creative. I find her rock songs a bit repetive but the softer ones like Hello are really enjoyable for me. As for American singers, I agree about it sucking. Rihanna :( she's so bad and all her songs are repetitive. As for Justin Bieber, he can technically sing okay but his new voice is soooo bad, I hate listening to it.

  • @MrNakhrul

    I respect you understanding of why people like Amy Lee. However, I have to disagree with her being just "ok musically." How well one can sing is both technical and subjective. From a technical perspective, she, as far as I and the majority of the people who have watched this video (judging by the like/dislike bar) can tell, she is singing perfectly. I'm sure most experts would agree she sang this song very well, her voice was not at all squeaky in any part.

  • @MrNakhrul

    This is not an "easy mode" song, like you said. Also, I listened to your link. I'm sure you think thats good music, but I don't. I really don't like any rock/metal bands or singers, other than Amy Lee, and mainly I just love her non-rock songs, like Lost in Paradise and acoustic versions. Back to Tarja, I found her weird voice mixed with the rock music horrendous. I'm sure from a technical perspective, she sang perfectly, but it was still really bad to me.

  • @TheFluffycat101

    I gave that video as an example for difficult song sang perfectly, you cannot expect to make an impression using a cell phone recording.

    That particular song is among the most greatest metal songs ever btw and was voted numerous of times among the best off all time in rock.

    It's not about brainwashing, but about how you develop as a person.

    Having no culture leads into having poor taste. And so, you may hear Bach or Pavarotti and hear "weird".

  • @TheFluffycat101

    Leaving aside the "technical perpective" if by simple audition and without even knowing this song, you hear it and consider it sang well and in tune, can's say much more.

    When and if I have time I will post here, marking the exact time where she misses the notes, strains or squeezes her voice.

    Leave that also aside and just listen to the voice. It's so generic and void of colour that I bet most cannot distinguish her without knowing it's her in advance.

  • @MrNakhrul

    Well, I really don't care about how great the song is, I think it sucks and hated listening to it. As for it being among the greatest, I doubt it. To her voice being generic and void of color, I also disagree. However, you're entitled to such opionions but you're not entitled to deem them that. And I'm sure most can distinguish her in advance without knowing. Thank you for stopping here :)

  • @TheFluffycat101

    I appologise however because I am certain my words are hurting some feelings.

    I'll stop here but reiterate by first thought. My advice to people is to experiment and not limit themselves on what they hear on the radio, TV, clubs.

    Music is so much more than than.

  • @MrNakhrul Just discovered a hidden gold mine thanks to you... What a voice!

  • @ahmedovahmed

    My pleasure :)

  • @MrNakhrul Amy Lee can sing quite well... This song is pretty hard to sing. It may not be her most amazing performance, but she's not singing poorly. No singer sounds identical to the CD version unless they're lip synching. As for Lady Gaga being better, that's your opinion. I personally don't think her live performances are too amazing. She's got lungs, but I don't find anything to special about her voice. It's not very unique in my opinion.

  • SALVAME DE LA OSCURIDAD

  • es lo maximo esta mina... canta bello !!!

  • is he looking close enough at his guitar?? his face is almost touching ha ha

  • @SkinnyBobaDoWob thats called dedication and a real talent

  • Amazing vocals!

  • bad ass-Ben and amazing-Amy!

  • Amy, you´re completely AMAZING

  • freakin love Amy Lee love her voice. your my idol girl

  • I like the full version better. Don't get me wrong, Amy Lee has an AMAZING voice, but Paul McCoy just makes the song. You at least need the male vocals or it just sounds...incomplete.

  • VERY VERY GOOD I LOVE AMY

  • Love this! I saw this years ago and now I found it again! Thank you.

  • Ben and amy have amazing chemistry its a shame he isn't there no more... Love this vid though :D

  • guao..amazing voice,

  • Happy birthday amy lee

    I love you -3

    My birthday is today too:)

  • POORRA! num importa se seja ao vivo ou nao acustico ou naum acustico ! Amy lee canta beem do mesmo jeito

  • @impuritybass That's not true at all!!!

    They're so much better now!!!

    He wanted to make them sound the same as everyone else

  • Damn.. wow. What a voice.

  • When I hear just Amy Lee, and a Guitarist unplugged, I know I'm in for a treat.

    It's real music, not some bullshit computer generated crap.

  • @ripcord1991 Everything is music. Computer generated or not.

  • @ripcord1991 she is a true singer

  • fucking chill bumps!!!

  • @Camg3591 remarkable voice,stellar guitar ,,

  • Is she an actress

  • yeah!! :D

  • *-* Linda

  • waw !

  • What a Voice...

  • i think i love this girl and her voice

  • i was expecting a WAKE ME UP!!! @ 0:53 :(

  • @loyster thanks for the warning bro

  • I really don't like this kind of music but I have to admit that she is amazing live!

  • Carly made 37 accounts to dislike this video...!!

    AMY GO ON!!Your voice is amazing!:)

  • :D she sings like an angel, if angels were as good as Amy-Lee

  • Beautiful ...

  • where is the backing song?

  • no one sings amy lee like amy lee. No one can top her.

  • She did the whole bridge in 2 breaths. Holy crap.

  • Seriously, this is not even right! :O

  • "Yeah, i'd kiss her face" :p

  • God gave Amy 4 lungs

  • This would of sounded even better with a male back up singer , epic !!

  • wow...just wow <3

  • la amo

    

  • I love her voice!

  • Comment removed

  • FUCKING PERFECT!!!!! #D-I-V-A

  • Not a hater by any means and I do like her... she sounds great recorded but has trouble maintaining control on stage. 1. Mariah Carey Not even going to mention the classically trained vocalists in the genre of Opera-

  • Lol there's nothing special about her lungs- shes a 1 or 2 level- Justin Beiber shouldn't even be acknowledged- he's a girl.

  • @TheKatrinaje You can't name ONE person who even comes close to amy so don't be hating cuz she can slaughter all the people that you like.

  • this lady sure does have an amazing voice !!!

  • is it just me or does anyone else feel close to crying? :') absolutely beautiful Amy!

  • Amazing tune, amazing guitar, amazing vocals...basically amazing!

  • The amazing thing about this performance is that the guitar is not being played on just one boring tone but it is changing with every word,,,,,,excellent performance.

  • Rock SOLID acoustic performance by both of them in this video. They just both put their heart and soul into this performance,what`s not to LOVE !! Amy Lee really ROCKS it !

  • they need to get rid of that fucking guitar. It sounds wrong

  • Wow, she looks like a girl that i date, but shes blonde, but the same face

    ,

  • @Ghost01x ok then say her to color her hair black.

  • this song is beautiful!

    Thanks Julia!

  • Dang this woman has the biggest lungs of all:)

  • @StacytheJew ...But she's no Chester Bennington.

  • @FurryWereWolf93 Agreed, they'd be one hell of a combo though.

  • AMAZING !

  • what did he find on the ground? he was looking down the whole time

  • Am i hearing an angel singing?feeling like living in the heaven...

  • you can say a person is a good singer when she/he sings acoustic without any technical enchancement....pure voice pure strings........amy lee your the best

  • amazzzzzzzzzinggggggggggggg omg!

  • Ai Love you mulher!!!

  • flawless. easily the best lead singer of a band ever.

  • @130987Cameron Sorry, but there's no such thing...

  • @Lordoftheflies234 as the best? i think she is the best.

  • @130987Cameron Your opinion. Peace.

  • I'd like to see someone stand up to Amy Lee's talents. That'd be the day. I know some quite great singers who sound great live, and Amy Lee's one of them. I will not put anyone of those singers higher or lower 'cause they're all really great!

  • WOW! her songs are always awesome! especially her singing, beautiful! :)

  • great voice,. but she's fucking ugly as hell eeek

  • @JamDeItaV you'rem right about her voice but about how she looks-WTF IS WRONG WITH YOU?!?!?

  • @AllTheSmileys 0:18 - 0:26 :S effin ugly to me, sorry man, watching her ruined the song for me. but anyway, still one of the best voices around, no doubt.

  • A 33 personas les gusta Justin Bieber y no saben de música..... Amy es PERFECTA!!!

  • love it love  it love it!!!! ♥_♥

  • Great acoustic session!

  • VideopPimp .0_o

  • she's so great, so hot

  • @puggypugpug101- lmao like

  • Little do you all know this song is about Jesus Christ :]

  • Little do you all know this song is about Jesus Christ :]

  • levels of singing

    -1 -Justin Bieber

    0-Just started

    1-Easy

    2-Medium

    3-Hard

    4-Expert

    5-FUCKING HARD

    6-God

    7-Amy Lee...

  • @puggypugpug101 Cough you forgot hayley williams -___-

  • @AhhhYewStalker SHUT UP I DON'T CARE ABOUT HALEY WILLIAMS.

  • @puggypugpug101 Damn who crapped in your cornflakes?

  • @AhhhYewStalker Haley doesn't deserve her own own number >.> she might me around 5 or 4.

  • @puggypugpug101 Fucking hard before god? HUAHUAHUA Amy rules!

  • LMAO oh poor bieber.

  • @puggypugpug101 that's a good one! thanks! greetings

  • @puggypugpug101 ROFL!!! So true.

  • @puggypugpug101 funniest shit ive seen in ages lmao

    she is awesome

    love her voice

  • @puggypugpug101 I got a Better one -1 -Justin Bieber 0-Just started 1-Easy 2-Medium 3-Hard 4-Expert 5-FUCKING HARD 6-God 7-Chuck Norris 8-Amy Lee...
  • @thesaber903 leave chuck out of this....

  • @puggypugpug101 But seriously i dont think anyone can beat amy lee at singing...

  • @thesaber903 of course, she is so underated, she has the best voice EVER and plays the BEST MUSIC ever!

  • @puggypugpug101 I'd rate myself as god. No-one is as good at Amy Lee.

  • 32 people couldn't be brought back to life after they tried to sing like Amy <3<3<3

  • I love Amy :D

  • WOW BRUTAL!!!!!

  • AWESOME PERFORMANCE.

    32 people just can't bring her to life.

  • just brilliant

  • beast!

  • epic duet ..

  • her voice it breath taking just amasing

  • Her voice is amazinng goioshhh

  • Amy my life *----------*

  • If someone could post tabs for this, I'd love them forever :D

  • I was listening to Amy ever since I was 5 now I'm 15 :)

  • i wonder if they have any concerts coming up soon

  • @zekrom96 they do im seeing them liveon october 11th

  • @aaronbenvenuti14 where?

    

  • @zekrom96 the palladium in hollywood

  • wow!!!!

  • I don't remember how old Amy was back then. :s

    Could someone help me out?

  • @yaoilover20 like 20-22

  • props to the guitar player ben moody that shit is difficult to play

  • @BigSexyKracker actual it is not hard at all. The verse is just 2 power chords. E5 and A5. He adds the 6th to the E5 before he goes to the A5. That is all the verse is. The chorus is just an E minor chord, G major chord, D major chord and back to the E minor. Thats pretty much the song. There are some other stuff he does for the bridge but it's a basic song a beginner could learn. At least I think.

  • @Deathtour2929 no im talkin about the added shit he puts into it like the palm mutes slides all that shit it sounds perfect and its a sick song to play on guitar

  • @BigSexyKracker Ya but that stuff isn't that hard. You can do it to easily. It just takes a little practice. Palm mutes and slides on a guitar are some of the easiest tricks you can do. I'm not saying Ben isn't a good guitarist cause he is. And a even better musician. But what he is playing here in this vid is not that hard. It does sound real nice though.

  • nice eyes

    nice voice

    

  • how can she do tht

  • Voz mais Bonita do Rock!

  • God she looks like Iraqi women XD

    she's so pretty and has a sweet voice T3T