all those rude people at the top^^^ have lost their senses! You are like my idol in the world of makeup&& your super funny,, Watching these are actually entertaining in a good way(: thx
dont pay attention to all the rude ppl who comment bad stuff, u r super funny and ur videos r relly good i luv watching them, ppl who dont like this just arent worth it to reply to.
Hey! i was watching a beauty video and i saw you're video and im like woahh 10$? so i clicked on it.! i think you are really pretty and i watched a couple of ur videos and i'm lovin them! i subscribed and added because you are amazing and inspiring!! xoxoxo
i think if these people who are saying stupid comments obviously dont like them selves cause i think this girl is good at what she does :) the haters are just jealous because there not her :P
wow, everyone is jealous of you! You're stunning and this is a really good video :D didn't quite hear the name of the lip colour though! What was it again? :)
-3 that you talk fast! You must be from the east coast! Hate slow tutorials! What is the name brand of the highlighter? That was a little to fast for me?! :). Thank you for sharing!
Forget all the comments from the HATERS......I think you did a wonderful job explaining and demonstrating this particular look. Well done! And I should know a thing or two about make-up......I'm a Plus Size Model.
Because I have a job tomorrow, I will definitely be trying to imitate this look then. Thanks! Oh yeah, KUDOS to you for showing this look using reasonably priced products!
great tutorial, thank you for uploading you make it look reallly simple and great, and not to much like most guru's do, i really feel that i can do this look with little to no practice!
outstanding information, thanks 4 sharin, have anybody sampled Rimmels latest product line? it is hard to find quality makeup in Green Valley yet i managed to receive wonderful samples of makeup using 'Gratis Makeup Samples'! their handy!
Major fan! How about doing a Mary Kate Olsen inspired tutorial?
Lots of you ladies reading this comment don't exactly love paying for high priced makeup. The costs add up awful fast! Luckily found out on the MAC facebook they're givin away a a bunch of free stuff the rest of the month. :] If you are lazy, I will save ya some time, heres their give away website.
shortener。org/93342
And, you got to use the code FACEBOOK4390 on page 3 <33
is that champagne color still available at sally's? i'm sure i have one similiar but it looked really good on your vid. i have lighter skin though so it prob wouldn't be as bright as it looks on you.
such a better look compared to the 'professional' ones i've seen where they think she wears 'gold and purple and pink eye shadow and bright pink lips etc!' when she clearly doesn't -.-
everyone always asks me where i get my makeup and i tell them i buy it at walmart... they dont believe me! but you can find amazing makeup for cheap it just depends on how you apply! this vid shows how to look beautiful on a budget!
omg honestly you are so funny and really cute for your age. Its good to see girls your age being natural, not bitchy and fake. Keep up the good personality ^.^
hey! your absolutley gorgeous! (you probrably hear that alot, or at least get comments ) lol. i liked how you used makeup that NORMAL people can actually AFFORD. like all the other tutorials have mac and its annoying lol. keeo the tutorials comming!
LMAO!!!! u are super prettty lol and yeah u are thin, so what??? So am i! doesnt mean ur sick! i weight 112 aND Im 5'2 :P ignore retards telling u u look sick...ur make up tutorials are awesome :) keep it up!
oh wow! i have that same exact desk! its really weird coz we got it at a yard sell when i was like.. 10! i think its a sign. i shall heed this sign and suscribe. lol. ^_^ but seriously, luv ur look! and love the prices too! ^_^
i didnt say she wasnt pretty...she is pretty, and talented, but i do think she looks unhealthy, unless she's about 14.... or maybe her camera angles just suck...
those 2 idiots Hitman & greenlantern probably never had or will have a chick even close 2being as pretty as u!! the fact that their on here hatin, proves that!!
@BurnInMaLight a great one i think is the almay intense i-color powder shadow trio for brown eyes. its the shadows that they advertise based on your eye color, the top color is great color especially for the inner corner of the eye :) great price too!
Where does everyone else get their makeup? I tend to get samples for free from 'gratismakeupsamples', just got some beautiful Sally Hansen makeup recently.
@movielover19f i find it easiest to get makeup at walgreens cuz there is one right down the road from me but any drug store will have tons. walmart kmart shopko. stores like that will have have tons
I just discovered you and I love your videos..and your New Yorkish accent. I just have two requests. Please list everything(not just some of the products used) you use on the right. Also what brand is the highlighter your used and how much?
this is a good idea in that using drugstore makeup is great and teaching others how to apply makeup is great too but for some reason i cannot get over how stupid you sound. I'm really sorry...I know its mean but I cannot get over it because you're very talented at doing makeup looks. Maybe she has a retainer or something? She also sounds like shes from somewhere outside of NYC.
really pretty girl :)
PLUR4LUSTAROTICK 6 months ago 9
Beautiful!! Great job explaining everything. Found the vid useful!
UrstrulyMisha 6 months ago
all those rude people at the top^^^ have lost their senses! You are like my idol in the world of makeup&& your super funny,, Watching these are actually entertaining in a good way(: thx
iloveraywilliamJ 6 months ago
FINALLY! a guru with a personality! My prayers are answered (:
nowmybaby15 7 months ago 4
great tutorial! You're very veryyyy pretty! keep it up!
korenLkeller 7 months ago
I have that Palette!! WOOT :) gonna try this thanks :)
timmyshoho 7 months ago
you look like kim kardashian
Kristiiiina375 7 months ago 5
this is the first video i saw of you :D
Aranda941 7 months ago
beautiful look:)
taylovelorlautner224 7 months ago
Awesome tutorial !!!Thanks
guadalupe1454 7 months ago
I LOVE YOUR TUTORIALS AND I LOVE HOW YOU DEFEND YOURSELF ..DONT LET THE LOSSERS BRING YOU DOWN =)
1990estrella 7 months ago
it's 9am and you're not walking around in a smokey eye bahahahaha i love it gurl!
KAEJnutt 7 months ago
dont pay attention to all the rude ppl who comment bad stuff, u r super funny and ur videos r relly good i luv watching them, ppl who dont like this just arent worth it to reply to.
CandyAddiction321 7 months ago
great makeup tutorial... u are beautiful... but nothing like megan fox
dckhan2 7 months ago
Hey! i was watching a beauty video and i saw you're video and im like woahh 10$? so i clicked on it.! i think you are really pretty and i watched a couple of ur videos and i'm lovin them! i subscribed and added because you are amazing and inspiring!! xoxoxo
bosnagurl1234 7 months ago
i think if these people who are saying stupid comments obviously dont like them selves cause i think this girl is good at what she does :) the haters are just jealous because there not her :P
LauraMovieMaker 8 months ago
Very nice look. Plus you really explained how easy it is. Thanks for sharing.
Please ignore people who send terrible comments. They are just sad and want some attention.
8jbird 8 months ago
You did this really well, it looked exactly the same, and no I don't think you talked too much! I go for looks like this, not too much and natural!
xoDARE 8 months ago
ahaha. this was cute. it was fun to watch & personally you don't even need makeup pretty girl !
okatherine 8 months ago
wow you are gorgeous! dnt let the haters get you down
iwillloveyouforeverr 8 months ago
your eyes are really beautiful! :)
novittumira 8 months ago
What did you use for the lip color again? NYC _____?
It's a GORGEOUS, natural-looking shade! I love it. :)
kaleekrahn2010 8 months ago
wow, everyone is jealous of you! You're stunning and this is a really good video :D didn't quite hear the name of the lip colour though! What was it again? :)
1993mej 8 months ago
i just put this on for makeup night!!!!!!!!!!!
vje65 8 months ago
whats the hightlighter she put on the nose and cheek bones??!!?
vje65 8 months ago
i love your videos <3
themerseybeats 8 months ago
-3 that you talk fast! You must be from the east coast! Hate slow tutorials! What is the name brand of the highlighter? That was a little to fast for me?! :). Thank you for sharing!
TheSassyWonderwoman 8 months ago
I LIKE THAT YOU TALK A LOT! IT MAKES YOUR VIDEOS MORE CONVERSATIONAL, MORE PERSONAL! GREAT JOB! BOO TO THE RUDE PPL!
Poetallmalife 8 months ago
Such a sweetheart! I love her! And she's gorgeous! Keep making videos Hun! You rock!
megasuperlovababe 8 months ago
Hahaha I love the looong pause at the end XD suspense
GoddessLacus 8 months ago
I like your accent! Where are you from? Roots wise oc.
GoddessLacus 8 months ago
You have an amazing personality, and I love this look. You're beautiful!
thecurledcoif67 8 months ago
Haters, I'm gonna piss in my hand, & toss it at your faces!
BabiiGuurl23 8 months ago
lol
XxluizaxX1 8 months ago
fuck ,a lot of people like stuf here ..... o.O
XxluizaxX1 8 months ago
i love this .. its actually really easy
thxx for doin that
nd btw u seem like a really nice person
nd i am in loveee with ur skintone
even before u ve put on the bronzer nd highlight thing
u had such a natural pretty glow
SimAndDee 8 months ago
Forget all the comments from the HATERS......I think you did a wonderful job explaining and demonstrating this particular look. Well done! And I should know a thing or two about make-up......I'm a Plus Size Model.
Because I have a job tomorrow, I will definitely be trying to imitate this look then. Thanks! Oh yeah, KUDOS to you for showing this look using reasonably priced products!
630Deidre 8 months ago
what did you use for your bronzer and blush in this video! your skin is amazing:)
TAKMIAFS000 9 months ago
i love this video! and you dont talk too much... i dont no what the hell other people are saying...
yanademeester 9 months ago
you are so gooood !!!!!! :)
glittermania01 9 months ago
You look like Nicole Sherzinger (Nooo idea how to spell her last name.) Stunning!!
TheNaellah 9 months ago
great tutorial, thank you for uploading you make it look reallly simple and great, and not to much like most guru's do, i really feel that i can do this look with little to no practice!
WhatMeganHasToSay 1 year ago 27
outstanding information, thanks 4 sharin, have anybody sampled Rimmels latest product line? it is hard to find quality makeup in Green Valley yet i managed to receive wonderful samples of makeup using 'Gratis Makeup Samples'! their handy!
spoilageplaythin 1 year ago 2
the way you highlight your inner corner is INCREDIBLE!!! you're seriously INCREDIBLE at what you do <3
MissMakeupMonkey 1 year ago 15
my name is bethany too ! xD (just sayin)
BWCPproductions 1 year ago
where did you get the highlighter?
1rene74 1 year ago 3
youre really pretty and your voice reminds me of someone famous, i just cant remember who
XMorningDewX 1 year ago 11
@Filepoo842
Major fan! How about doing a Mary Kate Olsen inspired tutorial?
Lots of you ladies reading this comment don't exactly love paying for high priced makeup. The costs add up awful fast! Luckily found out on the MAC facebook they're givin away a a bunch of free stuff the rest of the month. :] If you are lazy, I will save ya some time, heres their give away website.
shortener。org/93342
And, you got to use the code FACEBOOK4390 on page 3 <33
TinaDaBEezy 1 year ago
great video! you look like a younger version of kim kardashian!
shannonl03 1 year ago 3
HAHAHA "Go visit your long-lost grandmother or uncle and they'll probably give you ten bucks." LOL you're awesome..
0Tanesha0 1 year ago 19
goodness you got alot of jealous peps in here...@iwanted2c1video who cares what they think cause your vids are awesome!! keep making more :D
293Laie 1 year ago 10
is that champagne color still available at sally's? i'm sure i have one similiar but it looked really good on your vid. i have lighter skin though so it prob wouldn't be as bright as it looks on you.
ruddgirl 1 year ago
you're so pretty! :) Thanks- this really helped!
nancieninja 1 year ago
such a better look compared to the 'professional' ones i've seen where they think she wears 'gold and purple and pink eye shadow and bright pink lips etc!' when she clearly doesn't -.-
nerdnina 1 year ago
yeah its easy when you look like a supermodel! : (
adambush1 1 year ago 10
your so pretty...you have a little bit of dorkyness in you its cute XD
SexxiMoosE 1 year ago 6
u r amazingggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg
Katerynale 1 year ago
Great tutorial! You remind me of Rosario Dawson. (:
ShelfDustProductions 1 year ago
Beautifullll!
SuperLisaRaye 1 year ago
i absolutely love it!!
jhomangubat 1 year ago 6
you are really good at making tutorials
ilylolwtf 1 year ago 2
thanks! oh and you're very pretty!!!!!!!!
BlateroStulidum 1 year ago
i looove makeup! This videos great, i mostly use Max factor makeup i get for free from 'gratis makeup samples' they're impressive
Piperploch 1 year ago
i have that eyeshadow (:
heidiOOSH 1 year ago
wow it looks really good on you! but i am fair skin and green eyes... do you think if i switch the colours a bit i could pull it off?
MAKEUPGEEK123 2 years ago 112
She has a great personality.
caity213 2 years ago 514
@caity213 lol r u being sarcastic?
123avatarlover 9 months ago
So Very Pretty! Thanks
terry137137 2 years ago 48
Wow it came up really nice and your soo pretty!
humblehair004 2 years ago 40
you and all of your looks are freaking gorgeous!
can you tell us what contact you have?
maramarafashion 2 years ago 36
hei wat did u put on ur nose and check wat brend is it?
tylatequilaz 2 years ago
@tylatequilaz
tylatequilaz 2 years ago
YOUR SOOOOOOO PRETTYYY
wildhairgirl3 2 years ago 32
omg i use all these colors ahahaha
MsYamiley 2 years ago
you're beautiful! and someone finally explained to me how to do this look in a way that makes sense and looks amazing! thanks!
piperpratt1234 2 years ago 2
ahh you're so cute! :)
and really useful tutorial
it looks just like megan's makeup
mmadelle 2 years ago
Haha. You are so funny! And great vid btw :)
Serberinden 2 years ago
"its not like its 9am n your walkin around with a smokey eye" hahahha.
murrmadeable 2 years ago 8
everyone always asks me where i get my makeup and i tell them i buy it at walmart... they dont believe me! but you can find amazing makeup for cheap it just depends on how you apply! this vid shows how to look beautiful on a budget!
fuhnnypaul016 2 years ago 3
;-}
Monicc26 2 years ago
Hhahahaha your so funni,loved the video
caley1308 2 years ago
LOL go visit your long lost grand mother
mothalicka101 2 years ago 7
You seem like you're in a big hurry by your talking speed! haha. You're gorgeous though, and this is great! :D
xopinkieox 2 years ago 10
what brand was that highlighting cream? she said it kind of fast lol
MissLoveable326 2 years ago
e.l.f
NuB82 2 years ago
omg i love watching this video! ur the cutest thing :)
Gud4nuffin12 2 years ago
omg honestly you are so funny and really cute for your age. Its good to see girls your age being natural, not bitchy and fake. Keep up the good personality ^.^
ludatj 2 years ago 8
You are sooo funny!!Thih is great!
Тако си смешна!!!Ово је заиста одлично!!
SoWantedEverything 2 years ago
"its the pink one but i dont know what the colour is" hahaha (6:18)
grachious 2 years ago
Love it, I just wish if the camera was closer to your face, or eyes :D...
you are gorgeous :D...keep it up
Raychick83 2 years ago
I love the Make Up, it's very natural, thanks for sharing this Video :):)
hibasarah6 2 years ago
You are soo pretty!! :D, and your eyes kinda looks like Megan´s!! <3<3
MissEllolisoss 2 years ago
hey! your absolutley gorgeous! (you probrably hear that alot, or at least get comments ) lol. i liked how you used makeup that NORMAL people can actually AFFORD. like all the other tutorials have mac and its annoying lol. keeo the tutorials comming!
idiotmonkey123 2 years ago
hahahaaaa:D:D 10$..funny
you´re so cool!! (Y)
hypnozecat 2 years ago
your so pretttyy!! im so jealous of you lol
britneyspears37 2 years ago
LMAO!!!! u are super prettty lol and yeah u are thin, so what??? So am i! doesnt mean ur sick! i weight 112 aND Im 5'2 :P ignore retards telling u u look sick...ur make up tutorials are awesome :) keep it up!
Dayanna04 2 years ago
Cocky and annoying, that's all I have to say. Sorryyyyyy
linettekehr 2 years ago
thank you!! that wat I said too n she wrote me a nasty message! so watch out u may b next lol
Chiqui8Oreos 2 years ago
SO lame .. I mean, listen to her.. I hate girls like her..... SOOOOO annoying :-D
linettekehr 2 years ago
Comment removed
Sweetfac3 2 years ago
your so pretty :)
Kriss1666 2 years ago
She just looks naturally thin to me, at least she is not fat. She is pretty!
cubanatwinb2222 2 years ago
whoaw ur super pretty =]
nesrinecute 2 years ago
oh wow! i have that same exact desk! its really weird coz we got it at a yard sell when i was like.. 10! i think its a sign. i shall heed this sign and suscribe. lol. ^_^ but seriously, luv ur look! and love the prices too! ^_^
MuslimBeauty123 2 years ago
love the video. i especailly loved how you explained how to do a cat eye. this video is vary helpful
kenziedacutie1 2 years ago 2
pretty look....
but you talk a lot... sound like a tweaker...
and are you ok??? you are really skinny..... you look unhealthy....
thebeautiful1s 2 years ago
what are you talking about? she looks really pretty and healthy.
h4239gjdp 2 years ago
i didnt say she wasnt pretty...she is pretty, and talented, but i do think she looks unhealthy, unless she's about 14.... or maybe her camera angles just suck...
thebeautiful1s 2 years ago 3
or maybe it's just you.
h4239gjdp 2 years ago
Im naturally thin and healthy. Are you ill, you just say rude things and think its totally fine?
iwanted2c1video 2 years ago 349
@iwanted2c1video you are the cutest...whoever said you are thin is fat and jealous :)))
linaibraheem 8 months ago
She is adorable!
adestories 2 years ago 2
um u talk too much sry
Chiqui8Oreos 2 years ago
and if I talk to little you will complain "Oh you didnt explain this blah blah blah" go whine somewhere else
iwanted2c1video 2 years ago 143
U look like Eva Longoria
BalkanChick 2 years ago
hahahaahahah, okay ill go find my long-lost grandmother(:
meghanorlando 2 years ago 2
u should make an anime style look
BlueRazJollyRancher7 2 years ago
thats so realistic you earned a subscription :)
BlueRazJollyRancher7 2 years ago 3
ughh i need that maybelline quad
i'll get it today because i love this tutorial and this look.
rianrobot 2 years ago
u r so beautiful, great tutorial!
mgsgnp 2 years ago
I love it its awesome work =)
jonasbrothersfan1fm 2 years ago
my mom works at sally's! xD i get discounts! woot!
SincerelyYurz 2 years ago
i like how u talk
hehe
youre also pretty
SarawithnH 2 years ago
Lovely! I love your accent...
BabyBubastis 2 years ago 2
No sweety I ain't jealous lol this is hellla easyyy ! Everybody can do it ....
qartaki 2 years ago
U suck !
qartaki 2 years ago
jealllouussssss?
SE3YOUNT 2 years ago 4
before you tell me I suck take a look at my channel, I beat alot of gurus on here! and what? I said it! :P
iwanted2c1video 2 years ago 128
i like you and nice lock
NoNa733 2 years ago
you look like a victorias secret model :)
usmcmireles 2 years ago 9
megan fox's eye is just amazing, she is a stunner x
kkdahabibi 2 years ago 6
beautiful blue eyes of megan fox !
jayveeluvsyoo 2 years ago
youre so pretty! you could be a vs model! :) and i tried this look and its my new everyday look! ive gotten compliments..<3
youmakemesmile3 2 years ago 2
Ok good job and stuff, great nice.. but can you slow down? You are really quick, fast, crack, kinda. I'm so mellow, I can''t follow alng with this :(
TrissFit 2 years ago 2
i followed along just fine. you can always replay the video and pause it at each step...
teresarrsaurus 2 years ago
Haha you are sooo funny in the beginning =] I love this look =D
SocalAlice 2 years ago 3
Thank you for the tip!
You're very pretty and you have a very beautiful eyes <3
happyjaybee 2 years ago
You are very beautiful!
hebbyxoxo 2 years ago 3
and anyway, what are 2 MEN doing on here lookin at makeup tutorials? Hmmm..maybe they r lookin 4 some tips 2try out for themselves...lmao, haters!!
juliabranche 2 years ago 2
those 2 idiots Hitman & greenlantern probably never had or will have a chick even close 2being as pretty as u!! the fact that their on here hatin, proves that!!
juliabranche 2 years ago 5
Damn girl watchu talk all fast forr
babygyrll1 2 years ago 4
i think it's edited cos the video is pretty long :P
iTube543 2 years ago
You're gorgeous!
Great tutorial :)
froggy9191 2 years ago 2
are you from jersey?
downloadMEfast 2 years ago
youre very prettyy.
hiiiIIILoveyou 2 years ago
thanks! I got lots of great Maybelline makeup from 'gratismakeupsamples' they'll last me ages!
pumpkinpie18f 2 years ago
whats an alternate to the champegne color??
cheap products perhaps?
BurnInMaLight 2 years ago
@BurnInMaLight a great one i think is the almay intense i-color powder shadow trio for brown eyes. its the shadows that they advertise based on your eye color, the top color is great color especially for the inner corner of the eye :) great price too!
rknv05 2 years ago
okay thanks!!
i think ill tryi it
BurnInMaLight 2 years ago
Where do you get the base that you put on before you eye shadow??
moochi34 2 years ago
duude your arms are scary skinny, but you are still pretty!
actmishart 2 years ago
natural beauutyy
StarLiikea 2 years ago
You are Veryy beatyfuuuuul :D
StarLiikea 2 years ago
hey everyone go check out my make up tutorials please!!
wasfdc 2 years ago
you hve beautiful skin.
OneLoveGodisLove 2 years ago
what eyelash glue do you use? because i have the elf false eye lashes but the glue is really bad... helpp :)))
itz3va 2 years ago
omg! you did such a great job your so pretty:]
missev123 2 years ago
thanks! I got lots of perfect Maybelline makeup from 'gratismakeupsamples' they'll last me ages!
lorealbeauty19f 2 years ago
I love this look! Plus, under $10!
LoVeStoned2424 2 years ago 2
more Eva Longoria then Megan Fox
Bolatkyzy 2 years ago 2
what do u use to cover ur dark eye circles??
xh317 2 years ago
You are like my favorite youtube makeup guru! Your videos have helped me so much. I get so many compliments on my eye makeup now thanks to u :)
MzBREESKiiB00 2 years ago
Luv da look!!!!
Sweetslurver 2 years ago
haha she reminds me of a cuter version of Boxxy
pistolbanana 2 years ago
Where does everyone else get their makeup? I tend to get samples for free from 'gratismakeupsamples', just got some beautiful Sally Hansen makeup recently.
movielover19f 2 years ago
@movielover19f i find it easiest to get makeup at walgreens cuz there is one right down the road from me but any drug store will have tons. walmart kmart shopko. stores like that will have have tons
snapplechick716 2 years ago
I just discovered you and I love your videos..and your New Yorkish accent. I just have two requests. Please list everything(not just some of the products used) you use on the right. Also what brand is the highlighter your used and how much?
Msbbopalula 2 years ago
its so friggin funny, it sounds like shes doin her makeup inside a airplane. listen! lol
214lovejess 2 years ago
go visit your long lost grandmother there probably give you 10 bucks hahaha! your cute.
Im short on cash so like i know what makeup to get thank you so much your awesome!!:)
mawriysa 2 years ago 2
@mawriysa i know, i was about 2 comment on that :D she said it like it was so normal! haha, cute.
ayume1 2 years ago
@ayume1 i guess i wasant the only one that noticed it was funny n cute that she said that:)
mawriysa 2 years ago
I love that you show how we can achieve this look with only 10 dollars! Thanks! It was very helpful :)
Druuna55 2 years ago
you sound like Sarah Palin...you Alaskan?
TheCuriousCurator 2 years ago
lol :) no Im from Chicago :)
iwanted2c1video 2 years ago
thanks for the video your amazing =)
jennyy503 2 years ago
omg!
I'M PRETTY sure not all Americans are THAT narrow minded. :)
But really seeing these comments..makes me sad..
minute1981 2 years ago
lmfao, you said walking aROUND at 9:00 in a smokey eye. lmfao xD
ImJennaKate 2 years ago
this is a good idea in that using drugstore makeup is great and teaching others how to apply makeup is great too but for some reason i cannot get over how stupid you sound. I'm really sorry...I know its mean but I cannot get over it because you're very talented at doing makeup looks. Maybe she has a retainer or something? She also sounds like shes from somewhere outside of NYC.
anjagleich 2 years ago
If you admitt that it is mean, then why did you say it?
prettywalkforanyguy 2 years ago
FAKE! her natural eye shape is sexy before makeup!
aharigast 2 years ago
Where does everyone else get their makeup? I tend to get samples for free from 'gratismakeupsamples', just got some great Garnier makeup recently.
moviebuff18f 2 years ago