蔡健雅寫的歌都好棒好細膩^^
k2222cute 1 month ago
超爱蔡健雅!! 几时会来大马? :(
acechoo 2 months ago
从7年前开始听tanya的歌...几乎每一首都听过...
从今年开始听eason的歌....只听过几首...其中最喜欢的就有多少....
听了这么久...几乎每天重复的只听这一首...
今天~才知道原来是tanya写的...然后找到了这个唯一的她的版本...
好久没有这种感觉了...为一首歌激动~
Sophilynz 2 months ago 3
好聽,兩個人都唱出不同的感覺!
即使是簡單的旋律也能唱出感動,Tanya就是那麼厲害
JungHaoWen 3 months ago 3
這個是DEMO
所以只有簡單的伴奏,ok?
ffiva 3 months ago
Eason version is better
cream923 3 months ago
this song makes me cry out like a baby :( what a great song!
dgftytxc 3 months ago
難怪我這麼愛多少這首歌 原來是蔡健雅寫的...
MaureenChao 3 months ago 6
陳奕迅的版本比較好聽。。可是還是很愛Tanya的 <3
Pigybarney 3 months ago
兩種版本都很啦!!!!
JamesWilson14720 3 months ago
陳的版本比較難唱.蔡都只是靠聲音.
stgf1080 4 months ago
好好聽!!!!
david123341 4 months ago
Comment removed
kaitat93811 4 months ago
此終都係聽蔡健雅唱得好過陳奕迅,可能是原key版本會較自然吧
首歌寫得咁好 點解唔留返比自己呢
沒有華麗編曲 但簡單的唱 讓人覺得舒服 當然畢竟這是DEMO 就像設計圖的草稿之類的 大家何必拿來跟完整版eason的做比較呢 沒有這一個DEMO 又怎麼會有完整版eason版本? 能夠聽到DEMO版 好棒 感覺赤裸裸的 聽到最原始的版本 感謝上傳
fireflyxing 5 months ago 11
Eason和Tanya都好棒
amanda840508 5 months ago
我還是比較喜歡陳奕迅的,比較有張力,比較歇斯底里,比較唱進我心裡:)
m250325 6 months ago 3
@m250325
雖然蔡健雅也唱很不錯,但是一種淡然的感覺…我也愛陳奕迅的!
927zoe 4 months ago
@m250325
為什麼大家都要批評那些按不喜歡的呢???
搞不好這首歌曾經是他的紀念~~~只是現在聽了難過!!!
又或者如何如何的~~~
人人觀點不盡相同啦~~~少批評多包容!!!
iceman1324555 6 months ago 19
三個人的耳朵都又問題
lovejolin8172 6 months ago
很好聽~~
sunminchen 7 months ago
手指朝下不是下載鍵哦 ~
MrMarimi 8 months ago 16
那個不喜歡的應該是點錯吧..........XD
getsea195 9 months ago 15
lok2235 9 months ago 8
那一個不喜歡的是誰阿
sunism0507 11 months ago 6
@sunism0507 太好聽感動到按錯了吧... 要不然沒道理阿
popo4ever 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我好喜歡蔡健雅淡淡味道淡淡憂傷歌聲---真好聽
趕快出新專輯吧!
LEXUSAM 11 months ago
我好喜歡蔡健雅淡淡味道淡淡憂傷歌聲---真好聽
LEXUSAM 11 months ago 3
呢首demo係邊度搵架??有冇出碟架>?/
sorachristy 1 year ago
三月在台北四月在台中要開演唱會了 加油.加油
wego186 1 year ago
不是多也不是少 我要的全是灰.....
ashingliu 1 year ago
跟eason有的拚!!!!
gn02275737 1 year ago 7
簡單的 background 音樂 動聽的聲音 好喜歡!!
cupidsheart100 1 year ago
佢e種唱法好清, 好鐘意佢d尾音
woodylf211 1 year ago
!:)
candy92912 1 year ago
GOOD
awesome!!!! just love it~
lmwpassion 1 year ago
默默的聽 默默的做自己的事 卻默默的紅了眼眶...tanya的聲音真美妙
jimsaipeter 1 year ago 8
@jimsaipeter 說得太好了 Tanya的歌聲真的有魔力 很有穿透力
jovotw 7 months ago
自己療傷 寂寞又堅毅
De2by7hung 1 year ago 4
love this version
strayheaven 1 year ago
聽了好想掉淚
aquar0131 1 year ago 4
簡單乾淨的伴奏~更有種唱到心裡去的fu~
Tanya的聲音總是那樣的撫慰了我的心
ANGELFY0719 1 year ago
This entire song is very similar to the song 'Amazed' by Lonestar, especially the beginning of this song is 100% the same.
evertraveler 1 year ago
Tanya 加油,第二十二届金曲奖等着你!
TamiiaShow 1 year ago
i love u tanya
陪著我長大的歌手
fixedouble 1 year ago
很有自己的風格~
werth568 1 year ago
Finally, I got this version. I can't say how much I love Tanya, also Eason perform this song perfectly!!!
garysuengyu 1 year ago 34
@garysuengyu Where did you get it? I want to buy the CD if I can. I live in the UK.
Gordominus 1 year ago
@Gordominus I believe I left my comment in a wrong way, I should say "finally, I found this version..." I don't think this was from a published CD or EP.
garysuengyu 1 year ago
@garysuengyu I see. Thank you anyway!
好愛你TANYA。
GlenFun 1 year ago 2
do u hv tis song in mp3?
hughug712 1 year ago
我愛蔡健雅~!!!!!!!
gaea0524 1 year ago 156
蔡健雅寫的歌都好棒好細膩^^
k2222cute 1 month ago
超爱蔡健雅!! 几时会来大马? :(
acechoo 2 months ago
从7年前开始听tanya的歌...几乎每一首都听过...
从今年开始听eason的歌....只听过几首...其中最喜欢的就有多少....
听了这么久...几乎每天重复的只听这一首...
今天~才知道原来是tanya写的...然后找到了这个唯一的她的版本...
好久没有这种感觉了...为一首歌激动~
Sophilynz 2 months ago 3
好聽,兩個人都唱出不同的感覺!
即使是簡單的旋律也能唱出感動,Tanya就是那麼厲害
JungHaoWen 3 months ago 3
這個是DEMO
所以只有簡單的伴奏,ok?
ffiva 3 months ago
Eason version is better
cream923 3 months ago
this song makes me cry out like a baby :( what a great song!
dgftytxc 3 months ago
難怪我這麼愛多少這首歌 原來是蔡健雅寫的...
MaureenChao 3 months ago 6
陳奕迅的版本比較好聽。。可是還是很愛Tanya的 <3
Pigybarney 3 months ago
兩種版本都很啦!!!!
JamesWilson14720 3 months ago
陳的版本比較難唱.蔡都只是靠聲音.
stgf1080 4 months ago
好好聽!!!!
david123341 4 months ago
Comment removed
kaitat93811 4 months ago
此終都係聽蔡健雅唱得好過陳奕迅,可能是原key版本會較自然吧
首歌寫得咁好 點解唔留返比自己呢
kaitat93811 4 months ago
沒有華麗編曲 但簡單的唱 讓人覺得舒服 當然畢竟這是DEMO 就像設計圖的草稿之類的 大家何必拿來跟完整版eason的做比較呢 沒有這一個DEMO 又怎麼會有完整版eason版本? 能夠聽到DEMO版 好棒 感覺赤裸裸的 聽到最原始的版本 感謝上傳
fireflyxing 5 months ago 11
Eason和Tanya都好棒
amanda840508 5 months ago
我還是比較喜歡陳奕迅的,比較有張力,比較歇斯底里,比較唱進我心裡:)
m250325 6 months ago 3
@m250325
雖然蔡健雅也唱很不錯,但是一種淡然的感覺…我也愛陳奕迅的!
927zoe 4 months ago
@m250325
雖然蔡健雅也唱很不錯,但是一種淡然的感覺…我也愛陳奕迅的!
927zoe 4 months ago
為什麼大家都要批評那些按不喜歡的呢???
搞不好這首歌曾經是他的紀念~~~只是現在聽了難過!!!
又或者如何如何的~~~
人人觀點不盡相同啦~~~少批評多包容!!!
iceman1324555 6 months ago 19
三個人的耳朵都又問題
lovejolin8172 6 months ago
很好聽~~
sunminchen 7 months ago
手指朝下不是下載鍵哦 ~
MrMarimi 8 months ago 16
那個不喜歡的應該是點錯吧..........XD
getsea195 9 months ago 15
lok2235 9 months ago 8
那一個不喜歡的是誰阿
sunism0507 11 months ago 6
@sunism0507 太好聽感動到按錯了吧... 要不然沒道理阿
popo4ever 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我好喜歡蔡健雅淡淡味道淡淡憂傷歌聲---真好聽
趕快出新專輯吧!
LEXUSAM 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
我好喜歡蔡健雅淡淡味道淡淡憂傷歌聲---真好聽
LEXUSAM 11 months ago
我好喜歡蔡健雅淡淡味道淡淡憂傷歌聲---真好聽
LEXUSAM 11 months ago 3
呢首demo係邊度搵架??有冇出碟架>?/
sorachristy 1 year ago
三月在台北四月在台中要開演唱會了 加油.加油
wego186 1 year ago
不是多也不是少 我要的全是灰.....
ashingliu 1 year ago
跟eason有的拚!!!!
gn02275737 1 year ago 7
簡單的 background 音樂 動聽的聲音 好喜歡!!
cupidsheart100 1 year ago
佢e種唱法好清, 好鐘意佢d尾音
woodylf211 1 year ago
!:)
candy92912 1 year ago
GOOD
candy92912 1 year ago
awesome!!!! just love it~
lmwpassion 1 year ago
默默的聽 默默的做自己的事 卻默默的紅了眼眶...tanya的聲音真美妙
jimsaipeter 1 year ago 8
@jimsaipeter 說得太好了 Tanya的歌聲真的有魔力 很有穿透力
jovotw 7 months ago
自己療傷 寂寞又堅毅
De2by7hung 1 year ago 4
love this version
strayheaven 1 year ago
聽了好想掉淚
aquar0131 1 year ago 4
簡單乾淨的伴奏~更有種唱到心裡去的fu~
Tanya的聲音總是那樣的撫慰了我的心
ANGELFY0719 1 year ago
This entire song is very similar to the song 'Amazed' by Lonestar, especially the beginning of this song is 100% the same.
evertraveler 1 year ago
Tanya 加油,第二十二届金曲奖等着你!
TamiiaShow 1 year ago
i love u tanya
陪著我長大的歌手
fixedouble 1 year ago
很有自己的風格~
werth568 1 year ago
Finally, I got this version. I can't say how much I love Tanya, also Eason perform this song perfectly!!!
garysuengyu 1 year ago 34
@garysuengyu Where did you get it? I want to buy the CD if I can. I live in the UK.
Gordominus 1 year ago
@Gordominus I believe I left my comment in a wrong way, I should say "finally, I found this version..." I don't think this was from a published CD or EP.
garysuengyu 1 year ago
@garysuengyu I see. Thank you anyway!
Gordominus 1 year ago
好愛你TANYA。
GlenFun 1 year ago 2
do u hv tis song in mp3?
hughug712 1 year ago
我愛蔡健雅~!!!!!!!
gaea0524 1 year ago 156
Comment removed
LEXUSAM 11 months ago