There's something about Ellen McLain's voice that sends varying types of chills through me. She may have called her Italian bad, but I thought that song was one of the most beautiful parts of the game.
This is more sad when you think about the whole "Chell dieing" theory. Yes, some people theorize that Chell's ride toward the wheat fields was her ascending to heaven, and that the wheat fields themselves were heaven. The turrets really did kill her.
This song reminded me of Dobby from Harry Potter, Mufasa from Lion King... The guy that hit his head on the propeller in titanic... When Darth Vader died... When Golum died in LOTR, When Dizzy died in Star Ship troopers... When Chuck Norris died in Ultimate Showdown.... When Dom died in GOW... and i just sat there... and cried... for the whole day.... no joke... :'(
@Immaimperfictcell what if Cave Johnson is alive? According to all records and accounts he's dead as a doornail, yet Aperture invented a type of stasis that kept Chell alive for so many years. Plus they managed to upload Caroline into a computer. It's never fully said that they didn't do the same for Cave, just assumed. <- new conspiracy theory invented :)
@madmanmapper Cave Johnson is alive inside us all, hes that voice in the back of your head that no matter what you say well always threaten you with incendiary lemons...
actually, you can still faintly hear the opera in the background even after Chell reaches the surface, so it would stand to reason that the actual tune is at least a bit longer than the released version
Lyrics cara bell cara mia bella MY DEAR BEAUTIFUL DARLING mia bambina,Chell BEAUTIFUL LITTLE GIRL, OH CHELL che lastima, che la stima WHAT A SHAME, WHAT A SHAME lacara mia WELL MY DEAR addio GOODBYE mia bambina cara MY DEAR LITTLE GIRL perche non passi lontana WHY DON'T YOU STAY AWAY si' lontana de scienza? YES, AWAY FROM SCIENCE? cara cara mia bambina MY DEAR, DEAR LITTLE GIRL lamia bell MY LOVELY lamia cara lamia cara MY DEAR, MY DEAR mia bambina MY LITTLE GIRL cara cara a mi DEAR, DEAR TO ME
@ahbrother Rather ambiguous hehe. All I can say is that the 'beginning' is the original song, completely and utterly unedited, not only for those who enjoy the original version, but to also juxtapose it with the edited. In any case, I still very much enjoy the original recording and don't think it needs any 'work' at all, but it was fun to offer an extended version. If you are referring to something else--perhaps w/ regards to cadence or pitch--I am always open to musical suggestions.
This is such an awesome song.... but I can't get to it super fast like I can to Want You Gone via Developers Commentary...I have to do Chapter 9 first....
2:46 is the best bit. You can almost see Chell staring up at the stars, wondering about Wheatly, while this playes in the background. As the song gets stronger, she forgives him and hopes he is okay.
Lyrics in English: Dear beautiful, my beautiful darling! My child, oh Chell! For I hold her in esteem... For I hold her in esteem. Farewell to my dear! My dear girl, why do you not walk away? Yes, away from Science, my dear, my dear girl? Ah, my beautiful! Ah, my dear! Ah, my dear! Ah, my child! Oh dear, my dear... thats where it ends on the game, not sure where to get entire song lyrics
I didn't cry at Steel Magnolias. I didn't shed one tear when Bambi's mother got shot. I wasn't the least bit depressed when I watched the end of Titanic. This made me weep.
I love this song, I love it so much it has a special place in my itunes and ipod. I raised my standards. Everything I had rated 5 stars is now 3, this is the ONLY 5 star song in my itunes. Plus its the only song with 5 different playlists.
I'm a metal head and THIS SONG is THE BEST. Please, if you know any others let me know.
@little2miss8piggypoo same here it made me sob and my sister had a hell of a tme sleeping with me like"omg souch a butyfull song *sob* I wanna hear again *relay* and repeat of the same stuff"
Valve just released the 3rd part of the official soundtrack on it's site and it includes an extended version called "Cara Mia Addio" which is about 2:30 long :D
@polarmanzues That's not Rattman, that's really just one of the frankenstein-turret/cubes hobbling past. Rattman put himself in a stasis chamber (which can only be opened externally) after getting shot in the leg by a turret, if you hadn't read the comic, so that can't possibly be him.
@Anthony883 At 1:30, I did, actually. It was a very minor (and only) loop to juxtapose the original with the edited--which actually comes a bit later. Also, if you'd like to leave some intelligent criticism, I certainly welcome it. 'Ew' is not very informative. And do try to listen to the entire piece (as opposed to stopping before the actual edits, ~four seconds in the next loop) before leaving a comment. Credibility shoots up this way.
@TheFuboo What problem are you having exactly? Simply hit the link in the description. Then, click on 'Download This File'--it is to the immediate left of an envelope icon. That should bring up another page (ignore any pop ups). Click 'Download Now.' It will bring up another page. It should tell you that the download will begin shortly in ~48 seconds or so. Just wait, then when it states it is ready, simply click that link. If you still encounter trouble, simply PM me.
1: when you change the tempo to a slower tempo, try to balance the bass and increase the pitch by 0.1 semitones. that will prevent a robotic sound, like at the end.
2:i think your dynamics were used correctly, but slightly in wrong spots. your pianoforte at the end should have started softer at pianissimo. then there is more room for the volume to grow and sound better.
3: instead of looping the track when the first is complete to the start of the next track., try looping the end of a phrase to a similar sounding start of a phrase. for example 2:20 after she says "bel" smoothly cut it back to 1:45. then at 2:03 smoothly cut it to 2:23.
4: some of the echos were unnecessary and could be taken out.
i hope this helped and again if you found any of this hurtful it is only meant to be helpful. thoughtful criticism. hope i see more work like this from you!
1. It is impressive. There is no doubt about that. The dynamics used in the second half of the song add a note of sadness and longing for a loved child missing, an altering of the mood before.
2. My only gripe is in the middle of the song where the song decrescendos to pianissimo. Personally, I find the "distortion" or "muffling" used to try to lend a note of distance is a mite overdone. If a future version were to be made, I would suggest it be removed.
@DFZero235 I actually completely agree on your second point here. I did not want it to be as soft and muffled either. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to edit and use a pre-rendered track with sound effects, modulation and everything already mixed together. Makes things much more difficult. I had to soften it at this part because, were it to be louder, the background of another part of the track (from which I was splicing) would be too audible and ruin the section.
In order to decrease this, I had to clean it and strip it a bit (the muffling) and lower the volume significantly. I do hope that Valve ultimately releases a version of the song with just the song. It'd be a dream to have the original, but anything without the sounds (like the elevator, etc) would be great. If that happens, I'll certainly upload a new version. Thank you for your thoughtful critique!
I wonder; because they may or may not release it as part of the Portal 2 soundtrack -- and if memory serves correct, it is free to download. I just can't remember where. I do know it's hanging around somewhere on the official site though.
Also, last I checked Volume 3 is yet to come, so it might be in there.
@ldf8u i agree with zero in that its a little to much, like it shouldnt have been as slow and it shouldnt sound so distant unless it were to come back faster for a lrger contrast and cooler effect. BUT either way this still blows me away. i love u for doing this =]. good job
I want to wander around aperture's every corridor from bottom of the salt mine to the top to view the most amazing facility time forgot. To this music. Brilliant.
when ever i'm at the grocery store im always afraid the lemons are going to set me on fire and burn my house down...
deadcrazymonkey 5 days ago
@madmanmapper I agree.Who says he is not in a stasis? even though,yes,they say he is dead as a melting rock. Btw,this was epic typing to the song.
Immaimperfictcell 5 days ago
:,)
ZGKShow 1 week ago
Nice work :D
NicholasX9 1 week ago
Love it...
thijsje6 1 week ago
There's something about Ellen McLain's voice that sends varying types of chills through me. She may have called her Italian bad, but I thought that song was one of the most beautiful parts of the game.
firewallednonspeaker 1 week ago 2
... I remember almost coming to tears hearing this, watching the elevator ascend to the heavens.
GiloLAAG2 2 weeks ago 2
This is more sad when you think about the whole "Chell dieing" theory. Yes, some people theorize that Chell's ride toward the wheat fields was her ascending to heaven, and that the wheat fields themselves were heaven. The turrets really did kill her.
BUUUT THAT'S JUST A SILLY THEORY C:
DemsClothsFoThrowin 2 weeks ago
3:46 No! Don't close to the door! :'(
Conservative4 2 weeks ago
This is truly a work of art.
Readmycommentfucka 2 weeks ago
This song reminded me of Dobby from Harry Potter, Mufasa from Lion King... The guy that hit his head on the propeller in titanic... When Darth Vader died... When Golum died in LOTR, When Dizzy died in Star Ship troopers... When Chuck Norris died in Ultimate Showdown.... When Dom died in GOW... and i just sat there... and cried... for the whole day.... no joke... :'(
WolfiePro 3 weeks ago 2
@WolfiePro chuck norris can't die! HES IMMORTAL >.<
SilverSugarwings 1 week ago
@WolfiePro chuck norris can't die! HES IMMORTAL >.<
SilverSugarwings 1 week ago
@WolfiePro
YOU BASTARD, I JUST NOW GOT AROUND TO PURCHASING GOW, JUST NOW.
I HATE YOU
xXjoelXx8 17 hours ago
You sad bastards. It's a lovely song but crying - really?!
SuperMathsBeaver 3 weeks ago 2
this made me think about cave, and i cryed thinking about him.i wish he was still alive );
Immaimperfictcell 3 weeks ago
@Immaimperfictcell what if Cave Johnson is alive? According to all records and accounts he's dead as a doornail, yet Aperture invented a type of stasis that kept Chell alive for so many years. Plus they managed to upload Caroline into a computer. It's never fully said that they didn't do the same for Cave, just assumed. <- new conspiracy theory invented :)
madmanmapper 6 days ago
@madmanmapper Cave Johnson is alive inside us all, hes that voice in the back of your head that no matter what you say well always threaten you with incendiary lemons...
deadcrazymonkey 5 days ago
this made me cry );
ReconRivaldo 4 weeks ago
The download link is down
99bottlesofwine 4 weeks ago
We ALL have to band together and write a letter to VALVe explaining that we want - need an extended version of this song!!!!!
jeramahia123 4 weeks ago
This song is beautiful, I'm not an Opera fan, but for this I'll make an exception. If more Opera songs were like this, I'd listen to them all day.
helix4811 4 weeks ago
@helix4811 Amen to that.
jeramahia123 4 weeks ago
i think that valve has a great sence of music to put in their games
spuddsstudios 1 month ago
thumbs up if you can reach those notes
johnchandara 1 month ago
this makes me want to play it over and over again c:
Foxx988 1 month ago
start playing this after nitself in about 1 second souds awsome
purejshots1 1 month ago
This, feeling, not sad - not happy, don't know what to say of this opera
CodFreNeS1 1 month ago
@CodFreNeS1 reflective? nostalgic? accepting?
I dont know what word fits it?
LemonySword 1 month ago
es la mejor opera del mundo
migiz11 1 month ago
My little brother wouldnt come out of the closet after his grandmother died, but when i played this, he came out. you worked wonders.
alishashaan 1 month ago 44
@alishashaan Wow. I'm quite touched and wish you both the best.
ldf8u 1 month ago 10
@ldf8u Is there no OST of this? I want to download it without the elevator :P
brandonhud60 2 weeks ago
the bass at 1:03 is so intense O.o
MrBenlus 1 month ago
actually, you can still faintly hear the opera in the background even after Chell reaches the surface, so it would stand to reason that the actual tune is at least a bit longer than the released version
kblargh 1 month ago
This... made me cry. QuQ
NachtschattenBowser 1 month ago
italian opera is cool :D
ELTROOPER1001 1 month ago
The last minute or so is fricking amazing man!
winndypops 1 month ago
I was about to bawl when Glados told Chell that she's going to let her free.
GirLuffer 1 month ago
JTopouzian 1 month ago
i love this song
lolollol75 1 month ago
Awesome work, but it seems the download link is no longer working :(
Shredderbox 1 month ago
esta es una cancion que bale la pena escuchar!
migiz11 1 month ago
Comment removed
migiz11 1 month ago
i fell asleep crying to this song...
darkhart64 1 month ago
i cried listening to this in the game
solokinks 2 months ago 4
wah why end so fast? guess we must convey the valve legacy foward forever!! dont fall back! let portal have new ones 3456789101112 and more!
solokinks 2 months ago
Hahaha, I put the snowflake feature on and it looks pretty funny.
Snowflakes aside, I really love this extended version. >w<
UchihaLover98 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
I fell in love with portal and I am so sad it ended...... I always cry when I see Chell at the end leaving
JaslFam 2 months ago
That picture is amazing, btw. I fell in love with this game, SO MUCH! -3
LurellePiano 2 months ago
Thanks very much!! This is an excellent version of this song.
:)
liizzset 2 months ago
Loved it but it could use work in the begining
ahbrother 2 months ago 7
@ahbrother Rather ambiguous hehe. All I can say is that the 'beginning' is the original song, completely and utterly unedited, not only for those who enjoy the original version, but to also juxtapose it with the edited. In any case, I still very much enjoy the original recording and don't think it needs any 'work' at all, but it was fun to offer an extended version. If you are referring to something else--perhaps w/ regards to cadence or pitch--I am always open to musical suggestions.
ldf8u 2 months ago 17
@ldf8u me encanta tu vercion es la mejor que oido en toda mi vida!
migiz11 1 month ago
wow amazing
emuscenede 2 months ago
This is such an awesome song.... but I can't get to it super fast like I can to Want You Gone via Developers Commentary...I have to do Chapter 9 first....
TheWierdo67 2 months ago
This was perfect to end the game. Almost brought a tear to my eye when Chell was going up and they played this.
TheCatapultTV 2 months ago 3
@TheCatapultTV Lucky... i actually did cry.
Evoshun 2 months ago
this song also applies for university graduation!
Kennychan222 2 months ago
Your extended part sounds out of tune in places. Ouch. It's still really good though. c:
AkaiUme755 2 months ago 7
@AkaiUme755 Thanks. It is all original recording, so if it is out of tune, it is the original song/singing.
ldf8u 2 months ago 4
@ldf8u I don't hear any out of tune-dness ^.^ I think it was amazing, thank you for making it :)
SailorStar84 2 months ago
@SailorStar84 Thank you for listening! :)
ldf8u 2 months ago
Dont like the lemons ? , Make the big guy take them back. MAKE COMBUSTABLE LEMONS.
TheMrSmide 3 months ago
@TheMrSmide IMMA BURN YO HOUSE DOWN.
WITH THE LEMONS. xD
extraORDINARY137 2 months ago
LETS HEAR IT ONE M0:00RE TIME!!!
mrredstonemaster 3 months ago 2
Extend it more, EXTEND IT MORE D:
WoWheadboy 3 months ago
i love chell!!
Kennychan222 3 months ago
WHY AM I CRYING
TheJellicious 3 months ago
@TheJellicious When You Cry When This Song Comes On Because You Think Of The Memories Of Portal 2... You Know You Are A True Fan
DarkGothGirl3212 3 months ago
2:46 is the best bit. You can almost see Chell staring up at the stars, wondering about Wheatly, while this playes in the background. As the song gets stronger, she forgives him and hopes he is okay.
GwanThwei 3 months ago
I had to Cry when I played the Game....
Amazing Game+Amazing End+Amazing Music = Epic win !!
Thx VaLvE for This EPIC GAME *o*
King92Kazma 3 months ago
Getting misty eyed...
neosoc 3 months ago
dlxHazedxlb 3 months ago
@dlxHazedxlb This loops, so those ARE the whole lyrics.
ckl2erkki 3 months ago in playlist Liked
the bass when the animal king comes in is just the best thing ever i love the sense of power in the bass notes
tasteslikechildren 3 months ago
I didn't cry at Steel Magnolias. I didn't shed one tear when Bambi's mother got shot. I wasn't the least bit depressed when I watched the end of Titanic. This made me weep.
MadDuckInc151 3 months ago in playlist Memes 50
@MadDuckInc151 You didnt cry when Bambi´s mother died?
WHAT KIND OF HUMAN ARE YOU!? D:
alekzander2010 4 weeks ago
@alekzander2010
A self aware terminator...I didn't cry either.
helix4811 4 weeks ago
best song i've heard
TheLiankhor 3 months ago
Ah, the soprano is just so fantastic *_*
If there is something like a choir of angels, please let them be turrets.
And if there will be a Portal 3, please let the Turret Opera become famous.
AcidIssue 3 months ago 4
@AcidIssue OMG YES!
WatTehHell 3 months ago
:O
It's just so beautiful....
:.........)
it just gives me bittersweet feelings..
SilverSugarwings 3 months ago
Amazing fucking song !
sikara5788 3 months ago
A close friend of mine is a full time Bouncer at a Heavy Metal bar, this brought tears to his eyes T_T
Satsujin1 3 months ago in playlist Favoriten von Satsujin1 39
@Satsujin1 Wait, there are heavy metal bars? Why has no one told me this?
NiceHotCupOfBro 3 months ago
16 people who disliked just fucking blind
Jackfromshack 3 months ago
@Jackfromshack I think you mean deaf.
sladikk 3 months ago
@sladikk I'm sorry, English is not my natural language
Jackfromshack 3 months ago
this song is addictive
TheGamingNuke 3 months ago 2
this is nice music
bardon18 4 months ago
It's so sad but wonderful
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@crysisgamefan2 same here man this song just makes me want to wander the lower levels of aperture and remember it 1 second ago
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
SuperGmodkid @crysisgamefan2 same here man this song just makes me want to wander the lower levels of aperture and remember it 1 second ago
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
@crysisgamefan2 same here man this ing just makes me want to wander the lower levels of aperture and remember it
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
I love this song, I love it so much it has a special place in my itunes and ipod. I raised my standards. Everything I had rated 5 stars is now 3, this is the ONLY 5 star song in my itunes. Plus its the only song with 5 different playlists.
I'm a metal head and THIS SONG is THE BEST. Please, if you know any others let me know.
crysisgamefan2 4 months ago
I hate spell check
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
@little2miss8piggypoo same here it made me sob and my sister had a hell of a tme sleeping with me like"omg souch a butyfull song *sob* I wanna hear again *relay* and repeat of the same stuff"
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
In the epic words (and sounds) of pOtAtOS *clap...*clap...*clap "oh good, thats still working." You are the best. i love you.
ninjapowa816 4 months ago
Niohohohoho TheGasMasks ja polak rozumiem cię! :D
NeltPL 4 months ago
@MrVixtiln StopTrollingForUnicorns or STFU
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
THIS IS DUMB PLEBEIAN MUSIC
MrVictiln 4 months ago
@MrVictiln You, are a terrible person.
SMSVideoWarehouse 4 months ago
@SMSVideoWarehouse That's what it says, A horrible person. WE werent even testing for that.
crysisgamefan2 4 months ago
@SMSVideoWarehouse ron paul 2012 libertarian socalist party burzum
MrVictiln 4 months ago
THANK THE LORD FOR REPLAY BUTTON!
Tundranom 4 months ago 2
Comment removed
Tundranom 4 months ago
Skvělé... Skvělé... Říkám to v češtině aby jste věděli že to slyšel i někdo jiný než z USA... :) /POTLESK/
TheGasMasks 4 months ago
I love it so much it's souch a buteful song
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
This is a great song
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
This always makes me cry my face off
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
This is souch a byte I'll song it made me cry smile and shiver at the same time it truly touched my hart
SuperGmodkid 4 months ago
This touched my heart.
Appleisgreedy 4 months ago
Best Extended-Version ever! :)
HabboJonnybanana 4 months ago
Such a beautiful song, thank you for extending it.
Tundranom 4 months ago
My name is Commander Shepard and this is my favourite song on Youtube.
ImmersiveGStudios 4 months ago 3
this put my baby sister to sleep, made me cry :')
Little2Miss8PiggyPoo 4 months ago 102
@Little2Miss8PiggyPoo That is one of the sweetest things I've ever read. Thank you. :)
ldf8u 4 months ago 60
@Little2Miss8PiggyPoo it does the same for my baby cousins when im babysitting,
trainman164 4 months ago
@Little2Miss8PiggyPoo
MY HEART!
THE CUTENESS~
It burns like fire...
LadyMurderMaid 3 months ago
@Little2Miss8PiggyPoo Its kinda funny cause the italian translation is something about her staying away from science. haha
chaquator 3 months ago
i've favorited 3 different versions of this song, and this is one of the versions.
guyyouseewhenyoudie 4 months ago
The only good extension...
LeoniCalatia64 4 months ago
Very nice!! :)
hoiasdo 4 months ago
(:(o):)
/ | \
merrickv2028 4 months ago
Valve just released the 3rd part of the official soundtrack on it's site and it includes an extended version called "Cara Mia Addio" which is about 2:30 long :D
skyhawk431 4 months ago
Just plain awesome song I never liked opera till this
kbv13 4 months ago
"I couldn't find a good version...
So I made my own"
Best philosophy ever.
heroepato 4 months ago 193
@heroepato Pretty much! As long as you can follow through, I think it's great. :)
ldf8u 4 months ago 57
@ldf8u Could you release it in higher quality?
Loss less preferably if not 320kbps would be nice.
Thanks mate, and thanks for doing this!
DrFuzzyBaIlz 4 months ago
@heroepato beauty is in the eye of the beholder i agree with that philosophy!
TheJoyfulJerry 4 months ago
@heroepato Now THAT'S the Cave Johnson mindset! :D
Cursusblok365 4 months ago 4
@heroepato if only everyone followed that philosophy
sucsessfullfailpro 4 months ago
@heroepato The only philosophy everyone should live by. Don't like it? Make it yourself.
Everyone should think like that.
TALOS7887 3 months ago
@TALOS7887 i agree :D
dustymyboy 3 months ago
(\/) ;,,,; (\/) zoidberg!
ZTownProductions 5 months ago
@ZTownProductions nah.
(V)(;,,;)(V)
That's more like it
C0DESUB 4 months ago
@polarmanzues not he isn't, its just a compainon cube in a tube
Haxgasm 5 months ago
saldra portal 3?
VanillaReseni 5 months ago
RAT MAN IS IN THE ACTUAL VIDEO ON THE 22 SECOND MARK
polarmanzues 5 months ago
@polarmanzues That's not Rattman, that's really just one of the frankenstein-turret/cubes hobbling past. Rattman put himself in a stasis chamber (which can only be opened externally) after getting shot in the leg by a turret, if you hadn't read the comic, so that can't possibly be him.
RandomFox11 4 months ago
Trop belle cette chanson et magnifique jeu également!!
Rodolphe1212 5 months ago
I think the second part is too quiet
warmos19 5 months ago
@LaZBoyziez Wow. I can imagine this exactly!
ldf8u 5 months ago
eww 1:30.. NO. leave this song AS IS..
Anthony883 5 months ago
@Anthony883 At 1:30, I did, actually. It was a very minor (and only) loop to juxtapose the original with the edited--which actually comes a bit later. Also, if you'd like to leave some intelligent criticism, I certainly welcome it. 'Ew' is not very informative. And do try to listen to the entire piece (as opposed to stopping before the actual edits, ~four seconds in the next loop) before leaving a comment. Credibility shoots up this way.
ldf8u 5 months ago
I'm having a hard time downloading the link you've posted.
Help ;_;
TheFuboo 5 months ago 2
@TheFuboo What problem are you having exactly? Simply hit the link in the description. Then, click on 'Download This File'--it is to the immediate left of an envelope icon. That should bring up another page (ignore any pop ups). Click 'Download Now.' It will bring up another page. It should tell you that the download will begin shortly in ~48 seconds or so. Just wait, then when it states it is ready, simply click that link. If you still encounter trouble, simply PM me.
ldf8u 5 months ago
@TheFuboo right click and go to save link as , now leave me to mellow out to the song
treerunner123 5 months ago
this is EPIC!!
yogscastfancub1 4 months ago
@LaZBoyziez That should be a extra at E3
mcaso123 5 months ago in playlist Going Def From Dubstep
This has been flagged as spam show
my criticism (i am not trying to be hurtful)
1: when you change the tempo to a slower tempo, try to balance the bass and increase the pitch by 0.1 semitones. that will prevent a robotic sound, like at the end.
2:i think your dynamics were used correctly, but slightly in wrong spots. your pianoforte at the end should have started softer at pianissimo. then there is more room for the volume to grow and sound better.
i have more, but too much to fit in this comment.
xxshottycurbxx 5 months ago
3: instead of looping the track when the first is complete to the start of the next track., try looping the end of a phrase to a similar sounding start of a phrase. for example 2:20 after she says "bel" smoothly cut it back to 1:45. then at 2:03 smoothly cut it to 2:23.
4: some of the echos were unnecessary and could be taken out.
i hope this helped and again if you found any of this hurtful it is only meant to be helpful. thoughtful criticism. hope i see more work like this from you!
xxshottycurbxx 5 months ago
Comment removed
xxshottycurbxx 5 months ago
Sounds like the elevators twice as long. SWEET.
mcaso123 6 months ago in playlist Going Def From Dubstep
Im going to show this to my grandma, my itallian grandma.
mcaso123 6 months ago
This is what it would like sound like if you went to heaven :O XD
princesslovelygirl 6 months ago
@princesslovelygirl LOL I actually would like it if i went to heaven like this.
mcaso123 6 months ago
Best Turret opera extended version ever ! LOVE IT
i'm gonna listen it every day to relax myself
NoxiDream 6 months ago
A little critique, if I may be so bold.
1. It is impressive. There is no doubt about that. The dynamics used in the second half of the song add a note of sadness and longing for a loved child missing, an altering of the mood before.
2. My only gripe is in the middle of the song where the song decrescendos to pianissimo. Personally, I find the "distortion" or "muffling" used to try to lend a note of distance is a mite overdone. If a future version were to be made, I would suggest it be removed.
DFZero235 6 months ago 13
@DFZero235 I actually completely agree on your second point here. I did not want it to be as soft and muffled either. Unfortunately, it is very difficult to edit and use a pre-rendered track with sound effects, modulation and everything already mixed together. Makes things much more difficult. I had to soften it at this part because, were it to be louder, the background of another part of the track (from which I was splicing) would be too audible and ruin the section.
ldf8u 5 months ago
In order to decrease this, I had to clean it and strip it a bit (the muffling) and lower the volume significantly. I do hope that Valve ultimately releases a version of the song with just the song. It'd be a dream to have the original, but anything without the sounds (like the elevator, etc) would be great. If that happens, I'll certainly upload a new version. Thank you for your thoughtful critique!
ldf8u 5 months ago 4
@ldf8u Ah, I see. That sucks. :\
I wonder; because they may or may not release it as part of the Portal 2 soundtrack -- and if memory serves correct, it is free to download. I just can't remember where. I do know it's hanging around somewhere on the official site though.
Also, last I checked Volume 3 is yet to come, so it might be in there.
DFZero235 5 months ago
@DFZero235 I know the site to which you're referring. I've already downloaded songs from there. Here's to hoping!
ldf8u 5 months ago
@ldf8u i agree with zero in that its a little to much, like it shouldnt have been as slow and it shouldnt sound so distant unless it were to come back faster for a lrger contrast and cooler effect. BUT either way this still blows me away. i love u for doing this =]. good job
cacjad 5 months ago
I had mixed feelings when I was look at the picture while listening. It's like GlaDOS was staring through my soul.
wharfreek 6 months ago
Very nice :)
3nimac 6 months ago
Hmmm this makes me feel really sad.
I want to wander around aperture's every corridor from bottom of the salt mine to the top to view the most amazing facility time forgot. To this music. Brilliant.
SupaGreenBean 6 months ago
@SupaGreenBean it makes you sad too? is it because you feel it's over as well?
Ivychandessu 6 months ago
@Ivychandessu Yessssssssss! D:
Some of the best funniest, most bewildered hours of my life were spent in virtual aperture.
SupaGreenBean 6 months ago
like the razgriz song in ace combat 5
runescape2678 6 months ago
When i first heard this watching the ending of portal 2 a few tears shed ITS SO BEAUTIFUL!
markd9011 6 months ago