Added: 4 years ago
From: bearzdotes
Views: 184,547
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (104)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I am always so saddened to hear a good peformer re-do a song and do it badly. Where's the heart and soul here? Not feeling this one in the least.

  • This type of (bad) singing of this song should be illegal.

  • Pink does it better. Melissa Ethridge does it better. Faith, I love ya but girl you aint got this voice for this song.

  • BLASPHEMY! BLASPHEMY! BLASPHEMY! HOW DARE SHE REMAKE THIS MASTERPIECE INTO A F****** NASTY ASS COUNTRY SONG. THIS HICK B**** RUINED MY FAVORITE SONG! BLASPHEMY! BLASPHEMY!

  • impossible to imitate janis joplin, this is crap!

  • It's a Ragovoy-Berns song recorded by Erma Franklin released in '67!

    Janis covered it in '68 on the Cheap Thrills album.

    Janis probably would have not liked this version but would not be "turning in her grave" since she was cremated and her ashes were scattered in the Pacific Ocean.

  • Hot, but not Janis.

  • This is crap, she should be shot for destroying a Janis masterpeice

  • Oh gawd! If Janis heard this crap she'd probably take a little piece out of you! haha!

  • she destroyed this song...it makes my ears bleed....the WORST cover EVER and that's saying a lot...I wished for her to get hit by a bus full of rednecks after she released this....so shameful...she should run away and never show her face again.

  • Don't do songs you don't have the voice for... 

  • Take a Cup of shut the f*** up

  • wow she really took a great song and turned it into a pile of poop, listen to janet then this? wtf? weak as water

  • I agree...Janis would turn in her grave!

  • Rendition is horrible.

    Outfit is atrocious.

    My opinion, but there it is. Of course, Janis is My Generation. For What It's Worth.

  • Faith I like you but this is not your song. Now faith go listen to Melissa etheridge do this and go back to your country twang lol

  • gay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • OMG that's awful. Stop! Stop! Please! Ahhhhh ..... Janis is rolling in her grave and calling Ms. Hill every filthy thing she can think of. OMG!

  • Please, don´t listen it, Janis. Makes me wonder, who are gonna play Janis in the new movie.. Zoey Deschanel? I don´t know.. Pink is maybe much better.. What do you think?

  • this bitch sucks so much balls compared to janis joplin that its laughable. if she was alive she would be sick to her stomach

  • OH MY GOD!!!!!! yea, i'm going back to JANIS JOPLIN to listento this just to make sure this isn't in my head!!!!!!! blaaaaaah

  • so a gun man killed Lincoln, Kennedy and Lennon but no one can stand up and dieservingly shoot her for trying to sing this song... we always kill the wrong ppl

  • This is disrespectful to the memory of Janis Joplin. I am both sad and angry right now.

  • @CanadianWalrus

    "The song in general is such crap"????? You, sir or madam, are a brachycephalic, drooling, retarded cretinoid waste of perfectly good protoplasm. Do I make myself clear? Idiot.

  • Watch Melissa Etheridge's version of this song on youtube. Make sure you're sitting down when you watch it, because you might pass out and hurt yourself. It's unbelievable. It's at:

    youtube - dot- com/watch - ?v=dM_4NR_Oee8&feature=related

  • damn tim mcgraw is lucky

  • This song belongs to Janice...another person singing/slaughtering it should just be illegal.

    No offense Faith but you sucked at it. I cannot even imagine that you would want broadcast to the public.

  • these people think they can take a great song and fuck it up royally.

  • y the fuk did they allow her to sing this song?

  • Really unfair to judge Hill's ability to to this song justice by this short shitty clip is is not? No offense towards bearzdotes intended. Just commenting on the youtube music critics assessments.

  • FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF­FFUCK YOU STUPID WOMAN.. You haven't the balls.. you can't sing this song..

  • Wrong wRong wrOng wroNg wronG WRONG wrONng WronG wROng wroNg. 10 kinds of wrong. Just say no Faith, really.

  • LOL NOOB

  • kereoke version of Janis, wow, how terrible...

  • This coversong sucks!

  • lets just all agree that the only person allowed to sing this is ONLY janis joplin... ignoring the fact that she no longer can

  • it's a horrible attempt. some songs are like old buildings and should be protected by World Heritage, so they can not be touched by amateurs...if you can't sing don't sing!

    Joplin must be laughing her head off!

  • i agree with you this is the worst janis i ever had stay with country music faith

  • -.-*

  • pink definately sings this better!!! faith should be embarassed lol

  • this is DEFINITELY not the song for her, but i give her props for taking it on, and it wasn't as horrible as you're all saying. but i kinda hope she stays away from janis' music. not for her.

  • It really isn't awful, is it? Still, it does sound awfully candy ass next to the Joplin version.

  • She needs a choir to help her with the "come on", and it still doesn't sound anything like Janis. I think that says enough.

    Awful.

  • i came buckets.

  • Brutal. Is this what people like Pat Boone used to do to people like Chuck Berry? Just pretend you're at a strip club & the best is yet to come.

  • is it cabaret?

  • this song absolutely did not fit her

  • Neither did that cat suit she squeezed her fat ass into.

  • lmao she did look a little fucked up

  • Good God, this is absolutely atrocious - Janis must be turning in her grave.

  • What's that in English?

  • @disgustingduo Ha janis has a way grittier style your right this is messed up, im glad its only 55 seconds long

  • @disgustingduo She's actually smiling angry, canting curses on ms hill!!!

  • Terrible commercial/pristine take on a great song by Janis Joplin.

    JANIS JOPLIN "Piece of My Heart". Remember that.

  • @LunaSeaSane Actually the original was by Erma Franklin, not Janis Joplin. And it's still the best version.

  • @millymungo Thanks for the correction. Always glad to know about true origins.

    I still find that current artists are way too posy for any credible form of delivery on such a song. Buisness is killing the soul of music; they're killing what made music stand out from the "buisness as usual" principle. With excessive image and palatable product concerns, they are sweeping music back into the idea of a profit industry; excessively pre studdied formats; musical approach, wardrobe & pose.

    A BORE.

  • Ugh...IT'S HORRID!!! NOOOO! How can she violate the song in this way?? This is just morally, musically and ethically WRONG on on levels of possible wrongness! Someone please slap FH. I had to pause it just to write my comment, I could not even listen it was so bad!

  • she's not right for this song

    janis rules

  • faith ain't suffered enough to sing this song, no pain in her voice!!

  • destroyed it.

  • today it's about beauty. you can look hot, and you can sing average and you are a star. Janis was the hottest female vocalist ever. No one will compare to her intensity or emotion. Blindfold yourself and listen to janis and and anyone that tries to sing like her. In the 60s and 70s beauty was not on the surface. most of the hot singers are not babes.

  • must have a heavy voice for this song

  • I like Faith Hill but Janis Joplin sings this song better!! ...Janis Joplin made this song famous!!

  • At one point of time Janis Joplin did exist and she lived and she performed music her way. So yeah, Janis Joplin (in my opinion) sings this song with more edge and soul.

  • faith is hot and she is not talented enough to sing that.

  • It's Country Soul brothers and sisters. Come on ....say it with me......kun - tree - sole --- very good.

  • I wish these people would shut it about Faith lacking soul. She sings country not soul. Her voice is beautiful and she sings with emotion.

    You want soul then go put on some Aretha or James Brown.

    I'm going to go watch an Amy Grant video and comment about she doesn't rock and roll enough. *said with complete sarcasm*

  • Janis Joplin put this song on the world stage and her gutsy,soul version is still head and shoulders above all the rest!!!

  • retard and its this type of "southern" mentality that made them lose the war and a slave to the north.

    go grow some fruit and send it up north you freakin tard.

  • Have you always been this retarded or is this something new? Did you eat paint chips as a kid?

  • lol.. u funny. don't forget to send up those fruits and veggies you southern freak. Make mine a double waiter.

    btw, it's not paint chips per se that affected people. It was the lead that was used to enhance colors in paint produced decades ago that caused the harm. So... its wasn't even a good attempt at a cut. Don't worry, I don't think any less of you southerner.

  • pffy. you go girl faith.

  • Faith hill is a great singer but she lacks in the soul department. The best version depends on that persons lifestyle.

  • Pink does the best version ever!!but faith can sing it`s just not as soulful

  • Worse than ruining Jani's song Faith is still married to that total egotistical asshole,Tim McPiece-of -Shit!!! They probably deserve each other!!!

  • "OlymPigs2010 (2 months ago) Worse than ruining Jani's song Faith is still married to that total egotistical asshole,Tim McPiece-of -Shit!!! They probably deserve each other!!!"

    If you knew a damn thing about this song, which you obviously don't, you would know that Joplin was the THIRD person to record this song. First was Emma Franklin, then Dusty Springfield, THEN Joplin. And of the three, Joplin's version was the worst by far, nothing but screaming. It wasn't blues, it was incoherent shit

  • I love Janis version...

  • oww. my ears.lol. i much prefer pink and janis joplins version.even megan mullys is better!!!

  • write your own song bitch!

  • Awful! Melissa Etheridge and Pink should be the only ones allowed to sing this song.

  • she sings this badly you should hear pink sing it she is awesome and if you dont no janis joplin sang it originally then hahahahahahahahahaah

  • Ppl who doesent know that this is not the original song, should thb bo banned from listening to it. How can u not know that this is Janis Joplins classic?

  • Faith Hill ruined this song!

  • Honey, This isn't Faith Hill's song. Janice Joplin wrote this in the 60's...It's one of the best songs of the 60's and Faith Hill ruined it. If I was Janice I would haunt Faith Hill in her sleep for butchering such an amazing song that can't be replicated.

  • janis joplin didnt write it but she did do the best version of it,it was actually written by aretha franklins sister

  • That doesn't sound right but, I wouldn't know I'm not friends with Janice or Aretha's sister. I'll be sure to ask if i see either one of them on the street...

  • FYI, Erma Franklin first recorded this song. Janis did the cover. Janis covered many wonderful blues artists from the early days. "Tell Mama" was originally Etta James' song. "Ball and Chain" belonged to Big Mama Thornton, who incidently was the first to record "Hound Dog" before Elvis. "Piece of My Heart" has been recorded & covered by everyone from Mary J. Blige to Melissa Etheridge and no one does it like Janis. I like Faith Hill, but she isn't gritty enough to do the song justice. Peace.

  • she should stick to her own songs, since she's not cut up to sing pieces of art

  • Weak. Just effin weak as hell.

  • This sux. Faith Hill needs pitch correction when she records and in concert she sounds horrible, my dog sounds better than this.  Also, Joplin is rolling in her grave because of this crap.

  • diooooooss!!es muy mala esta version. Peor no lo puede hacer la pobre. Es como coger a Janis Joplin vestirla con un vestido de lentejuelas rosa, no pega para nada.

  • I think that she doesnt want to do her version in concert..cause she really doesnt sound like that anymore...a lot better by the way...so she does this version

  • why does everthing she sings sounds country???was janis joplin a country singer??yeah pink's cover is a million times better

  • everything she sings sounds country because shes a country singer. it does make sense doesnt it? no janis wasnt a country singer.

  • you cant really top MISS JOPLIN!!! nah, sorry, faith you did a splendid job, but Janis just owns it

  • OK -- but Janis Joplin IS this song, forever.

  • pinks version is soooooooooooooo much better :)

  • Yeah, not to mention the version by a little lady named JANIS JOPLIN!

  • Melissa Etheridge does a bitchin' version too!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more