I understand the 'earthiness' of sister but does she have to look like a bag lady on stage? There are so many ways to be modest and quite stylish. She still gets a thumbs up from me, make no mistake about it.
bad ass performance. went to see her last year in san diego but the vibe in this video is totally different than the concert i saw.... maybe we're just too uptight here?! please respond and share your opinion!
i think she sounds fantastic.... i dont think being a great singer is always about being on key, sometimes its just the emotion thats put into it... its art, i mean who wants to color inside the lines ALL the time??
@gyrl1da16 I don't know it add to the emotive quality when the singers intonations is at least in the same ball park,.,.She's a Legend but she for sure missed some notes,.,.
@Feesharp9er Amel is a creator, not a person who you will see get up there and perform the exact same show a million times. In order to do that, she takes certain liberties with her melodies and notes, like @schanfir said, its something they do very often in Jazz. I suppose its an acquired taste, but I love it. I get a different show everytime I see her.
She's not off key, she's just bending her notes (also known as blue notes)and singing a lot of minor, augmented,and diminished intervals in the scale (not typical western scale). similar to what you hear in jazz. This actually shows that she has an amazing ear because most singers cannot do this! Jazz instrumentalists (ex. John Coltrane) play outside the scale all the time, just rare to hear the human voice imitate. So to the normal ear, this sounds off. Love u Amel!!
Well said, well said, u took the words right outta my mouth! i love her music and style, perfect vocal skills! she really can hit all of those notes, on and off scale, saw her on wednesday nite for the first time in 9yrs!
@schanfr Very true. Just listen to how she goes on key and off key at will. That is mind boggling to that with an instrument (ex miles davis and john coltrane on the trumpet) . But to have the ability to do that with the voice is.....unreal.
guys, she's in tune but on a different scale. she's not hitting prominent notes of the song that's why it sounds so not in tune. but it is perfectly in same scale.
amel is so wonderful live. we saw her in seattle at jazz alley a few months back. she sing her whole heart out til she can't sing anymore!! at the end of her show she's just so tired she can barely go on, but she does and she does it for us!!! i took two of my daughter's age 12 and 3 who are amel junkies. she was so gracious, and signed both of the cd's we bought for the girls and let them take pics!!!! amel is the real deal.
i think she was vocally tired, and ended not matching pitch, that's all. she still sounds great :-) i love Mrs. Larrieux-- she is my inspiration as an artist.
hey, why do people get minuses for expressing their opinion? i like her too, but I just wanted to point it out since no else seem to have noticed it...or maybe they did but didnt wanna admit it? lol
Lifelong fan here... Her voice inspired me to want to sing. Though I'm doing it as more of a hobby at the moment, I hope to really do something with my singing after I finish grad school...
Amel is wonderful. Just saw her for two nights at Dakota Jazz Club in Minneapolis. Got to meet her and her husband and the band. She is just wowowowowow...that's all I can write.
Be Sure to pick up her latest CD "Lovely Standards"...its amazing like ALL her other artistic works..BlissLIFE baby...Amel iz a breath of fresh air from these poptart girlz..lol
My fave female artist besides...Jill Scott,Norah Jones,India.Arie,Erykah Badu,and Alicia Keys!!!...Amel is the most non-commercial and pure though. I luv her for that. Amazing performance!..wish I were there...
i was at this show with me ex fiance.... this was a great show/night.... damn i miss her #ahhhmemories
upncomingbeats 9 months ago
I understand the 'earthiness' of sister but does she have to look like a bag lady on stage? There are so many ways to be modest and quite stylish. She still gets a thumbs up from me, make no mistake about it.
blqceaser 11 months ago
I WOULD LOOOOOOOOVE to experience her live!!! i love amel... she is magic.
Dc3atl 1 year ago
oh!! I love this song!!!
blackcherryblitz 2 years ago
love it
gabrielekhavirel 2 years ago
bad ass performance. went to see her last year in san diego but the vibe in this video is totally different than the concert i saw.... maybe we're just too uptight here?! please respond and share your opinion!
alecnation 2 years ago
This is one of my Favs. of Amel. Reminds me of my bro. & all brothers going through tough while times coming of age.
Nenendude 3 years ago 3
i think she sounds fantastic.... i dont think being a great singer is always about being on key, sometimes its just the emotion thats put into it... its art, i mean who wants to color inside the lines ALL the time??
gyrl1da16 3 years ago 9
@gyrl1da16 I don't know it add to the emotive quality when the singers intonations is at least in the same ball park,.,.She's a Legend but she for sure missed some notes,.,.
Feesharp9er 1 year ago
@Feesharp9er Amel is a creator, not a person who you will see get up there and perform the exact same show a million times. In order to do that, she takes certain liberties with her melodies and notes, like @schanfir said, its something they do very often in Jazz. I suppose its an acquired taste, but I love it. I get a different show everytime I see her.
gyrl1da16 1 year ago
@gyrl1da16 I understand that. We have different definitions of liberties,.which is ok.
Feesharp9er 1 year ago
Love it!!!!
GotImani 3 years ago 2
interesting rendition .. especially live 10 years later
fasteez 3 years ago
She's not off key, she's just bending her notes (also known as blue notes)and singing a lot of minor, augmented,and diminished intervals in the scale (not typical western scale). similar to what you hear in jazz. This actually shows that she has an amazing ear because most singers cannot do this! Jazz instrumentalists (ex. John Coltrane) play outside the scale all the time, just rare to hear the human voice imitate. So to the normal ear, this sounds off. Love u Amel!!
schanfr 3 years ago 26
Good ear, schanfr...playing with lydian scales, is what you mean.
divaRights 3 years ago
Well said, well said, u took the words right outta my mouth! i love her music and style, perfect vocal skills! she really can hit all of those notes, on and off scale, saw her on wednesday nite for the first time in 9yrs!
ezridax 2 years ago
@schanfr not really.,.please read omegapdx's comment ,.
Feesharp9er 1 year ago
@schanfr Very true. Just listen to how she goes on key and off key at will. That is mind boggling to that with an instrument (ex miles davis and john coltrane on the trumpet) . But to have the ability to do that with the voice is.....unreal.
JayPleezer304 1 year ago
@schanfr Well put:)
Sylentera 6 months ago
@schanfr now you my dear know REAL music! Thank you for clarifying!
QueenlyandConfident 3 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She was a little off key. Maybe she was drunk
columbusohio72 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this was not a good performance
crazylea 3 years ago
guys, she's in tune but on a different scale. she's not hitting prominent notes of the song that's why it sounds so not in tune. but it is perfectly in same scale.
soulsting25 4 years ago 3
@soulsting25 nope.
Feesharp9er 1 year ago
amel is so wonderful live. we saw her in seattle at jazz alley a few months back. she sing her whole heart out til she can't sing anymore!! at the end of her show she's just so tired she can barely go on, but she does and she does it for us!!! i took two of my daughter's age 12 and 3 who are amel junkies. she was so gracious, and signed both of the cd's we bought for the girls and let them take pics!!!! amel is the real deal.
dcmagbenga 4 years ago 4
i think she was vocally tired, and ended not matching pitch, that's all. she still sounds great :-) i love Mrs. Larrieux-- she is my inspiration as an artist.
omegapdx 4 years ago 4
@omegapdx Ditto,..!!!
Feesharp9er 1 year ago
petezpan, I'm an Amel fan and I noticed it too. It's still one of my favorite songs but there's something I cant put my finger on that sounds off
aymero23 4 years ago 3
she sounds so off!?!
petezpan 4 years ago
I think that she was going flat, since she is singing jazz, but i think that in this case she went too flat and started wandering out of key.
ThaPoetess 4 years ago 4
@ThaPoetess major ditto!!!
Feesharp9er 1 year ago
hey, why do people get minuses for expressing their opinion? i like her too, but I just wanted to point it out since no else seem to have noticed it...or maybe they did but didnt wanna admit it? lol
petezpan 4 years ago 2
Lifelong fan here... Her voice inspired me to want to sing. Though I'm doing it as more of a hobby at the moment, I hope to really do something with my singing after I finish grad school...
deezedayz 4 years ago
She's one of the greats in neo soul!
I praise AMEL! :D
vangelissopamena 4 years ago 4
Amazing Amel!..WOW..
Traycuzsex 4 years ago
Sista is so talented...I wanted to go to BB's to see her but didnt make it
nicky1167 4 years ago
OOhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh Shytttttttttt!!!
I LOVE THIS SONG!!!
RadReese73 4 years ago 3
Amel is wonderful. Just saw her for two nights at Dakota Jazz Club in Minneapolis. Got to meet her and her husband and the band. She is just wowowowowow...that's all I can write.
VLM123 4 years ago
Be Sure to pick up her latest CD "Lovely Standards"...its amazing like ALL her other artistic works..BlissLIFE baby...Amel iz a breath of fresh air from these poptart girlz..lol
Traycuzsex 4 years ago 3
Please Post EVEN IF PLEASE
boop007 4 years ago
thanks for posting this!!! one of my all time favorites....
Bartiani 4 years ago 2
My fave female artist besides...Jill Scott,Norah Jones,India.Arie,Erykah Badu,and Alicia Keys!!!...Amel is the most non-commercial and pure though. I luv her for that. Amazing performance!..wish I were there...
Traycuzsex 4 years ago 2
agreeesss~
vibravibra 4 years ago
I was there as well...Just on the other side of the stage!!!
Amazing Amazing Amazing!!!!
Go To BLISSLIFE!!!
MsAmor18 4 years ago
Beautiful performance. I had so much fun and I can not wait to see the wonderful and talented Amel again.
tajmabruno 4 years ago
you waste no time. i was there yd as well but i want to figure out how to fix my audio on the videos i took of her as well
SexxyTiger 4 years ago