Added: 3 years ago
From: andybearden2008
Views: 11,919
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (134)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • well that was gay

  • Dude, it's like, I know they're awesome and all, I understand the whole "spell it right or GTFO", but what I think everyone is trying to tell you, is that they lack the understanding of the song to sing it with the appropriate emotion. The song is lacking life. I get it that it's a showchoir, but they're SINGERS before being a choir. Emotion is a part of being a singer. I know that because I made half my school cry singing Total Eclipse of The Heart in the Talents' show.

  • and honestly i wouldnt care about this at all if it wasnt a hard rock/emo band being totally misrepresented.

  • people are so hypocritical.. i'd like to see them get up on stage and dance and sing at the same time. it's harder than it looks. and their dancing isn't bad, it's fantastic. it's very sharp and clean and their vocal sound is incredible.

  • @Chasetheidiot your username describes you perfectly because you are obviously an idiot! And you obviously don't understand the concept of show choir. So go find somewhere else to be a dumbass!

  • i liked the dance breaks. and thats about it. but at the same time, im used to my show choir doing it this year so that can afflict my judgement

  • all the idiots who are complaining about this, come face me, face to face so i can kick your ass, cause this choir is one of the best in the nation, and all of their awards will prove it, and they did beat Clinton Attache, so jsut shut hte hell up idiots.

  • all the idiots who are complaining about this, come face me, face to face so i can kick your ass, cause this choir is one of the best in the nation, and all of their awards will prove it, and they did beat Clinton Attache, so jsut shut hte hell up idiots

  • nice try. but wrong style. there should me melachonic feeling in the soloist. its too tenuto already. the trumpets' sound isn't full. there's the sound of the raw brass. @2:47, trumpets too flat, i guess. the whole song is of wrong style. but nice try though.

  • People need to chill out. I didn't think it was that bad actually. For show choir. And yea, if you don't have anything nice to say how about just not saying anything at all? It'd save everybody some trouble. But me being an MCR fan I think it was not bad for a performance like that. It's not bad, just different.

  • hey cliin1300, get a life and go agrue with a tree, you might when that.

  • que tierno ^^

  • Awful, and no amount of awards can change it.

    It's not even that this shouldn't be done, it has every possibility to be badass but this wasn't it.

    Next time get someone to choreograph who isn't over 30, tell the kids to not dress like preppy douchebags, and listen to the song hard enough to realize that there is a distinct difference between this kind of "positivity" and that of earth day.

  • Hmm...the soloist didn't float my boat, he was flat, and his tonal quality was terrifying. The blend of the overall choir scared me the women really overprojected....it was like watching middle schoolers trying to be a show choir. It saddens me to think that this is the choir that won first place...it's the fall of Broadway and show chiors, nay! The fall of entertainment everywhere! The choreo was WAY predictable as well, oh, ripple down, ripple up...spin...and it didn't fit the music.

  • if your gonna hate on this amazing song, why even look it up in the first place? grow up, im glad ima part of a'ville showchoir now:D this song is great along with every song centerstage does!

  • ok, the guy that comes in with the snare drum, is terribly off sync. and if its the "black parade" why are they in red? and the drums sound nuthing like the originaal and completely overpower everything and sound like crap. the only part i like is when the guitar comes in for like 5 seconds. and u turn a song thats about death and darkness into freaking high school musical 4!!

  • @Chasetheidiot Sorry but you have NO understanding whatsoever of what that song is actually about! The song is NOT about death and darkness. It's about the fact that we will carry on with our lives when people whom we love die instead of dwelling on their deaths and letting it ruin our lives! It's all about the strength we all have inside of us!

  • @andybearden2008 maybe im wrong about that, but u still dont turn it into the next episode of glee.

  • Comment removed

  • it sounds fucking terrible...

    but i'd like it with another song...

    i mean it's mcr, not Cats... LOL

    it's fucking... BRITISH!!... or maybe australian... but not american!!!

    fuck you all!!

    it's fucking gay and you suck (even as gays!)

    God you messed up MCR!!!

  • @Giin1300 It's not supposed to be MCR! It's supposed to be show choir! And that's exactly what it is! MCR and show choir are worlds apart! But so are most of the things done in show choir. That's why it's called show choir and not let's see how close to the original we can get!

  • @andybearden2008 if its not suppose to be MCR, then dont play/ruin their song, dont imitate their costumes, and dont turn their beautiful song into a broadway musical.

  • it sounds fucking terrible...

    but i'd like it with another song...

    i mean it's mcr, not Cats... LOL

  • it is awkward to have a kid singing the intro.... "When I was a young boy...." Arent you a young boy already?

  • i very much like the vocal arrangement, i think this just needed a shredding guitar but since its about the choir, i say great performance

  • this is horrible. the soloist has a terrible sound and vowels. the music isnt sung to the correct style. the costumes dont make sense. the choreography is horrible and could use some cleaning....they must be performing at some low grade competitions.

  • @titaniumman54 I agree that the soloist isn't the best. But he isn't the worst either. And idk how you say the music isn't sung to the correct style. It's supposed to be show choir. Not rock. Show choir is all about diction and clarity while in rock music most of the time you can only understand half of the words! The choreography isn't the greatest but they did it near perfectly. I don't see the flaws you are seeing and I have watched this video more than you can imagine.

  • @andybearden2008 ok, u obviously hav no idea what rock music is. Rock music is bands like green day, MCR, and the fray. can clearly understand most of the words. i believe ur getting that confused with heavy and death metal. so do sum homework before u diss and great genre of music

  • @titaniumman54 And as for the low-grade competitions comment... If you call constantly being put up against the nation's top show choirs being at low-grade competitions then you are absolutely right. BTW... they beat the #1 show choir in the nation with this show. That's right. They beat Clinton Attache by 13 points I do believe it was! And everyone knows that Clinton invented the game of show choir and that they are in the top 3 every year. Most of the time they are #1!

  • all that smoke and screen stuff was just to pull away from the fact that they can't dance!

  • @puredemocrat55 All the choreography awards from that show disagree with you!

  • @puredemocrat55 they can dance its just simple choreography

  • yuck

  • For a show-choir (or any choir for that matter) singing this piece I thought that they did fairly well. I think the main problem is that this song (just like so many other rock songs) is not meant to be sung with choir voices. A choir voice is smooth, harmonious, and pure and strives to be what one might call "perfected". However, songs in the rock genre are meant to be sung with a more common voice. This voice is raw, strong, and passionate. It does not strive to be "perfected" but to be

  • i thought my home town choir did awesome

    this show made me decide to do middle school show choir

  • its hard to sing when dancing.. very nice! i like it

  • This is so lacking. What was with all the happiness? Did none of you get it? Did you actually READ the lyrics or just skim? Its about death and how he misses his father. He's not sining showtunes when his fathers dead, hes not tap-dancing on his grave! Geez people way to mess up a perfectly good sad song...

  • ew ginger

  • for all you haters, this choir recieved top honors in the nation

  • I guess I could say... please dont try to replace MCR. But I can see you werent. Good job I guess... Being part of a show chior I know how hard choreography is but I dont really think that your coreography didnt really match the song. Too happy I think. Overall good job on the song.

  • <3333333 wow

  • Whoa, thats totally me drumming away, wow I look sooo small

  • EPIC. :D

  • wtf is that

  • Don't really know what to say. WOW.

  • @Napolean287 I AGREE. JUST. DUDE IM STUCK IN ALLCAPS XD

  • ok the kid at the start need to show some kind of emotion like anger but i dont do show choir so i dont know if it is supposed to be like that or not

    CONCERT CHOIR FTW!!!!

  • hey im part of the hillside singers we competed against you this year at Branson and i just want to say it was an honor it was a really close competition and we both performed great. to all you people bashing you obviously have nothing better to do with your lives or are just jealous i know when we first saw them performed we got scared! lol congrats guys!

  • ahahahah

  • didnt like it

  • wow. just, wow.

  • wow, if you can't say anything nice, then don't say anything at all. Plus, your not a judge, and so basically your comment is a waste of space and a waste of your own valuable time. Also, if you don't like it then why did you comment on it? And God blessed us with a singing ability, and what you say doesn't matter because we did amazing that year, and God blessed us tremendously. So in the future, watch what you say.

    Thanks.

  • and the drummer sucks and gets off beat

  • plus the soloist sucks at singing

  • VERY VERY GOOD!!!!!!!

    i like it much much better than the original one!

    KEEP IT UP!!!! WOW!

  • Ewh what?

    Really?

    My Chem are legends

  • this is so bad and disturbing. i hate it i hate it

  • lol! how is it bad? and please dont say... cuz its not anything like the original... cuz if you do i am gonna crown you the king of stupid for not reading the comment thread. lol!

  • someone doesn't understand the concept of show choir. and about the song... the chorus is "your memory will carry on." if that's not a happy thought, what is?

  • wow your comment was a waste of space. If you or your sister don't like it don't watch it. Also it's not creepy to like showchoir it' amazing and changes lives so chill out.

  • me encanto  la core todos bien paregitos i love mcr

  • wow cool i wish our school would do sumthin like that...well once were doin a school declamation and we have sound effects and my classmate played wttpd by mistake...it was funny...i love mcr!

  • but it is so bad and disturbing

  • sorry, i just didn't feel like reading 65 comments. and i totally knew it was mike :)

  • who choreographed this?

  • lol! u obviously dont read honey. the choreographer is mentioned at least twice in the comments already and he is listed in the description of the video. but jst for you, his name is mike weaver and he is from chicago!

  • is that a guy singing or girl?

  • lol! its a guy!

  • come on andy put it on here

  • someone needs to put our show on here from this year =] its rockin

  • as soon as i get my DVD from opelika in(which should be somtime this week) i will be putting all the finalists' shows on here!

  • well it kinda pisses me off that they cut it but i wanna hug the teacher that made them sing it and kiss the principal that let them. they never woulda let us do that at our school. all the talk about death woulda freaked the admins. out.

  • wow that was great! plus its my chemical romance so how could it not be great

  • agree! this made my hair stand. :)

  • Yay! My Chem!!!

  • omg love it

  • i think this is amzing

  • i do admit that NO ONE could do this like My Chem. BUT this was fricken AMAZING!

  • That is cool! ^^

  • everything i loved about this song was ruined because of these choir kids and they dont sing it with any true meaning, unlike gerard way :) loved the smoke though

  • okay is the re haired freak a guy or a girl cuz he/she looks like a freakozoid and lmao such a badd singer.

  • this is gay

  • we'll take that as a compliment seeing as how im gay and im frickin awesome! lol!

  • AHA! genious!

  • well thanks! it was all thanks to our genious directors Scott Rains and Natasha Tidmore and our amazing choreographer Mike Weaver!

  • its not about winning trophies for real. more about showing what you can do and what you put together that year.

  • HEY I SAW ME!!!!! i was fat... ohh wait i still am haha

  • hahahahahah.......this is a joke.? right???

    this is an insult 2 mcr

    xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxx

  • lol! why do some people still not get that this is showchoir and not rock n' roll? of course its gonna be nothing like MCR! it's not supposed to be! use your brain sweetheart!

  • Hahah I wonder what My Chem. would say if they saw this.

  • they would probably say that its a very innovative thing to do and that they are flattered! lol!

  • I have no problem with showing you the trophies from this past year or the years before that. Even the Best band trophies 6 out of 6 places we went. In other words.. WE DONT LOSE! Its gonna be a wild right all year long I know and good luck to you. But try and keep up with us.. I dare you. ;)

  • This is simply amazing! You guys are awesome...and such nice people too! I met you guys in Branson and fell in love with you!!

  • thanks so much. our southern hospitality definitely shows through in us! we get compliments everywhere we go from people telling us how we are one of the best if not the best group of teens that they have ever had to deal with! what school were u from? and what was y'alls show?

  • sing to high in the begining

  • aright everybody shut the hell up right now. if u are a showchoir person then odds are u like this but not everbody is a showchoir person and wont like because its not hard core rock n roll like the song but everybody has their opinion but yall dont have to get worked up over what everbody else thinks

  • thanks for using your brain! lol!

  • no offense, (i mean i liked it) just the guy was really high pitched and it's supposed to be low so yea~ i think the showchoir should have picked a lower voice...~

  • um... lol! have u ever listened to the actual song? it is not low-pitched. it is a very high-pitched tenor solo. lol!

  • i agree... although it was more that he didnt have a strong enough voice.. but it was still really good =]

  • that just kinda killed it for me...

    sorry...

  • its okay. u r entitle to your opinion. but just so you know most of the showchoir world disagrees with you. this was called "one of my favorite showchoir moments of all-time" by one of the tops showchoir judges in the nation!

  • u guys suck...

  • lol i love it how we were so awesome that people were and still are jealous! that doesnt happen with us a lot!

  • well if you think this was good then you have low standards b**ch...

  • well i guess that some of the best showchoir judges in the country have really low standards then!

  • I don't get it. I voiced my opinion because I'm aloud to. Yet y'all are the ones who are making a big deal out of one comment. So all of y'all should get off my freakin back.

  • Maybe you should re-read what you said and then think about it. Fuck Y'all? I can't take you seriously if you're saying things like that.

  • *GASP* Andy! I remember you from school! We only talked once I think. In the lunch line. You commented of a comic I had called Devil May Cry XD

  • Not gonna lie, the fog effect is really cool...

  • i saw this at petal invitational and i really liked it!:)

  • I'm not in showchoir anymore, but I have been I have never been impressed with this group ever.

  • well you obviously arent too smart considering your comments so we'll just overlook your insults as immature and childish!

  • You know what.....Fuck all of y'all. This sucked and all of y'all know. Y'all just don't want to admit it.

  • I don't get it. I joined to have fun, but some kids make such a huge deal out of it.

    A school a mile down the road is making it their sole goal to make us their enemy.

    And Petaldrummer2010, I'm sure your show choir class doesn't miss you.

  • Sucked? right right.... Thats why we (Albertville) beat your ass all year long? Right, and the past year and the year before? Huh? I've been playing drums for this group for 6 years. Received many compliments, offers to schools and much more. This group is feared. I would be too if I had to face them. Anytime you want too, we're coming to Petal to OWN again this year. We shall have a drum off. I'll take your pride you have built up and shove right back up your large rear end. Cool?

  • Um... no you won't. Petal has gotten really good you know... the odds could be against you since they have newer people who are well educated....

  • You see my 'friend', Petal was and still is good but nothing like it used to be. Things change just like with this program. We have 2 choirs now who tonight both had shows for roughly 2,000 with 2 more sold out shows Saturday. I may seem bias, but its a known thing now Albertville is 1-2 with Clinton. Ask Clinton how it feels to be beat by a Southern choir?

  • THAT WAS SO FREAKIN' FUNNY:))))

    wtf was that?XD

  • ok... im impressed!.. im the drummer of our show choir called the Wavaires.. we're going 2 N.Y. this year 2 play at the statue of liberty, jazz and lincon centre and other places!...

    u guys totally rocked it out.... and that drummerboy thing at the beginning is priceless! GREAT JOB!!

  • We're going to CHICAGO and I'm pretty excited. I think we're hitting West VA too, which should be fun too.

  • cool song....hey petaldrummer2010 you suck..hahah pansy gay bitch.. hahaha!

  • @johncena222 Ummm... im sorry but what does being gay have to do with anything. Its not insulting. It is a way of life. Its like calling someone a quaker. Its a chosen way of life. (or sometimes not chosen but that may be the way it works out)

  • As an AHS and CenterStage alum, I can honestly say that this is an excellent performance. Scott Rains has done a wonderful job with this group over the years. From when we couldn't even place at Opelika to winning Nationals. I'm proud of you guys! Keep up the great work!

  • There were A LOT of us in the pit at Piqua that loved this number. Good job, guys!

  • i absolutely loved that whole show last year. it was amazing. i saw it about four times, and it was great every time.

  • You Guys sucked. This song was already bad enough with our you guys making it even worse! >:(

  • Well i guess it didnt suck since they won a lot of awards with that song.

  • wow. lol. u obviously arent a good judge of show choirs. and u definitely arent a good judge of music cuz that is a really great sing!

  • Why do you have to insult other choirs like that? Does it make you feel good about yourself or something? Judging by your name, I have a pretty good idea what school you are from and that comment doesn't reflect positively on your choir. That's sad, because your choir has always been a fav of mine and I have a bunch of respect for the members of it.

  • i will say that you didnt completly ruin the song and congrats on that

    but please, lets leave rock music with rock music and show choir with show choir from now on

  • alright so you can be the person that goes from school to school just to make sure they arent doing a rock song... basically your opinion doesnt matter and its not going to keep any director from doing rock songs.

  • Fucking terrible man.

  • well its must not have been terrible since it won us so many awards! your opinion doesnt matter. only the judges opinions matter!

  • ;O awsome :B!

  • This is excellent. Congratulations to you all.

  • thanks so much!

  • OMG this is awsome and so wtf? at the same tieme. Love it♥

  • lol. thanks... i think!

  • Look, this recording is crap. It was NOT mic'd well. At ALL. I was AT THAT PERFORMANCE, and that was my FAVORITE number for that particular group.

    The high brass sounds like garbage in this performance. In real life, it was GREAT. The player projected to the back of the auditorium where I was seated, and the group was much louder.

    Pretty darn good in real life. Not on YouTube, for sure! Too bad if you didn't see it :P

  • thanks! i completely agree about it not being mic'd well at all.

  • WOAH.

    That is really awesome.

    I like it.

  • thanks!

  • That was awesome! I really liked it.

  • thanks!

  • this is amazing!

  • thanks! we worked really hard on it!

  • Okay, Actually... This was pretty awesome.

  • thanks!

  • Again, so different, So dynamic. This is more than just a staged show choir number. There is a cohesive mastery of content regarding the lyrics and staging that is just excellent.

  • This is neat. Plus I love the song. My opinion I would give this an A-. Fun song!

  • GRIFF IS AWSOME!!!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more