believe it or not, the point of this piece is that it is SUPPOSED to be played slowly, speeding it up takes away from the emotional aspect of the piece itself. we played it slowly and half of us were crying by the end. also, i just happen to know a thirteen year old girl who started playing french horn three weeks before our concert, and she nailed that solo on her first try. sorry if i'm being a pessimist, but this video is the first time i have EVER heard this song and not started to cry.
Actually sounds good, but the tempo definitely takes away from the feeling and story behind the song. Dynamics could have been more dramatic, too, but an overall good sound. (I've played both 1st alto and tenor sax on this piece and it's awesome)
Did you Know that holsinger wrote the song when he was sailing back form england to the americas to pick up his wife because when she and her five daugthers went for a vaction to europe the boat they were sailing in sunk. The only survior was the the wife. That night when going back the americas he started writing this song when his boat got to the garves of his five daughters.
its great that these people get to have a good time playing together, but they are honking out this song. the intonation and balance are ....well there is no intonation or balance. these people are not communicating with each other at all.. : (
Our band played at contest this year. we got straight 1s
TheSaintsfan16 9 months ago
believe it or not, the point of this piece is that it is SUPPOSED to be played slowly, speeding it up takes away from the emotional aspect of the piece itself. we played it slowly and half of us were crying by the end. also, i just happen to know a thirteen year old girl who started playing french horn three weeks before our concert, and she nailed that solo on her first try. sorry if i'm being a pessimist, but this video is the first time i have EVER heard this song and not started to cry.
brassbaby112 10 months ago
Comment removed
sk8erkid6485 11 months ago
Actually sounds good, but the tempo definitely takes away from the feeling and story behind the song. Dynamics could have been more dramatic, too, but an overall good sound. (I've played both 1st alto and tenor sax on this piece and it's awesome)
couchspud95 1 year ago
Comment removed
theDIEHARDGATORFAN 1 year ago
Did you Know that holsinger wrote the song when he was sailing back form england to the americas to pick up his wife because when she and her five daugthers went for a vaction to europe the boat they were sailing in sunk. The only survior was the the wife. That night when going back the americas he started writing this song when his boat got to the garves of his five daughters.
Its sad but the song is so... beatiful.
Fuego1224 2 years ago
@Fuego1224 Actually, Holsinger only made an arrangement of this song. The lyrics were written by Horatio Spafford and put to music by Philip Bliss.
AlyJeanie 1 year ago
One of them just falls over in a heart attack...lmao...
grooms63941 2 years ago
that's pretty shameful that an adult horn player screws it up when teenager nails it!
dathingsowner 2 years ago 6
to fast..its supposed to be slower
vTyLeNoLv 2 years ago
i agree too rushed it loses all the beauty
dathingsowner 2 years ago
its great that these people get to have a good time playing together, but they are honking out this song. the intonation and balance are ....well there is no intonation or balance. these people are not communicating with each other at all.. : (
sweetmpea55 2 years ago
Wow, so beautful :)
Im playing this in my 8th grade Symphonic Band.. And it doesn't sound half as good a this. :)
Job well done :)
DragonsSword123 3 years ago
then your band sucks
thane5001 2 years ago
Nicely Done! I prefer it a bit slower but that's just me.
snajkdog 3 years ago
just amazing and beautiful!
soltisviolin 3 years ago