Bella and Charlie- I loved her first

[aleesha1395]

i love the look he has on his face when he comes into the hospt!

[alicebellzz]

That was beautiful...:) I dont think people think about Charlie's feelings too much..They should though :DD This was soo him. Great job

[Balto1q]

WOW... Im Gonna Play This For My Wedding.... :´)... Thank You.. With Out I, I Would Never Had Seen This Song...!!

[99999Malu99999]

WOW! amazing I almost cried 

[tdsrockz]

That was beautiful!

[milangirl123]

OMG twilight with a little charmed thrown in i a in heaven great video loved it loved i cried =)

[renesmeeinez]

when i here this song i think of me and my dad

[SummerOfRachel]

this is a beautiful video.. my first Bella\Charlie :) the song fits them sooo well! Great job!

[toothfairy60]

This was really fitting, and very pretty...brought tears to my eyes!

[titanicfanatic99]

Wow. That's all that I can say! You did an AMAZING job!

[curreye]

I love this song it is so sweet

[jessanne235]

This is so *snif* sweet ♥ I loved it! It fits!

[PeaceLoveAndBabyDuc]

i wanna dance to this at my wedding! it makes me cry.

[EmilyAndMissy]

i love this song!!!!!!!!

[samgamgeeisbrilliant]

I still think Charlie should have shot him. Charlie is the hottest thing ever!!!!!

[TheMaryWhitlock]

Awww. *sniffle* Love it!

[Warriorsfan26]

This was Amazing!

[reuti787]

so sweet, i have tears in my eyes .

[xhidingbhindmysmilex]

i cried watching this....Charlie is awesome as a dad

[biblegirl]

Aww

[desireejeansoule]

this video is a mixture of twilight and the tv show CHarmed. I love it!!!!!!!!!

[samgamgeeisbrilliant]

Charlie is a sexy beast! Sorry! Mum says I'm a weirdo because she fancies Edward, but totally, Charlie is Teh Sex!

I liked that Edward and Bella didn't talk because they seemed like PEOPLE in this video. Do you know how hard that is to achieve?

Yeah, I agree. It's perfect for them. The song is perfect.

[87sidneylover]

i loove diis sonng :P soo perfect for themm

[tazfretwell]

This is beautiful its made me cry. The song shows there bond so well <3

[twilightlover10817]

yesss!!! ome (o my edward) it made me cry

[relhoff]

It's really good...You could maybe even make it again with Clips from New Moon,although I did love the splash of Charmed thrown in there...

[CarlisleLover22101]

Wow....that was nice...I cried :) Good job. Really heart felt....

[MultiSilverStorm]

this is the perfect song for them! great job!

[musicrocksf2w4]

its sad

[dirrtyemz91]

cant believe it!!! i downloaded this song a while back & thought "wouldnt it be perfect for charlie & bella" and then i found this!!

great work, i love charlie ;)

[MelindaPotter]

@dirrtyemz91 I did the same thing this song is perfect for them. Glad you liked it.

[Lawrawwr]

@dirrtyemz91 can you send me the song, cause i can't get it anywhere :( x add me as a friend and i'll send my email :D thankkkyouuuuu (; and charlie is THE best film Dad ever!

[rafadi4]

AWESOME VIDEO!!!

[stefyjonas1]

sniffle!

beautiful! someday Edward will feel that way about Renesmee with Jacob!

[DukeandLeafvids]

Aww I bet nearly all dads feel like this when their little girls grow up into young women and meet a guy, ect. lol good video by the way :) :3.

[MegaJoeJonasGirl]

It made me cry I loved it

[earthgirl1998]

omg i love this

[CodieCullen]

sniffle! :( love this song and i really cried ..aha ..

[pcolocoful]

who's that kid??

[nadiak0824]

this is perfect!!!

[rosalie467]

i love this soug forever

[yeshua4givs]

i love it!!!!!!! good video! made me get all choked up, and warm inside! :P

[tayser74]

i love this song we need a song for charlie to dance with bella

[Huey027]

I adore the opening scene :D good choice.

[pausinifan]

omg the best ever u.u snif snif. i actually cried the first time i watched this u.u... and im a twilight fan

[MelindaPotter]

I made you cry?! Yay my mission in life is complete. I made someone cry. LOL I'm kidding. Glad you liked it.

[XTwilightDuckyX]

so pretty :) x

[MelindaPotter]

thanks

[Gatomon90]

I don't think commenting likes me...it never seems to show up. =(

What I said was this video was so sweet because it fit them so well.

And now I have a song to write for. (I write Twilight Songfics)

[MelindaPotter]

You do? Wow I love fanfics. Let me know when you have it done. I would love to read it.

[Gatomon90]

I'm writing it right now. =D It should be done in just a little bit. ^^

[mNmz013]

You did a great job with this.

The best "I Loved Her First" vid i've seen, amazing quality.

Loved it!

[cullenfreak555]

this is more for breaking dawn. I mean Charlie is losing his daughter to a boy . shes his little girl. This song fits this video and breaking dawn as i said in the beginning.

[MelindaPotter]

I know and as soon as breaking dawn comes out I am going to redo this video with some of those clips but I couldn't wait.

[venaboyfan7583]

It fits breaking dawn

[MelindaPotter]

I know

[MelanieEarle]

My sister wanted me to play this song at my wedding. This is the firsttime I've ever heard it. Now I wished I did pick it.

[MelindaPotter]

You should have it is a beautiful song. Hope you liked the video!!!

[MelanieEarle]

No I didn't and now I'm sorry I didn't I let my dad pick the song :)

[UrReallyFuckedUp]

great :)

[MelindaPotter]

Thanks!!!