WHAT DO THESE WORDS MEAN IN ENGLISH. I SAW THE MOVIE REDS I ASKED MY GRANDMA WHO LIVED ON TSARIST RUSSIAN-POLISH BORDER WHEN SHE WAS LITTLE THEN IMMIGRATED TO THE USA. LATER SHE MOVED TO CANADA. GRANDMA WHO WOULD U SUPPORT LENIN OR THE TSAR WELL IF I HAD TO CHOOSE IT WOULD LENIN BECAUSE THE PEOPLE WOULD EAT
sir thank you i stand corrected that does help so it was after the civil war yes CCCP game into power I do know it was Kerensky who got his duma as well spoke to the workers called the the Soviets i thought kerensky was in switzerland lenin was in switzerland but was he shocked of how the Soviets came to support him eh. did u know thatr John Reed american supported the Bolshiviks he is the only american burried in the Kermlin he wrote a book 10 days that shook the world
COMRADRE WHO WAS THE GENERAL WHO TRAVELLED TO THE EASTERN FRONT WITH THE TSAR 1916 MEANWHILE KERENSKY PROVINCIAL GOVT GETS HIS DUMA BUT HE FAVOURS WAR ALL MOMUMENTS OF THE TSAR WERE TORN DOWN CCCP CAME INTO BEING YES NOW ON HIS WAY BACK THE IS FORCED TO ADBICATE THE THORN OUT OF HIDING FROM SWITZERLAND LENIN RETURNS WITH TROTSKY ZIMMINOV GERMANY AGREES WITH LENIN YU MAY TRAVEL THROUGH GERMAN TERRITORY HOWEVER NO ONE MAY LEAVE THE TRAIN. WHO WAS THE GENERAL WHO FOPRCED THE TSAR TO ABDICATE
@liberal20111 Everything wrong! Kerensky got in office on 21 July 1917 (Czar was long gone). USSR wasn't formed until 1921. Czar was forced to abdicate by Provisional Government formed by "Duma" (parliament) and "Soviets" (workers councils). Trotsky was living in New York City at the time of February Revolution of 1917
WHO WAS THE GENERAL WHO FORCED THE TSAR ABDICATE MY GRANDMA LEFT TSARIST RUSSIA WHEN SHE WAS 2 YRS, OLD SHE WAS BORN ON THE TSARIST RUSSIAN POLISH BORDER. I SPOKE TO HER ONE DAY BEFORE THE MOVIE REDS ASKED HER WHO WOULD U SUPPORT SHE SAID MAY SHE REST IN PEACE SHE SAID THAT IS TWO EVILS BUT I WOULD SUPPORT THE BOLSHIVIKS BECAUSE THE PEOPLE WOULD EAT. DO NOT BE MAD AT ME I SPEAK WITH RESPECT.
I AM A HISTORY TEACHER WE WILL BE TALKING ABOUT THE CAUSES OF THE RUSSIAN REVOULTION CCCP IS IT TRUE THE REVOULTION BEGAN WHEN THE TZAR WAS FORCE TO ABDICATE COMING BACK FROM FRONT. ARE THESE YOUNG PIONEERS THIS IS A VERY GOOD CLIP. I REMEMBER HEARING THIS CLIP CCCP WAS PLAYING CANADA FOR THE GOLD MEDAL HOCKEY SHOWING CCCP PRACTICE CCCP WON THE GOLD MEDAL. WHEN EVER CANADA PLAYED CCCP VERY EXCITING I WAS IN THE CCCP WE PLAYED IN MOSCOW
I do feel that, when you were getting to the storming of the Winter Palace and the rest of the video, you should have used the Internationale (in Russian, of course) rather than Slavianka.
Hey, gorgorbey9, if you knew anything about communists and communism, you'd know that North Korea is almost universally denounced among communists. It's not even CLOSE to being a communistic society.
what you are saying is true, I wanted to say that communism is an utopia. the idea is nice, but when you put it into practice it can't work, because there will be always opposition.
God has given 70 years of terror to the Russians because of'17 have desecrated and profaned churches .. the same is with who does black magic .. but God is good and merciful as demonstrated by Jesus Christ who gave his life to save us. Just follow the path of Jesus Christ, Abraham, San Pietro.
you really believe that the life of Saint Peter is over so, on a cross?.. if you want.. you go in the gulags. I think that you don't see the paradise in the future..
FUCK YOU. Its People like you that destroy the world. You can take the fucking religoin and die. Pleas, none will miss you.
You christians always complains on the muslims that they are extremists/terrorists. BUT CHRISTIANS HAVE MORE TERRORISTS THEN ISLAM WILL EVER HAVE! Fuck you, little boy.
No need to insult religion, Communism stands for equality, including racial, religous and economic equality. As long as people dont go imposing there beliefs on everyone its fine. Like I always say, Live and Let Live.
bullshit!the church has a might about ppl that it doesnt deserve,only god has that power!but the church always tried to get mighty and more powerfull,they were usind the word of god, and the fear of ppl to die,to get more powerfull!church is not the work of god!church gives ppl power about ppl,and not god!so church is a work of evil,and thats why they have been burned!if u believe in god you dont need a church or somone else,you only need god!
i know that the world is not perfect! and its hard to find a paradise here, but if you look the ppl are scared to die, thats the only reason why religion has last so long!
as karl marx said, its opium for the ppl! and its like this!cuz i have never seen someone beeing helped because of a prayer!
i have only seen ppl that put their life in the hands of god, and hope that he will do their work for them!
but anyways, i respect that you believe, i do too, but i know that i have to work for a paradies, do you know that anikdote about that women that was lost in sea, and started to pray that good will help her, and after some boats came she said, god will help me, and after she died, she asked god, why he didnt help her, and he said, who you think sent you the boats!
Sorry but i haven't created this life. And for me, this life is too hard and cruel for human people. You have done an example.. and other example exist.. For example: INNOCENT children die!! Why?!!!!.. Despit this.. i don't believe that the life of San Pietro is finished on a cross! It's not possible.. Must exist someone that must do justice!..
i know what you mean! but i think something like justice doesnt exist, its like eat or beeing eaten, i know it sounds like animals, but unfortunately its like this!not everyone is born the same!
Russians tend to mistakenly, see the Bolshevik revolution as merely a Russian event. It was the product of many nationalities. Marx, Engels, Liebknect: Germans, Luxemburg and Dzerzhinsky: Polish, John Reed: American, James Conolly: Irish, then we go into the non-Russians within the Empire and finally, minor figures who in many ways were very important. The Balts who were victorious in the first uprisings, the Scandinavians who formed Lenins bodyguard on and after his trip from Germany and etc.
I thought this was good...at least you've got the story right. Pity you couldn't have left the door off the latch and really stormed the Winter Palace. LoL
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
You can not use this argument that the Tsar had food and the people had nothing to eat. What about communist leaders did they starve for their people? They had more than the Tsar.
If you believe in God you would know that communisam is not correct.
Lenin suffered more than the Tsar could ever know. The Tsar, lived a life of luxery. Lenin live most of his life on the run. If you knew anything about Lenin and the Bolsheviks you would know their cause was just. The Tsars soldiers shot innocent men women and children asking for bread, peace, and land. The Tsar is a murdering coward who put his country into the most pointless war in history. Millions of Russians paid with their life for his luxery. He got exactly what he deserved in the end.
It seems yo had a great time dudes!! Well the October Revolution Ideas should not perish and live on to teach us that the people's struggle to achieve freedom and respect is alive. Long live the 1917 revolution!!!
yeah sure, don't really know how to use youtube, but if possible i guess send me your email in a private message and i'll send it to you that way (unless there's an easier method). If you don't want to do that - don't worry, I wont be offended :) - i think there's an application on mozilla firefox that lets you download youtube footage, might be worth checking out.
WHAT DO THESE WORDS MEAN IN ENGLISH. I SAW THE MOVIE REDS I ASKED MY GRANDMA WHO LIVED ON TSARIST RUSSIAN-POLISH BORDER WHEN SHE WAS LITTLE THEN IMMIGRATED TO THE USA. LATER SHE MOVED TO CANADA. GRANDMA WHO WOULD U SUPPORT LENIN OR THE TSAR WELL IF I HAD TO CHOOSE IT WOULD LENIN BECAUSE THE PEOPLE WOULD EAT
liberal20111 3 months ago in playlist Liked
sir thank you i stand corrected that does help so it was after the civil war yes CCCP game into power I do know it was Kerensky who got his duma as well spoke to the workers called the the Soviets i thought kerensky was in switzerland lenin was in switzerland but was he shocked of how the Soviets came to support him eh. did u know thatr John Reed american supported the Bolshiviks he is the only american burried in the Kermlin he wrote a book 10 days that shook the world
liberal20111 6 months ago
when the tsar abdicarted the throne on his way back to petrodgrade who was the general who i believe was the general of the white russians.
liberal20111 7 months ago
THE THORN. DID THAT GENERAL LEAD THE WHITE RUSSIANS IN THE CIVIL WAR IN THE CCCP.
liberal20111 7 months ago
COMRADRE WHO WAS THE GENERAL WHO TRAVELLED TO THE EASTERN FRONT WITH THE TSAR 1916 MEANWHILE KERENSKY PROVINCIAL GOVT GETS HIS DUMA BUT HE FAVOURS WAR ALL MOMUMENTS OF THE TSAR WERE TORN DOWN CCCP CAME INTO BEING YES NOW ON HIS WAY BACK THE IS FORCED TO ADBICATE THE THORN OUT OF HIDING FROM SWITZERLAND LENIN RETURNS WITH TROTSKY ZIMMINOV GERMANY AGREES WITH LENIN YU MAY TRAVEL THROUGH GERMAN TERRITORY HOWEVER NO ONE MAY LEAVE THE TRAIN. WHO WAS THE GENERAL WHO FOPRCED THE TSAR TO ABDICATE
liberal20111 7 months ago
@liberal20111 Everything wrong! Kerensky got in office on 21 July 1917 (Czar was long gone). USSR wasn't formed until 1921. Czar was forced to abdicate by Provisional Government formed by "Duma" (parliament) and "Soviets" (workers councils). Trotsky was living in New York City at the time of February Revolution of 1917
ssmusic214 6 months ago
WHO WAS THE GENERAL WHO FORCED THE TSAR ABDICATE MY GRANDMA LEFT TSARIST RUSSIA WHEN SHE WAS 2 YRS, OLD SHE WAS BORN ON THE TSARIST RUSSIAN POLISH BORDER. I SPOKE TO HER ONE DAY BEFORE THE MOVIE REDS ASKED HER WHO WOULD U SUPPORT SHE SAID MAY SHE REST IN PEACE SHE SAID THAT IS TWO EVILS BUT I WOULD SUPPORT THE BOLSHIVIKS BECAUSE THE PEOPLE WOULD EAT. DO NOT BE MAD AT ME I SPEAK WITH RESPECT.
liberal20111 7 months ago
I AM A HISTORY TEACHER WE WILL BE TALKING ABOUT THE CAUSES OF THE RUSSIAN REVOULTION CCCP IS IT TRUE THE REVOULTION BEGAN WHEN THE TZAR WAS FORCE TO ABDICATE COMING BACK FROM FRONT. ARE THESE YOUNG PIONEERS THIS IS A VERY GOOD CLIP. I REMEMBER HEARING THIS CLIP CCCP WAS PLAYING CANADA FOR THE GOLD MEDAL HOCKEY SHOWING CCCP PRACTICE CCCP WON THE GOLD MEDAL. WHEN EVER CANADA PLAYED CCCP VERY EXCITING I WAS IN THE CCCP WE PLAYED IN MOSCOW
liberal20111 7 months ago
LENIN its MONGOLIAN KHALMIG HUMAN!
urmatetgu 1 year ago
lol
stokiecam 2 years ago
when referring to imperial russia, it is spelled tsar.
1Iana1 2 years ago
@1Iana1 Since Russians do not use Latin alphabet, but Slavic, there is no such thing as "correct spelling" of any Russian word in English.
ssmusic214 7 months ago
It isn't Tsar. It's Czar
MrGilenoRanna 2 years ago
Intelligent and well bred young class-conscious people in this video-love it, thanks!
formeliandialogue 2 years ago
cool video and very good recreation but you forgot to do the excecution or murdering of the Tsar and his family
mateogalvis97 2 years ago
The Tsar was a fucking murderer. Lenin did the right thing.
ComradeLenin1289 2 years ago 7
@ComradeLenin1289 Lenin had absolutely noting to do with fall of Russian Czar.
He was nowhere near Russia (in Switzerland) when it happened.
ssmusic214 1 year ago
@ssmusic214 VERY TRUE LENIN HEARD ABOUT IT MADE DEAL WITH GERMANY TO TRAVEL THROUGH THERE TERRITORY TO RUSSIA NO ONE WAS ALOUD TO LEAVE THE TRAIN
liberal20111 7 months ago
I do feel that, when you were getting to the storming of the Winter Palace and the rest of the video, you should have used the Internationale (in Russian, of course) rather than Slavianka.
ComradeLenin1289 2 years ago
LOL. I love this video! I'm putting it on my favorites list. :D
Nice job with the recreation, comrades! Hehe.
ComradeLenin1289 2 years ago
hahahah!!!
"evils of capitalism"
good!
Diazeva 3 years ago
capitalism is indeed 'evil', but I would prefer living in a capitalistic society instead of a communistic one, like in north Korea
gorgorbey9 3 years ago
Hey, gorgorbey9, if you knew anything about communists and communism, you'd know that North Korea is almost universally denounced among communists. It's not even CLOSE to being a communistic society.
ComradeLenin1289 2 years ago 3
what you are saying is true, I wanted to say that communism is an utopia. the idea is nice, but when you put it into practice it can't work, because there will be always opposition.
gorgorbey9 2 years ago
karl marx DENOUNCED utopianism, read scientific and utopian socialism
cary123 2 years ago
God has given 70 years of terror to the Russians because of'17 have desecrated and profaned churches .. the same is with who does black magic .. but God is good and merciful as demonstrated by Jesus Christ who gave his life to save us. Just follow the path of Jesus Christ, Abraham, San Pietro.
gilles2777 3 years ago
if you are religous you can go and die. Everybody know that God didn't creat us, we created him.
Religion is an Opium for the people.
parokj 3 years ago
you really believe that the life of Saint Peter is over so, on a cross?.. if you want.. you go in the gulags. I think that you don't see the paradise in the future..
gilles2777 3 years ago
FUCK YOU. Its People like you that destroy the world. You can take the fucking religoin and die. Pleas, none will miss you.
You christians always complains on the muslims that they are extremists/terrorists. BUT CHRISTIANS HAVE MORE TERRORISTS THEN ISLAM WILL EVER HAVE! Fuck you, little boy.
parokj 3 years ago
as a result ;). also to you :)
gilles2777 3 years ago
No need to insult religion, Communism stands for equality, including racial, religous and economic equality. As long as people dont go imposing there beliefs on everyone its fine. Like I always say, Live and Let Live.
darthkabuto 2 years ago 3
bullshit!the church has a might about ppl that it doesnt deserve,only god has that power!but the church always tried to get mighty and more powerfull,they were usind the word of god, and the fear of ppl to die,to get more powerfull!church is not the work of god!church gives ppl power about ppl,and not god!so church is a work of evil,and thats why they have been burned!if u believe in god you dont need a church or somone else,you only need god!
eugenmichailow 3 years ago 2
i know that the world is not perfect! and its hard to find a paradise here, but if you look the ppl are scared to die, thats the only reason why religion has last so long!
as karl marx said, its opium for the ppl! and its like this!cuz i have never seen someone beeing helped because of a prayer!
i have only seen ppl that put their life in the hands of god, and hope that he will do their work for them!
eugenmichailow 3 years ago
but anyways, i respect that you believe, i do too, but i know that i have to work for a paradies, do you know that anikdote about that women that was lost in sea, and started to pray that good will help her, and after some boats came she said, god will help me, and after she died, she asked god, why he didnt help her, and he said, who you think sent you the boats!
eugenmichailow 3 years ago
Sorry but i haven't created this life. And for me, this life is too hard and cruel for human people. You have done an example.. and other example exist.. For example: INNOCENT children die!! Why?!!!!.. Despit this.. i don't believe that the life of San Pietro is finished on a cross! It's not possible.. Must exist someone that must do justice!..
gilles2777 3 years ago
i know what you mean! but i think something like justice doesnt exist, its like eat or beeing eaten, i know it sounds like animals, but unfortunately its like this!not everyone is born the same!
eugenmichailow 3 years ago
We watched this in our history lesson,I think it's really sweet :)
Oldmusiclover2 3 years ago
It's nice to see young people in England take interest in Russian history.
ahmadhadji 3 years ago 2
Russians tend to mistakenly, see the Bolshevik revolution as merely a Russian event. It was the product of many nationalities. Marx, Engels, Liebknect: Germans, Luxemburg and Dzerzhinsky: Polish, John Reed: American, James Conolly: Irish, then we go into the non-Russians within the Empire and finally, minor figures who in many ways were very important. The Balts who were victorious in the first uprisings, the Scandinavians who formed Lenins bodyguard on and after his trip from Germany and etc.
reyter2007 3 years ago
You obviously forgot to mention one important nationality :)
ahmadhadji 3 years ago
And which was that?
reyter2007 3 years ago
IF YOU BELIEVED IN COMMUNISM YOU WOULD KNOW THAT gOD IS NOT CORRECT !!!!!!
kyletjackson 3 years ago 4
I thought this was good...at least you've got the story right. Pity you couldn't have left the door off the latch and really stormed the Winter Palace. LoL
Long Live Marxist/Leninism
formeliandialogue 3 years ago 2
Also I love this music...where can i get this from? Thanks in advance.
formeliandialogue 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
You can not use this argument that the Tsar had food and the people had nothing to eat. What about communist leaders did they starve for their people? They had more than the Tsar.
If you believe in God you would know that communisam is not correct.
srbija23232323232323 3 years ago
Lenin suffered more than the Tsar could ever know. The Tsar, lived a life of luxery. Lenin live most of his life on the run. If you knew anything about Lenin and the Bolsheviks you would know their cause was just. The Tsars soldiers shot innocent men women and children asking for bread, peace, and land. The Tsar is a murdering coward who put his country into the most pointless war in history. Millions of Russians paid with their life for his luxery. He got exactly what he deserved in the end.
tylerpharaoh1989 3 years ago 4
"If you believe in God you would know that communism is not correct. ": What a persuasive argument! hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
lbronstein 3 years ago 2
LOL funny. "If you believe in God you would know that communism is not correct."
Were you drunk when you composed such a stupid comment?
reyter2007 3 years ago
IF YOU BELIEVED IN COMMUNISM YOU WOULD KNOW THAT gOD IS NOT CORRECT !!!!!!
kyletjackson 3 years ago
does anyone know the titles of the songs they play in the clip??
sojinism 3 years ago
Kalinka
Vottaksuka 3 years ago
Katyusha and Farewell of Slavianka.
reyter2007 3 years ago
It seems yo had a great time dudes!! Well the October Revolution Ideas should not perish and live on to teach us that the people's struggle to achieve freedom and respect is alive. Long live the 1917 revolution!!!
wiccanwanderer 3 years ago 9
brilliant
CaptainDusk7 3 years ago 3
welldone lads!! nice vid.
turistomar 4 years ago
i loved this!
can you send me ths in a file, since i can't save this off the internet. btw, im not really 37, if that creeps you out or anything.
im doing a report on the russian revolution
and i would love to use this as my visual:)
christinax0x 4 years ago
yeah sure, don't really know how to use youtube, but if possible i guess send me your email in a private message and i'll send it to you that way (unless there's an easier method). If you don't want to do that - don't worry, I wont be offended :) - i think there's an application on mozilla firefox that lets you download youtube footage, might be worth checking out.
sovcait 4 years ago
this was amazing. very well put together.
WFPLiaison 4 years ago
OMFG!!!!! 'mazing, Dame Kyle approves greatly.
kyletjackson 4 years ago
aww you guys this is brilliant! i actually watched the whole thing hahaha. well done :) - emma.
nuvolebianche 4 years ago
The best thing i have ever seen. Especially Jimov
JimHobbit 4 years ago