I'm a biker, but to be honest the car is gonna win because four tires is better than two. The bike has the straight line but the car has the braking and cornering. Well I guess it depends on wich track they race on.
The Desmo is a production machine! Advanced Motorsports in Dallas, TX is one of the leading distributors, the Ducati Desmosedici RR retails for around $72.5k. Walk into the shop, plop down the necessary wampum, and ride away on this incredible bike. Two were at the trackday at Motorsports Ranch last week. Saw one ridden by an idiot in sandals and a shorts leave the bars on McKinney in Dallas in the Fall. It certainly IS a production machine.
If i was the ferrari i would slow down and let the ducati pass me....If i was the ducati i would let the ferrari win at the end....i think at the end i would ride them both all day....
For what it's worth, I watched a modded Fireblade race against a 750bhp modded Scooby at Knockhill. The car was spanked on the straights but the bike lost out on the corners. Drag - won by bike. Lap - won by car. It was incredibly close though. On a time trial where they both had a totally free track? Who knows.
the car would probably win, but would be close....but i mean a bike is sooooo much more intimate, a lot more skill to ride fast too. And tbh whats an f430? 200k? whereas a desmo is 40k? and the f430 is defo not 4.5 times better? plus bikes are sexier anyway
Haha, yes :). I think the Atom is amazing and I love TopGear (for most of the time anyway), but putting it up against a 600 with a rider that rode like they did was obviously just meant as a showcase for the car, not a true race. Can't wait to see this one ;-).
I think motortrend did this with a GXSR1000 and a ZO6 vette at willow springs in CA. Cant remember the mag but the bike killed it. The 1000 was like 53mph faster in some of the sweepers. in the 90's cars were faster then bikes in the corners but with the trickle down from Moto Gp is so fast, like 4 years cars cannot keep up on a race track. In saying this Get a it only takes money to make a super care an Uber car and then the important times are real close. IMO
there is no bike like 1198R. there is only 1098R. I think it's not desmosedici RR cause there is no lights !!! BTW desmosedici has 200 HP or 230 if you have racing license. And it is better in performance than 1098R.
But, how i said, it's not desmosedici RR but racing desmo GP9 ( exaust out of tail and no lights)
Like others have said, 4 wheels/tires = better braking... How much good is all that speed the bike makes if the rider can't slow it down. better than the car that has carbon brakes... I believe formula1 cars run faster lap times... Jussayin'
its just physics dude...only reason bikes can keep up at all with a car on a turn is cause the can use more of the lane...top gear has done a few vids on this very thing long time ago...and nobodies talking about normal asphalt are we?? nope, we are talking about the track man...bike wins straight line, car wins twisties
Top gear is clearly from the car side. On superbike magazine (italian edition) I read taht the only category of cars that can fight with bikes are the racing prototype
It mainly depends from wich circuit you are picking to run the test, choose something with lots of tight or mid range turns and you don't even need a Desmo to win...
Tights means hard on the brakes and quick direction changes. Not even the desmo could out brake a F-430. I'm a bike man but cars like that are faster on technical tracks. Open straights and mid range turns means a bike victory. Tight turns hand it to the car.
I don't see the point for those unuseful tests...
Carlovfx 9 months ago
Production bike vs production car. Bikes kicked ass!
gixergav 2 years ago
Yeaaa that´s true...!!!
PablitoAraujoC 2 years ago
they wouldnt have all this hipe about it if the bike was gona loose, its obvesly gona smash it
miky1990 2 years ago
I'm a biker, but to be honest the car is gonna win because four tires is better than two. The bike has the straight line but the car has the braking and cornering. Well I guess it depends on wich track they race on.
deebaystunna 2 years ago 2
@deebaystunna
That is absolutely correct!
A very fair comment.
What's more, the bike is not a production machine.
The ferrari is.
But to make things even more complicated let consider the cost of the two!
billysgeo 2 years ago
The Desmo is a production machine! Advanced Motorsports in Dallas, TX is one of the leading distributors, the Ducati Desmosedici RR retails for around $72.5k. Walk into the shop, plop down the necessary wampum, and ride away on this incredible bike. Two were at the trackday at Motorsports Ranch last week. Saw one ridden by an idiot in sandals and a shorts leave the bars on McKinney in Dallas in the Fall. It certainly IS a production machine.
jdubbsmonkeynutts 2 years ago
OK, I didn't know that.
And maybe I didn't phrase it right.
Here in Greece, by production bike we mean a bike that is street-legal (lights, turn-signals etc.).
The dealers don't even sell you a non-legal bike (track-bike) if you are not a certified racer and/or collector how doesn't ride his bikes.
billysgeo 2 years ago
mate u can watch the race the bike wins bye nerli 15seconds
ThePacman994 2 years ago
If i was the ferrari i would slow down and let the ducati pass me....If i was the ducati i would let the ferrari win at the end....i think at the end i would ride them both all day....
Guatemalanfatkid 2 years ago
My hearts with a bike anyday so i'm defo behind the Duke. Carl Fogarty has that car!,He was at Ducati Manchesters openday.
MITOMAN125 2 years ago
I say Ferrari theres probably Italians all over in Italy fist fighting in Pubs over this discussion as we speak LoL Ducati fan vs Ferrari fan.
mistabiggz16 2 years ago
For what it's worth, I watched a modded Fireblade race against a 750bhp modded Scooby at Knockhill. The car was spanked on the straights but the bike lost out on the corners. Drag - won by bike. Lap - won by car. It was incredibly close though. On a time trial where they both had a totally free track? Who knows.
MrButterscotch1 2 years ago 2
i bet in Ducati!!!!
brucuro 2 years ago
the car would probably win, but would be close....but i mean a bike is sooooo much more intimate, a lot more skill to ride fast too. And tbh whats an f430? 200k? whereas a desmo is 40k? and the f430 is defo not 4.5 times better? plus bikes are sexier anyway
PHoSawyer 2 years ago 3
No way of comparison...
Ducati: 210 hp x 170 kg
Ferrari: 490 hp x 1400 kg
albatrossdumale 2 years ago
it has 165 o the rear wheel
AcXr50 2 years ago
Ferrari - 510 hp x 1300 kg Its a Ferrari F430 Scuderia look close at 0:14
mistabiggz16 2 years ago
Haha, yes :). I think the Atom is amazing and I love TopGear (for most of the time anyway), but putting it up against a 600 with a rider that rode like they did was obviously just meant as a showcase for the car, not a true race. Can't wait to see this one ;-).
wasdom01 2 years ago
The sound of that Ducati when it piles on the revs is pure GP....
bodgerover 2 years ago
0:28 dont lowside.......
AshFromCan 2 years ago
Let's see Clarkson outrun this bike - on this track - in an Atom :)
wasdom01 2 years ago 2
@wasdom01 ha ha...
hvkv0000 1 year ago
Hope the bike will win...
fenrirOZ 2 years ago 2
I'm a bike person,hope Ducati can win!
fenrirOZ 2 years ago 3
awesome, cant wait to see it! making it a little more interesting, better camera shot than usual!
shotokanbiker 2 years ago
ps. Ducati Of Seattle dynod a Desmo at 165 hp at the wheel. It may be on youtube. Everyone is optimistic when it comes to dyno numbers,
AcXr50 2 years ago
Lets just put it this way.
BIKE faster in the straights
CAR Way better braking and handling.
Im a bike lover and i wish it wasent that way.
AcXr50 2 years ago 5
But if bike had car handling, would you want to ride it?
bean318 2 years ago
@AcXr50 and a bike way better in the traffic :P
nevonja 8 months ago
bike will win
Bestever4everSince 2 years ago
I think motortrend did this with a GXSR1000 and a ZO6 vette at willow springs in CA. Cant remember the mag but the bike killed it. The 1000 was like 53mph faster in some of the sweepers. in the 90's cars were faster then bikes in the corners but with the trickle down from Moto Gp is so fast, like 4 years cars cannot keep up on a race track. In saying this Get a it only takes money to make a super care an Uber car and then the important times are real close. IMO
mdbangsund 2 years ago
get an fxx on track. that would be good
zaph0dbeeblebr0x 2 years ago
a 430? is this even fair?
Destro357 2 years ago
i always looked at it for the money. money/speed ratio BIKES WIN...lol
tyler109j 2 years ago
No its not the best car in the world, But boiii is it nice (y)
rapidrhys09 2 years ago
nice
jecki007 2 years ago
bike will pull its pants down and spank it
2wheels2fast 2 years ago 2
That Desmosedici is a nice bike, but overrated. I'd rather he was riding a 1198R if he must have been a Ducati.
mocioclistu 2 years ago
there is no bike like 1198R. there is only 1098R. I think it's not desmosedici RR cause there is no lights !!! BTW desmosedici has 200 HP or 230 if you have racing license. And it is better in performance than 1098R.
But, how i said, it's not desmosedici RR but racing desmo GP9 ( exaust out of tail and no lights)
Furiousme 2 years ago
Huh?
1kperday 2 years ago
what you don't understand ??
Furiousme 2 years ago
Uhm, the new version of the 1098 is the 1198... They increased it because of SBK rules which now allow 2 cylinder engines to have up to 1200cc.
masterknaster 2 years ago
yeah right . I know that. BUT it is still named 1098R . 1098R had 1200 ccm engine right from the beginning.
Furiousme 2 years ago
Well if we're talking about the R model then you're absolutely right. But the standard and S model were 1098cc and now increased to 1198.
Cheers!
masterknaster 2 years ago
yes :)
Cheers for you too :P
Furiousme 2 years ago
WOW! I can't wait for this! This sounds so awesome, and the desmo graphics look sick!
sampsalol 2 years ago
Like others have said, 4 wheels/tires = better braking... How much good is all that speed the bike makes if the rider can't slow it down. better than the car that has carbon brakes... I believe formula1 cars run faster lap times... Jussayin'
ZZRgirl11 2 years ago
braking is important yes...but where the 4 wheels REALLY wins is in the corners...bike has to slow down twice as much as a car does in a corner...
musiciskey777 2 years ago
Yeah it's mostly the corners. cos although the car can brake better it has to brake earlier because it weighs much more
Eurofighter2499 2 years ago 2
I'm not sure that a bike have to slow down twice, maybe YOU do, but I never see a car go faster on normal asphalt.
BIKE RULES!!!!
PedtheFox 2 years ago 3
its just physics dude...only reason bikes can keep up at all with a car on a turn is cause the can use more of the lane...top gear has done a few vids on this very thing long time ago...and nobodies talking about normal asphalt are we?? nope, we are talking about the track man...bike wins straight line, car wins twisties
musiciskey777 2 years ago
On top gear the ducati 999 beat the Lamborghini on the racetrack...
1kperday 2 years ago
never said who wins...all depends on the track...F***n A...just saying...good bike is faster on a straightaway, a good car is faster in the turns
musiciskey777 2 years ago
that was Fifth gear not Top gear
mistabiggz16 2 years ago
What was Fifth Gear?
wasdom01 2 years ago
Top gear is clearly from the car side. On superbike magazine (italian edition) I read taht the only category of cars that can fight with bikes are the racing prototype
PedtheFox 2 years ago
bike wins
bradman158 2 years ago
italy's best?, lol.
which one will it be?
09166410632 2 years ago
can't wait !
afiqorb123 2 years ago
Bike lover as I am, but I just have to say it... AWESOME car!
xD
xemurai 2 years ago
It mainly depends from wich circuit you are picking to run the test, choose something with lots of tight or mid range turns and you don't even need a Desmo to win...
gonzo73 2 years ago
Tights means hard on the brakes and quick direction changes. Not even the desmo could out brake a F-430. I'm a bike man but cars like that are faster on technical tracks. Open straights and mid range turns means a bike victory. Tight turns hand it to the car.
addys 2 years ago 3
completely the opposite is true. The bike prefers a big open circuit
shauncarlpope33 2 years ago
The desmo shouldn't have a problem beating the car
1i4mc 2 years ago 4
this shouldn't be about beating - these are both beautiful engineered things - nice to see them play together :)
lamilumag 2 years ago 2
Totally agree with this - both are absolutely amazing. Glad someone talks sense round here :)
MrButterscotch1 2 years ago