I like Carrie a lot but this wasn't the right song for her. One of the hazards of Idol theme weeks. Thankfully Carrie can now do her own music and do it her way and she is doing very well. For a much better cover of this check out Allison Iraheta's version on youtube
This is pathetic. Like that idiot Pat Boone singing Black Sabbath. She's got a good voice but doesn't have a clue what to do with it. Left to her own instincts she'd be lucky to be working at the airport Holiday Inn lounge. She's just a totally manged and produced product, like Coca Cola or Miley Montana, Mediocrity is taking over our dying world...
@JayMe2823 she is not good either. not bad either...so she is awesome? nope.. that make her average at the best. and I'm not even compare her with the original. but alot of covers even amateur ones are better than this..sorry.
How so? She was singing a song about how men break her heart and she was smiling and winking during it.Not to mention as the judges said she looked stiff
Wow...awful:( Idk why anyone would think making that song country would be a good idea!?? (Thanks Faith Hill for ruining a great song!)
xxxBritticusxxx 6 months ago
Gos bless Janis
mariapedr0 6 months ago
ruined the song.
luvs2dance77 6 months ago
haha she looks silly dancing while trying to do some wierd bendy knee thing.
nat4flick 9 months ago
I like Carrie a lot but this wasn't the right song for her. One of the hazards of Idol theme weeks. Thankfully Carrie can now do her own music and do it her way and she is doing very well. For a much better cover of this check out Allison Iraheta's version on youtube
AHetaFan 11 months ago
This was pretty average. Shes still hot though.
panefuldeath 1 year ago
luh-HAME
EretzLaAm 1 year ago
takes the soul out of this song
trexx32 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Shit, please, don´t listen it, Janis.
Makes me wonder, who are gonna play Janis in the new movie.. Zoey Deschanel? I don´t know.. Pink is maybe much better.. What do you think?
HailyTheEscapist 1 year ago
so sad...it makes me cry...such a strong song of one of the greatest woman ever...and this...so sad...
FragileLittleAngel 1 year ago
i love how the judges don't seem to know that faith Hill did a country version of this song.
Regardless, Carrie still only did an ok job with it.
Recjus 2 years ago
hmmmmmmmmmmm yuk!! i like carrie but that wasnt a song for her.
14jaenak 2 years ago
This is pathetic. Like that idiot Pat Boone singing Black Sabbath. She's got a good voice but doesn't have a clue what to do with it. Left to her own instincts she'd be lucky to be working at the airport Holiday Inn lounge. She's just a totally manged and produced product, like Coca Cola or Miley Montana, Mediocrity is taking over our dying world...
KingKook 2 years ago 2
this lacks................................
trinitybenkaiazeth 2 years ago
strange, very very strange she say's "take a piece of my heart" but wtf was that song
derekhayescampR4Life 2 years ago
@derekhayescampR4Life haha...thumbs up (Y)
lilyanne111 1 year ago
strange version...
No, there is just no Janis in it :D
pupsmausl 2 years ago
I would like to hear her sing it now. I think she would do a pretty good version of it.
But no that wasn't very good.
1benjy1 2 years ago
@1benjy1 Do you want to hear the best version i've ever heard? i think this is a very everage one.
Search for "Diana piece of my heart" from portuguese idol.
alvarosoares87 2 years ago
this was really average...like this singer generaly..
sodade21 2 years ago 12
@sodade21 she is not average
JayMe2823 1 year ago
@JayMe2823 she is not good either. not bad either...so she is awesome? nope.. that make her average at the best. and I'm not even compare her with the original. but alot of covers even amateur ones are better than this..sorry.
sodade21 1 year ago
Oh dear.
scarypeter 2 years ago 4
nope... missed guts and volume...
well, just leave this song alone girlie
pinkfan07 2 years ago 3
I love her smile in the beginning=]
Carrie is just soooo ADORABLE!!! GOT TO LOVE HER<3
tiedie93 2 years ago
not very good, a little messy. she is good but this type of songs not for her.
crestinortodox4ever 2 years ago
lol ffs ... little whore house in texas? .......shoite where that come from.. why do folk clap ...........embarassed?
19glitabug65 2 years ago
Lol not soooo good, actually. Sorry, Carrie
andilendlovu20 2 years ago 2
porkeria de kancion wakala!!!!!!!
no hay nada como la verson origina
me kaga
porkeria
porkeria
porkeria
porkeria
porkeria
porkeria
joizCobain 2 years ago
ai ke fea version...y ademas la bajaron de tono!!!! ke chistee...
mS28m88 2 years ago
awful
AntiStupidGirl 2 years ago
I love Carrie but she should have stayed home on this one
annoyingu4fun 2 years ago 2
ugh, she has a nice voice but she ruined the song. Kelly C. does a WAY better job. Sorry Carrie fans.
Thumbs down me all you want, you know i'm right.
Cynthsam21 2 years ago 2
Melissa E. does the cover the best.
sexysueboo 2 years ago 2
she was doing faith's version...
osahju914 3 years ago
LOL
HAHA
bummedoutforlife 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
horrible.. absolutely horrible
deadydreamer 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
She dances like she has a yeast infection!!
Kattx07 3 years ago
ur immature
AuntyTala 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
whats a yeast infection?
piratepony101 3 years ago
i think she dances so cute(:
Dreamer094 3 years ago 3
Her hair looks way better straight..good!
xbriixluvvsxgee 3 years ago 3
Her hair looks way better straight..good!
xbriixluvvsxgee 3 years ago 2
*thumbs up!* awesome!
Libbyfan4 4 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This just didn't work. She wasn't comfortable and it was quite shaky. Wrong song. She is good though
Frazzla94 4 years ago
i always love carrie....
yukitotc143 4 years ago
It kinda seems like she's singing the Faith Hill version, but Janis Joplin is the original, and the bestttttt.
ohboyitskayla 4 years ago 3
The original actually is by Erma Franklin (Aretha's sister).
Frazzla94 4 years ago 3
who is this by?
timnfaith04 4 years ago
Janis Joplin, durrrr.
ohboyitskayla 4 years ago
she is singing faith hill's version though
zm2187 4 years ago 2
ya its not obvious why she won or anything. she was leagues ahead of EVERYONE even at this point.
jbenkelman 4 years ago 4
i agree with you.
AnneeLoovee 4 years ago
How so? She was singing a song about how men break her heart and she was smiling and winking during it.Not to mention as the judges said she looked stiff
Stormiya 4 years ago 2