Added: 3 years ago
From: gnrfanatik
Views: 605,846
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,329)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • no whiskey lullaby?

  • proof died AFTER that video was made so you might want to fix that. ems stating he doesn't want anyones life or beef put on his soulders

  • Jeremy only shot himself, he didn't kill any of his classmates, he asked to go to the office through class one day, came back to English with a revolver, in his mouth and gone before anyone could react :(

  • you want too feel sad you must see this

    watch?v=lUC8NJySBaw

  • In my opinion a very sad song will be Whiskey lullaby, if you don's know it it is the story of a viy that comited suicide because his girlfriend left him. They found him with a note that said: I'll love her till I die''. Then the song tell us how the girl blame herself and at the end she also suicide, the found her with a picture of him. It is so sad! I strongly recommend listening to this song and undestanding the lyrics. I'm Spanish so excuse my mistakes writing in English :p

  • No Eric Clapton- Tears in Heaven. A song he wrote about the loss of his 4 year old son. Not only is the story of the song sad but the music itself is so sad, the music alone could make you cry. Go search it, I personally think the song beats everything on this list.

  • He Stopped Loving Her Today is one of the saddest songs ever. It is one of those timeless country songs.

  • load of shit 

  • Go check out these songs guys. Real tear jerkers :)

    Sia- Breathe Me,

    Strays Don't Sleep- For Blue Skies,

    Listener- Seatbelt Hands,

    Noah Gundersen- Jesus, Jesus,

    and most of what Right Away, Great Captain! puts out.

    Thumbs up to spread the good music that never makes it mainstream!

  • the toy soldier desreption is all wrong , the songs about shoog night .

  • these are good songs but most of them are not really sad...

  • @gnrfanatik You call those The Most Saddest Songs Ever?! Yeah Right! But What About Call Me By Shinedown Or Overcome By LIVE? Or Mama I'm Comin Home By Ozzy Osbourne? Or GoodBye To Romance By Ozzy Osbourne? Or Lightning Crashes By LIVE? Or With Arms Wide Open By Creed? What Any Of Those Songs?

  • I thought Jeremy just shot himself in front of his whole class? I didn't think he killed anyone but himself

  • toy soldiers was written before proof died

  • i hate bullying and doing something without knowing the truth plus hurting people's feelings is terrible

  • Where is suicidal thought by biggie? And Scars by papa rouch?

  • That Snorlax you just called fat? Yeah, it’s eating rare candies by the dozen for you to accept it. That Gastly you just called ugly? It’s been trying to learn a new move to replace its Mean Look. That Slowpoke you just tripped? He has a learning disability that makes him legally retarded. See that Hitmonchan with the scars? He fought in Vietnam for your freedom today. Re-post this if you’re against PokeBullying. Help Pokemon with a visit to the Pokemon Center. I bet 95% of you wont

  • I cant listen to the song "what hurts the most" because they played it at one of my close friends funeral almost 6 years ago when i was in eighth grade

  • concrete angel, such a good song. the first time i heard it was on GAC back when that was a TV station. channel 27 i believe... anyway i heard it.. and i cried.

  • ima write a rap song about my past nd thats going to be number 1 sad song

  • Dear all,

    I have written a song about the cruelty we inflict upon others...namely bully one another or watch our friends get bullied and do nothing. It is called Locusts by Paul Mayo. Please feel free to listen.

  • ReaD MEMO? u Serious? This is YOUTUBE xD

  • @stamatello1995 I thought you were sad?! -_-

  • If you want truly depressing songs try Timelessness by Fear Factory, Top of the World by Dixie Chicks and maybe Bang Bang Bang by Tracy Chapman

  • Every top 10 saddest songs list I've seen have a song by Eminem in the top 3. Coincidence? I think not!

  • I also thought that Cleanin' Out My Closet by Eminem was very sad; it's one of the few songs that can really get me choked up.

  • On toy soldiers it was actually written a year before BIG Proof past away proof was the person in the hospital bed in the video R.I.P. Proof

  • Where's Mockingbird?

  • except for what hurts the most

  • lame

  • Actually Toy Soldiers is made BEFORE Proof's death. Toy Soldiers came out in 2004. Proof got shot in 2006. Thumbs up so people can see.

  • STAN really that songs is ironic! look up the songs

    Woe Woe by Twiztid

    Cold Cruel World by Boondox

    Sing for the Moment by Eminem

  • -_- Depression and Sadness is another type of Fear...only this type of Fear...is stupid, a lot of people have this type of Fear because they are weak.Their soul is weak and their heart is weak. to me..it's ridiculous how many people are so weak..

  • wanda's song-the readings

    when im gone-eminem

  • Here is a sad song for ya. Alyssa Lies ( child abuse)

  • Where's 'Winter' by Joshua Radin??

  • stan a sad song??? mkay

  • @tomski120 no a guy killing himself and his pregant wife isnt sad at all.....  ..l..

  • What was the intro music(name?) from the very beginning of the video?

  • A 15 year old girl holds hands with her 1 year old son. People call her a slut, no one knows she was raped at 13. People call another Guy fat. No one knows he has a serious disease causing him to be overweight . People call an old man ugly. No one knew he had a serious injury to his face while fighting for our country in the war.People call a women bald but they don't know she has cancer Re-post and like this if you are against bullying and stereotyping

  • @ktitnes one of the greatest  comments ever thumbs up if yuo agree!!!

  • No Kelly Rowland's Stole?

  • You shouldve added Fade to Black by metallica or No Leaf Clover. Both those songs can put you into a sad mood right away

  • @HammerStone82 YOU, sir, are so mean, go help the ppl, dont make the ppl WANT to kill themselves

  • @ahwfulv I am not obligated to help anyone, nor do I have the desire. If my comment makes someone slit their wrists, that just proves my point. The world is better off without people offing themselves over "hurtful" comments. Stand up for for yourself instead of cowering in a dark corner, hoping the world will pass you by. Because guess what? It will do exactly that and not shed a single tear.

  • @HammerStone82 I don't get you.

    "suicidal people disgust me" tbh I really can't stand that,

    Someone I love so much in this world nearly died because of suicide. It's not something you can help if you feel like nothing will ever get better, You'll never know what it feels like to see someone that way, until you expeirence it,, don't judge people because they're going through unbearable pain in life. Hope you won't ever see pain in someone you love like I did.

  • @isaconnors i saved my gf from suicide

  • @isaconnors First of all, I did go through it so your trivial comments don't mean jack. I never really did care about someone's petty feelings of depression and suicide, and after the former girlfriend tried to OD on blood pressure pills, I care even less. Also being told your not loved is not an "unbearable" pain. Unbearable pain is being flayed alive or some other type of excruciating torture. Then suicide is an honorable option. Why do you think Spies have cyanide capsules? Weakness = death

  • @HammerStone82 haha. okay. You wanna be like that? and not give a shit about anyone?

    Fine by me tbh. Just remember karma exists.

  • @isaconnors Tbh, karma is a superstitous falicy based entirely on a fool's opinion and dumb luck. I've got no use for voodoo dolls, charms and witchcraft in my life. EVERYTHING is cause and effect. Make a poor decision, expect an equally poor result. Simple as that... I'm sure you've got a lot of experience with that hippie. Now go do something good for someone and maybe you'll find a dollar on your way home.

  • @isaconnors This is not heaveon son, and its good as it is.

  • for the record... Toy Solder was recorded before 2 years before Proof died.

  • Comment removed

  • Difficult by Eminem listen to that saddest song EVER !!!!!

  • the last song is no sad

  • just a sujestion i think hurt by jhonny cash is alot worst

    or kidcudi soundtrack to my life

  • just a sujestion i think hurt by jhonny cash is alot worst

  • HEY gnrfanatik.... your fucking wrong about the blue October song. It was written to explain Justin's (the lead singer) feelings about his life and the passing of his mother. He was also contemplating suicide.... and that's kind of FUCKING WHY HE SAID THAT HE WANTS TO SWIM AWAY BUT DOESN'T KNOW HOW. SO HE DECIDES TO JUMP OFF THE FUCKING BOAT TO GODDAMN WELL DROWN!!!!

  • what about last kiss by pearl jam anyone agree???

  • Only Hope was originally written and sung by Switchfoot's Jon Foreman

  • yeah stan is a very sad song

    

  • Immortal Technique - Dance With The Devil... changed my whole view on hip hop and music itselff

  • also, Helena by My Chemical Romance.

    That song is about Gerard's Grandmother (who died) she taught him how to sing and everything and he was devistated when she died :P

  • if you could say music VIDEOS we could say Three days Grace...i think its called never to late? lmao well that video is pretty damn depressing and sad :P about a little girl getting molested... yeah not the best :P

  • what about Everybody Hurts

  • holy crap i agree with number 1. love that song!!!!!

  • how can u b sooo wrong on the song ill b missing you? not only that TOY SOLDIERS wasnt about the rapper proof it was about all the diff beefs in hip hop u deff dont know yer music so am not gonna even try check out yer other 8 out of 10 songs cos prob find couple em wrong 2 read up on yer shit before postin cos peeps like u start all the bullshit stories if believed that is.

  • Good vid mate but toy soldiers was written before proofs death, proof was in the music video of the somng ironically in the song he got shot, I think he really died about six months later.

  • The rascall flatts song makes me cry every time, and my mom insists listening to it all the time -__-

  • for a real sad song check out all thats best in you by one less reason

  • hey asshole ill be missing you was done my the police in the 80's Sean comes doesn't have enough talent to come up with his own music and on top of that song was meant for biggy

  • @Impaler1984 both songs had the same rythm and had close to the same chorus but sean COMBS had more verses and he did also change up the chorus just a bit

  • i agree not just cuz i love eminem just the song you got on here

  • completement naze

  • you mean compliment nazi?

  • the song wasnt for jay from  run dmc stupid retard it was for biggie from brooklyn get the facts staight it was biggies wife singing the corus

  • @ch4d232 "retard", read the description

  • mad world :(

  • sorry i had to but also jeremy in real life just shoots himself. not his classmates

  • In jeremy his parents loved him. and that really happened his parents loved him a lot.

  • i still cant listen to stan-makes me sad every time :/ but i still love Eminem

  • all these songs are fucken bull this aint sad. lol wanna hear something sad then listen to apolyptica and a song by hollywood undead.

  • toy soldiers was made before proof died

  • Very nicely made video. Loved the fact that you explained the plot of the song so to say, but except for the nr 1 song (Stan) I didn't find them particularly good. Anyway that's just my opinion.

  • wow Rascal Flatts - What Hurts The Most is about a man's girlfriend breaking up with him and the way he deals with it and the thing that hurts him the most is being so close to loving her and then her leaving him.....just saying :/

  • what about 'in this river' by black label society(Zakk Wylde). saddest song ive ever heard and its real about dimebag

  • What Hurts The Most is about a man who has a girlfriend, and he comes home one day breaking up with him....

  • Rascal Flatts can lick my left nut

  • @JakeBasketball443 let me guess, justin beiber is sucking the right nut

  • @alman107 Nope. Turns out he sucks at sucking too.

  • @JakeBasketball443 hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha­ha, i just freakin pissed myself laughing

  • Umm.. dude...

    "Like Toy Soldiers" wasn't about how he took granted of Proof... >.>

    It's about how he was in a beef with Ja Rule which he got from 50 and all that.. but thats mostly it but Em never took Proof for granted.. just saying... and with Eminem in it -

    Mockingbird... When Im Gone... 25 To Life... Youre Never Over... etc... xD

  • Well "Into the Ocean" was written about his wife dying and how he wish he could get away from that fact. "The loss of her, the one I love." He jumps overboard to try to get away from it (suicide) but realizes he can't bring himself to do it. "How can one man stop his ending, I thought of just your face. Relaxed and floated off to space."

  • None of these songs are really sad in my opinion. 

  • O.O i thought that sound of silence would be here

  • The last one was dumb. No one kills themselves just cuz some famous rapper doesnt write back to them.

  • why in the hell would you put stupid country songs on this.if your a fan of country music you should kill yourself .......

  • @diamond09ify

    I won't insult you,because I'm not that low.But let me tell you something.

    You can not insult someone just because they like the kind of music you can't stand. I personally don't like rap or hip hop but I don't go around screaming at people who like that music. So if you are that low and tell gnrfanatik he/she should kill herself just because he/she listens to country you are no better than the others who are brain-dead.

  • @diamond09ify Hey Hey! I love country music and theres nothing wrong with it! It's better then all this Rap and Hip hop cussing shit!

  • @diamond09ify you are one smart man

  • like toy soliders was written before proof died, proof is in the music video for like toy soliders

  • i hate it

  • Hey, I think your top ten is a really good choice! :)

  • Stan is actually partically true story. That's what I heard somewhere. I think I read it in a interview.

  • concrete angel was based on a real event martinas sister beat her daughter to death and she died thats y martina wrote the song

  • Okay I'm just saying this because I love Switchfoot and want them to get credit... Switchfoot is the artist of Only Hope. Mandy Moore just did a cover of it. Jon Foreman of Switchfoot wrote the song in 1999. A Walk To Remember didn't come out until 2002. I loved the list and agree with most of it!!! Just wanted to correct the little mistake about Only Hope.

  • DONT TRY THIS CAUSE IT WORKS.YOU WILL BE KISSED ONT HE NEAREST FRIDAY BY THE LVOE OF YOU LIFE.TOMARROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY FO YOUR LIFE HOWEVER IF YOU DO NOT POST THIS COMMENT ON AT LEAST 3 VIDOES THEN YOU WILL DIE IN 2 DAYS. NOW YOUVE STARTED READING THIS YOU CANT STOP. THIS SI SCARY. PTU THIS ON 5 VIDOES IN 143 MINTUES.WHEN YOUR DONE PRESS F6 AND YOU LOVERS NAME WILL APPEAR ONT HE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS.THIS IS SO SCARY CUASE IT REALLY WORKS.

  • Where's my immortal?

  • HERES MY LIST; 1. tupac - hit em up 2. biggie smals - big poppa 3. eminem - without me 4. blink 182 - first date 5. oasis - rock n rol star 6. tupac - fuck all yall 7. eminem - the real slim shady 8. arctic monkeys - brianstorm 9. slipknot - phsychosocial 10. katy b - lights on
  • i like pie

  • The song Jeremy was a true story about a boy named Jeremy Wade Delle

    He only shot himself in front of his class not his classmates

  • Eric Clapton - Tears in Heaven should be on every list

  • Not a bad list but the song at the start, Hallelujah should have made the list!

  • nothing compares 2 you from sinead o'connor is the saddest song i ever heard... listen to that song and you will agree with me.

  • the saddest song i have ever heard was 9 crimes by damien rice and fall for you by secondhand serenade

  • What is this? these songs aren't very sad at all!!

  • The saddest song I've ever heard is Crash by Sum 41..

  • sadest song i think is JAMES BLUNT - GOODBYE MY LOVER

  • these aren't sad songs, they are sad events, these song's beats are too uplifting if you aren't payin attention to the lyrics (which most the time i can't understand anyways)

  • In number 1 its DIDO not DIDDO

  • You do love guns.

  • In my opinion, the saddest song is Polly by Nirvana. Its about a 14 year old girl that gets kidnapped and hung upside down in the guys mobil home. He then tortures her with a razor, whip, hot wax, and a blow torch. She eventually escapes when she was tied up in the back seat of his car when he stopped for gas.  Sad sad song

    R.I.P Kurt Cobain

  • whats the third song called, n whos it by? I love that guys voice!!!

  • if you want a sad song listen to neil young- philadelphia

    it will rip your heart out and send chills down your spine

  • none of those songs were sad. angel is a sad song. untitled by simple plan is a sad song. where the hell have you been

  • Where is Christmas shoes? That song is about a kid trying to find a gift for his dying mom on Christmas. To make it worse hes poor and cant afford much things

  • Your "concept" of Into The Ocean is bullshit. It is miles deeper than just a boy jumps overboard. You obviously cant read lyrics very well. Blue october are amazing.

  • @muserocks01 Exactly. Thank you. It's about Justin's (Lead singer) depression and his struggle to get out of it and past his personal demons.

  • i love rascal flatts like if you agree

  • ok am i the only one who thinks start forever over again by rascal flatts is way sadder?

  • Just thought i would let you know that like toy soliders was released late 2004 early 2005 and proof died in 2006, this song was not created after a real life event but in the video proof is the one lying in a hospital bed dying, therefore the song is not proof dying it is actually about the fued eminem had with ja rule and benzino who where talking about haliie. Also this song is about the fueds in the rap community in the past for example the jay z and nas fued.

  • Eminem <3 he knows how to make songs speak to you and really make you think. Like if you agree :)

  • @kakarhcp have you seen the video for stan

  • @MultiSasuke2000 yes i have :) like a billion times! why?

  • intro song autmn tears-at a distance 10)pink-i dont believe you 9)kansas-dust in the wind 8)wish u were here 7)richard markx 6)christina perri-jar of hearts 5)within temptations-pale 4)bryan adams_ never let go 3)evanesence-immortal 2)within temptations-memories 1)trevor robbins-the guardian suite bonus dead before sunrise give me ur name
  • hate me is more sad then into the ocean (blue october rocks!)

  • Blue october, and eminem are clearly the best. THUMBS UP, if you think soo?:)

  • Jeremy did not shoot his classmates

  • I love I'll be missing you :)

  • i think Last Kiss from Pearl Jam should be on the list too...

  • The song from P Diddy was originally I'll be watching you by the police. Not being negative but honest. at least it's based off that anyhow.

  • What about Mad world?

  • Thumbs up if you didnt read the memo like me >:)

  • I made a whole new list in my video. probly doesn't fit anyone those. my personal ones

  • I was watching, and then when #6 came on, I thought "Every Breath You Take" isn't a sad song!

    Thumbs up if this happened to you, too.

  • i would think adams song by blink182 would b in there somewhere

  • In What hurts the most the girl was not pregnant!!!!!

    

  • @mtnpooh she so was why do you think in the vid she was pukeing!

    

  • @mtnpooh

    Actually I think she was I remember a scene with her sitting by a toilet. I'm not 100% sure thought..but I think she was.

  • In the arms of the angel- Sarah McGlauchlin....my saddest song

  • bro the saddest song ever is the scientist by coldplay, and i dont even listen to coldplay. check it out and watch the vid if you want to put the words to motion thou it means different stuff to different people im sure. thumbs up if you agree.

  • where's the song that makes all us guy's cry? "Leader of the Band" by Dan Fogelberg this song is about the important bond between a father and his son.from the beginning. to when the father passes away :'(

  • all i have to say about #9 is good 4 janie shoot that basterd

  • proof died after toy soldiers cameout..the song is about all the violence in the rap buisness..the song youre never over off the recovery album is about proof

  • #6 is defintley the saddest song to me.... this was my brothers favorite song!!!!!!

  • #1 is Stan?

    Really? Of all the soings in the world you picked Stan?

    I dont expect you to go as deep as Moonlight Sonata but Stan?

  • I love the movie A Walk To Remember even though it's really sadd ..

  • #6 was written for biggie thats why faith evens is featured in it also

  • jeremy is based on a kid pearl jam singed eddie vedder went to school with as a kid. he killed himself, but not his classmates....otherwise there would be no eddie vedder, nor would there be a pearl jam.

  • Congratulations to Eminem & Puff Daddy for attaining enough wealth to purchase a time machine.How else could Eminem release a song about his bestfriends death 15 months before it occured.Puff sets precedents by going back 5 years to write a dedication song to the Mix-master of all DJ's.Puffy should've went back and switched Tupac, Biggie & Eminems rhyme books just to make life interesting

  • Love # 1 :(

  • not that you picked bad songs but dude listen to dance with the devil with immortal technique and if you dont cry you have no soul

  • To me the saddest and most terrible song is by far Jeremy by Pearl Jam. The first time I heard the story I felt so heartbroken for the kid and so angry at the same time cause it's unbelievable that such a little child can be treated so bad that he decides there's nothing worth living for at the age of 8. It's the biggest proof that our society has big issues.

  • like toy soldiers by eminem...was in 2004,proof died in 2006.....you do the math,its obviously not written about him, 'difficult as it sounds' written after proofs death...was about him

  • wow i guess nobody here has ever heard videotape by radiohead or my weakness by moby

  • Only Hope was written by Jon, lead singer of Switchfoot. You make awful videos. Js.

  • @haleysuelaber yeah and its also about God...

  • Jeremy is about a kid with Autism :|