海闊天空 Under A Vast Sky

[coffeecat012]

懷念家駒

[nsrgy]

Singing in Cantonese is a lot different from speaking Cantonese. Any accent is masked by the music. Non-native speakers usually have difficulties with the 8 to 9 Cantonese dialect tones. Try asking them to pronounce these 3 sentences in Cantonese: 1. I kiss you. 2. I smell you. 3. I ask you.

[vanillasky91]

Respect!! I am chinese and you sing great!

[CakePortal7]

ht tp :// wa m jelly.com /?ref =31 6934

[pazu99]

This is one of my most favorite songs of all time and glad to hear Metro singing it in a new way!

[myunicon]

It's such a beautiful song, sang in Cantonese by a group of foreigners from different countries. Their pronunciation are perfect, if I did not see their faces, I would never be able to tell they are not Chinese. This is wonderful and I am so proud of them that they learn the language so well which is beyond my imagination. Their performance is amazingly profound and marvelous. I wish all of you the very best in your singing career and thank you for putting it on you tube-

From Canada with Love !

[Krismak123]

I believe that of there is english subtitle the video will be even better

[HeungRose]

Great performance today! Please add oil and sing more Canto pop to us ;)

[barrhavener]

@HeungRose

Oh My Gosh !!

...add oil...?

it shows that Hong Kong is not under British rule anymorel

[cernjiachechong]

真心喜爱Beyond

[WALKUREX]

FUCKING AMAZING!!!!!!!

[wisedennis]

唔知他們的BASS ( 拍拍下) 的是不是用 口水做出來的? 還是用拍手? 好利害

[HKSKYAA]

@wisedennis 用口架!

呢d 叫beat box 用噴氣聲模仿鼓聲

a Capella 係全部用口架, 不用任何樂器

[1324allison]

@wisedennis 個d叫beat-box

=.=

[McDennisChau]

外國人學到最難學既廣東話....

香港"歌手"就連同廣東話差唔多既普通話都學唔好



[TheCamron86]

does someone know the pinyin lyrics of the hongkongnese version? 感谢

[harrychank73]

@TheCamron86 What do you mean by Pinyin? Putonghua or Cantonese?

[AlbeLowns]

@harrychank73 he means cantonese but itsnt familiar with their Jyutpin :)

[AlbeLowns]

@TheCamron86 you mean Jyutping

[AlbeLowns]

@TheCamron86 Here you go. Its a good website

[AlbeLowns]

Fs youtube. Google "Sing k lyrics" > go to groups > Beyond is the first one > some songs, this one is -hoi-foot-tin-hung it has the Jyutping lyrics to kind of sing along to if you practice enough :) im ok with it now :DD

[TheCamron86]

@AlbeLowns thanks mate. very useful site! and thx for enlightening me. I've studied mandarin for a year now and didn't know there is something called Jyutpin. shame on me^^ greetings from Germany

[AlbeLowns]

@TheCamron86 haha no worries, im going to china for a month soon to continue my mandarin then visit hk and maybe practice cantonese.. :)

[medicomrah1977]

Very touching

[gn009672471]

awesome!!!

Great song with great vocal group!!!

[fungbbbbb62]

42個dislikes,係係學校音樂比賽唱海闊天空fall左­

[nananeneh]

It's great seeing people that are not Chinese enjoying our music.

[LouisTKK]

THIS is real music. METRO GJ.

And, that leads to a discussion : can Hong Kong singers NOWADAYS do so?

I doubt it.

[244776177]

METRO

[wonlouis]

its ok, we got C All Star :) finally

[fannykhuu1108]

noce cover could go beyond Beyond 

[ysman2006]

最簡單的聲音卻最能感動人心

[28721615]

一開始仲以為徐錦江唱咖先 哈

[28721615]

中意家駒戈首多d,比較豪放,不過這首都好听

[Bianca26660]

1:35 個樣有d似世榮

[hokawaimail]

同beyond 有得揮~



[pplareppl]

@hokawaimail nice joke

[Mcburgerdennyfatkid]

你不孤獨 闊天空 聲樂組合 們比起香港

[jos2002130]

its canto

[chris2favip]

keep up the good work....a chinese (mando/canto) CD perhaps?

[klsuperman]

如果佢地可以唱埋《情人》就正囉，《情人》呢首歌好適合用Voc­al形式去演譯

[paintersongs]

超好聰!好精彩的人聲演繹.

[xpanda92]

That's the best cover of 海闊天空, although it never beyond Beyond's.

[felixfelixlele]

好聽><

不過始終都係beyond好聽d

:D

[chuntings]

好似唱緊文藝歌 將隻歌提升到另一個層次

[zhdavidzh]

唱的真好！他们也去天天向上唱过

[RubyLakewood]

great ! you guys are amazing ! thumb up !

[pplareppl]

honestly, its a terrible cover. I wonder the reason why it has such positive feedback from users is just because the privilege that we feel where there is a white group trying to copy us...

[perverted77]

@pplareppl I can only say one thing, you've got TERRIBLE ears... or music sense, take your pick...

[pplareppl]

@perverted77 you could pick what you like, I'm just speaking my thoughts, I'm a piano teacher for 14 years, used to be the pianist for Hong Kong Orchestra, been around the world and I have no doubt on my ears, nor my sense of music

[AdrianLukBB]

Amazing performance!!

[umbdude]

Wow!! Awesome...sounds great.

[koeral183]

LOVE U GUYS :) fm HK

[chaukaki123456]

nice

[sickwoman2005]

Add oil Metro!!!

[0316Redfield]

AwEsOmE!!!!

[111rubbish]

中共狗,只會抄襲，正一copy dog。不懂英文啊？！查字典啦，傻仔

[stmboyfgh]

把聲好舒服 wo

[heymee1637]

我覺得佢地把聲好好聽



[Hanlin163]

原来背景音乐就是一堆人在后边嘟嘟嘟，太牛逼了

[yellowlynx]

@Hanlin163 外國好多組合都這樣的，之前有名的叫 The Flying Pickets...

[TYJiahui]

Nice one guys ! Quite accurate pronunciation on cantonese !

[philip233096]

Today I m glad to see your performance in Macau. : )

[alex1b38]

正=]

[jeffery850218]

我覺得他們唱得還不錯，會讓人想聼下去

[colinhuang930124]

Beyond 永远是经典~~~

[ahiunglim]

Wong Ka Kui will hear this one, and I bet he will be pleased. Beyond has been be my only favorite band since I was a little brat. Now, I'm 23 y.o., still no other band can replace beyond.

[tub3la]

人類只懂得大自然的美,,

鳥兒的歌唱聲,,

海浪的拍打聲,,

卻忘記了自己天生也有一把美妙的聲音,,

無需樂器,,

只靠四個人的聲音,,

亦可創造出不輸樂器的音樂,,

所以請好好珍惜自己的一切吧...

[TheFeederG]

@tub3la 人自身不算是大自然的一部份嗎?

[jtsai866]

Metro = 4 person group > all of HK singers combined.

[Rudyzhao]

I can't purchase this song, its not on iTunes.

[sean23mimic]

一首好歌，可以陪伴我們度過好幾個人生的寒暑，家駒，你不孤獨，­我們終有相聚的一天，希望到時候我能買到你演唱會的票。

[yy123456789ful]

好感動。  音樂係世界ge語言，無分國度，無分彼此

[Lingslow]

他們比起香港沒實力,只得外表的歌手們,還是好得多!!

[hohungto]

香港的"歌手"們, 慚愧嗎?

[bolove520]

@hohungto

唔好拎D唔係音樂既音樂同真音樂比..ａ



[KazukiPoP]

@hohungto

何為"慚愧"?

你問得E個on9問題證明你系個on9仔啦!

香港咩地方嚟架? 你唔知?

屌你唔知咪撚出聲啦! 7頭皮!

[specbrian]

@KazukiPoP 佢問個問題邊度ON9?

[hohungto]

@KazukiPoP 從你回應的態度, 我終於明白香港今時今日是一個怎麼樣的地方了! 多謝指教! 祝你龍年心想事成!

[KazukiPoP]

@hohungto 知道就好=w= 可以彈開了嗎?

[hohungto]

@KazukiPoP 悉隨尊便

[Cantonese2638]

@KazukiPoP 傻閪..影衰埋我

[vanill23]

@KazukiPoP

-__-都唔知你up乜9

[matthewtsanghinkiu]

@hohungto

(正面討論:) )

首先我想講,就係因為你地睇唔起香港歌手所以至咁

你諗諗,如果香港歌手唱D歌,根本冇人支持

佢地可以進步咩??

我唔係話METRO差

但係佢地一定練咗好耐

咁相反,香港歌手我唔信冇努力過

點解你地唔可以接納下呢??=]

[HKSKYAA]

@matthewtsanghinkiu 香港有邊個捨得幫 a Capella 拍個咁靚既mv?

就算 c all star 咁出名都未捨得咁投資啦.........得伍賢肯自資出隻碟咋

個個都要好有商業價值先做, 點支持呀?

[wyattgrl]

I think Metro did a great job on the remake of this song. Very impressive!

[joyceoie]

if ka kui saw this he would definitely be very happy cause now here music is really international!!

[mrbean435]

metro boy band can team with beyond chinese rock band !! promotion 海闊天空 will always be remembered by the songwriter wong ka kui

[perverted77]

@leonlee10021 Fucked-up asshole, YOU fuck off...

[maymay588]

證明了華人的音樂得到認同!

BEYOND is the BEST!

[KingsleyNin]

iz really awesome.. the words that i could use to describe this song iz fuckin perfect although iz different kinda style..

[tonychan2288]

好.

顶一下

[hokaching]

我愛香港！我愛世界！

I love Hong Kong! I love the world too!

[JASon98ification]

好好聽



[dumdidolabumbuladido]

for liberty 為自由

[lamce3226]

正正正 比D歌星好好多LO

[jeffchankitkit]

thz metro i reli reli like it

[emyrchambers]

this is absolutely better than many other bands. Good job@@ but still, Beyond's the best.^_^

[cobia1995]

Ho yan ah ...guai lo..

[zhiminong]

Ang moh ?0.o

[MrMonkey868686]

damn very good ah , Qoay Lau!

[mangowithyou]

外國人唱呢首歌，真的很好。

感情也很好，好舒服及較溫和的版本。

NICE! 黎香港發展 好似MC JIN咁。

[mangowithyou]

好過好多香港歌手.///~!

[pearlivory]

唱得很好！谢谢你们！

[titoxullman]

no english comments

[pc0211hk]

十個讚！！！！



[allpguy]

有一種無法形容的澎湃感覺。。

[123sangsang]

好好聽~.~感動

[0819589]

海闊天空可以走向世界啦.

好感觸.

beyond的成就

家駒嘅的理想係唔會白費

[OHellFireo]

really good speaking!

[jason9610193330]

最少一樣野

感情經已嬴了香港歌手

[Mirokism]

@jason9610193330 香港歌手翻唱beyond既歌: 永遠唱唔出beyond味道

當外國歌手翻唱beyond既歌: 最少感情經已嬴了

..........

[badbabya3a]

好正丫;))



[patrickpun199857]

感覺難已形容啊;]



[namida401]

support

外國人要唱廣東話唔容易,睇得出有用過苦功去學唱哩首歌~

[cks1995]

他只是發音不準，如果唔係咁，佢地勁過我地好多香港歌星啦~~~­

[alex19971121]

個外國人佢d字同我一樣到係咁= =  唱得好good

[hkoowind]

雖然係班外國人d讀音唔係好準確,,但佢地唱既海闊天空,,擁有­令人想聽落去既心情(唔識表達)

[ken580230184]

@hkoowind 系咪想表示比原曲更好。

更有感情。我鍾意聽

~

[skynie09]

@hkoowind 好感動, 真係感受到音樂無國界, 係唯一一個我接受到ge cover...

[peebeelaa]

 好听极了！！！证明音乐並不真正需要语言，他们唱不准也​一样唱出感觉！

[MrKongt]

Metro我永遠支持你

[Scolded247]

awesome, they sang it well!

[ohhwat]

geezz. awesome.. 

[zhangmifigo]

擦，真牛逼

[puiszepatsychan]

They use A Capella to sing Beyond's Famous Song. So Great!

[zhuowu]

厉害~加油 ~

[b8585885]

阿卡貝拉!!

[list67]

佢地唱得好勁呀 ! 外國人唱得廣東歌證明 香港市場擴闊, 我期待Metro 會 打入香港樂壇. 證如 '我地一齊加入Beyond既行列!'

[tintin121000]

勁呀

[Lemoncoke09]

Bravo!!! 勁 ！！

[Tiffystars]

a really good cover :)!

[rahxephon52]

Legit. 

[Jessmohk]

你們知不知道拍攝背景在那裡呢？就是在童年成長時代，有小台灣之­稱的調景嶺的山上一座堡壘拍的，記得小時候常常上去這座堡壘玩的­，雖然調景嶺已拆了，但堡壘依然存在，現在每次上去好像去到十二­歲的那一年。

[Jessmohk]

你們知不知道拍攝背景在那裡呢？就是在童年成長時代，有小台灣之­稱的調景嶺的山上一座堡壘拍的，記得小時候常常上去這座堡壘玩的­，雖然調景嶺已拆了，但堡壘依然存在，現在每次上去好像去到十二­歲的那一年。

[Peonybobo]

gd!

[Y2o0u0T8ube]

好正



[jojojoannnnne]

The audio started playing before the video did, and I was so convinced they were Asians singing the song. I'm very impressed that they're not native speakers!

[jojorandomsox]

@jojojoannnnne Lol i read jojo- and i wasn ike i didnt comment on this video xD

but thn i realized it wasnt me

[luck99xxx]

very creative. love it.

[w28225060]

good

[w28225060]

so good!

[imMethuselah]

wonderful... famous song... but impressive for caucasian 2 sing it :D

[Cantonese2638]

硬係要比LE樣哥樣,兩樣唔同GE野梗係有分別GA LA

好好地欣賞或從另外角度思考米仲好。

[hustla1469]

無beyond 版咁poignant.....

[Naturepheonix]

Music is infinite like the sky and water.

音樂是無限的。

[pk572]

35 people missed the nice song and voice :(

[hugo9180]

MARCUSSSSSS! HE's SUPERRRRR HOTTTTT!!!!

[titochion]

Just amazing!!!

[Shutupcrazybitch]

nice

[nelsondns]

唔知點解...

一有唔開心就E 首歌心情就好番好多..... 

[ET7360]

The song is fantastic, very touching and comfortable.

I can't find any reason (for those 34 ppls) to dislike this song!

Support metro vocal group!

[bmb007]

No musical instruments but sounds so ***king great!!!

[a5f5g6h66j55]

要外國人學中文,仲難過你學印度文,我覺得佢地真係好比心機唱

[hide98000]

海闊天空,,獅子山下,,半斤八兩呢幾首我覺得係代表香港既歌

[PLATMAN]

this was one of my favs back in the day haha

[2redstick]

Dammmnnn, you guys kick butt,,,love it love it love it.....thanks....thanks....tha­nks... you make my day.......:)

[etyam2009]

wot a gud song.



[SuperKelvinLiang]

this song is so damn good!

[Kenny5101997]

@13YoshiMan

haha

[LINkevin1000]

家駒我相信祂也聽到了吧 ... 跟原版聽起來有很大的不同 但是 感動度是一樣的

[b8585885]

我覺得很好聽啊!!

因為他們也喜歡這首歌才唱啊!!

為什麼會不喜歡呢?

[hmchee]

the feeling is just not right. Acapella version sounds strange. But nice job!

[younghanson]

Super! They have sung the passion of this song albeit the cultural difference.

[totorolon]

外國人唱廣東歌,雖然風格不同,

卻比香港現時那些所謂的歌星都要好得多,

讀歌的,看著歌詞都聽不懂的....唉~~

我想他們選擇唱這首歌時也有了心理準備讓人比較,

其實沒必要拿來比吧?說他們唱得不好是覺得他們褻瀆了家駒嗎?

換個角度看,這不是證明了家駒的存在和成就嗎?

[pall0121]

@totorolon

他們在唱這首歌的同時

一定也看過這首歌的粵語翻譯

一定也認同家駒的想法

不然不會想翻唱這首經典名曲