All-4-One - If Your Heart's Not In It

[itsmebellaluna]

I prefer Westlife version because it sounds more emotional that suits with the touch lyric.

[Antzeleyes]

'Cause I would give the whole world for you

Anything you ask of me I'd do

But I won't ask you to stay I'd rather walk away

If your heart's not in it

[amaiTinashe]

if your heart is not in it please don't try to fake what you don't feel!!!i just love the song so much

[Maveli08]

i don't know how old westlife (the band) but this is one old ass band this song probably came out in the early early 90's .. 90-92 but correct me if im wrong plz :)

[toeberries111]

i didn't knew they sang this.. lol nice version but i really love westlife's version..

[VpY22]

i like both versions. this version is refreshing because its gotta slightly different sound.

[MrWalkinblue]

you know what separates this two boyband???voice quality...westlife's voices are more powerful than all 4 one...

[maoruviel]

this version is good but I still love Westlife's version..they tend to sing it with a lot of emotions causing the listener to feel the pain..

[davadrsg]

VERY NICE SONG...WITH LYRICS PA... :)

[meigan091]

wow! I love it!!! I love both westlife's original and this one :) This version is much more of RnB type. Both are incredible versions!!

[shnicky7]

am a huge Westlife fan but this version.. WOW.. blew me away!

thanks for sharing this!

i never knew this version existed!

[avantgarde808]

@chellechubbies yes, westlife versions better though I love both of these groups. I think the big reason why some of us love the westlife's version is that they sang the song with MORE INTENSE FEELINGS that we feel and internalized pouring on to every words in the lyrics. :))

[vanskilig]

whos the original singer of this song?

[Silvia84IT]

@vanskilig WESTLIFE

[SarahBogus]

All-4-One is my fave band, the second one is Westlife... Westlife's version is better in my opinion, cause the song for me has that disdain emotion, like, he is telling the girl to go away as if he didn't care that much, but he is hurting a lot. Mark Feehily gives it in his voice, some frown, some urgency. All-4-one is too soft. It's like hearing angels singing about human feelings! They got the best harmonies, but in this song, they don't mean to hurt anybody.

[jocas85]

all 4 one version is better

[truelovebc]

el perro está enamorado de Miguelito jajaja

[renaird]

def all 4 one version. 

[phollyza1974]

both are good!

[oonaman21]

this versi0n sucks!!!,,westlife rules!!

[natBMWshane]

westlife all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[SummerS1998]

i like both all 4 one and westlife

but all 4 one is better to me

[Tum2185]

The best version goes to All-4-One. Amazing!!!!

[Galovesongs]

I like the westlife version coz for a sad song this sounds too happy.

[cbrigoli]

All for 1 never ceased touching my soul with their songs!

[osvntwnteit]

which one is original? westlife's or this one?

[danger2407]

@osvntwnteit Westlife is the Original Singer of this Song!

[osvntwnteit]

@danger2407 oh i see. Thanks. I actually knew from Westlife first. in 2001 when i had their world of our own album. what year was it revived?

[danger2407]

@osvntwnteit This Album No Regrets Released Last September 2009, That's Why The Song Revive Of All 4 One That Year! :)

[PinkRanger90]

Westlife still is the best!

[jocas85]

all 4 one version is better

[gmaine27]

all4one is better.

[danger2407]

I Like Westlife Version ..

[RAIDEN80809]

all 4 one,one 4 all is better!!!lol

[danger2407]

I Like Westlife Version . Not Because I'm Westlife fan .. i really like the version of westlife .!

[danger2407]

Who is The Original of this song ?? Westlife or All 4 One >????

[blueberrypoptart1995]

This Is MY JAM!!! :)

[michyful05]

Westlife version is more emotional than them

[gurukid08]

These gentlemen, all four of them and other male R & B artists from the 90s black or not, are the type of men I, my cousins, and at least one of my friends try to be like. What I mean is we carry ourselves dignity and respect for ourselves, our fellow men, and especially women. So I'm a hugh supporter of All-4-One, Boyz II Men, After 7, Dru Hill, K-Ci & Jojo, etc.

[gurukid08]

I like All 4 One's version better. I think its because you don't see black artists make music like this anymore. I'm referring to Delious Kennedy and Jamie Jones of course. Today's black male artists make music about drugs, money, how many women they've slept with, how many women they want to sleep with, and just all kinds of bullshit that make black people, particularly men look bad.

[wirelessjunkhead]

i have been listening westlife's version of this song for .. lets see, 8 years.. and i swear it never gets old.

But i really enjoyed all-4-one's version as it is more modern and up-beat...

Great cover lads! Keep it up.

Although theres one thing inevitable... this song is timeless.

[jerelkewl1990]

Westlife had a great version of this song but if u compare the instrumentals, All-4-One has the better music.. hehe

[twilightmad1997]

westlife are better

[ImTheAsianChick13]

I think if you're into more of the pop sounds then go with Westlife but I'm going with his guys version because I been craving classics this days. XD

[MrBee1726]

nice but westlife did the best version of it!!!!1

[phantomjuggalo83]

good song tho i like it and please dont mistake me for a racist although that last comment can be seen as being racists but why is it when a white group is called a faggot boy band but when a gruop of black guys get together is called an r&b group? especially when they sing the same sappy love songs just curious please someone explain why that is to me i would greatly appreciate it

[Sideswipe1125]

@phantomjuggalo83

I don't know how old you are but I don't think you know who All-4-One is. This is not a group of black guys. There is 1 black guy, 1 biracial guy, 1 white guy and 1 hispanic guy. I don't think you are racist as I can see what you are saying but I'm just pointing out to you that there are multiple races in this group not just blacks. Please don't stereotype because there are plenty of other races that sing r&b like Mayer Hawthorne, Joss Stone and Frankie J. Not just blacks.

[phantomjuggalo83]

@Sideswipe1125 come to think of it guy ur right i did sound like an idiot on that one my apologies and i am 27

[phantomjuggalo83]

ok i like all 4 one but almost all their songs that are hits were originally done by white guys or groups that are almost unknown take for instance they got i swear and i can love you like that from john micheal montgomery and now this one from a group of white guys called westlife i mean seriously no wonder they werent around for too long they rip other peoples songs and people like their versions why cuz they are black? think about that one

[MsKianEgan]

OMG only just found out that they covered this song :O

Wow!!!! me like...fantastic cover x

I love both versions...obv im a devoted Westlife fan...but All-4-One were awesome when i was younger x

[ButterflyM27]

Super like

[yatz1110]

yeah, the song was very nice... . .i love the version of westlife...hehehe

[56cocoa]

man idc what anybody says.. its 2010... All-4-One is back!!! and they killin it. especially this song. Westlife sucks compared to this version. =) (highly opinionated)

[Draqoni]

I love Delious Kennedys Voice, it almost makes me melt hmmmm.......

[Kirkyy15]

Shane Filan's voice is unreplaceable! Anyway, credit to these guys to cover a wonderful song from the best band in this universe!

[greiz09]

i would prefer westlife version ...but i like all 4 one ♥♥♥

[numptie09]

westlife version defo better

[luisalove13]

westlife version is better... more ballad :)

[mayalove9]

westlifes´s version is the best... XD

[DisposableWarrior]

this is the more r&b than pop. i just like the westlife version better because they sings with their emotion so lively. this one is just sound too plain.

[MrDopwop]

@DisposableWarrior  are you out of your mind

[brianmcfadden1000]

@MrDopwop hey westlife is better because their voice is natural and soft in ears than that fucing all-4-one !!! westlife is better westlife has many platinums had received!!

[nickylover1012]

i love westlife's version way better cuz they sing it w/ more feelings in it n it sounds more original. this one sounds so dead. not even close to what i've expected.anyway, this is juz my opinion. no offence,all 4 one fans

[amzarifah]

i love you,forever and ever

[chellechubbies]

... Both of Westlife and All for one are good... but I like the Westlife version. I think it's because I've heard the westlife version for years ....

[avantgarde808]

@chellechubbies yes, westlife versions better though I love both of these groups. I think the big reason why some of us love the westlife's version is that they sang the song with MORE INTENSE FEELINGS that we feel and internalized pouring on to every words in the lyrics. :))

[algeniuz]

i love this version look soft & real.. its more better than westlife..

[greiz09]

love the song..♥♥♥

[abnas]

Omg... Westlife and All 4 One are both great groups! I really like and always will love Westlife's version.

[malia1020]

both version is good

but this guy sings it more meaningful..

which means I like this version better.

[gyrlie]

i love this verson so much better...

although it was really westlife's song...i,

personally, think that this one is better..

because of the fact that it's more modern

day, and sounds like it has more meaning..

just by how it's sung...

[lonelypro]

I love this version .

[SmOk3Y1234]

dam baby dont fake if your love aint for reall i rather walk away dont say that you loved me if is not true so dont say words that u dont mean just tell me the true how u feel because if your not in it i rather walk away i wont ask you to stay baby sorry

[Brucelee4eva]

all 4 one with more soul more feeling. westlife better?i dont think so and im very fair 4 both 2 groups.

[gel0o08]

westlife version is million times better! ^_^ nice try

[KARENK1991]

tbh da westlife verison is so much better an dey say westlife r stealin so many sngs???

[IrishGoblin27]

Good for you that it was a Joke...

... Westlife are the best of all.

I'm absolutely in love with tha song

for years since I first heard it on Westlife

Album "World of our own"... this Version is pretty good, didn't knew that

All-4-Onestill exist ^^

[poeticmakaveli]

westlife are absolute muck! if ever i heard bad singers and false music,its westlife! mimers! i have lost respect for all 4 one for taking this track from a group that would totally outsing! but its too late and they have be littled themselves by copying this song from complete talentless group called westlife! A JOKE!

[WestlifexRose]

think i prefer westlifes version x

[CapriciousFate]

Glad they're bringing R&B back.

[atbnorge]

this is beautiful! I love Westlife's rendition; but it's also good to hear a different rendition. Two thumbs up!

[graysky2309100]

i've loved this song from westlife's CD

[Temptap]

This one is more soulful and R&B than Westlife. Both good though.

[TheSpiritDreaming]

Westlife did it better!

[calvert87]

not just better, way way way! better. :D

[amymarkwl]

u think that maybe because ur used to westlife's version

[TheSpiritDreaming]

@amymarkwl No I think that because Westlife's version is the better version. This is no where near as good.

[brianmcfadden1000]

@amymarkwl hey hey hey you what the fuck look at the voice of that guy than the voice of shane and mark and listen to marks voice!!

[amymarkwl]

@brianmcfadden1000 it was just my opinion. i like the wl version more too. i said 'maybe', take that in account

[behindtheprettyface]

@amymarkwl westlife's version is more...sincere. i don't know how to explain it. to each his own.