Napat je vous connais depuis assez longtemps pour savoir que votre choix à ses raisons et je peu vous dire, que je vous comprends ! ! ! ce n'est pas le chant d'une diva, mais d'une bergère, mis en musique classique ! Une belle voix lyrique...j'en suis très heureuse !!
I quite like her rendition of this. It is light and sweet. This song is ruined by heavily operatic voices. It's a light, lyrical song sung by a shepherd girl. She does beautiful justice to it. It needs a lighter sweeter treatment than any of the operatic divas give it.
Breathing and support are her problems. Listen to her notes in the piano passages: she finds them first and then crescendos. She's fine on the forte passages when her support is constant. Didn't like the fussy arrangement with some strange harmonies.
Oui, c'est très bien. Mais j'ai une petite préférence pour Federica von Stade avec le Royal Philarmonic Orcherstra dirigé par Antonio de Almeida (Sony Classical)
Yes, it's very good. But I have a little preference for Federica von Stade with Royal Philarmonic Orcherstra directed by Antonio de Almeida (Sony Classical) - Sorry for my English!
Just bought this CD. Excellent vocalist. I don't make comparisions with people. She sounds wonderful and this is a great album! Kiri Kanawa is much older, therefore much more educated in the gift of what both singers do quite well.
stop being so elitist and enjoy a beautifull song as this is .
MrBearcub300 13 hours ago
Napat je vous connais depuis assez longtemps pour savoir que votre choix à ses raisons et je peu vous dire, que je vous comprends ! ! ! ce n'est pas le chant d'une diva, mais d'une bergère, mis en musique classique ! Une belle voix lyrique...j'en suis très heureuse !!
Marie :)
543693The 3 weeks ago
I quite like her rendition of this. It is light and sweet. This song is ruined by heavily operatic voices. It's a light, lyrical song sung by a shepherd girl. She does beautiful justice to it. It needs a lighter sweeter treatment than any of the operatic divas give it.
I'd love to hear Dawn Upshaw sing this.
BirdwoodPress 2 months ago
@BirdwoodPress
Oh que vous avez raison et dit juste !! cette bergère est divine, au chant si doux !!
J'aime beaucoup avec Victoria de Los Angeles ! mais là un peu plus de simplicité interpelle ....
543693The 3 weeks ago
@BirdwoodPress how about Renee Flemming rendition?
MrBearcub300 13 hours ago
can CRHG1946 jump in fast flowing river and do all a favour,no pleasing some people
TheTerrylang 3 months ago in playlist TheTerrylang's favourites
This has been flagged as spam show
viva la creatività.....un saluto... creativity aLIVE
zioband 5 months ago
Breathing and support are her problems. Listen to her notes in the piano passages: she finds them first and then crescendos. She's fine on the forte passages when her support is constant. Didn't like the fussy arrangement with some strange harmonies.
CRHG1946 7 months ago
how could anyone put a dislike to this .
londoncabby1 9 months ago
I totally agree with leontud.
Gohst1968 10 months ago
wowjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjjj
bedos10 10 months ago
wow
bedos10 10 months ago
wow
bedos10 10 months ago
wow
bedos10 10 months ago
Beauitfullllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Lisa281977 1 year ago
a certain choice for the Royal Wedding - William & Kate... and yes Kiri Te Kanawa is far superior but perhaps a bit stuffy for this generation...
barrielad 1 year ago
Comment removed
barrielad 1 year ago
Should listen to Karita Matilla - amazing voice!
Suji24 1 year ago
Prachtig ingetogen gezongen.
tonter1 1 year ago
wow you have a beautiful voice !
seafish71 1 year ago
Netania Davrath's version is the best one of this song.
shaQGee 1 year ago
Listen to KIri Te Kanawa version. A masterpiece
leontud 1 year ago 2
nice - but to hear the way thisi should be sung- listen to Kiri te kanawa - A Masterpiece
napo1812 2 years ago
she's fantastic!
brava!
alexnel 2 years ago
it would be very interresting to hear the original folk songs, to see how far Canteloube took them from.
jeamphe 2 years ago
very good job; but, I still prefer the Moffo and Auger versions.
tenorote 2 years ago 2
All I can say is WOW.....Beautiful
homethoughts1 2 years ago
Von Stade et Almeida font vraiment cru du terroir
manrico061 2 years ago
Very nice, but no-one matches Victoria de los Angeles, the definitive version.
ianjohnson1000 2 years ago
Oui, c'est très bien. Mais j'ai une petite préférence pour Federica von Stade avec le Royal Philarmonic Orcherstra dirigé par Antonio de Almeida (Sony Classical)
Yes, it's very good. But I have a little preference for Federica von Stade with Royal Philarmonic Orcherstra directed by Antonio de Almeida (Sony Classical) - Sorry for my English!
ChuloJacques 2 years ago
Thx for sending, it makes me again a bit tired..lol
but wonderful voice..
gfkd11 2 years ago
Just bought this CD. Excellent vocalist. I don't make comparisions with people. She sounds wonderful and this is a great album! Kiri Kanawa is much older, therefore much more educated in the gift of what both singers do quite well.
Rider222 2 years ago
Si bien su voz no es "tan especial", como muchos lo piensan. Esta cancion a mi parecer si es diferente y agradable
Lilu8X 2 years ago
this is a favorite classical piece
JOLEEFEE 2 years ago
This version they play most on Classic FM.....a truly great piece:)
NKT3505 3 years ago
I heard her when she was just 16 years old. Fab!
theno1singstar 3 years ago 2
beautiful woman, beautiful voice but not up to Kiri Kanawas standard.
leontud 3 years ago
EMI tries to make Kate Royal such a Diva, but they are failing a bit?
She has everything except very distinctive operatic voice....
Good for lied tough....
kukku1980 3 years ago 8