TERRIFIC! I'm learning this tune now, and there are different published editions with slight variations. Mrs. McTier's version is consistent with the version I'm learning to play -- and she emphasizes the sentiment and the story within the tune without becoming sentimental! Way to go Mrs. McTier -- this is great! THANK YOU!
Thank you sooo much for posting this!! My piano teacher told me to create a story for this song to get me more emotionally into the song, but I'm not very good at story-telling. May I use the story and embellish it a little to give to my teacher? :)
Nicely played and loved the explanation - hope I can still play that well at that age - haven't got too long to wait LOL - arthritis is a problem. My Mum learnt the Melba method from a pupil of Dame Nellie Melba. She's 87 and while frail still has a good voice. I actually thought the sound quality was OK possibly the piano needs a tune but congratulations anyway. Piano is one of the hardest instruments to record. Have been listening to all the versions on UTUBE of this lovely piece.
@iheartgossipgurl do you play piano? or "genuine7160" either? do you play this song? it is _extremely_ hard to get the voicing perfect and for an 84 year old lady, I think it's pretty good. also the mistakes are few and barely noticeable. didn't your mom ever tell you not to say anything at all if you didn't have anything nice to say?
TERRIFIC! I'm learning this tune now, and there are different published editions with slight variations. Mrs. McTier's version is consistent with the version I'm learning to play -- and she emphasizes the sentiment and the story within the tune without becoming sentimental! Way to go Mrs. McTier -- this is great! THANK YOU!
DavesXXXXXXXX 1 year ago
Thank you sooo much for posting this!! My piano teacher told me to create a story for this song to get me more emotionally into the song, but I'm not very good at story-telling. May I use the story and embellish it a little to give to my teacher? :)
rabbitsrockalot523 1 year ago
Nicely played and loved the explanation - hope I can still play that well at that age - haven't got too long to wait LOL - arthritis is a problem. My Mum learnt the Melba method from a pupil of Dame Nellie Melba. She's 87 and while frail still has a good voice. I actually thought the sound quality was OK possibly the piano needs a tune but congratulations anyway. Piano is one of the hardest instruments to record. Have been listening to all the versions on UTUBE of this lovely piece.
denis4510 1 year ago
very beautiful. Thank you.
KatanMusic 1 year ago
Comment removed
KatanMusic 1 year ago
she is 84 years old lady
have mercy on her
kahil88 2 years ago
Very Nice *****
ibuildfences 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
a lot of mistakes and bad voicing for a piano teacher...
iheartgossipgurl 3 years ago
Comment removed
genuine7160 2 years ago
There really weren't any mistakes. If you look through the music and play the piece, you'll see that she actually played this quite well.
The sound quality on this movie was pretty decent, too.
nanshee7 2 years ago
he is is 84 years old lady
kahil88 2 years ago
@iheartgossipgurl do you play piano? or "genuine7160" either? do you play this song? it is _extremely_ hard to get the voicing perfect and for an 84 year old lady, I think it's pretty good. also the mistakes are few and barely noticeable. didn't your mom ever tell you not to say anything at all if you didn't have anything nice to say?
rabbitsrockalot523 1 year ago
Wonderful! I am currently working on this song, and I really like the way you explain the emotion and character of this song.
pianogirl1212 3 years ago 4