@Hausisse yes. Of course Sarah was the original, and a pretty darn good Christine, but I like my Christine's to be a little more operatic. Sandra Joseph is my all time favorite Christine. Followed by Julie Hanson.
@angstypunk Ah, actually SB is one of my least favorites, but hey, to each his own. xD I just love opera opera so much, I really do prefer my Christines sounding like real opera singers, hahaha. :)
Beautiful rendition, I like the ending cadenza here more than the one on the OLC. She also looks exquisite in this clip, I love how her hair was done.
Hahaha, al comparar y juzgar no se disfruta lo que realmente se requiere, esta obra es bellisima, y Sarah es la pieza que encaja perfectamente en este exitante papel. Asi es que la preferire mil veces a ella pero siempre disfruto la voz de otros sin comparar. para que?, no tiene caso...no es el objetivo
Sarah Brightman, great as usual she has the most beautiful vioice ever heard, even when other singers have more powerful and stronger voices they are not able to make me feel goose bumps. She is simply the best.
rebecca is an opera singer while Sarah is a soprano not an opera singer, and please EnzFab73 as you said (since you adore caine´s christine a lot of people love sarah´s) quoting you : (Sarah Brightman who is a POP-era diva at best, is not fair to Brightman since Caine is vocally far superior. ) what the heck is your problem?
I do not have a problem. I was merely stating my opinion which is allowed I presume. I was stressing my opinion on 2 very different voices and agreeing with the poster who stated Caine was better.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Technically speaking YES Rebecca Caine is vocally superior, Just ask any classically trained singer, opera singer & they will lay it out for you. You can like Brightmans voice better as millions do since there is no accounting for taste but technically Brightman is not even in the same league as Rebecca Caine who is a classically trained opera singer & has sung in opera stages across the globe & has played parts Brightman can't even attempt at portraying.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
i understand but being able to sing (for example) the high e in full chest but sound like ur shitting a brick makes her voice sound bad....so if it is a matter of science rebecca is but a matter of sound Sarah has to be...and it isnt as if Sarah isnt trained...more popular and has better control
Yeah, I guess I should know better than to come to a Brightman video & say such words considering there are probably a gazillion of her fans waiting in the wings. However, since I adore Caine's Christine whenever I see a comment about her I have to post to either agree or to rebuttal. I guess you can say I am as passionate about Caine's Christine as you are with Brightman's. Cheers.
I think she really does sound like Emmy Rossum, especially in Think of Me and The Phantom of the Opera.
There is a comparison, because there is no real "mark" in music.
People may think Caine is superior, Brightman is superior, or even Rossum. But there's no real saying to another person with another preference "mine is vocally superior".
I did state "tastes differ" & "is subjective". IMO however, I fail to see how a full blown operatic Lyric soprano like Rebecca Caine who's voice is huge, with rich, dark tones & has played the lead to much acclaim in countless operas can sound even remotely like a 16 year old with a light though pretty but still not fully trained soprano. Brightman having the same light overtones is a better comparison IMO & I will never state another persons opinion's not valid I'm just stating mine.
You were saying it in a very commanding manner, such that it makes Sarah appear very, very inferior to Rebecca, when in reality many people don't feel that way.
It's not FACT that Rebecca is "vocally better" than Sarah; It's opinion. Which is why I've always put "in my opinion", "I think" and similar in my posts on this video.
And really, there's no explaining some things. I just FEEL that Rebecca SOUNDS like Emmy, in her tone and expressions.
Honestly, Sarah fits the part much better, than Rebecca(in my opinion, lol) because she doesn't have the classically trained opera voice. In fact, she has the most unique voice I have ever heard, this is why the Phantom chooses her. Because it is like no other voice he has heard. And, agai in my opinion, this is why there has yet to be a Christine that lives up to Sarah, because all of the other singers are a dime a dozen, no one, not even Emmy has been able to capture this.
I disagree again. I think Rebecca, although superior in acting skills, her voice just simply doesn't have that special tone for me. She sounds like a trained Emmy Rossum, in my opinion. Sarah, however, has this very unique tone in her voice that makes her my absolute favourite.
Outstanding, she is amazing. I've ever known somebody like her. She is beautiful and talented I really love her. This is the best performance of this song.
good
redberry0 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Still the best!
Dlightaz 1 year ago
Still the best!
Dlightaz 1 year ago 2
...Am I the only one whose favorite Christine isn't Sarah Brightman or Emmy Rossum? Haha.
Hausisse 1 year ago
@Hausisse Who's your favourite Christine? Mine is Rachel Barrell, but Sarah + Emmy are amazing!
SkittlesSarahxx 1 year ago
@SkittlesSarahxx Sarah for me!! Amazing voice!!!
ThePokegaga 1 year ago 3
@Hausisse yes. Of course Sarah was the original, and a pretty darn good Christine, but I like my Christine's to be a little more operatic. Sandra Joseph is my all time favorite Christine. Followed by Julie Hanson.
angstypunk 1 year ago
@angstypunk Ah, actually SB is one of my least favorites, but hey, to each his own. xD I just love opera opera so much, I really do prefer my Christines sounding like real opera singers, hahaha. :)
Hausisse 1 year ago
She Is An Amazing Amazing Live Singer!!!
jamarmtz 1 year ago 5
LOOOVVVEEE that cadenza!!! xxxx
christinedaae87 1 year ago 4
preciosoo!! :)
emiliofenix05 2 years ago
Theres no one that can sing the songs of the phantom of the opera better than sarah =)
atipacti 2 years ago 8
@atipacti True that!!!!!!!
ThePokegaga 1 year ago
Most popular, biggest record sales of any soprano in music history: Divine Sarah Brightman, The Angel of Music.
shiankiang 2 years ago 9
Time from 2:02 till 2:10
She brease out singing Uuuuuuuuu.
Do not know how you call it in vocals, but definately She has very GOOD lungs.
She may be a good freediver too :)))
deepswim 2 years ago 8
Yes theres my childhood hero ppl might think im a dork since my heroes an opera singer but hell shes perfect wait no better.
There are no words for this.
alluvermin 2 years ago 12
Beautiful rendition, I like the ending cadenza here more than the one on the OLC. She also looks exquisite in this clip, I love how her hair was done.
EponineGraydeChagny 2 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I do LOVE Rebecca Caine's voice, but Sarah's voice is so weird that it's extremely beautiful. It's definitely a tie right now.
lilrowyravenclaw 2 years ago
Hahaha, al comparar y juzgar no se disfruta lo que realmente se requiere, esta obra es bellisima, y Sarah es la pieza que encaja perfectamente en este exitante papel. Asi es que la preferire mil veces a ella pero siempre disfruto la voz de otros sin comparar. para que?, no tiene caso...no es el objetivo
Te Amo sarah!!! XD
7AlbertoPlancarte 2 years ago 8
a beautiful song
sarahbrightmanteamo 2 years ago 4
Sarah Brightman, great as usual she has the most beautiful vioice ever heard, even when other singers have more powerful and stronger voices they are not able to make me feel goose bumps. She is simply the best.
schweretraume 2 years ago 8
Les guste o no esta es la mejor version, grande Sarah.-
OyolaLuisAlberto 2 years ago
rebecca is an opera singer while Sarah is a soprano not an opera singer, and please EnzFab73 as you said (since you adore caine´s christine a lot of people love sarah´s) quoting you : (Sarah Brightman who is a POP-era diva at best, is not fair to Brightman since Caine is vocally far superior. ) what the heck is your problem?
sainto24 2 years ago
I do not have a problem. I was merely stating my opinion which is allowed I presume. I was stressing my opinion on 2 very different voices and agreeing with the poster who stated Caine was better.
EnzFab73 2 years ago
caine is not vocally superior.....
hunt44 2 years ago 10
I agree, Sarah's voice is much better
Davidzz17 2 years ago 17
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Technically speaking YES Rebecca Caine is vocally superior, Just ask any classically trained singer, opera singer & they will lay it out for you. You can like Brightmans voice better as millions do since there is no accounting for taste but technically Brightman is not even in the same league as Rebecca Caine who is a classically trained opera singer & has sung in opera stages across the globe & has played parts Brightman can't even attempt at portraying.
tabugirl 2 years ago
Comment removed
tabugirl 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i understand but being able to sing (for example) the high e in full chest but sound like ur shitting a brick makes her voice sound bad....so if it is a matter of science rebecca is but a matter of sound Sarah has to be...and it isnt as if Sarah isnt trained...more popular and has better control
hunt44 2 years ago
@tabugirl THANK you. :p
Hausisse 1 year ago
I have not blamed you for comparing. It's just that you said it in a
"You're free to think which brand of chocolate is better, but a FACT is that MY brand of chocolate is superior in making chocolates".
See where I stand now? I get why people can think Rebecca is superior, and I hope you can see why people can think Sarah is superior.
I do love Rebecca's Christine by the way, she does a great job, but I just prefer Brightman.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago 2
Yeah, I guess I should know better than to come to a Brightman video & say such words considering there are probably a gazillion of her fans waiting in the wings. However, since I adore Caine's Christine whenever I see a comment about her I have to post to either agree or to rebuttal. I guess you can say I am as passionate about Caine's Christine as you are with Brightman's. Cheers.
EnzFab73 2 years ago
Yeah, it's the same with Brightman comments for me :]
Cheers.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago 2
I have stated "in my opinion".
I think she really does sound like Emmy Rossum, especially in Think of Me and The Phantom of the Opera.
There is a comparison, because there is no real "mark" in music.
People may think Caine is superior, Brightman is superior, or even Rossum. But there's no real saying to another person with another preference "mine is vocally superior".
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago
I did state "tastes differ" & "is subjective". IMO however, I fail to see how a full blown operatic Lyric soprano like Rebecca Caine who's voice is huge, with rich, dark tones & has played the lead to much acclaim in countless operas can sound even remotely like a 16 year old with a light though pretty but still not fully trained soprano. Brightman having the same light overtones is a better comparison IMO & I will never state another persons opinion's not valid I'm just stating mine.
EnzFab73 2 years ago
Sarah was 22.
You were saying it in a very commanding manner, such that it makes Sarah appear very, very inferior to Rebecca, when in reality many people don't feel that way.
It's not FACT that Rebecca is "vocally better" than Sarah; It's opinion. Which is why I've always put "in my opinion", "I think" and similar in my posts on this video.
And really, there's no explaining some things. I just FEEL that Rebecca SOUNDS like Emmy, in her tone and expressions.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago 2
Honestly, Sarah fits the part much better, than Rebecca(in my opinion, lol) because she doesn't have the classically trained opera voice. In fact, she has the most unique voice I have ever heard, this is why the Phantom chooses her. Because it is like no other voice he has heard. And, agai in my opinion, this is why there has yet to be a Christine that lives up to Sarah, because all of the other singers are a dime a dozen, no one, not even Emmy has been able to capture this.
zram2008 2 years ago 14
and, the whole entire Phantom of The Opera was written for her lol. ohhh i adore sarah...
ladyrose837 2 years ago 34
This comment has received too many negative votes show
100% agreed. You've got it spot-on.
navinkc5 2 years ago
Rebecca is good, but is not as refined as Sarah. Sarah is the Goddess!!!
HollyNihon 2 years ago 4
I just looked Caine up, she does have a beautiful voice, but ah, to each his own :).
I'm just in love with SarahB :)...
navinkc5 2 years ago 5
I disagree again. I think Rebecca, although superior in acting skills, her voice just simply doesn't have that special tone for me. She sounds like a trained Emmy Rossum, in my opinion. Sarah, however, has this very unique tone in her voice that makes her my absolute favourite.
CoolMapleStore 2 years ago 6
I agree!
Despite the fact that Caine does have a beautiful voice, but you're right in saying Sarah's has something unique :).
navinkc5 2 years ago 3
Outstanding, she is amazing. I've ever known somebody like her. She is beautiful and talented I really love her. This is the best performance of this song.
schweretraume 2 years ago 3
THE BALLET ICE SKATER ARMS ARE AWESOME
Babs22h 2 years ago 5
I absolutely love her ending over Emmy Rossum's!!!
kimahulimage 3 years ago 12
yea, Emma really doesnt even compare. she wasnt really singing opera..
KingdomHearts500 2 years ago
I love you so much Sarah!
SMiJadeB 3 years ago 9
She's the only one who can do these amazing songs justice.
navinkc5 3 years ago 13
Magnificent! Divine Sarah in full voice.
hawgwallah 3 years ago 13
I agree, but she is still in full voice!
muscle25ftl 3 years ago 10
beautiful rendition
Juancsc 3 years ago 12
Elegance, style, grace, beauty, class. Bel Canto.
shiankiang 3 years ago 30
sUPERB.
Quibre 3 years ago 12
I loved!Very good Sarah, I very like you!
carlinhosedu 3 years ago 10
well darn! she proved to all the doubters she can cadenza!
RaWrZzZz 3 years ago 17
Sarah Brightman is fantastic! She is perfection
gygggyhhh 3 years ago 16
gracias por este video
MagdalenoGuzmanGames 3 years ago 8
great!
Tarathiel1983 3 years ago 6