People have not generally had good luck with song on Idol. Carmen Raspusen, Mikaylah Gordon, and Karen all three sang it and were all voted off the week they sang it. Karen had the best version of this song.
If only the title wasn't "Idol" then Fox wouldn't have to allow the audience, which is comprised mostly of morons to vote. It's better if the judges did it on their own. Over the years people have always gotten screwed and this year, if idiots like Stefano Langone, Jacob Lusk or Thia Megia even made it close to the Top 3, I probably would've shot myself in the mouth. There's so many people this season Karen Rodriguezshould've outlasted.
@Mr1131988 if audience wasnt alowed to vote they wouldnt make much money would they, and thia didnt come close to the top three. Karen was a really good singer and she should have listened but people like different things and she obviously didnt have as much fans as the others.
@dickinson509 Uhm they still would make a shit load of money coz it will still be the highest rated show on earth. It's very simplistic. Any idiot can understand the concept. And I only said IF Thia, Stefano or Jacob made it to the top 3 which isn't the case now of course. All I'm saying is fan votes are too risky if you claim to be looking for a superstar coz most of the time it never worked. Did anyone really think Kris Allen or Lee DeWyze could sell records or win Grammys? Please!
@Mr1131988 Yeah but they make more money from the votes as well karen wouldnt win anyway even though she was good but most of the others were better than her apart from stefano and lauren
@dickinson509 Well I was rooting for James Durbin so I don't really have to argue for Karen Rodriguez other than I feel like she could've done more than some of the others. Maybe they should do a 50-50 thing with judges and America votes like 'Dancing with the Stars'. That way, there won't ever be another Kris Allen or Lee Dewyze and rare talents like Adam Lambert and Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been screwed. Oh well...
@Mr1131988 I was rooting for hayley or james but their both gone now :(. But i know what you mean karen didnt deserve to go as early as she did. in my opinion first three who should have gone, stefano, lauren and naiama
@dickinson509 Yeah what a fucking bummer! James and Hayley, two straight disappointing weeks! I couldn't care less for the finale now. I respect SCotty's originality and identity but he's nothing great at least to me.
People have to realize that American Idol's not really about talent anymore. Sure the talent plays a part but mostly, its a popularity contest sad to say. Not saying she should have won, since there are better singers there, but she could have gone longer there. But because she's not TOO appealing to the public. She got the least number of votes and was let go. *shrugs*
love it....
jefian08 3 days ago
People have not generally had good luck with song on Idol. Carmen Raspusen, Mikaylah Gordon, and Karen all three sang it and were all voted off the week they sang it. Karen had the best version of this song.
schtheguitarman 2 months ago
she has an AMAZING voice. she should've made it farther..
allisonraee 7 months ago
OMG!!!
bucamarie 9 months ago
If only the title wasn't "Idol" then Fox wouldn't have to allow the audience, which is comprised mostly of morons to vote. It's better if the judges did it on their own. Over the years people have always gotten screwed and this year, if idiots like Stefano Langone, Jacob Lusk or Thia Megia even made it close to the Top 3, I probably would've shot myself in the mouth. There's so many people this season Karen Rodriguezshould've outlasted.
Mr1131988 10 months ago
@Mr1131988 if audience wasnt alowed to vote they wouldnt make much money would they, and thia didnt come close to the top three. Karen was a really good singer and she should have listened but people like different things and she obviously didnt have as much fans as the others.
dickinson509 9 months ago
@dickinson509 Uhm they still would make a shit load of money coz it will still be the highest rated show on earth. It's very simplistic. Any idiot can understand the concept. And I only said IF Thia, Stefano or Jacob made it to the top 3 which isn't the case now of course. All I'm saying is fan votes are too risky if you claim to be looking for a superstar coz most of the time it never worked. Did anyone really think Kris Allen or Lee DeWyze could sell records or win Grammys? Please!
Mr1131988 9 months ago
@Mr1131988 Yeah but they make more money from the votes as well karen wouldnt win anyway even though she was good but most of the others were better than her apart from stefano and lauren
dickinson509 9 months ago
@dickinson509 Well I was rooting for James Durbin so I don't really have to argue for Karen Rodriguez other than I feel like she could've done more than some of the others. Maybe they should do a 50-50 thing with judges and America votes like 'Dancing with the Stars'. That way, there won't ever be another Kris Allen or Lee Dewyze and rare talents like Adam Lambert and Chris Daughtry wouldn't have been screwed. Oh well...
Mr1131988 9 months ago
@Mr1131988 I was rooting for hayley or james but their both gone now :(. But i know what you mean karen didnt deserve to go as early as she did. in my opinion first three who should have gone, stefano, lauren and naiama
dickinson509 9 months ago
@dickinson509 Yeah what a fucking bummer! James and Hayley, two straight disappointing weeks! I couldn't care less for the finale now. I respect SCotty's originality and identity but he's nothing great at least to me.
Mr1131988 9 months ago
I can't believe Karen has been eliminated, one of the best voices in the competition
j060387 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i MIss you Karen..!
audition again..!
love you....
hashimjalal 11 months ago
i MIss you Karen..!
audition again..!
hashimjalal 11 months ago
ARGH!!! >:I I can't believe she left so early!!! Her voice is amazing and I got chills every time she sang on AI
LesiAhWong 11 months ago
No not really have you not noticed that American idol has alot to do with ur looks!!!:)
Wildthing308 11 months ago
American Idol Needs a Latino to WIN!
raulfreed 11 months ago
People have to realize that American Idol's not really about talent anymore. Sure the talent plays a part but mostly, its a popularity contest sad to say. Not saying she should have won, since there are better singers there, but she could have gone longer there. But because she's not TOO appealing to the public. She got the least number of votes and was let go. *shrugs*
manzter127 11 months ago
She deserved to win! : (
pianozippy77 11 months ago
I cant believe she was voted off...but i still think she has a future...keep the faith...keep pushing for her peoples!!!!
shanoelani 11 months ago
i luv her singing...... n espically the spanish part
manny19971 11 months ago
Wow..amazing..brought me chills!
kathleen416 11 months ago
She was the business. I really wanted her to win and see a latino up there but AMerica's so eurocentric that i'm not surprised she's gone.
ashleyen3 11 months ago 6
missssssssssssssssss herrrrrrrrrrr
OhStangvideo 11 months ago 10
In my opinion this is the best recording from this week
ghettojut 11 months ago 14
i luv her singing
manny19971 11 months ago 3
She got out.
YabutMark 11 months ago
KAREN!!! I love this girl!! I really hope she makes top 5 if not better!
mrmarxx 11 months ago 2
She can be the first Latina American Idol!!!! SUPPORT mis latinos
raulfreed 11 months ago 7