Added: 2 years ago
From: rcitoses
Views: 193,624
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (339)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • shut up and listen to this song.. those 'plagiarism' issues are coming from the extremist SNSD antis...where ever they are...

  • DOESN'T EVEN SOUND THE SAME AS SNSD _

  • To. snsd's fans in the world. I'm Japanese sone. I apologize to you instead of Japanese anties. They are crazy. TIMBALAND's FANTASY and PINK MOSOON use the same voice effect. is PINK MONSOON a copy song too?全然違う曲じゃないですか?少女時代のthe boysは世界3大作曲家「テディライリー」が作った曲で、パク­リとは全く関係ありません。あと、洋楽でこんな感じの曲­はたく­さ­んありますw 例をあげれば、TIMBALANDのFANTASY!マクロスの­pink monsoonがパクリですね?きちがいネトウヨ完敗w

  • Iymt is totally different from the boys -_-

  • Now, I wouldn't say that I'm bias to either side, but if you try, you can sing either song on top of the other perfectly. So simillar chord progressions and a simillar beat. Either way however, I don't think there is a need for such a huge argument over this. Especially in the aggressive manner it's coming out right now.

  • WOI think! if u guys think the rythims or the beat is the same, then u called it plagiarism, then i think there are ALOT MORE SONGS should be called plagiarism.

    and oh,

    im a Japanese fans too.

    no offense guys

  • Its totally different guys, check it out closely! dont u guys have ears?? better than comparing this, u guys should have a better things to do rather than mocking snsd or sheryl nome. leave em for peace

  • I don't get how Pink Monsoon and The Boys suddenly got compared. I mean, Pink Monsoon has been out since 2 YEARS AGO. I agree that The Boys sound better but Pink Monsoon has been out since the previous 2 YEARS so there's a possibility that SNSD copied and made it sound better.

  • @chisuruMiki finally! someone who finally understand me

  • pink monsoon is nothing compared to the boys...

  • People please stop saying, "THIS" sounds like the boys. Instead say, the boys sounds like, "THIS." Pink Monsoon is a whole two years older than the boys.

  • the resemblance is just....... 34% i thought ._.

  • これは完全にアウトだね!完全に音符が合ってる

    それも最後まで

    

  • SNSD IS PLAGIAT!!!!!!!!!!

  • @vichoiminho no! SM ent. yang beriklan lagu.. snsd cuma tinggal nyanyiin, kalo gitu apa gunanya ada sm ent. ?

  • lol People are still comparing this to The Boys?

    like srsly...

    They sound almost nothing alike... maybe the pacing... but w/e. lol

  • very different from the song snsd the boys..

  • don't know why people said that it is similar to the boys..it is very different ..

  • snsd the boys is better than this !

  • @VinzSNSDLover98 to you only

  • @vinsvalentin O !

  • I'm a girl and EVEN I think Sheryl Nome Has Sexy in the palm of her hand.

  • it really diffrent wtih snsd the boys song,buth both are nice,

  • this is better than snsd song the boys for sure!

  • It may be full of engrish, It may be cheesy as hell - but damn listening to this song over and over has somehow lifted my spirits haha

  • totally different, but both are cool song, i think

  • sounds a little bit but i preffer thece song

  • In my opinion they sound similar but, i don't think SNSD plagiarized it.

  • it is true in my opinion, they are alike

  • it's different the boys

  • really very different from soshi's song but this song sounds good too!

  • i really hope it's not sones where all those dislikes came from. if so, i'm disappointed :/ this song rocks guys~! and so does the boys :D (yes im a sone)

  • different

  • Comment removed

  • this is a good song ♥

  • people who told snsd copy cat this song is jealous of snsd !

  • OH MAN,THIS IS NOT SAME !!!

    SM not stupid,they will not use "The Boys" as debut Soshi in US,if "The Boys" is plagiarism

    Oh mannn...come on,are you hate soshi so much ?

  • only electric sound is similar....

    others seem to be different

    waowaowaowaowao~~~

    hope someone can cut the position which are the same, if u find that

  • there IS a similarity, but i wouldn't say it's plagiarism. anyways - is this a reason to thumb down this song?

    i came here from the boys, but honestly i think this one is better lol

  • damn haters. Wasting 4mins of my life. (no offense to this song tho)

  • it's very different with snsd song

  • No doubt there is little similarity of the song beats between Pink Monsoon & The Boys, the difference is there is rapping and more energetic in the The Boys song which Pink Monsoon don't. I've listened to both songs concurrent before writing my opinion. No offence to the fans. Relax and enjoy both songs which that is what they are paid for, to entertain us.

  • @uhoomi

    The opening beats are very similar, not the entire song.

  • I suppose it sorta sounds like they're similar at the start, but when the chorus kicked in it's totally different. Well to me. Anyhoo, music is always influenced by maintreams and songs from different regions and countries, esp when they use similar chords. So as long it's not a complete 100% copy, I'm fine with it

  • those silly claims!!!

  • Its not simillar to snsd new song the boys but both song are nice

  • SO COOL <3<3<3

  • there's no such thing as bad publicity. Agree if you come here after reading the accusation that SNSD has plagiarised this song

  • wonder why theres so many snsd fans in here.

    oh sorry its everywhere.

    anyway dont thumbs down the song if its becos of the incident and not becos the music suck.

  • Is dissimilar

  • seriously-.- to those who said it sound the same!

  • Lol What the hell, the two songs don't even sound alike AT ALL. At least when people were comparing SNSD's "Be Happy" and Lady Gaga's "Born This Way", I could actually hear similar beats and rhythms. But this is just so stupid. ._____. Haters need to spend their time on something else. /facepalm/

  • @illusionmagician

    You tone deaf too?

  • @darkmax1974

    So I re-listened to this and THE ONLY "similarity" I found was the first 10 seconds. .___. If people are really gonna use that and call it "plagiarism" then I have no comment. Many songs have similar beats so I guess they must all be copied from one another then.

  • HAHAHAHA.. you guys better check the tablatures of both songs.. shizz, idiots..

  • The beats of both songs sound so different. So what if some parts of the tune is similar? I'm pretty sure many songs out there sound more similar than this...

    If the melody of every single song that we listen to is original, there won't be many songs around isn't it?

  • i'm not a fan of snsd. but i have this say The Boys doesnt really sound like Pink Monsoon. if i were to listen to this song on my own i wouldnt have linked it to The Boys at all. beats and rythms like these are very common in pop music. take Britney's music for example.

  • Though I am not a fan of snsd or ted ridley the composer of the song 'the boys', I have to say the only thing I can find similar of this song to the boys is the 'pauses' at certain parts. But other than that I don't find it same in any other way?

  • it doesn't sound similar in the tempo.

    By the way, grab hold of Ted Ridley, the song composer, and question him, had he heard this song before somewhere?

  • haters gonna hate

    

  • Come on guys. Do you think almost the same is close to PLAGIATISM? We just have do re mi fa sol la si do . It may the accident.

  • both this and the boys are good, i hear no similarity damn haters

  • I've listen to this song for ages, even before the boys came out, and it's nowhere near -.- And what about the beat? If that's how you define plagiarism, then all the songs with the same bpm should have been labeled plagiarizing too.

  • It's similar. You guys need to hear the beat, not the singing.

  • GO MACROSS FRONTIER!

  • I don't think they are even similar. They are both wonderful songs! <3

  • Why must all you anti-japan people post so much negative things? Cant you all just keep your negative opinions to yourself? I LOVE SNSD AND MAY'N.

    And if you think Japanese people cant speak english, listen to Rie Fu!

    And if you all hate Japan so much, THEN I HATE KOREA! AND I CANT BELIEVE YOU ALL MADE ME SAY THAT COS I LOVE SNSD!

  • @IzuruKiraLuver I really understand you. No need to say you hate Korea (though I was feeling that at one point cuz of some stupid KPOP fans) because you'll only stoop to their level.

  • @IzuruKiraLuver im completely with you on this issue, think these fans need to open there ears a bit, and start recognizing that a LOT of songs are very very similar, take a look at ed sheeran you need me i dont need you video and then listen to train soul sister, you will notice similarities in the tone. and its the same in this case so open your ears and listen to the tone not the vocals.

  • listen from about 2.55 min into Pink Monsoon then from about 1.37 of the SNSD song, and tell me that its not similar.

  • what part of the song is Plagiarized??LOL

  • @gymikk If you insist that both songs are the same in terms of atmosphere, then ask yourself a question : are techno songs/songs for clubbing all the same? Because apparently, according to you, they have the same ATMOSPHERE

  • Even my dog is a better listener than the Japanese.. well OBVIOUSLY.. Listen to me you anti fans, go watch your JaPorNese okay..? Oh crap , you JaPorNese don't understand English... Maybe " Ah aH ahh. Ah.. " is the only English word you JaPorNese knew. ReTarDs

  • @itsuki689 FUCK YOU. SOME PARTS ACTUALLY SOUND THE SAME. SO STFU.

    BAKA! AND HELL IM A FAN OF SNSD TOO! AND I LOVE MAY'N! SO STFU! YOU DONT HAVE TO SAY NEGATIVE THINGS RIGHT?!?! WHAT SHIT 'JAPORNESE' YOU TALKING ABOUT?!!?

    OI, THEY ARE JAPANESE! THEY WERE MEANT TO SPEAK JAPANESE! NOT ENGLISH KAY? BAKA!

  • OMG!! This? lyk SNSD's "The Boys"??? Some people just need to invest on more Q Tips!!!!

  • if you're listening it very well there's some parts that lil bit same as the boys.. I don't know.. not all.. just a few.. try hard to look for that part by yourself..

  • WOW, u call this the same?? Are japanese tone-deaf, rhythm-deaf, pitch-deaf, beat-deaf?? If this is the same as 'the boy' den its a same as saying good bye means the same thing as hello.

  • Japanese and Koreans hating on each other over some shit that a few

    no life trolls said and its not even true. Just STFU and listen to the song!..

  • Okay, we get it, the two songs sound nothing alike! Whoever said so were some trolls. So can everyone PLEASE stop commenting about SNSD on a video that's not even related to them and bringing hate to Japan and May'n? Thanks...

  • @mikee1125 hi japanese anti^^ I think you are a deaf..

    always blah blah~~~it's all Greek

  • Comment removed

  • WOW guys really?! It doesn't even sound the same!!! the beats are the not same rhythm and the melodies are no where the same. The Boys is THE BOYS and Pink Monsoon is PINK MONSOON. They're TWO DIFFERENT SONGS OKAY? Just chill. -.-

  • @xMichieChan

    Are you tone deaf?... Wait! If you're SNSD's fan, then you probably are.

  • @darkmax1974 LOL. I am not tone deaf. You don't know me anyways. EVEN IF I WAS TONE DEAF, At least I would know what TALENT sounds like. People like you are indenial.

  • @xMichieChan

    Yes I'm "indenial", if there's such a word, it'll probably mean NOT denying. Frankly, SNSD has not produce a single song that they can sing without that much synthesizing.

    And I've personally saw them live (as a part of a show). They are just a bunch of artificially enhanced dolls with mediocre voices.

    May'N here on the other hand has great vocals and performs live with her own voice, not lip-synching.

  • @darkmax1974 I was going to argue. But I have nothing that I can or anyone can say to change your opinion. Your opinion is your opinion, weather I feel it's completely worng or not .

    And I'll just enjoy this song and let it slide. But please. Everyone stop bringing up SNSD on other videos. This sounds nothing like the boys except they are in similar genres. If you want to talk about SNSD go to SNSD videos, if you want to talk about May'n stay here and don't bring up others.

  • @lero99rose that's called copy right infrigment

    confirm by law !

  • Teddy Riley copied this?? LOL, japanese are so funny

  • @KwonRyn so what? The Boy wasn't that great to begin with. Japanese this, Japanese that. Bigot!

  • come on man! this is pretty different from snsd unnie's the boys =_="

  • rada miriplah..

  • SNSD THE BOY is way better

  • @dautay1996 O_O"..... u so full of it lol

  • sorry but that other song doesn't even come close to this awesomeness.....I love Pink Monsoon

  • SONES can be so tiring but oh well, nice to see the likes increasing. This is free publicity for the song although, Macross Fontier doesn't need it

  • @vinsvalentin SIGH I know & agree... they feel free to attack every other artists out there but dont think that no one else should attack at snsd .... fools.

  • It sounds like a music in a pub/bar :) HAHAH

    And it has a sexual feeling, way too different from SNSD - The boys!

    SNSD!<3

  • why is people thumbing down the song tho?

  • Comment removed

  • @apisky001 yeah lol 'cept they don't sound alike. thats like saying the boys copied this song when they're not even similar at all

  • @zesshi sorry.... but I'm upset because of japanese anties...

    I can't understand why they insult snsd..TT

  • @zesshi they ARE similar, just not exactly the same. It's not plagerized though.. just the beats sound similar.

  • @fjgh9996 a troll calling out another troll. cool.

  • well... i don't give a damn about the issue both songs are good....

  • thanks for introducing me to another song. this sounds pretty good but nothing like the boys

  • omg XD n'importe quoi. bon le beat ressemble vite fait mais qu'est-ce que teddy riley irait chercher ça oO il doit meme pas connaitre

  • 62 itu pastinya fan SNSD 

  • and cant believe ppl are using racist slurs and some are just being a plain racist. newsflash: some dumbfuck trolls from 2ch ≠ all japanese ppl.

  • lol this sounds nothing like the boys. source is from 2ch who started this. and no one gives a fuck about anything regarding 2ch. seems like the korean media just picked this "news" to make it seem like a big thing and the ultimate result is to give snsd more exposure. how smart of them.

  • Came here because of SNSD but this song sounds nice :33!

  • are you fucking kidding with me? whats wrong with these people? omg

    this have NOTHING to do with snsd's song O.O

  • Hey this are good songs! Very unique and different though. Lol at the Jap netizens. More publicity for our 9 girls is always welcome.

  • i don't think teddy riley even cares about japanese music -.-'

  • im here because snsd issue ?? i think i had been fool ~~ there's no part that same in snsd song???!!! anyways i think this a good song too kekek

  • Pls, take the SNSD argument out of here. This is anime for pete's sake

  • @vinsvalentin then stop comparing the song, please!