she tries to sing in french?? why do you complain about that? can you sing better than her? i BET you CAN'T! and she can sing in english, spanish and french and whatever she wants!
all frenceh hater why dont you upload a vid of you singing the song... i dont know the lyrics but she did a great job.....of course half of you wont be able to understad a thing i wote.
@ultrabaron Va chanter anglais toi. Essaie sans accent qu'on rigole. Casse toi , viens pas niquer la vidéo tu vois. Les gens comme toi, ils servent a rien. Stoi la pute, va dormir. Beyonce a très bien chanté cette chanson, si t'as un truc a dire, trouve des arguments. tchiiiiiiiiiiip.
Je ne sais pas combien de fois j'ai regardé cette vidéo aujourd'hui, mais à chaque fois je ris aux éclats !! :D C'est vraiment... Etrange ! On a tellement l'habitude de la voir tout maîtriser à la limite de la perfection que le moindre échec semble être inenvisageable ! Moi ça me fait juste rire je ne la critique pas c'est une très grande artiste, mais avec un tel talent et une telle célébrité, elle aurait mieux fait d'éviter de chanter cette chanson... :D
Moi je dis seulement RESPECT. Avant de critiquer une personne essayer de savoir si vous même vous auriez pu faire la même chose à sa place. Vous n'êtes jamais content de rien, il faut toujours vous plaindre. IL ne faut pas oublié que la plus part des chansons françaises ne sont pas celle que l'on écoute souvent, alors quand une star mondiale fait l'effort d’interpréter un titre, vous préférez la critiquer que de l’applaudir. c'est quoi???? De la jalousie, de ne pas pouvoir en faire autant???
Franchement, pour quelqu'un qui parle pas français elle s'est très bien débrouillée! Elle chante bien, et c'est cool qu'il y ai des reprises comme celle-ci. Normal que l'on comprenne pas certains mots, elle est américaine!! Alors à tous ceux qui disent qu'elle a massacré la chanson, changez de vidéo et arrêtez de dire de la merde parce que je suis sure que vous faites pas mieux... :)
@ultrabaron Et bien , on a pas tous eu la définition du respect.
Mais c'est sûr qu'avant de respecter les autres, il faut se respecter sois-même ce qui demande peut-être de faire preuve de trop d'esprit pour certains...
Pour tout ceux qui disent qu'elle a "ruiné" notre langue. J'trouve que c'est bien ! Elle n'a surement pas sorti un mot en français avant cette chanson donc respect :)
arreter d'etre jaloux elle chante super bien elle chante d'ailleur mieux que certains chanteur francais ...enplus c mm pas sa langue ....ca doit faire mal hein....
lol WHAT? I had no idea she had ever sang this song. she has a nice voice but it sounds funny... when you know french, i mean. I like the original version better :p
arretez de dire qu'elle parle mal francais parce ue vs vous croyez que vous savez parler anglais mais en fait pas du tt votre accent c'est de la merde
au moin elle chante mieu que shakira elle ses rien si on comprend rien mes au moin ses mangnific donc quand ta fill elle va chanter comme sa mes lui des baff!!!!!!!
Wow, Beyonce a vraiment une voix magnifique♥♥.. L'accent anglais, on s'en fout sérieux! C'est comme si on vous disais : vas-y parle en irlandais avec l'accent parfait. Sa ne doit pas être très facile! Moi je dis vive les belles voix comme celle-ci!♥♥
She did her best, and it still sounds poetic ! ( she could have worked more on the prononciation, tought, as this sounds like haitian french, but you must agree, french IS difficult !)
This is horrible, i'm french and i had a hard time understanding 1 word out of 10. Extremely bad idea from Beyonce, sounds like shes speaking Haitian Creole.
..to go in front of the Academy...and the world...in a language far from ur native is amazing and courageous. I can bet 99% of you wouldn't even think about attempting what she did.
@punisher929 sorry im french ( from montreal) and i speak currently french, english, spanish and italian so shut the fuck up and try to say at least on word in french.
I would say that YOU dont want to learn any other language than your own fckn one!!!!
Can it really be that hard to learn how to pronounce the words of one song. It's not as though she had to learn the language. Still this interpretation of the song is well done.
French people tend to forget at they REFUSE to speak another language...... because they think that french is still superior..... I would love to see a french guy/girl singing Halo in english ^^ we can all have a laugh then.
beyonce sang this song great ... yeah she's saying alot of words in the wrong way . But its like scottish and UK english .. it still hase the same meaning doesn't it?
@punisher929 first i want u to know that i'm french and i'm fluent in english i desagree with u when u say french people do not speak any other language of course we're proud of speaking our language and we try our best to spread it around the world i don't know where u're from but i've never met native english speaker that speak another language propperly cause u do think u got the international language so u don't need to bother yourself with other language and to finish her french is awfull
@punisher929 congratulation !!!! the question is not about speaking many other languages it is to do it propperly it's not her case and sorry but i don't believe you when you say such thing i made spanish italian russian and mandarin at school but i don't pretend being fluent in all those laguage i'm just quite good in spanish an italian i'm not lyig to myself
@punisher929 strange i would have said you're lying about dutch knowing that your belgium i've once been there and they were all fluent in french and german! Well that's mean you're fluent in dutch and english then. Anyway you've just pissed me off insulting french people is that because you're belgium??
@punisher929 historical facts ??!! don't get it i said that cause you made fun on french accent in a way while saying that that we're not able to sing halo propperly at least that's what i understood
@punisher929 half French on both sides of my family. Am I an overly-patriotic frog-eater with a snail fetish and a refusal to speak anything that isn't pure Francais? No, my dear idiot, no I am not.
Besides english is easier to learn than french. English is everywhere. French is close to dead. so YAY for beyonce TRYING to do this for you french assfuckers... while she has no reason TO DO SO.
@punisher929 i'm not interested in how many times you can insult me, and I don't recall ever mentioning Beyonce. Besides, as long as there are French people, they're not about to let it go out of fashion...
This had nothing to do with "fashion" your government should learn to accept that French isn't a Global language any longer.
All important buisnesses Cummunicate in english , they use it as a universal language , so everyone understands eachother, and your government tries so hard .. to stop children from comming in contact with the English language at a young age.
Beyonce, you have a great voice, I love you, but pleasepleaseplease. Learn French songs with someone to correct your pronunciation. I think you managed to make some new words, there. ;)
allow me ( french teacher and pronunciation examiner in french language ) : well , we all agree that she cant speak french ( nor sing in french language) but there should ve been a french teacher to fix her pronunciation a bit more coz there are words that are 100 % wrong ! but let me add ( as a choir singer now ! ) she adds some beyonce spirit in it ! and that what makes it special . IN GENERAL , I LIKE ! ( but lets keep it as a 1st time trial , no more ! )
i am french and i agree with you she's awesome. It is hard to speak french but she did a great job. @ichbineinGenie Shlanpe geht zum den achloch beyonce ist die besser
don't criticize her...i mean come on guys..French is not her mothertongue...if someone ask u to sing in German or Chinese although u aren't are u goining to do it better?
@axel1lover im brittish but can talk and sing in most european accents and american the thing is the with most european languages the meanings of words depend on how you say them and i can speak french and that song doesnt make sense because she cant prenounce the words correctly shes basically singing jibberish but with a good voice
To somebody who doesn't speak French, she just sounds like the same amazing Beyonce as usual and that's all that matters. She doesn't have to be perfect or cater to your picky desires.
WHAT THE FUCK GUYS, SHE IS BLACK OK? SO WHAT MAYBE HER FRENCH IS A LITTLE OFF? so what? would you rather hear rebecca black sing this in a perfect french accent or hear beyonce murder it with some faulty french?
I'm french and I know that french it very dificult to learn, so this song(by beyonce) is great, And if we don't listen to the lyrics , her voice is so amazing , i love it !
I admit her French is bad, but most French speakers usually have a way worse English so she gets some credit for trying, BESIDES, Im a Spanish speaker and at least in my native language she has done real good, that gives her another point over you haters. And BESIDES #2: how many of you can sing like that? ...I thought so.
would you guys stop it , i speak french , im in a french school , i speak English better then french , i sang this 5 years ago , she did such an amazing work , even though he french isn't that good
you should never ever copy a song without knowing the language! And this song was wirtten for a choire why did she sing this!? I've got a headache... D:
wtf is this ..-_-...> This song is made for a choir, not for hiphop. And I am gonna leave all the technical details aside, but I find it disrespectful for the composer, the choir and really wrong.
I love beyonce, but it's too overdone, there's a message in this song and I think it scenically not the same way between B and the song! She shouldn't smile like that, it's a serious song! it s true that her French is horrible, other American singers were better in French!
she tries to sing in french?? why do you complain about that? can you sing better than her? i BET you CAN'T! and she can sing in english, spanish and french and whatever she wants!
9daavid 3 days ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm french and even if it's not perfect it's cute and she did it as better as she can :)
jejezara12 3 days ago
hahahhaa sorry but what kind of french is that? hahahahha
ZvezdaKrasnaya 5 days ago
ahahhahahahahahahah elle m'a vraiment fait rire cette Beyonce
santaquier de la nouit lol, gamings dzoublié
saysha3dady 6 days ago
@vanstys There's no doubt that Beyonce has a good voice and can sing, but it doesn't change the fact that she butchered the french words.
jasminie87 6 days ago
Her voice is amazing! But ...her french :/
Danuliq952 1 week ago
She should never do this again. French is so boring to listen to.
wTrevorh 2 weeks ago
woow sorry beyonce but your frenc... it just.. sucks!!!! D=
ellachoekerella 2 weeks ago
all frenceh hater why dont you upload a vid of you singing the song... i dont know the lyrics but she did a great job.....of course half of you wont be able to understad a thing i wote.
vanstys 2 weeks ago
@vanstys The point is that she shouldn't be singing a song she doesnt even know the lyrics to; not that she can't sing.
Emilybudgie 1 week ago
euhm...
Ristridin96 2 weeks ago
Comment removed
MademoiselleVermell 2 weeks ago
@ultrabaron Va chanter anglais toi. Essaie sans accent qu'on rigole. Casse toi , viens pas niquer la vidéo tu vois. Les gens comme toi, ils servent a rien. Stoi la pute, va dormir. Beyonce a très bien chanté cette chanson, si t'as un truc a dire, trouve des arguments. tchiiiiiiiiiiip.
BuongBuong 2 weeks ago
c'est vraiment terrible la pauvre...
SylviaDfrnch 3 weeks ago
que manera de destrozar una cancion...pesimo beyonce...pesimo.dedicate a cantar tus canciones que bastante es.
scherezade39 4 weeks ago
"Deeeeee...EEEEE...eeee...EEEE...eeee gloiiiiiiiiiiiiiire."
NellyxRose 1 month ago
Cette vidéo c'est... Une grosse blague... Très grosse.
NellyxRose 1 month ago
Je ne sais pas combien de fois j'ai regardé cette vidéo aujourd'hui, mais à chaque fois je ris aux éclats !! :D C'est vraiment... Etrange ! On a tellement l'habitude de la voir tout maîtriser à la limite de la perfection que le moindre échec semble être inenvisageable ! Moi ça me fait juste rire je ne la critique pas c'est une très grande artiste, mais avec un tel talent et une telle célébrité, elle aurait mieux fait d'éviter de chanter cette chanson... :D
SignorinaCannella67 1 month ago
Moi je dis seulement RESPECT. Avant de critiquer une personne essayer de savoir si vous même vous auriez pu faire la même chose à sa place. Vous n'êtes jamais content de rien, il faut toujours vous plaindre. IL ne faut pas oublié que la plus part des chansons françaises ne sont pas celle que l'on écoute souvent, alors quand une star mondiale fait l'effort d’interpréter un titre, vous préférez la critiquer que de l’applaudir. c'est quoi???? De la jalousie, de ne pas pouvoir en faire autant???
NDiosN 1 month ago 2
Franchement, pour quelqu'un qui parle pas français elle s'est très bien débrouillée! Elle chante bien, et c'est cool qu'il y ai des reprises comme celle-ci. Normal que l'on comprenne pas certains mots, elle est américaine!! Alors à tous ceux qui disent qu'elle a massacré la chanson, changez de vidéo et arrêtez de dire de la merde parce que je suis sure que vous faites pas mieux... :)
Moon92e 1 month ago 3
see upon your path, children lost and forgotten thats the only translation i can remember
mollylee1 1 month ago
Elle a rien niquer, c'est même plutôt un honneur pour les français qu'elle l'ai chanter, elle l'a super bien chanter !!! Vive Beyoncé !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
diesel145145 1 month ago 11
@ultrabaron TG ! C'est pas une francaise ! Normal quel est du mal tu frai pas mieu
thelouiseyoutub 1 month ago
ELLE A NIQUE LA CHANSON CETTE PUTE !
ultrabaron 1 month ago
@ultrabaron ta mere
MissDoOja1 1 month ago
@ultrabaron Et bien , on a pas tous eu la définition du respect.
Mais c'est sûr qu'avant de respecter les autres, il faut se respecter sois-même ce qui demande peut-être de faire preuve de trop d'esprit pour certains...
CallMeLauraBieber63 1 month ago
vois sur ton cheman gamans oublie e garé don ne loe la man poe le mene ve dotre lendeman... looks in no possible way of French...
supasky69 1 month ago
Franchement, Non mais vous êtes con ou quoi je vous rappelle qu'un accent Anglais sa se pert pas en claquant des mains.
TheKamera13 1 month ago 4
Pour tout ceux qui disent qu'elle a "ruiné" notre langue. J'trouve que c'est bien ! Elle n'a surement pas sorti un mot en français avant cette chanson donc respect :)
xEloodii2e 1 month ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
arreter d'etre jaloux elle chante super bien elle chante d'ailleur mieux que certains chanteur francais ...enplus c mm pas sa langue ....ca doit faire mal hein....
kaylie27 1 month ago
the worse thing she sang v.v even beyonce has a black past hahaha
Simply2Good4You 1 month ago
merci d'avoir ruiné notre langue
dimey94 1 month ago
@dimey94 vtff
MissDoOja1 1 month ago
no bad that accent ! hahaa loll
divanas2005 1 month ago
Beyonce comme here and I will give you french language course...
ludoelens 1 month ago
Beyonce, girl,your voice is beautiful, but your pronunciation is just horrible x__x
MaiaSleepmonster 1 month ago
This. is. so. bad. This song is terrible for her, and she can't even pretend to speak French. It's an insult to the composer..
zeno137 1 month ago
she should not sing french songs. or at least take a french class before she tries
JudyDannQuave 1 month ago
eurgh....son francais est.......pas mal =\
aortablue 1 month ago
i cant even.
SENS A CURE de la nuit
ADORE de la vieEY..... >__<
Momooshon 1 month ago
lol WHAT? I had no idea she had ever sang this song. she has a nice voice but it sounds funny... when you know french, i mean. I like the original version better :p
MegaSingerful 2 months ago
the french pronounciations should be better
fa rizzle
OfficialBulb 2 months ago
oh beyonce. why did you have to ruin this song, ?
jessilovesbenefit 2 months ago
I'm french and.. I don't understand at all..
BKxAddict 2 months ago 35
arretez de dire qu'elle parle mal francais parce ue vs vous croyez que vous savez parler anglais mais en fait pas du tt votre accent c'est de la merde
MPweloveyouetmakeup 2 months ago
WHY BEYONCE?! WHY WHY WHY WHY WHY?!
MusicalLovingGeek 2 months ago
I don't even speak french but I can definitaly say is is way of it!!
This is the worst version of that song I have ever heared. :(
cujen88 2 months ago
au moin elle chante mieu que shakira elle ses rien si on comprend rien mes au moin ses mangnific donc quand ta fill elle va chanter comme sa mes lui des baff!!!!!!!
59nawal 2 months ago
Shakira a une meilleure prononciation (je l'aime à mourir)...aucune excuse!
yanou4u 2 months ago
je ne comprends rien
yanou4u 2 months ago
moi j'aime pas :o elle détruit la langue française
saintcharles29490 2 months ago
Wow, Beyonce a vraiment une voix magnifique♥♥.. L'accent anglais, on s'en fout sérieux! C'est comme si on vous disais : vas-y parle en irlandais avec l'accent parfait. Sa ne doit pas être très facile! Moi je dis vive les belles voix comme celle-ci!♥♥
Superbiloutjes 2 months ago
healer voice...dear majasty beyonce..
seyyahification 2 months ago
y no sabe cantar
bazinga223 2 months ago
icnorant no se la sabe
bazinga223 2 months ago
bad! baaaad bad bad! but her voice is still great ;)
extremesfeelingxD 2 months ago
Bad pronunciation, and these kind of songs just are not made for her type of voice
claruuuuuuuuuuus 2 months ago
Her french is funny, she still sings good :)
UpcoRaul 2 months ago
ok someone really needs to give her a pronunciation lesson ><
Klr707 2 months ago 2
eww this is not a pop song, and her french is horrible.
dtsmz2 3 months ago
the movie version is so much better! I love beyonce but this is not a good song for her 2 sing.
italianatheart19 3 months ago
lol she cant sing french for shit :P
SkylRR 3 months ago
her frensh is horrible.
and jean babtiste maunier is waaaaaaayyyyyy better!
TheNixe96 3 months ago
No tiene ni idea de pronunciar el frances
MarinaLOVEOskar 3 months ago
she is great
laetitia771 3 months ago
I dont know French so I can't say if the pronunciation is correct but vocally phoenominal!
royalty333 3 months ago 2
BEYOCNE DID AMAZIIIINGGG!!!
carlamoon1 3 months ago
She did her best, and it still sounds poetic ! ( she could have worked more on the prononciation, tought, as this sounds like haitian french, but you must agree, french IS difficult !)
beanarnia 3 months ago
I'm french and even if it's not perfect it's cute and she did it as better as she can :)
Chounetss 3 months ago
beyonce trying to go for her grandparents nationality shes cherole
aiswright 3 months ago
Well, nice singing. Could work a little more on pronounciation, though.
AmiMusicTree 3 months ago
This is horrible, i'm french and i had a hard time understanding 1 word out of 10. Extremely bad idea from Beyonce, sounds like shes speaking Haitian Creole.
AcEast 3 months ago
it sounds awful when beyonce sings this beautiful song! she destroyed it!
PiikaFaan 3 months ago 2
If she can't speak French then whats the point of singing in French?
ActionGirlist 3 months ago 2
Pretty voice. Pronunciation is doing my head in....
AlexaKay53 3 months ago
..to go in front of the Academy...and the world...in a language far from ur native is amazing and courageous. I can bet 99% of you wouldn't even think about attempting what she did.
EdwinElChulo 3 months ago 2
Her voice and strong, strong control and overall perfection makes up for her horrible French pronunciations. She's so talented. #WOW
EdwinElChulo 3 months ago 2
@punisher929 Im french ( from montreal ) and i speak currently french,english,spanish and italian so shut the &$"?)! Up !
GabCroteau 3 months ago
@punisher929 sorry im french ( from montreal) and i speak currently french, english, spanish and italian so shut the fuck up and try to say at least on word in french.
I would say that YOU dont want to learn any other language than your own fckn one!!!!
GabCroteau 3 months ago
j ai l impression d entendre les mamas de mes amis ^^
LovaGaGa 3 months ago
Can it really be that hard to learn how to pronounce the words of one song. It's not as though she had to learn the language. Still this interpretation of the song is well done.
ogoldi88 3 months ago
film de merde, mais interprétation trop stylé de la Beyonce !
kimcattralouh 3 months ago
Her voice remains the same, that is obvious but please, compare this to the original version... horrible.
Edge73100 3 months ago
She sings perfectly even though she might have a few issues with french; i'm french but i dont judge her on her pronounciation, her voice is amazing!
wtfsupinfocom 3 months ago
French people tend to forget at they REFUSE to speak another language...... because they think that french is still superior..... I would love to see a french guy/girl singing Halo in english ^^ we can all have a laugh then.
beyonce sang this song great ... yeah she's saying alot of words in the wrong way . But its like scottish and UK english .. it still hase the same meaning doesn't it?
punisher929 3 months ago
@punisher929 first i want u to know that i'm french and i'm fluent in english i desagree with u when u say french people do not speak any other language of course we're proud of speaking our language and we try our best to spread it around the world i don't know where u're from but i've never met native english speaker that speak another language propperly cause u do think u got the international language so u don't need to bother yourself with other language and to finish her french is awfull
mllechihiro4 3 months ago
@mllechihiro4
im from belgium.
speak dutch, french, german , and english.
punisher929 3 months ago
@punisher929 congratulation !!!! the question is not about speaking many other languages it is to do it propperly it's not her case and sorry but i don't believe you when you say such thing i made spanish italian russian and mandarin at school but i don't pretend being fluent in all those laguage i'm just quite good in spanish an italian i'm not lyig to myself
mllechihiro4 3 months ago
@mllechihiro4 i'm pretty fluent. just not in german. lol
punisher929 3 months ago
@punisher929 strange i would have said you're lying about dutch knowing that your belgium i've once been there and they were all fluent in french and german! Well that's mean you're fluent in dutch and english then. Anyway you've just pissed me off insulting french people is that because you're belgium??
mllechihiro4 3 months ago
@mllechihiro4
insulting french people? i gave you historical Facts.
punisher929 2 months ago
@punisher929 historical facts ??!! don't get it i said that cause you made fun on french accent in a way while saying that that we're not able to sing halo propperly at least that's what i understood
mllechihiro4 2 months ago
@punisher929 half French on both sides of my family. Am I an overly-patriotic frog-eater with a snail fetish and a refusal to speak anything that isn't pure Francais? No, my dear idiot, no I am not.
AlexaKay53 2 months ago
@AlexaKay53
I said most. Deal with it. These are facts.
Besides english is easier to learn than french. English is everywhere. French is close to dead. so YAY for beyonce TRYING to do this for you french assfuckers... while she has no reason TO DO SO.
punisher929 2 months ago
@punisher929 i'm not interested in how many times you can insult me, and I don't recall ever mentioning Beyonce. Besides, as long as there are French people, they're not about to let it go out of fashion...
AlexaKay53 2 months ago
@AlexaKay53 has nothing to do with "fashion" .
English is used in the buisness world,TV,Billboards,internet,
and the french government refuses to teach kids some proper english. They rather Dub Tv-shows than Sub them
punisher929 2 months ago
@AlexaKay53
This had nothing to do with "fashion" your government should learn to accept that French isn't a Global language any longer.
All important buisnesses Cummunicate in english , they use it as a universal language , so everyone understands eachother, and your government tries so hard .. to stop children from comming in contact with the English language at a young age.
punisher929 2 months ago
@punisher929 Talking only French isn't going to kill them...
And also, I meant in the context of 'as long as there are French people, French will be a language.'
Speaking of languages, we seem to be talking different ones, as it takes me about five minutes to work out what you're rambling on about...
AlexaKay53 2 months ago
@AlexaKay53 Still 50x better than the average french population.
punisher929 2 months ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
My point has just been proven. Once again, what are you on about?
AlexaKay53 2 months ago
to all the french people. Is she really that bad??? is she making any sense lol?
thatstheone87 3 months ago
Beyonce, you have a great voice, I love you, but pleasepleaseplease. Learn French songs with someone to correct your pronunciation. I think you managed to make some new words, there. ;)
Zeebraskill 3 months ago 29
@Zeebraskill its beyonce, the french should move around her, not the other way around.
thatstheone87 2 months ago
i think this is the new language of beyonce ...XD
mjlovesLZA 3 months ago 23
allow me ( french teacher and pronunciation examiner in french language ) : well , we all agree that she cant speak french ( nor sing in french language) but there should ve been a french teacher to fix her pronunciation a bit more coz there are words that are 100 % wrong ! but let me add ( as a choir singer now ! ) she adds some beyonce spirit in it ! and that what makes it special . IN GENERAL , I LIKE ! ( but lets keep it as a 1st time trial , no more ! )
MrDory333 3 months ago 2
i am french and i agree with you she's awesome. It is hard to speak french but she did a great job. @ichbineinGenie Shlanpe geht zum den achloch beyonce ist die besser
rizlou73 4 months ago
joder que cagada mas monumental... y manera de joderme una cancion :@
que se ponga un tanga muy ajustado aver si se le pone la voz mas aguda u.u
y el acento jolin uwu, no cantes mas porfavor
regt19 4 months ago
mdr quel horreur
OnslaughT44 4 months ago
eehw she sucks! she thinks she has THE BEST VOICE EVER but i think it sounds like SHIT. i dont like her.
ichbineinGENIE 4 months ago
that was beautiful ! So what if she couldn't speak that crappy language you people should be happy she sang that awful song in that awful language.
johhnnww 4 months ago
odour de la vie?
Boutiqueeny 4 months ago 2
moi j'aime bien. c'est mignon. :)
pallamidessi 4 months ago
don't criticize her...i mean come on guys..French is not her mothertongue...if someone ask u to sing in German or Chinese although u aren't are u goining to do it better?
axel1lover 4 months ago
@axel1lover im brittish but can talk and sing in most european accents and american the thing is the with most european languages the meanings of words depend on how you say them and i can speak french and that song doesnt make sense because she cant prenounce the words correctly shes basically singing jibberish but with a good voice
TheRaulip 4 months ago
wie schrecklich.
DiieJulia95 4 months ago
she does not sing with real feeling .. it's not so nice
the original song is better !
AnnaLikeBonbons 4 months ago
To somebody who doesn't speak French, she just sounds like the same amazing Beyonce as usual and that's all that matters. She doesn't have to be perfect or cater to your picky desires.
maybesomeday1 4 months ago
@maybesomeday1
I don't speak franch very well and I know that she sings so horrible. And her french is sooooo bad.
LindaNaomiHolofernes 4 months ago
@LindaNaomiHolofernes i speak french and half of that is gibberish she cant pronounce the words so they dont mean anything
TheRaulip 4 months ago
@TheRaulip
At the first time I heard this I thought : "Oh she's singing the finish version"
LindaNaomiHolofernes 4 months ago
@LindaNaomiHolofernes at least she sang in a strange lenguage in fromt of many peoples, thing that you would never do
ENRIQUE881 3 months ago 3
moi j'aime bien...
Nana91160 4 months ago
lol no.
6HerpDerp9 4 months ago
ähh.... gut dass sie singen kann.
lesekatze20 5 months ago
WHAT THE FUCK GUYS, SHE IS BLACK OK? SO WHAT MAYBE HER FRENCH IS A LITTLE OFF? so what? would you rather hear rebecca black sing this in a perfect french accent or hear beyonce murder it with some faulty french?
vivita98 5 months ago
That sounds horrible.
hellsDragonwolf 5 months ago
who cares about the lack of french accent.....
AssassinsReign 5 months ago
Oh man, her french sucks :P
TheAwesomeAnoud 5 months ago 4
This song is beautiful but she ruined it ;(
luvart2607 5 months ago
Her french accent is shite.
thesassywhitegirl 5 months ago
i'm not french so like it (fuck french)
sashabjk 5 months ago
son francais est pourit elle boufe la moitier des mots
laurine1993 5 months ago
I'm french and I know that french it very dificult to learn, so this song(by beyonce) is great, And if we don't listen to the lyrics , her voice is so amazing , i love it !
AnaelleM10 5 months ago 3
I admit her French is bad, but most French speakers usually have a way worse English so she gets some credit for trying, BESIDES, Im a Spanish speaker and at least in my native language she has done real good, that gives her another point over you haters. And BESIDES #2: how many of you can sing like that? ...I thought so.
rnbwerewolf 5 months ago 3
would you guys stop it , i speak french , im in a french school , i speak English better then french , i sang this 5 years ago , she did such an amazing work , even though he french isn't that good
mca06021996 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sounds like she going to eat the song. Is she hurry?
datkhuong2011 5 months ago
Sounds like she going to eat the song.
datkhuong2011 5 months ago
Sounds like she going to eat the song.
datkhuong2011 5 months ago
french people your english is even worst, at least she tries
CARLOSGURO 5 months ago 2
leave her she speaks french at her level
laetou1990 5 months ago
Jean Baptiste Maunier sings better!!!! love the movie.... <3 i love him!!!!!!!!!!!
AlinaSculcuvant 5 months ago 39
I dont even Speak french.
And americans, please dont't take ofense, but whenever they try to speak a foreign language it doesnt sound gut :s
ruffdj 5 months ago
you should never ever copy a song without knowing the language! And this song was wirtten for a choire why did she sing this!? I've got a headache... D:
XXNichtlustigXX 5 months ago
parece mas coreano que frances.
Wkhalito 5 months ago 2
If she wasn't such a hoe I'ld give it a chance, but this version sucks. I guess she had to contain herself from stripping in this song.
Maybe its me but all her songs seem appropriate for a strip club? Soon you might see a Brittney or Lahonda dancing this in a pole.
takostand 5 months ago
@takostand Yes it is just you and you alone :).
Shapew 5 months ago
She's not french..She sounds beautiful even though her french may be bad..lol WELP!
saiah022 6 months ago 30
her....... french..... oh dear
miraXmanson 6 months ago 2
a cagar la cancion...
tsutsanFD 6 months ago 2
@tsutsanFD Su francés es muy malo pero su capacidad vocal es increíble!! :)
SomosSoloPersonas 5 months ago
ademas se lee ¨la nyi¨ y no ¨la nuit¨ grrr
sPamplina 6 months ago
malogra la cancion
sPamplina 6 months ago
I can sing this better and I've only taken two french classes. (I'm american)
SeleneJessabelle1262 6 months ago
u killed it bey !
HibBeyonceLove 7 months ago
I don't blame her for wanting to sing this song even though she doesn't know any french.
This song is the BEST!
CupcakexKitty 7 months ago 4
At least it vocally sounds great
IntenselyMorbid 7 months ago
She killed French but still her vocal performance was wonderful!!! Love you forever Beyoncé!!! <3 <3 <3
savamounange 7 months ago
i think it would be better if she would sing english. i mean, she's a beautiful musician, but THIS IS SO FUCKIN BAD !!!!
Claramagbananenmilch 7 months ago 2
wtf is this ..-_-...> This song is made for a choir, not for hiphop. And I am gonna leave all the technical details aside, but I find it disrespectful for the composer, the choir and really wrong.
NyoronChibiChan 7 months ago
Donnen lu lamann?? --Donnez leur la main s'îl te plait!
AnnaEdogawa 7 months ago
french is beautiful language!
plaisirbleu 7 months ago
hahaha !!!!
natoushe1999 7 months ago
yuuuck what a horrendous thing this is... C'mon Beyonce !! Show us you can do better than this crap !
aeroavia89 7 months ago
amazing voice ... but jesus her french
Shababasha 7 months ago 3
@Shababasha absolutely!
AlexaKay53 7 months ago
rubbish jbm was much better
319LuLu 7 months ago in playlist Les Choristes
Bit worse then nails down a chalk board! But thanks for uploading all the same!
AuroraGreenleaf 7 months ago
Why did she do that? o_O
roseonyourcoffeedoor 7 months ago 2
I liked it!
BiBiZMee 7 months ago
Who on earth thought that this ... ... ....mess ... would be a good idea?
markfromireland 7 months ago
Eeeeks I thought she was singing in Spanish or what...
taylorswift091196 7 months ago
I love beyonce, but it's too overdone, there's a message in this song and I think it scenically not the same way between B and the song! She shouldn't smile like that, it's a serious song! it s true that her French is horrible, other American singers were better in French!
miyaou 8 months ago 2