she was talking to God or asking Him some questions doesn't mean an atheist (she is NOT).. she is catholic. she even studied in a catholic school! :) but she is influenced by her father's Lebanese heritage.. that is why many of her songs have kind of Arabic style or words like in this one.. :)
i think that in the part that says 'you've made mistakes well that's ok 'cause we all have, but if you forgive yours, will you forgive mine?' she is not talking about God.. I think she's talking about other people in general. remember the song starts with the catholic prayer 'Our God'--- the part that says 'Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who have trespassed against us'
- and just because she is curious about things (like everyone) and she decided to write a song about it as if sh
Who'r u?to give yourself the right to be a judge!keep philosophy to philosophers,science to scientists,religion to the experts...and keep your interest in moving your waist Mind!..The mean puppet can't be at any time a wise woman !!!!!!!!!
I think she just simply mixed her mother's strong roman catholic heritage, because Spanish countries are strong roman catholic believers.... as well as her father's Arabic heritage because he is of Lebanese descent. Thats why the begining 'prayer' or watever u wana call it begins in Latin and the last 'prayer' or watever is in Arabic.
Don't understand the significance of either in the song, cuz it wud have had the same impact without it, buttt, i still like it!
@Charoula1608 Because we chose sin. And some people still do choose it and don't love God and each other. Without loVe there is NO PEACE. You can't help it in any way.
@fuckoffanddietwice, no offence buh wats spellin got 2 do wiv any thin, its like sayin you cant hav a job coz u gotta welsh accent i mean wats tha about, just coz sum 1 dont spell summin right dont mean they cant spell at the end of the day if people wanna mis spell sumin wen they type they hav the rite 2 every 1 has the rite 2 talk how they like, y dont i critisise u bout the fact u hav a swear word in ur usaname? exactly u wudnt b happy bowt it so stop tellin ovas how 2 write
katie123672, look im an evangelical christian, buh ive got nothin against u just because ur muslim, and if thats what u think about us christians then you need to seriously listen to your re teacher coz at the end of the day u just steriotyped us christians, wer not ll like that, i dont go round sayin tha coz ur muslim u take the mick out of a cetain religion, ok so stop bullying, and dont say your not, because you are, its about the pain and the suffering in the world, now is that ok with you?
ok, so u guys are christians! and if i said to u that i'm muslim would u guys treat me the same? of course u won't!! but u guyz, alway say that we should unit! then why do u act like this against muslims!! i'm not acussing anyone! i'm just saying how i've been treated!! and btw, ALLAH means god in islam and she said some arabic words!
uy esta cancion suena rebien y en latinoamerica dicen que shakira se perdio y es una gran mentira solo ke no escuchamos completos sus albumes y por eso es que decimos puras babosadas shakira sigue solo que no la vemos
Oops I did not get to finish my statement. I think this song does represent a lot of the thoughts in today's world. It's okay to ask questions. Job, who was a righteous man, certainly asked God many questions (the book of Job in the Old Testament). We, as human beings are so curious. However, we will not always have the answers to everything and when we do, we may ignore the answer. It's good to understand that God is in control and without suffering, there would be no compassion or strength.
SOMETHING GOOD WILL HAPPEN TO U AT 9:10 SOMEONE WILL CALL YOU OR TALK TO YOU ONLINE AND SAY I LOVE YOU OR ASK YOU OUT BUT HERES THE CATCH Send To 3 vidoes
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Finally proof there is no god or the fact that god is obviously evil.
I love Shakira. Finally a woman with a brain who can think for herself and don't need a book written by a barbarian in the 6th century to tell her how to think.
Religion only benefits Clergy men and it poisons minds of young children. I am sure Shakira is an Atheist. If she is I love her even more this means she has a brain and can think for herself. And she believes in logic and reasoning.
If ur perception of God is evil then i feel sorry for you, u feel that religion benefits only clergy men? tell that to everyone who finds strength in faith, ur mind is no less poisoned than those "young children"
@jikkh Before you disrespect someone's personal opinion you should work on your grammar. No one is going to take the advice of someone who uses "ur" and "u" instead of "your" and "you" very seriously, now are they?
This song contains a big controversy !! HOW MANY PEOPLE DIE AND HURT IN YOUR NAME?
Love this song , it is so clever !
Xcubanchick21 2 days ago 2
Comment removed
MrsVampire1994 5 days ago
i really love this song ! clever!!!
xxGaby1699xx 1 week ago
she was talking to God or asking Him some questions doesn't mean an atheist (she is NOT).. she is catholic. she even studied in a catholic school! :) but she is influenced by her father's Lebanese heritage.. that is why many of her songs have kind of Arabic style or words like in this one.. :)
izpinky7 1 month ago
i think that in the part that says 'you've made mistakes well that's ok 'cause we all have, but if you forgive yours, will you forgive mine?' she is not talking about God.. I think she's talking about other people in general. remember the song starts with the catholic prayer 'Our God'--- the part that says 'Forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who have trespassed against us'
- and just because she is curious about things (like everyone) and she decided to write a song about it as if sh
izpinky7 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God doesn't make mistakes!
blueluver99 2 months ago
"You've made mistakes and that's ok 'cause we all have but if i forgive yours will you forgive mine?" Genius!
josedeloza 2 months ago
Who'r u?to give yourself the right to be a judge!keep philosophy to philosophers,science to scientists,religion to the experts...and keep your interest in moving your waist Mind!..The mean puppet can't be at any time a wise woman !!!!!!!!!
75KINGNOTHING 3 months ago
@75KINGNOTHING u're an asshole..
0ooluoo0 2 months ago 2
@0ooluoo0 0ooluoo0's is right
TheMultiShineegirl 1 week ago
I think she just simply mixed her mother's strong roman catholic heritage, because Spanish countries are strong roman catholic believers.... as well as her father's Arabic heritage because he is of Lebanese descent. Thats why the begining 'prayer' or watever u wana call it begins in Latin and the last 'prayer' or watever is in Arabic.
Don't understand the significance of either in the song, cuz it wud have had the same impact without it, buttt, i still like it!
punkzipX3 4 months ago
So does this mean shes an atheist or something?
punkzipX3 4 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
@punkzipX3 She doesn't even know what she is...
zorelita 2 months ago
If you wrote the script...why the troublemakers? why are there are wars? why do Your creatures(humans) kill other humans?
Charoula1608 4 months ago
@Charoula1608 Because we chose sin. And some people still do choose it and don't love God and each other. Without loVe there is NO PEACE. You can't help it in any way.
pryscylla12311 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I just love this song *__*
zia6855 4 months ago
I just love this song *__*
zia6855 4 months ago
Ohh it said and if our fates. i thought it said hey there fart face :) lol
smexyme22 5 months ago
this song speaks to me, and i agree with a lot of it but mostly 0:53
Colton8500 5 months ago
Ya sé que la gente cambia y todo eso y de verdad lo respeto, pero no podría Shakira volver aunque sea un poco a componer y a cantar así?
I miss you Shaki :(
ImRottenToMyCore 6 months ago
@ImRottenToMyCore Concuerdo contigo :) extraño a esta Shakira de letras profundas
pipez20 6 months ago 3
@ImRottenToMyCore Escucha su CD entero y después opina!!!! que bronca me da la gente que habla al dope
lukaspiojo 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ImRottenToMyCore Escucha su CD entero y después opina!!!! que bronca me da la gente que habla al dope
lukaspiojo 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ImRottenToMyCore Escucha su CD entero y después opina!!!! que bronca me da la gente que habla al dope
lukaspiojo 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ImRottenToMyCore Escucha su CD entero y después opina!!!! que bronca me da la gente que habla al dope
lukaspiojo 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ImRottenToMyCore Escucha su CD entero y después opina!!!! que bronca me da la gente que habla al p...o
lukaspiojo 4 months ago
I like the "I sometimes cry" part
dirtyrobin 6 months ago
Comment removed
XxXMikufangirlXxX 5 months ago
@dirtyrobin I don't think she's singing I sometimes cry... I think she says "Are you sometimes sad?" instead
guillemrv85 1 week ago
la seule musique que j'aime est de Shakira's.
ReallyMitchieTorres 7 months ago
thine is kingdom and the power and the gloryy AMEN!!! amen shakiraa. flawless:)
sugarbear941 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh... this song is unique. Shakira passed undermine the faith when she was writtenig this i think (because she isn't Atheist)
TorukMakto6 7 months ago
Comment removed
TorukMakto6 7 months ago
This song is...unique:)
QueenStafani 7 months ago 2
Nice video :D But doesn't she say "Do you ever cry? Are you sometimes sad?" instead of "I sometimes cry"?
guillemrv85 8 months ago 4
i like this song because it is so meaningful ...
leaquennie 8 months ago
MAN ITS THE SAME SHIT SAME GOD DIFFRENT NAMES !! WHATEVER DUDES!!!
ishaandtwins 9 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this lyrics are a disgrace!
SuperTNsly 10 months ago
@SuperTNsly Wonder why?
Whats wrong with some simple questions?
Ever read her Octavo dia lyrics?
Timor?
ultimente2 9 months ago
I love her.
1futbolandmusic 10 months ago
LoVE THIS SoNG
RAFAKRDENAS1 11 months ago
shakira i lovvvvvvvvvvvvvv u n ur songs
apurva9000 1 year ago
@fuckoffanddietwice, no offence buh wats spellin got 2 do wiv any thin, its like sayin you cant hav a job coz u gotta welsh accent i mean wats tha about, just coz sum 1 dont spell summin right dont mean they cant spell at the end of the day if people wanna mis spell sumin wen they type they hav the rite 2 every 1 has the rite 2 talk how they like, y dont i critisise u bout the fact u hav a swear word in ur usaname? exactly u wudnt b happy bowt it so stop tellin ovas how 2 write
1995ChelseyJaime 1 year ago
katie123672, look im an evangelical christian, buh ive got nothin against u just because ur muslim, and if thats what u think about us christians then you need to seriously listen to your re teacher coz at the end of the day u just steriotyped us christians, wer not ll like that, i dont go round sayin tha coz ur muslim u take the mick out of a cetain religion, ok so stop bullying, and dont say your not, because you are, its about the pain and the suffering in the world, now is that ok with you?
1995ChelseyJaime 1 year ago
Comment removed
Onnanas 1 year ago 2
weird... :-|
lenmar9598 1 year ago
ok, so u guys are christians! and if i said to u that i'm muslim would u guys treat me the same? of course u won't!! but u guyz, alway say that we should unit! then why do u act like this against muslims!! i'm not acussing anyone! i'm just saying how i've been treated!! and btw, ALLAH means god in islam and she said some arabic words!
katie123672 1 year ago 2
best singer at whole world ....
salam shakira
zwitalo 1 year ago 2
uy esta cancion suena rebien y en latinoamerica dicen que shakira se perdio y es una gran mentira solo ke no escuchamos completos sus albumes y por eso es que decimos puras babosadas shakira sigue solo que no la vemos
emanueldark23 1 year ago
why all the fighting people? lay down your arms and unite, lest our father turns around and leaves us to face this world alone for good.
alexns 2 years ago 26
@alexns :) I love your comment, made me smile. Very beautiful
Pinkalicious112 1 year ago
@alexns we do what we must to survive and when everyone wants us dead we deal with the problem for good
MegaCoolcole 4 months ago
Oops I did not get to finish my statement. I think this song does represent a lot of the thoughts in today's world. It's okay to ask questions. Job, who was a righteous man, certainly asked God many questions (the book of Job in the Old Testament). We, as human beings are so curious. However, we will not always have the answers to everything and when we do, we may ignore the answer. It's good to understand that God is in control and without suffering, there would be no compassion or strength.
duhitzdani 2 years ago
I think
duhitzdani 2 years ago
Oh my , i love this song shakira is amazingly talented and all her songs are beautiful.
michaud78 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
SOMETHING GOOD WILL HAPPEN TO U AT 9:10 SOMEONE WILL CALL YOU OR TALK TO YOU ONLINE AND SAY I LOVE YOU OR ASK YOU OUT BUT HERES THE CATCH Send To 3 vidoes
LightningFang210 2 years ago
great song!! love you shakira!! <3
xxxxanahixxxx 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Finally proof there is no god or the fact that god is obviously evil.
I love Shakira. Finally a woman with a brain who can think for herself and don't need a book written by a barbarian in the 6th century to tell her how to think.
Religion only benefits Clergy men and it poisons minds of young children. I am sure Shakira is an Atheist. If she is I love her even more this means she has a brain and can think for herself. And she believes in logic and reasoning.
MMATSdreadnautLOVER 2 years ago
Well spoken yo.
ryantiomanno 2 years ago
If ur perception of God is evil then i feel sorry for you, u feel that religion benefits only clergy men? tell that to everyone who finds strength in faith, ur mind is no less poisoned than those "young children"
jikkh 2 years ago 3
@jikkh Before you disrespect someone's personal opinion you should work on your grammar. No one is going to take the advice of someone who uses "ur" and "u" instead of "your" and "you" very seriously, now are they?
fuckoffanddietwice 2 years ago
ok you no nothing i feel sad for you :(
parnmkie 2 years ago
@parnmkie You could learn to spell before you judge others, okay? n_n
fuckoffanddietwice 2 years ago
Comment removed
TheCroatianprincess 1 year ago
i feel sorry for you :(
MOBYLEEful 2 years ago
@MOBYLEEful Feel sorry for yourself first before you cast stones at someone else.
fuckoffanddietwice 2 years ago
Comment removed
MOBYLEEful 2 years ago
This song is the best!
- Simple as.
And it is something we all should think about, undoubtably.
OblivionHazzard 2 years ago 4
love the song shes the best singer in the galaxy
varriaza2003 2 years ago 2
I love her and I love her sings. God bless her.
mkan94 3 years ago 5
Great job!
cheapEmilie 3 years ago 2
Shakira is one of the best singers and songwriters on this planet. That´s for sure.
Well done. :-)
Kipshoven 3 years ago 84
@Kipshoven She was, not anymore!!!!
jaimealonso74 5 months ago