Thank you for this documentary. I love victorian time but I have never discovered american history in nineteenth century. I think this part of history is very interesting. Thanks!!
That explains why Washington Heights along with the rest of Manhattan is full of Irish Pubs in a neighborhood thats all hispanic now,,, Plus a long line generations Irish cops and so on.. Awesome documentary.. Alot of my questions about my neighborhood were answered watchin this film... 2 Thumbs up for this posting.
The cool thing about nyc, is that is historically and today, seems a nation all its own. Kinda like Washington, Ore and Cali seem to ba a nation all its own. but this is just one city, impressive.
These things will probably never happen again. Everyone in America today settles their ideas with words, yeah there're still gangs, but revolutions and militant actions are all but gone. Whether this is for better or worse, only history will show
@Astrithor I would disagree. The gangs haven't gone anywhere and their rule never ended. They have simply become more sophisticated, wealthy, and their ends are still the same.
@Astrithor poverty has a direct link to the cruelty and violence humans are capable of, the last few generations had plenty, more then any before them, they had no reason or motivation for violence and have become soft. But as you see on the corrupt news every day now, times are changing, poverty and fear are moving into the american daily life like a wild fire, violence will follow. A wolf who just ate will avoid you, a hungry wolf will rip you apart, there are a lot more hungry wolves now.
@BigChiefWiggles Great point obvious as it may be but they will not address this hear. They haven't once admitted that poverty led to this fighting. In fact the guy at the beginning insisted that the irish "wanted" to live in the five points.
@Astrithor Wait until poverty takes over america in the coming years. We havent evolved that much as a people. Wealth keeps people in check and when it goes east to china americans will start fighting again.
Watching this after the Scorsese flick really makes me respect his film-making. Although he dramatised certain parts of the film (as is his right - it's a movie after all) he really nailed loads of the important details of this era in New York's history.
These immigrant mobs you refer to controlled voting, patronage etc in new york for two hundred years so yeah I would say it covered a social movement. Not everything in life can be clear cut these mobs were what today would be called political action committees.
Truly great !!! So Tweed had a similar arrest to this of Louis XVI a hundred year before: taken by its portrait ! Does anyone know where I could found some pics about NYC archaelogical excavations in Five points ? I saw some very few ones and it seems that the ground of 1863 is meters under the present street level because of land fulfillings.
Thank you for this documentary. I love victorian time but I have never discovered american history in nineteenth century. I think this part of history is very interesting. Thanks!!
maximeoliver 7 months ago
@maximeoliver Thanks for watching.
Docmate 6 months ago
thanks
TheNigerianScammer 7 months ago
wow, excellent documentary!! well done!
zeelove8 8 months ago
damn this is interesting.,. i wanna see more. :P
fritiofkonkas 11 months ago
That explains why Washington Heights along with the rest of Manhattan is full of Irish Pubs in a neighborhood thats all hispanic now,,, Plus a long line generations Irish cops and so on.. Awesome documentary.. Alot of my questions about my neighborhood were answered watchin this film... 2 Thumbs up for this posting.
RobThaLastRemedy 11 months ago
Very good documentary,pity to this day we irish are still emigrating because of the corruption still at the heart of irish politics.
MossyKong 1 year ago
Man, civil action was awesome before it got hijacked by concerned mothers and feminazis.
zyphoid666 1 year ago
The cool thing about nyc, is that is historically and today, seems a nation all its own. Kinda like Washington, Ore and Cali seem to ba a nation all its own. but this is just one city, impressive.
jake666thehellion 1 year ago
These things will probably never happen again. Everyone in America today settles their ideas with words, yeah there're still gangs, but revolutions and militant actions are all but gone. Whether this is for better or worse, only history will show
Astrithor 1 year ago
@Astrithor I would disagree. The gangs haven't gone anywhere and their rule never ended. They have simply become more sophisticated, wealthy, and their ends are still the same.
heyheymonkees 1 year ago
@heyheymonkees you are SO correct. Now they just have legal fundraisers and buy votes in congress and the senate.
jackkedrabbit 1 year ago
@Astrithor poverty has a direct link to the cruelty and violence humans are capable of, the last few generations had plenty, more then any before them, they had no reason or motivation for violence and have become soft. But as you see on the corrupt news every day now, times are changing, poverty and fear are moving into the american daily life like a wild fire, violence will follow. A wolf who just ate will avoid you, a hungry wolf will rip you apart, there are a lot more hungry wolves now.
BigChiefWiggles 1 year ago
@BigChiefWiggles Great point obvious as it may be but they will not address this hear. They haven't once admitted that poverty led to this fighting. In fact the guy at the beginning insisted that the irish "wanted" to live in the five points.
ITHEREONETHATHASNT 11 months ago
@Astrithor Wait until poverty takes over america in the coming years. We havent evolved that much as a people. Wealth keeps people in check and when it goes east to china americans will start fighting again.
ITHEREONETHATHASNT 11 months ago
Thank you so much for the UpLoads! awesome!!!
trashman1guy 1 year ago
Good stuff boyoo.
oldsreo 1 year ago
Wow!
Barclay1987 1 year ago
wow....life seems crazy now. but not in comparison to this!
ringbolt9 1 year ago
Great upload!
Watching this after the Scorsese flick really makes me respect his film-making. Although he dramatised certain parts of the film (as is his right - it's a movie after all) he really nailed loads of the important details of this era in New York's history.
OpT1mU5PrYm3 2 years ago 8
@ 2:24
I think Scorcese makes a slight verbal gaffe. He says Tammany Hall went up to the 1950s-60s -- this can't be right, can it?
I believe he means 1850s-60's until the downfall of Tweed.
mikepalomino 2 years ago
Tammany Hall refers to a Democratic Party organisation in NY.
I think it ceased activities in the 1960s.
lamenzies 2 years ago 2
Ah, yeah I guess my assumption was that Tammany Hall ended with Boss Tweed. Good to know.
Thank you. : ]
mikepalomino 2 years ago
Tammany controlled patronage and politics of new york until 1960 after kennedy became president.
ITHEREONETHATHASNT 2 years ago
The last Tammany Hall boss was Carmine Gerard DeSapio. Wikipedia has more info on it.
ferrer65 2 years ago
Scorcese had it pretty bang on... wicked thanx.
EVILTRIPS666 2 years ago 5
Awsome documentary,Thank you very much!!!
Alos21 2 years ago 11
No Worries. Thanks for your comment.
Docmate 2 years ago
not a single social movement covered in this. just all immigrant mobs and benevolent state reformers.
bjarczyk 2 years ago
These immigrant mobs you refer to controlled voting, patronage etc in new york for two hundred years so yeah I would say it covered a social movement. Not everything in life can be clear cut these mobs were what today would be called political action committees.
ITHEREONETHATHASNT 2 years ago
Truly great !!! So Tweed had a similar arrest to this of Louis XVI a hundred year before: taken by its portrait ! Does anyone know where I could found some pics about NYC archaelogical excavations in Five points ? I saw some very few ones and it seems that the ground of 1863 is meters under the present street level because of land fulfillings.
1y 2 years ago 6
Very interesting !
I read the book by Herbert Asbury and I favorited all 4 parts... Thanks for upload.
usbfish 2 years ago 5
interesting documentary
glaxev 2 years ago 3
excellent post- i watched all 4 parts.
platinumrecluse 3 years ago 12
thanks mate
Docmate 3 years ago
Same
Greg78X 3 years ago 3