【PV】月のかけら / ベッキー・クルーエル

[Nocchidesu4]

They cant really sing....but the music is nice

[lilosweet24]

I Think my Dinner Will Came Up Now!! From Down There =____="

[BJVIP21]

I think they are all cute! :D

[VanillaCream10001]

bad autotuned =.=

[pipoot22]

Why I feel this pv is so long -,-

[Minisuka12]

*-*

[sammyxsaysxboo]

miku-wannabe

[YoYonpi]

0:26 I like this girl ^^

But all they're awesome

[GChiKaraKai]

my ears are bleeding, SHE HAS TO HAVE MUCH MORE SINGING LESSONS!!! AND she has a strange accent.. -__-"

[Minisuka12]

(y)

[torochan281]

Bad dancer!!! It's make them become silly and also not suitable w this song!!!!

[Reikko8]

I actually think her accent is cute, but this video isn't that nice

[Calmthemtits]

She needs more better vocal lessons and needs to get the japanese accent down better. Nice attempt, though.

[XxsaixX1]

these are two girls right ?? not just one girl O.o

[YoYonpi]

@XxsaixX1 these are 3 girl ^^

0:18 , 1:45 Beckii Cruel

0:26 , 2:06 Gemma Cruel

0:35 , 2:24 Sarah Cruel

[berriiakb]

this is so cute ^_____^

[TheGDRAGONLOVE]

They can't even sing. And the MV is so stupid. And what's with the dancing? No offence.

[thaihoa192]

anyway i wanna fuck her

[BLoodyALiceXseriX]

...why is her rponounciation so off XD

[thaihoa192]

đồ con lai

[Tmarsev]

@thaihoa192: hybrid and so what?

be gentle...

[vytaylorswift]

your move not good. u should have another move greater than this.This move so ugly. u beautiful but have more move greater ok



[vytaylorswift]

i dont want saying anything to u because i saw u sang great but dance not cool much. the voce u just like japan song. ok.i angree but u should practice more

[Tmarsev]

I like this song

the best japanese song I've ever heard

anybody has the HD version?

[LuckySmileage]

I like the girl at 0:38 ,I don't like Gemma's voice and Emotion ,nor Beckii's they seem like they're trying to look at words far away ,but the girl at 0:38 ,I think she's idol worthy :)

[vocaliod12]

luckyyyy i wanna be in japan

[aszx61013]

好想看看他們的男友

[12strawberrylover]

I just realised that there are actually three different girls in this vid...*facepalm*

[TheBlueBelochka]

This would be less awkward if her face expressed the feeling of the song too...

[Jeneshisu3]

Lindas niñas pero...x__x Wuak que feas voces ... oh por dios! la chica del minuto 0:37 si mejore su voz puede irle bien...pero wuak!!

[maymay1889]

the song is very nice but they shouldn't sing all together ...

[bubbamax1990]

i think this song is rather nice, and obviously that japanese dude picked them because many japanese people liked their image and didnt mind there singing. if Japanese peeps can try to be british/american or black, then whats wrong if she tries to behave like an anime character? no offense to anyone here, but please stop hating on them or being jealous that you cant be in there place, okay?

[Yoshuayovel]

@bubbamax1990 Their are different kinds of i-dolls in Japan. We don't necessarily need to enjoy vocalists. There broken voices are just the natural side of our i-dolls. No one is perfect. And we willingly accept their voices.

[JrockNerd]

@bubbamax1990

I don't really give a shit, but they obviously sound like shit, and It's not a question of preference, both pronunciation-wise and singing. If you can speak any Japanese, you'd hear they most likely don't even know what the F they are trying to sing, and the singing? Geez... compare it to anybody who can actually sing, you would have to be tone-deaf as shit to like this.

[JrockNerd]

@bubbamax1990

The issue is not that It's a foreign person doing a Japanese song, there are plenty of great artists that are really good, see Monkey majik etc.

Now there's some real artists.

There's also a lot of others that deserve a chance much more than this complete bullshit.

[bubbamax1990]

@JrockNerd

yes i know that their may be other bands that have more talent then this lot, but they didnt get a chance so tough. there's no need to cyber-bully and troll on these girls just because you dont like there work.

[JrockNerd]

@bubbamax1990

Cyberbully? Lol

Stating the obvious truth will do them nothing but good, but sadly I bet they give jack shit about what people think.

Because if they did they wouldn't keep doing this so called music, and "work" has got to be the fucking overstatement of the year, really.

Maybe It's not their fault as much as the retard that gave them some kind of contract, but equal hatred to them all for unleashing this abomination on the world, peace out! : )

[bubbamax1990]

@JrockNerd

you bet, yep, so true. couldnt agree more. I KNOW RIGHT!!! golly, your so correct about everything! *sighs* i know, you took the words out of my mouth.

bye-bye, live a good, long life.

[KLucy194]

o_ô

[3lTip0]

tipica hijita de papa con plata y sus amiguitas ¬¬ por favor ELLA NO ES CANTANTE!!!! D:

sus voses estan muy arregladas, pendeja con suerte!

[TheBobyboy24]

I KNOW MUTE PEOPLE THAT SPEEEK BETTER JAPANESE THAN HER!!!!

[swaggbaybe]

She doesn't fit in with Japanese 

[takarlor12]

wtf This was so bad i thought it was a Paraody :l

[swaggbaybe]

@takarlor12 ikr i was like wtf is this!

[MultiVivianH]

Well, I can sing Japanese

[MultiVivianH]

I really love it

[TheKupoQueen]

Their voices aren't bad...they just look Bored.

Horrible acting like you'd see in a crappy Drag Queen.

[Sariface18]

ahhh controversy, comments are fun to read

[Chaeromanie]

I don't get why people are complaining? Sure, it sounds like shit. But most idols can't sing to save their lives, either, and sound like complete crap. Is it because they're white and weeaboos get pissed, when non-Japanese people, other than themselves, of course, copy Japanese popculture?

[Edenilium]

people really got nothing to do but criticize teenaged girls? pathethic........

[poppneko]

it might be nice if i sang this xD

[NixiieOlaa]

my ears are fucking ruined now.

[AmberPANDA15]

She really can't sing. I am sorry, even if her dancing was the best in the world (Which I don't think it is) she shouldn't be singing, she is terrible at it. And the video, it is just trying to copy other styles, and it doesn't suit the song.

[VocaloidsAreMyWorld]

I must be a masochist D: 

[Namikori]

are there 3 girls? :D or less :D

[jazzybaby449]

@Iantheparty what I'm saying is that I think it's werid that a non jappanese person is trying to be jappanese when their not.

[ChocobosAteMyBrain]

nothing spectacular, but they are only, what, 14, 15 years old in this mv? people shouldn't be so critical. they're doing their best and they're enjoying themselves. you can't expect the same kind of quality and expertise from kids as what you'd expect from beyonce or lady gaga, or even japanese artists like wakeshima kanon or utada hikaru :/

[jazzybaby449]

She just basically comes across as a try hard white British girl trying to be jappanese when she's not, shes being someone she isn't and can never be, it's just so fucked up.

[Iantheparty]

@jazzybaby449 If it was a Japanese girl trying to sing a song in English, would you tell her the same thing?

[InsideJokesloll]

@jazzybaby449 Because of the way she looks? I wonder if people will ever stop judging people by how they dress or their skin colour.

[jazzybaby449]

A white girl trying to act like she's jappanese? Oh please.

[zuz423]

@jazzybaby449 yes sooo stupid

[smukase]

i cant wait for white ppl to take over japan. then maybe those deluded japanese will start making anime that is more asian. i mean it fucking pisses me off, their anime is full of white kids yet they r alway going "no gaijin, no gaijin" like crazy little retards. u hear that white ppl, go take care of them next!!! XD

[haleyjellygirl]

They don't sing very well. But deal with it, haters! People should respect their hard-works, not make fun of them!! How cruel u are for using those bad words to comment about them! Shame on those people! This PV is beautiful and the song is cute anyway! :)

[silkroadonline123123]

will she can sing maybe but some one have to say ue moves rly suck u can learn dancing maybe???

[gene397]

congratulations for this song ... belle chorégraphie thank's ... HAPPY NEW YEAR to you and your sisters ... from FRANCE

[MaryMonsterKiddo]

At least here Beckii's pronounciation is much beter than in the Danjo song ^^ but the clip is aweful... bad lipsync, trying to be sexy or something like it, some parts are like... emotionless and some are super (fake) happy... but like I said before, I respect it that they're doing what they like no matter what people say :3

[xHimeYuna]

I went to this page to dislike. I thought I'd be the only one..

[Aikokeki]

WTFFFFFFFFFFFFFF D:

[TheKomakii]

They're not very good at singing and dancing, watching other idols... They're like those who send covers on youtube. OMG and some youtubers are better.

[chizzygirl18]

i really wish they alll had great voices....the song is fantastic but their voices did not get it to it's full potential...nice effort though

[6ftdwn]

@chizzygirl18 agree with you...the song is very nice but the singing is not that good...

[luciaxxalph]

see i really hate beckii and i diddnt think she was good at singing and danceing but i somehow like this song

[kvxrock]

MATENSE !!!! JILAS KULIAS!!!!!!!

[BittenBiscuit]

Its actually not bad...

[JejeNyaan]

For me HelloPeachS has the most potential her voice stands out and her pronuciation is so much better than that of gemma or even bekki.

[CosplayCrazy]

what ever happened to those two?

[thomasthaott]

i didnt totally hate this. hmmm not bad not bad.

[CallMoiE]

im sorry but who are theses girls?

[Oaksmanor]

@CallMoiE She is Beckii Cruel

[gladitsnotme]

NOBODY TOUCH THE LIKE DISLIKE BAR

[JaejoongPrincess]

@gladitsnotme I just did. That is not real talent. I see no talent in her dancing and singing. Anybody can do what she dose. Of course people who like her will say she has talent "she can sing, she can dance" and never admit how bad she really is.

[gladitsnotme]

@JaejoongPrincess Okay, you missed the point. It was perfectly 118/118. NOW THE SYMMETRY IS RUINEDDDD!! Y U NO KEEP SYMMETRY?!?! lol

[gene397]

Mademoiselle Cruel ,What is the titre of your song ..? it pleases me very much ..! thank's  from FRANCE

[gene397]

quel est le titre de la chanson ..? Merci ...

[RosiiDesu]

@gene397 Tsuki no kakera ! ^^

[gene397]

@RosiiDesu thank's for the responce bye ...

[69misseli]

Beckii's voice is horrible ! OMFG >.< XDDDD

[samxlili]

@69misseli She's working on her Japanese~ You have to understand, she's from Britain. :/

[69misseli]

@samxlili Okay, I understand but she sings very bad D:

[sapphire9495]

Honestly the third one that sings sounds pretty good.

[samxlili]

It's the new Perfume girls! :D

[BittenBiscuit]

@samxlili No..Perfume ARE WAY BETTER THEN THEY ARE!

[tomaszbogusz1974]

Cool !!!

[kazukkoi]

but they're not singing lol xd and they can pronounce japanese but they dont put the effort c:

[sofi1290]

the song is ok, but the video is lame

[Sayuriku]

@MaluaMakingMayhem LOL

[StrawberryAbbey06]

I think the second girl is pretty =]

[hihi2230]

PAH rich girls get there own music videos....she a copier of Japanese idols. her voice is FUCKING ITCHED UP!!! if she had talent she would sing in her own voice

[LukaMikuru03]

**yawns*

[xmitsxtax]

So... People, I'm from Germany and there's a Singer called Lena Meyer Landrut, and all People lover her but her English is terrible. For example she says "die" instead of "day". Maybe you know her fron Eurovision Song contest. I think this song is cute, but a bit autotuned, but thats their style at all.

[PlasticNotes]

Anyone hear Teto? Not bad a song but a bit err... auto tuned.

[youmakemewannalala21]

what it sounds like is that they're just reading lines off a paper. there's no feeling in their singing

[fuwapan]

I like how the people who judge them always seem to be fat anime obsessed westerners.

Being Japanese myself, I think they are doing well. They are in Japan for a reason, you know. We chose them.

[hihi2230]

@fuwapan not all westerners are fat. how could you be so mean. your horrible.

[fuwapan]

@hihi2230

Oh, since when did I say ALL westerners are? Point it out then we can continue this discussion.

[bubbamax1990]

@fuwapan

LMAO! hhaahah you go girl. and i agree totally!

[Mryanmika]

are they singers in japan ?? O.O thats rare

[Sayuriku]

@MaluaMakingMayhx uhh..same goes for you, random dancing girl. I don't even think you know basic Japanese. Keep lipsyncing. 

[bambiywea]

彼の歌を聞くことは恐ろしいコンピュータの声です。

[xColdNostalgia]

beckii is gorgeous. sad this song isnt

[m1o4752]

Whatever Bros I applaud all attempts at embracing Japanese culture and the 2D world. And truthfully they aren't all that far from lady gaga and kasha who people rant and rave about all the time because they are soooo "good."

Also, I'm sure this video and auto tuning was harder to make than it looks by the way.

[kairinaminemix]

I honestly hate to say this because i believe in the bottom in my heart they are good people but they just cannot sing "well." Sorry

[sooziezoo]

@kairinaminemix who cares whether or not they are good people? you can't even make that assumption about a person watching a hastily crafted music video. however, it is very true that they cannot sing well. their dancing skills and songwriting skills are very questionable as well.

[kairinaminemix]

@sooziezoo I'm just trying not to be hater and say this as lightly as possible...

PLEASE! I was about to even say they're the weaboo version of Rebecca Black. but nobody deserves feel hated. Thanks for making this heavy :P

[sooziezoo]

@kairinaminemix -_- you get the participation award.

[sailorsolidersfan1]

how are these girls idols? they are terrible, sing so unnatural and don't look like they are enjoying singing

[sailorsolidersfan1]

SOUNDS SO UNNATURAL

[sailorsolidersfan1]

THEY R TERRIBLE

[atikuchiPi]

this song is definitely catchy but their voice totally murdered the whole song.....i admit that they are pretty but no offence they just cant sing

[joshvargas2]

Its funny because in England they are social rejects

[Traxine]

OMG some people are OVER-CRITICAL, I like this song.

[Kimi21796]

@Traxine same here its a good song

[Kimi21796]

Ok people who keep complaining about there pronouncing that's how they were TOLD to say it >__> god now leave the poor girls alone they were told to sing it that way and remember there not Japanese they have there own accents so it is another reason they pronounce it wrong anyone ever think about that huh?

[ButterflyUta]

@Kimi21796 Good point.

Too bad they can't sing e ue

[AznKpopLuvr]

I wish they had better voices, less autotune, and had better pronunciation.

Ugh.

I don't care if whites speak Japanese, I mean, I'm white and am learning Korean, it's just.. FUCKING LEARN TO PRONOUNCE THE WORDS CORRECTLY! >_<

Especially if you're going to be an "idol" there... learn the language dipsies. -_-

[Sayuriku]

@AznKpopLuvr I agree completely. Otherwise people won't take you seriously. I mean even here in the US it's "WE'RE AMERICAN. SPEAK ENGLISH". Some places won't serve you if you don't speak English well

-____- Geno's in Philly for example.

[bit0213]

可愛いよね。

[bubbamax1990]

im sorry if this offends a large audience, but to be honest i think the japanese and american-japanese-wannabes-tha­t-think-they-are-truly-autheni­c's think that they are really special now, just because there culture is more popular now, and loads of people are getting in the groove of it. it really annoying, even japanese people that do japanese dances looks like retards so i dunno what they're complaining about.

[18Wolfram]

for me, the third girl is the best among the three

[UchuujuuHoshi]

Those T's are killing me. Either way it's still a good song. Maybe without the auto tune it would've been better. But that's all I have to say :U

[childofreletivity]

If they gave'em all lessons in Japanese I think everything would be far better :)

[TheGalaxyStars]

I love the sound of this song I wish someone could make a cover. But I think they should learn to pronounce the words better. Anyways this was really good :)

[oddmaggie]

Beckii Is the prettiest and has the best voice!

[tikiyu100]

Monster Jehovah woman.

she should die soon.

[AnnaTFan]

I like how people judge there pronouncing because they are white girls.

When you hear asian people sing in english that dont speak it, I never hear anyone say how bad it is.

These girls are cute and they are fine with their singing.

Just let them have fun!.

[MegaOverCross]

@AnnaTFan Cause most of the Asian that do a western cover pronounce each word precise.

[MsMixedVegetables]

OH MY GOOD GODDDDDD. THE PRONUNCIATIOOOOOOOOONNNNNNNNN

[SakuraXmanga1]

haha u know what?, these voices were automated. You know why because they are horrible singers...well mainly be....-cki(ugh) truthfully i didnt just make this up it completely true

[TheTorisen]

she cant sing :´(

[sachikosan100]

Gemma kawaii

[CuteLemonpie]

the voices dont fit, this is a nice song, maybe some singing lessons for those girls would help.. autotune cant make miracles

[gene397]

beaucoup de progrés depuis l'année derniere..! congratulations to you miss cruel

[Hahapancakes]

The video was awkward to watch, even alone. It was just weird.

[jevanni0611]

This is completely autotuned.

[Jumonji41]

waaadduuufuuuugg is thiss?

is she suppose to be...dancing?

[angiijay]

wow fml, lol at the autotune, what are they famous for?

[soymilkmilk]

WTF is this?

[McCaffreySnuggleCat]

このは私の一番好きなベッキー歌です！

[relive22]

beautiful song.i became sad.

[Sayuriku]

Ugh this was slaughtered. D: Rule no. 1 of singing in Japanese: DON'T PRONOUNCE YOUR T's. Rule no. 2: learn to pronounce. Sarah is the least grating of the three. Arg! all their pronounciation is atrocious! and the autotune D: save meeeee! how are these girls idols?!

[Iantheparty]

@Sayuriku That don't pronounce your T's rule doesn't always apply to every word, just saying.

[Sayuriku]

@Iantheparty In this, it does. This whole thing just screams of awkwardness.

[bubbamax1990]

@Sayuriku

jealous much? its not as if japanese people pinpoint english pronunciations in their songs. ¬_¬

[Sayuriku]

@bubbamax1990 There's a difference. Japanese singers typically don't market their songs for America, and the ones that have (Kuraki Mai, Utada Hikaru, etc) haven't really made much of an impact sadly. This is marketed for the Japanese. Don't you think it would be in their best interest to actually learn how to pronounce the language? I'm not jealous. Just appalled and embarrassed at this atrocity.

[bubbamax1990]

@Sayuriku

they are most likely trying there best. i'll admit that some of beckii's songs are not very good, but this one is nice, and its irritating how people think they are the master's of japanese and keep on being horrible to her about it. if japan itself like these songs then theres nothing to complain about. if you say so.

[Sayuriku]

@bubbamax1990 she charted at number 47 for her first week and sold less than 2k singles. Clearly Japan itself doesn't like these songs. I'm not being "horrible to her about it". The only thing horrible is the autotune and mismashed Japanglish. That's her own fault and it's up to her to work it if she wants to improve. She's worked on her singing, but it's terrible. By the way, I'm 16, studied Japanese in COLLEGE for 3 years. I'm far from a master, but I'm closer than what Beckii will ever be.

[bubbamax1990]

@Sayuriku

thankyou for the numbers, i thought japan itself liked them because many japanese people say they do. i agree that when speaking other languages you have to adapt to the accent and stuff too, but i think some people are just trying to act way to authentic here. well good for you, congratulations, no, really, have a good life, but just try not to act like your the big boss of japanese. :)

[Sayuriku]

@bubbamax1990 Jesus christ. You don't understand anything, heck you can't even speak proper english. Stop taking everything personally. You aren't Beckii. By the way, you can't substantiate the claim that "many Japanese people say they do". The numbers speak for themselves. Beckii = Under 2k for a first single. Utada Hikaru's first single : 772,080 Leah Dizon's first single: 48,554 melody's first single: 20,054 Ito Yuna's first single: 471,099 Cristal Kay's first single: 19,990. ALL FOREIGNERS.

[bubbamax1990]

@Sayuriku

i understand alot. i can speak great english, i just cant be bothered to use the queen's language and grammer on here where words are limited. i know im not beckii, and your not the judge of japanese music. can you stop talking about how much music sells in japan please, my point is that it annoys me when people keep on getting depressed that these girls dont have perfect japanese, and that they dont deserve their fame etc etc.

[Sayuriku]

@bubbamax1990 Nowhere did I state any of that. Your arguments make no sense. I'm not depressed because "these girls dont have perfect japanese and they dont deserve their fame etc etc." It shouldn't annoy you that my opinion differs from yours. I can be the judge of Japanese music. Why? Because anyone can judge music and in my opinion, this is absolute garbage. I'm surprised they managed a short contract deal when they did, and their 15 minutes of fame is already up.

[Sayuriku]

@bubbamax1990 My point is that your point is invalid because I just proved that Beckii isn't popular in Japan. With the universal language of science, aka NUMBERS.

[bubbamax1990]

@Sayuriku

my point is valid because its my opinion, you dont always have to have science and history books to be right about something, or have to right to say what you feel. well believe what you will darlink, theres no point in discussing anything with people that worship 'numbers' and all of these proofs they've gathered, they can never stick to common sense you see. ¬_¬

well goodbye =)

[Sayuriku]

@bubbamax1990 You claimed that Beckii is popular in Japan. That's not an opinion. How do you measure popularity? The only solid proof is numbers. I disproved your claim.

Common sense is derived from science. Otherwise whe