@360Wilhtekz to answer your question it can be live because back then people had talent and passion not a machine to do all the work and counting the days to the next pay check (which they dont deserve)
phil collins is amazing being only 14 some finid it odd i acctually know who phil collins is its sad thats why i thank my mom for raisign me of songs from the 80's and 90's i personally like music like this better than todays
Was this in Tampa stadium on May 17th, 1992? Can anyone clarify this for me? If I have the right video, this was my first concert ever. I just turned 10 years old at the time and he cancelled the show because of a sore throat. I remember riots and police and on the way back to the car, I broke a beer bottle. lol
i got a kid ,his 6 years old,his mum was the love of my life but she dicide to move far away but i couldn,t follow her and know she is married with another man, she sais her hasband love my son..but he is not son of his..every time i hear this song i think about him...
Heard this on LAST FM when I selected Roger Waters for my musical theme artist! Cool, eh!? I can sing this song, ya know?! Forgotten recent classic. I wondered if this was autobiographical, not really aware
@titantrons1211 - I know, I lived it too. I'm 50, and I still carry the weight, but I try to put it down every now and again. Mine split when I was 4.
its been tough finally being able to listen through the entire song. when ever it would come on the air i would always have to change it. i read your post titan and i have never posted to any of these sites but wanted to let you know that it will get better and be strong. i grew up in the southwest on a ranch and my mother left me and my younger brother when i was 8. my father was gone 40 weeks out of the year. when he got into drugs he lost his gig and spent it at home taking it out on me.
physically my body was a war zone but mentally i was broken. mental abuse is in my opinion the worst there is. titan talk to people let them know whats going on and hang in. wish you the best
Ist glaub echt schwierig so einen Menschen zu hassen. Seine Genialität und die Perfektion. Der Mann ist einfach großartig. Und ein großer Teil von Genesis. Best thanks for this Video,
You don't think you can overcome the pain. It is so overwhelming. But you can defeat it... You must< this cannot be the end... You must overcome it...
...and I need a place where i could hide somwehere I could mine...
I love this song even if is so sad ...reminds me when I had some problems with my dad...(not the same problems like the song says ) and so when I listened No son of mine, I cried a lot.
Of course now between me and my dad things are GREAT!!!!
@Ripplessa something about life... Phil is for many , too many people a great man , not only a great musician ...♥ I passed all day before celebrating his birthday alone and listening their songs...I love him too...! and GENESIS TOO MUCH ♥
@Ripplessa fully agree its a wonderfull track fuck these music by the mob followers if it says something to u about ur life then thats 100% true to you & great music. My dad died in March, lots unresolved.
...einfach nur schön...
Felina41196 1 day ago
How the hell can this be live?! PHIL, you are and will always be THE FUCKING BEST!!<3
360Wilhtekz 1 week ago
@360Wilhtekz to answer your question it can be live because back then people had talent and passion not a machine to do all the work and counting the days to the next pay check (which they dont deserve)
luisg13571 6 days ago
phil collins is amazing being only 14 some finid it odd i acctually know who phil collins is its sad thats why i thank my mom for raisign me of songs from the 80's and 90's i personally like music like this better than todays
chloeisfuzzycute 2 months ago
God what a sad song. So wonderful.
mbatl0907 4 months ago in playlist Genesis (1992), The Way We Walk
As usual the sound person forgets the keyboards
grantfoster1 5 months ago 2
It is a truth, universally acknowledged, that Phil Collins is amazing.
TopGearFanForever 6 months ago
This song has made a lot of people cry.
UserUnfriendly21 6 months ago
Was this in Tampa stadium on May 17th, 1992? Can anyone clarify this for me? If I have the right video, this was my first concert ever. I just turned 10 years old at the time and he cancelled the show because of a sore throat. I remember riots and police and on the way back to the car, I broke a beer bottle. lol
MrRustyWaters 6 months ago in playlist Top
@MrRustyWaters I think this is either Wembley or Knebworth.
LightHeartuk 2 months ago
@MrRustyWaters This clip is from the Earls Court show (in London), filmed at the time for VHS release, and now available on DVD.
MattSingh1 1 month ago
that's great music
NoxProphetha 6 months ago
Phil is more better than Gabriel
noe71000 7 months ago
@noe71000 different not better
grantfoster1 5 months ago
I love this song so much
WissamTheLebanese 8 months ago
Excellent song!First of my favourite song!
MoonWalker778 8 months ago
Excellent song!Second of my favorite songs!
MoonWalker778 8 months ago
live 1992 i was a baby at t time not i ma 18
1garriran 9 months ago
This is filmed from the Genesis Goodbye tour I LOVE GENESIS
robloxMATTY1319 9 months ago
This is filmed from the Genesis Goodbye tour
robloxMATTY1319 9 months ago
can you please tell me where was this concert? TANKS
PatoOlivera 10 months ago
I think like Ozzy Osbourne, eventually Phil will hit the road on his own RETIREMENT SUCKS tour! or No More Tours tour?? hahaha
MetallicBill 11 months ago
8 minutes for just a three chords bullshit ? Gabriel kill them all!
svanur75 11 months ago
@svanur75 Gabriel's a putz. Team Phil.
BettinaBalser 10 months ago
@svanur75 umadbro?
dole2011 10 months ago
tak ,tak,tak, tak właśnie tak wyglądają prawdziwi goście !!!!!!!!!
darekzlasu 1 year ago
Thank's.
Tune was Here!
TuneLoony61 1 year ago
i got a kid ,his 6 years old,his mum was the love of my life but she dicide to move far away but i couldn,t follow her and know she is married with another man, she sais her hasband love my son..but he is not son of his..every time i hear this song i think about him...
sparta091 1 year ago
@sparta091 Shit dude im srry thats hardcore pain and i step dads are shit compaired to your real dad
tanyao1962 11 months ago
@tanyao1962 Wouldn't know because I'm adopted, but my "dad" is pretty tough, he's not a "big softy"
MetallicBill 11 months ago
the live version sounds almost exactly alike the album version. amazing song, by far one of my favorite songs i have literally ever heard in my life.
Dan100496 1 year ago
this is real music ! the children today dont know real music!
the teen stars cant sing live!
sry for my bad english... ;)
phil collins, joes cocker,michael jackson & Co 4 ever
Befiboy1 1 year ago 2
this is so awesome:)
barbj7121 1 year ago
Heard this on LAST FM when I selected Roger Waters for my musical theme artist! Cool, eh!? I can sing this song, ya know?! Forgotten recent classic. I wondered if this was autobiographical, not really aware
MetallicBill 1 year ago
Epic awesomeness!
Lana181 1 year ago
one of my many great songs sprung out from Phil/ Genesis, dont know where we would be without them.
maxthemother 1 year ago
Thanx!!!!
samsaugen 1 year ago
Thank you for posting this
GeckoCA 1 year ago
Bravissimo !!!
xr250toni 1 year ago
Ich liebe dieses Lied. (:
LauralovesAvatar 1 year ago 4
Sounds unbelievably good for a live performance!
samsamba08 1 year ago
I love the guitar sound they use in the intro. How did they come up with that? I've tried replicating it, and haven't had much luck.
shaskaraven 1 year ago 5
@shaskaraven
It's a sample taken from random noise generated by Mike's guitar during a recording session of the We Can't Dance album. Don't worry about it.
Shiesen 1 year ago 3
@Shiesen The band has officially christened that sound "Elephantus" - which was the original working title of No Son of Mine. :)
SPeacock 1 year ago
@shaskaraven The sound came from Mike bending two strings/notes together during the recording of the album circa March-October 1991.
MattSingh1 1 year ago 6
@shaskaraven That might be the synthesizer.
4rlorenti 5 months ago
@shaskaraven Its a sample, not a guitar
Obelisk2290 2 months ago
@Obelisk2290 It's actually a sample of a guitar piece.
MattSingh1 1 month ago
@MattSingh1 I know this
Obelisk2290 1 month ago
@titantrons1211 - I know, I lived it too. I'm 50, and I still carry the weight, but I try to put it down every now and again. Mine split when I was 4.
sean3415 1 year ago
living through this right now. hoping i wont wake up in the morning.
Titantrons1211 1 year ago
Comment removed
TRUEBLOOD352 1 year ago
its been tough finally being able to listen through the entire song. when ever it would come on the air i would always have to change it. i read your post titan and i have never posted to any of these sites but wanted to let you know that it will get better and be strong. i grew up in the southwest on a ranch and my mother left me and my younger brother when i was 8. my father was gone 40 weeks out of the year. when he got into drugs he lost his gig and spent it at home taking it out on me.
TRUEBLOOD352 1 year ago
physically my body was a war zone but mentally i was broken. mental abuse is in my opinion the worst there is. titan talk to people let them know whats going on and hang in. wish you the best
TRUEBLOOD352 1 year ago
EN VIVO
jorgealbertobaron 1 year ago
Ist glaub echt schwierig so einen Menschen zu hassen. Seine Genialität und die Perfektion. Der Mann ist einfach großartig. Und ein großer Teil von Genesis. Best thanks for this Video,
Stefan
Bastelmike 2 years ago
This is why the arts run my life
Obelisk2290 2 years ago
I have to learn it for English oO
I didn´t like it but now I do xD
It´s great! ^.^
CMPunkSuchti 2 years ago
die stimme ist einfach der hammer..
ochsnfisel 2 years ago 8
You don't think you can overcome the pain. It is so overwhelming. But you can defeat it... You must< this cannot be the end... You must overcome it...
mundrubjet 2 years ago
Wrong song Soran!!!
Great tune and a good performance!
kya1260am 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This song was done for Eric Clapton when he lost his 5 years old son falling down 4 stores from the balcony of a hotel.
It was very sad. The only son Eric Clapton had.
soranB55 2 years ago
no no tht was 'since i lost you'..
xman090909 2 years ago
Wrong song dork!
kya1260am 2 years ago
Check out Mike's solos. very cool
TheElusiveBirdMan 2 years ago
...and I need a place where i could hide somwehere I could mine...
I love this song even if is so sad ...reminds me when I had some problems with my dad...(not the same problems like the song says ) and so when I listened No son of mine, I cried a lot.
Of course now between me and my dad things are GREAT!!!!
I love you Phil!!!...and Genesis Too
P.S Sorry for my english
Ripplessa 2 years ago 28
@Ripplessa something about life... Phil is for many , too many people a great man , not only a great musician ...♥ I passed all day before celebrating his birthday alone and listening their songs...I love him too...! and GENESIS TOO MUCH ♥
genesisinsideme 2 years ago
I'm totally agree:-)
Ripplessa 2 years ago
@Ripplessa fully agree its a wonderfull track fuck these music by the mob followers if it says something to u about ur life then thats 100% true to you & great music. My dad died in March, lots unresolved.
tranmer3 1 year ago
This is a good song.
rockmonkey11 3 years ago 18