Robert Winston meets Lucy

[Aheadstix85]

Im an orderly, and BULLSHIT!, Lucy was a fake, i have seen two documentarys on how they faked her, scientists could make her walk upright so they sawed off a nub of bone on her hip, so she looked like she could walk upright, it was a fake mate, deal with it, just like all the others, i have extensive reports on it and everything, you have been lied to, plus there is a vid on you tube called "Lucy, she no lady".

[Aheadstix85]

You miss my point, the fact is Lucy was fabricated from a range of sources not even anything to do with where her remains where found, there was not enough evidence to give a deep analogy of her, and yes working in a hospital i do know about anatomy, i also know that there are no tags on freshly dug up bones that say "this was a ape man blah blah" , scientists assume the rest, and just go look up Hoax missing links, Lucy, its not hard.

[Ishta5]

@Aheadstix85 what do you do in a hospital? lucy was not a hoax and was 40% complete.

[Aheadstix85]

Ummm?, moron!, lucy is a well known fraud, she was built from bones scattered all over a site, not just one, and most experts agree she was just a 3 foot tall chimp, there is no evidence to link her or any other of the "missing links" to human evolution, and biology proves we have always been human anyway, as the cell proteins develop outside the cell wall, that fact just proves we have allways been humans, and ducks always been ducks.

[NorthForkFisherman]

@Aheadstix85 Again, stix, you need to provide data to prove your point. Your inarticulate ramblings show that you simply don't understand what the issue is. Your profile indicates that you work in a hospital. Haven't you taken a basic anatomy and physiology course? If you had, you would've learned that you can tell a great deal about a person from a single bone, IF you pay attention. And AL 288-1? She's not the only Au. afarensis found. There are hundreds of speciemens.

[Aheadstix85]

Lucy is a fraud!, its been proven!.

[NorthForkFisherman]

@Aheadstix85 A fraud? Really? /sacasm. OK, now all you have to do is prove it. Exactly what are your issues with AL 288-1. Please be specific. I know I will.

[macmitchdog]

G'day all.

Love reading Mr Winstons Books.Great stuff and of course his documentries on DVD, Reading "Human Instinct" at the moment, insightful.

Mitch.

[cathy356]

HaHaHaaHa! AhHaHaHaHa!

[fox408]

(still, cant help thinking that our ancestors would have looked a lot sharper though!)

[Ishta5]

guess looking at tribal culture might be the best way to get the truth

[Aheadstix85]

@fox408 This is crap, they have just found out that neanderthal man was probably smarter than moderman, so this means nothing.

[fox408]

haha, i was sure that there WAS an animal out there somewhere with dirty matted hair n knew it would only be a matter of time before someone set me straight, good work, that was pretty quick!

[fox408]

you will NEVER see an animal in the wild with dirty matted hair, it will be seen as a sign of illness and will be killed or outcast by its own community...every bird and animal has an impeccable appearance...something that is always overlooked by documentary makers attempting to reconstruct early human appearance!

[Ishta5]

ever seen a sloth

[cmsahe]

It's a moving documentary.

[TheDayAt]

fantastic

[roidroid]

Wow, imagine if 10 years old was still average breeding age. It's be nuts!

[Aheadstix85]

@roidroid This is bullshit!, there is no evidence supporting this, her skeleton was less then a quarter complete and they got all this from her??!!!, such a lie!.

[roidroid]

you've studied her?