This is wonderful! I have this '63 Carnegie Hall CD- a "bootleg" disc given to me as an offhand bonus to another Dylan CD i was purchasing. I've enjoyed this one more!
I've always loved this song since I heard it for the very first time as The Byrds' cover-version, back in early 1966. But this is the best version. It's the emotion that is so clear.
This IS the Carnegie Hall 26 October 1963 version. Note that the vision is almost pantheistic, seeing god in nature. Note the structure, verses and chorus the same pattern. What a fabulous song, and this is cleaner than the acetate I've had for ages. D's phrasing is perfect, flawless. I love this.
There is a studio recording of this song. It was included on an Italian bootleg(?) that I owned years ago. If you own a copy, please post it. I listened to the song so many times that I heard it in my sleep so I sold the LP unfortunately.
There is a studio recording of this song. It was included on an Italian bootleg(?) that I owned years ago. If you own a copy, please post it. I listened to the song so many times that I heard it in my sleep soI sold the LP unfortunately.
According to the book "Positively Fourth Street" by David Hadju, Dylan wrote this song while he was living with Joan Baez in California. He suggested that it was about her.
@zzscotty Correct, but this is not the performance from "Biograph." The "Biograph" performance was an outtake from the 1964 album "The Times They Are A-Changin'" I believe this may be from the "Witmark Demos", which were recorded a little earlier. This is IMHO one of Dylan's most beautiful songs in lyric and melody.
@bathroommonkey76
Oh, yeah that's the one I was talking about. But like I said, that's not the full concert & it's out of order.
Rossonero072213 4 months ago
@bathroommonkey76
Was it 'In Concert'? Neither of the full shows has been released. Only certain songs. It sucks.
Rossonero072213 4 months ago
Just brilliant from the poet master,no one can touch this mans genius.
blindingrunt 4 months ago
i love this even more than the studio recording, just perfect :)
TomThumbsBlues1965 4 months ago
i want this played at my funeral.
drinkingpoolwater 6 months ago
@drinkingpoolwater Ok. No problem. We will make sure! Do you have a date set?
Dave897456 6 months ago
Dylan/Sony have to release the Carnegie & the Town Hall concerts soon!
Rossonero072213 6 months ago
I hope that somebody posts the studio version! Please!
Dave897456 6 months ago
This is wonderful! I have this '63 Carnegie Hall CD- a "bootleg" disc given to me as an offhand bonus to another Dylan CD i was purchasing. I've enjoyed this one more!
UTubist512 7 months ago
I've always loved this song since I heard it for the very first time as The Byrds' cover-version, back in early 1966. But this is the best version. It's the emotion that is so clear.
Thanks for posting this! It's wonderful.
ameckst1 7 months ago
Dylan's studio version, as I recollect, is less adventerious in his phrasing. More stately, anthem-like.
spazhat 8 months ago
This IS the Carnegie Hall 26 October 1963 version. Note that the vision is almost pantheistic, seeing god in nature. Note the structure, verses and chorus the same pattern. What a fabulous song, and this is cleaner than the acetate I've had for ages. D's phrasing is perfect, flawless. I love this.
chillroom 9 months ago 9
This IS the Carnegie Hall 26 October 1963 version.
chillroom 9 months ago
This song is played during the closing credits of *No Direction Home*, the Scorcese film from a few years ago. You can get it from iTunes.
laddiemcmasters 9 months ago
@laddiemcmasters Yes-but is that the studio version, or this one?
I thought I knew all of the early Dylan-but hardly a cultist-but never heard this until the Scorsese film-some strartling imagery here
Labienus 9 months ago in playlist DYLAN, Bob
Is this the only recording of the song that Dylan himself did?
This is the unreleased studio? Did he ever sing it in concert?
Labienus 9 months ago
Play this to anyone who says that Dylan can't sing.
lizmil 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
There is a studio recording of this song. It was included on an Italian bootleg(?) that I owned years ago. If you own a copy, please post it. I listened to the song so many times that I heard it in my sleep so I sold the LP unfortunately.
spazhat 11 months ago
There is a studio recording of this song. It was included on an Italian bootleg(?) that I owned years ago. If you own a copy, please post it. I listened to the song so many times that I heard it in my sleep soI sold the LP unfortunately.
spazhat 11 months ago
@bathroommonkey76 humans have to cry at songs that aren't sad?!
degas5000 11 months ago
I stood unwound beneath the skies and clouds unbound by laws, the crying rain like a trumpet sang, and asked for no applause. What a line.
BoobyMcDoogle 1 year ago
Hadju's assumptions are ridiculous.
whetstraw 1 year ago
Fierce and awesome.
quad1000 1 year ago
According to the book "Positively Fourth Street" by David Hadju, Dylan wrote this song while he was living with Joan Baez in California. He suggested that it was about her.
djkovalik123 1 year ago
No voice can hope to hum.
4l4ddin77 1 year ago
Marvelous! Marvelous!
astrolog7000 1 year ago
Wonderful! Makes me cry! So beautiful! Marvelous! It rearranges my brain cells. I don't think I've ever heard such a beautiful song.
astrolog7000 1 year ago
Even the words are beautiful, even without the music. This is pure inspiration. I think it's wonderful, and thanks for posting it.
astrolog7000 1 year ago
where can i find this version? This isn't the one on biograph. I like this one better
21dandandan12 1 year ago
This song is on CD1 of the 3 CD boxed set collection "Biograph." As far as I know, it never appeared on an original album--only on this collection.
zzscotty 1 year ago 2
@zzscotty
this song and in live at canergie hall , 1963
Nicotineuh 1 year ago 4
@Nicotineuh
Thanks for the information.
zzscotty 1 year ago
@zzscotty
Effectivement elle ce trouve aussi dans "biograph" mais ce n'ai pas la même version ;) =)
Celle ci et bien la version qui ce trouve dans live at carnegie hall 1963!
Really it it also finds in " biograph " but it's not the same version .
that her and definitely version of carnegie hall 1963 =)
Désolé pour mon anglais désastreux ^^
Nicotineuh 9 months ago
@zzscotty Correct, but this is not the performance from "Biograph." The "Biograph" performance was an outtake from the 1964 album "The Times They Are A-Changin'" I believe this may be from the "Witmark Demos", which were recorded a little earlier. This is IMHO one of Dylan's most beautiful songs in lyric and melody.
brando92346 6 months ago
@brando92346 Woops, no there's clapping, so it's not Witmark. Carnegie hall?
brando92346 6 months ago
I love this song because it is way beyond beautiful. I give it two thumbs up!!!!
TheJessical1 1 year ago 2
this is my favorite song by dylan... it's just beautiful
zoeruls 1 year ago
Thank you, thank you for this vid! Huge Dylan fan!
puckf17 1 year ago