Very true, this is why people like Lang Lang simply will never be able to play their pieces 'properly'. Even their most 'perfect' renditions are barely vague semblances of the real piece, nothing more than a very unflattering homage.
Not nationality, I mean the ways in which the expression/performance talent is cultivated, the ideas that inform it. Lang Lang sounds like someone who was cultivated to emulate.
I used to think Lang Lang as a big show off, but am very much a fan these days. People do change and improve as they get more life experience. If you rule out people from different culture playing music of other cultures, you might as well say Van Cliburn can't play Tchaikovsky, or Keith Jarrett can't play Jazz.
I,m a pianist myself and never payed much attention to Gilels ,dont ask why .....but hearing these Rachm. interpretations ,I must say:GENIUS. One is never too old to learn new worlds<HA! It takes my breath away,thank you for posting these jewels!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
for a pianist Rachmaninov was one of the best but I just was never so interested in much of Rach s music. Though the preludes and some of the Etudes Tableux are fab.
I always felt most of Rachmaninoff's music was about "somewhere" more than "something." Maybe that is why it is easy to get so lost.
toogoodbw 5 months ago
pure ecstacy... this is real music.
bwv812bwv812 9 months ago
pure ecstacy... this is real music.
bwv812bwv812 9 months ago
This piece reminds me of just laying in the snow relaxing, watching snowflakes fall :DD
MsThisNameIsTaken 11 months ago
Fantastic performation, absolutely fantastic !!!
MadameAmelieSon 11 months ago
Only 102 people were able to come out of the daze after hearing to push the 'like' button.
Yourczarmine 11 months ago
I love Gilels!
Lenochka1107 1 year ago
Gilels was truly brilliant.
1969GibsonL5 1 year ago
dear mr. Gilels, your music means very much to me and I am thankful for it.
I am so sorry you passed away so young.
May you have peace, as you give me peace with your beautiful play.
(R.Metz , from the Netherlands)
mrsmetz1 2 years ago 9
@mrsmetz1
He be dead in peace (died in 1985).
youququq 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mrsmetz1 Pussy
w00densh31ld 1 year ago
if anyone wants to understand the other side of the tipical mayor tones, must listen Rachmaninov...
si cualquiera quisiera entender el otro lado de la tipica musica mayor, debe escuchar Rachmaninov...
aleixenbmsn 2 years ago
on of my favorite preludes...so full of emotions...
ElAurian 2 years ago
@ xGh0stf4c3x Rachmaninov is my favourite pianist of....Rachmaninov...:)
robert140602 2 years ago
If anyone wishes to understand Russia's history, one should listen to Rachmaninov.
TheCrazyHairPianist 3 years ago 16
If anyone wishes to understand Rachmaninov's music, one should listen to Gilels.
libetta 2 years ago 47
If anyone wishes to understand Gilels, uhhh....
Kurtyoungblood 2 years ago 48
if anyone wishes to understand Gilels, look at his face..
jonasbacklund 2 years ago 3
i know it sounds wrong, but i meant his expression
jonasbacklund 2 years ago
...his face expresses very hard work....
DorianGray2005 2 years ago
@libetta One should listen to Rachmaninoff perform first, then listen to Emil Gilels - and a handful of others :-))
Bret6464 6 months ago
Very true, this is why people like Lang Lang simply will never be able to play their pieces 'properly'. Even their most 'perfect' renditions are barely vague semblances of the real piece, nothing more than a very unflattering homage.
AnthemicPolemic 2 years ago 6
I'm not a Lang Lang fan, but what do you actually mean by "people like Lang Lang"?
You telling me that in order to play a piece properly you need to have the same nationality of the composer?
If so, then I should disconsider Richter's recordings of Chopin's Scherzos?
jubulalau 2 years ago 3
Don't be a showoff. idk
seanmcnally 2 years ago
Not nationality, I mean the ways in which the expression/performance talent is cultivated, the ideas that inform it. Lang Lang sounds like someone who was cultivated to emulate.
AnthemicPolemic 2 years ago
I used to think Lang Lang as a big show off, but am very much a fan these days. People do change and improve as they get more life experience. If you rule out people from different culture playing music of other cultures, you might as well say Van Cliburn can't play Tchaikovsky, or Keith Jarrett can't play Jazz.
FlyingMelbournite 2 years ago
(I am not Russian) If anyone wishes to understand Gilels in order to understand Russian history, one should listen to Gilels play Rachmaninov
Then listen to Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture
:-)
TwelfthRoot2 2 years ago
gilels is my favourite pianist for rachmaninoff
xGh0stf4c3x 3 years ago 8
That is so good!!
OldRabit 3 years ago
Poetry.
michanso2 3 years ago 6
I,m a pianist myself and never payed much attention to Gilels ,dont ask why .....but hearing these Rachm. interpretations ,I must say:GENIUS. One is never too old to learn new worlds<HA! It takes my breath away,thank you for posting these jewels!!!
peterlunow 3 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
chad 410 has bad taste. brahms is a joke compared to rachmaninoff.
bachmaninoff 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
for a pianist Rachmaninov was one of the best but I just was never so interested in much of Rach s music. Though the preludes and some of the Etudes Tableux are fab.
chad410 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
im not a huge fan of rachmaninov slightly cheesy music but here one is made to think of it as brahms or Chopin. delicious
chad410 4 years ago
maybe you've listned only bad interpretors till now :)
cccpredarmy 4 years ago 2
well it s true my love for most Russina composers and more is evident however he makes rachmaninov yes perhaps more serious than i thought.
chad410 4 years ago
check out the rach vid i uploaded on my account
4c00h 3 years ago
Don;t call R's music "cheesy," mon dieu.
fmorgana 3 years ago 12