The Band really should be considered national treasures, not just a Canadian treasure but a North American treasure. This is amazing stuff and they don't get nearly the respect or recongnition they deserve. This song just rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!
...pickers out there will be interested to note the metal finger picks on robbie's middle fingers there, working in combo with the flatpick...one of the keys to his angsty, never too-smooth sound...
@Mattiscool771 Festival Express, a documentary featuring awesome performances form The band, Grateful Dead, Buddy Guy, Janis J and others. Highly recommend it!
Is it just my perception, or is Robbie Robbertson the only musician in ANY group who gets bludgeoned repeatedly for not being a vocalist? The three members of The Band who COULD sing exceptionally well shone all the brighter for singing Robbie's lyrics. Creative talent manifests itself in many ways, including but not limited to having a great set of vocal chords.
@Stephanjnj Yeah, but since Band fans are more interested in fighting the Helm-Robertson war than educating others about the group, I guess we're going to have to keep hearing about how he can't sing. Ironically, he does put his voice to good use on songs like "Somewhere Down the Crazy River"
Not really. Whenever I listen to him solo, it seems like he hits the same note over and over. Not to mention he was the one responsible for breaking up the band.
He's not an ace player but many top guys felt he had a lot of soul. He was THE arranger and main writer for The Band so without him they would have been just a backup band playing covers, albeit an immensely talented backup band. |His ego got in the way and it ended The Band, true. His solo stuff sucks IMO but he had a stretch of pure genius there for a while. The Band will never be recreated and I am grateful for RR's contribution to music.
@axwell21 He's capable of a great solo, but some of his others can get somewhat repetitive. He's said that the Dylan influence changed him from focusing mainly on guitar playing to songwriting.
for all the comments abah the vovals robbies mic was always switched off due to his weak voice and lack of confidence what a tune tho RIP RICHARD AND RICK X
Why don't people want to play like this anymore? Am I the only one? There are so few acts that could compete with this, in terms of passion, musicianship (brother Robbie is on fire!), and the beauty in taking such a simple song and just playing the hell out of it... I love these huge singalongs they are able to do (like on "ain't no more cane") where you have all these amazing voices singing at the top of their lungs... Why don't people do this anymore???
You are so right on! Saw The Band several times.... no band rocked better! One of my fav personal music related possesions is a guitar pick Rick gave me.-, right after he gave me a bear hug.
Go see the Cate Brothers live if you can. They have a connection with The Band as well, for those that are not aware. They even play some Band tunes at their shows.
I really don't think that any of robbie's solo stuff sounded anything like the band. It seemed like a group effort to me. Without the band robbie didn't amount to much.
I wonder if Robbie sang just because he thought it was fun, or if he was trying to get the audience to believe he was singing. either way, he isn't audible in most live recordings, and on the ones he is, the vocal harmonies suffer.
He actually used to like singing along with the guys but since he knew that his voice was bad, they turned the mic off. I don't know why he thought so. If you ever hear 'Out of the blue' from the Last Waltz soundtrack (it's not in the movie,) that's actually him singing because no one could find Richard. But it's actually really good.
He sings a bit on the Bastment Tapes, too, which I thought he sounded pretty good on. Check out "Bessie Smith" from the Basement Tapes on here. Good tune with Robbie singing.
Is that right? Robbie sang "Out of the Blue" because Manuel couldn't be found? Well, good for Richard that day, as Robbie did a good job on a great song.
It has been well documented that Robbie would sing into a mic that was not on. In all of their live stuff, Robbie is singing into a dead mic. His voice was terrible but he liked to sing along during live shows. Levon is not the only one to talk about this.
i love Levon, but he is unreasonable. Robbie clearly wrote all the Band's material (he is a songwriter, Levon is not), Robbie doesn't call himself a singer.
Firstly, Robbie did no write all the Band's material. He wrote the vast majority of it, after the first album. But what you say has little or nothing to do with the comment you were responding to. It's as much a fact as Napoleon's defeat at Waterloo that Robbie was singing into a dead mic.
I think Levon's point was that even if Robbie brought the original song in for playing or recording, the other members made enough contributions on many to be considered co-writers.
I know what you are saying and im sure in some cases that is very true. im sure robbie was a bit of an egomaniac and hogged song writing credits on songs that others were involved in but its also perfectly plausable that levon is a bit jealous and bitter in old age having started out as the leader and longest serving member of his band to have been usurped by robbie. also all musicians add their own style to songs they play on but it they didnt write the tune or the words they dont get the $!!
Man, it's nice to see Richard playing up some steaming piano there. It always seems to be Garth who gets the keyboard-limelight, but Richard, man, what a solid contender!
You could tar, feather and drive this group through a car wash while performing, and they would still sound tighter than any band ever. There were no adverse stage conditions their musicianship could not overcome. Their Dylan boot camp days served them well...
I first saw this at the cinema in canterbury, there was only 4 people there but this and janis joplins cry baby is on the festival express to that was brilliant but too. has anyone seen any good black blues vids???
This is soooo great! This was supposed to be their standard encore song, but they never played it when I heard them. There was supposed to be a bootleg version of it floating around in the 70s that everyone wanted to hear, but nobod I knew ever heard it.
Now I only want to hear the original demo version of "Don't Do It."
The Band really should be considered national treasures, not just a Canadian treasure but a North American treasure. This is amazing stuff and they don't get nearly the respect or recongnition they deserve. This song just rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!
TPG3471 2 months ago
絶頂期の演奏ですね。ロビーのソロなんか、気合一発で凄い、迫力ですね。(^v^)
tamura1962 4 months ago
great tune...
74bomayemcfc 5 months ago
people really underrate Robbie robertson but really he has a unique voice theres just some thing different and unheard till the 60's
TheLazZzar 7 months ago
@TheLazZzar His new album is awesome. He sings half decent too. Great guests and his slide work is very very good. Get it!
AngusShanks 7 months ago
...pickers out there will be interested to note the metal finger picks on robbie's middle fingers there, working in combo with the flatpick...one of the keys to his angsty, never too-smooth sound...
fatschlamp1 8 months ago
is this on film????
Mattiscool771 8 months ago
@Mattiscool771 Festival Express, a documentary featuring awesome performances form The band, Grateful Dead, Buddy Guy, Janis J and others. Highly recommend it!
hnh4 8 months ago
I love them all so much it hurts. I've cried myself to sleep thinking about how incredible they are.
rad311 9 months ago
Shit. STILL the best video on the 'Tube.
duanejerry 9 months ago
Very, but very gooood!
jcpons1967 1 year ago
I read the Band biography and it actually says that Ronnie Hawkins claims Levon is hung like horse. He is the ultimate male
Wdec29 1 year ago 2
Simply Amazing
TPG3471 1 year ago
folks... the band
Fruscianteistheman 1 year ago
Danko's bass really kicks in this song. It's criminal how underrated his playing is.
AFatGuyNamedPete 1 year ago 5
As my dad would say "It sounds like Robbie is playing with his toes!"
PageandPlant4Life 1 year ago
Is it just my perception, or is Robbie Robbertson the only musician in ANY group who gets bludgeoned repeatedly for not being a vocalist? The three members of The Band who COULD sing exceptionally well shone all the brighter for singing Robbie's lyrics. Creative talent manifests itself in many ways, including but not limited to having a great set of vocal chords.
Stephanjnj 1 year ago 4
Comment removed
NursingSoftware 1 year ago
Comment removed
NursingSoftware 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Stephanjnj Yeah, but since Band fans are more interested in fighting the Helm-Robertson war than educating others about the group, I guess we're going to have to keep hearing about how he can't sing. Ironically, he does put his voice to good use on songs like "Somewhere Down the Crazy River"
NursingSoftware 1 year ago 3
Rock from the soul..rock of ages!!
dialacroc 1 year ago
Merci pour cette vidéo , hyper sympa , c'était bien notre époque avec de la vrai musique !!!!! où que sont passés mes vingt ans!!!!
kaliane62 1 year ago
Damnit, Robbie. Who taught that guy to play guitar?
axwell21 1 year ago
@axwell21
No one. Don't like his playing?
AngusShanks 1 year ago
@AngusShanks
Not really. Whenever I listen to him solo, it seems like he hits the same note over and over. Not to mention he was the one responsible for breaking up the band.
axwell21 1 year ago
@axwell21
He's not an ace player but many top guys felt he had a lot of soul. He was THE arranger and main writer for The Band so without him they would have been just a backup band playing covers, albeit an immensely talented backup band. |His ego got in the way and it ended The Band, true. His solo stuff sucks IMO but he had a stretch of pure genius there for a while. The Band will never be recreated and I am grateful for RR's contribution to music.
AngusShanks 1 year ago
@axwell21 He's capable of a great solo, but some of his others can get somewhat repetitive. He's said that the Dylan influence changed him from focusing mainly on guitar playing to songwriting.
NursingSoftware 1 year ago
Comment removed
NursingSoftware 1 year ago
@axwell21
Roy Buchanan
Buster59 1 year ago
CHECK OUT'JOHN LENNONS 'band of motherfuckers' doing ''slipin and slidin' live
sunriseRISE 1 year ago
not a patch on the original by LITTLE RICHARD , but nice try
ray482 1 year ago
as soon as the bass kicks in you realize danko is a master of all things amazing.
PCPrabbit 1 year ago
This is pub rock at its finest!
Stephanjnj 1 year ago 2
Killer. Richard could burn.
AngusShanks 1 year ago
All you have to do is listen to Robbie's vocal in this song and you'll see why his mic was normally switched off.
lonelyboylv 1 year ago
hmmn likey not Bearsville
cielo27rah 2 years ago
Does anyone know where this was recorded?
adven229utube 2 years ago
@adven229utube this is from the festival express documentary, can't recall the exact city but somewhere in Canada, maybe Calgary?
patmz15 2 years ago
Toronto, at the CNE.
AngusShanks 1 year ago
for all the comments abah the vovals robbies mic was always switched off due to his weak voice and lack of confidence what a tune tho RIP RICHARD AND RICK X
joeykirk09 2 years ago
stop ripping stuff directly from levon helms book. it definitely was not switched fof here. and levon never said it was ALWAYS switched off anyway.
michaelvkelly1 2 years ago
ok robbie had the best voice infact he contibuted to the band hamonys both on record an live..........NOT
joeykirk09 2 years ago
that was a strange comment, i suspect a hint at sarcasm! who ever said he had the best voice? not me, just making the point that he was singing here.
michaelvkelly1 2 years ago
good comment. i just wrote an almost identical comment and then scrolled down and saw ud got there first! i hate the way people do that!!
michaelvkelly1 2 years ago
it wasnt always switched off. u r just basing that on what you read in levon helms book.
michaelvkelly1 2 years ago
I was there. Robbie's mic was not switched off, you could hear him singing.
jirishanca 1 year ago 4
good stuff. people base all their opinions on one book!!
michaelvkelly1 1 year ago
Why don't people want to play like this anymore? Am I the only one? There are so few acts that could compete with this, in terms of passion, musicianship (brother Robbie is on fire!), and the beauty in taking such a simple song and just playing the hell out of it... I love these huge singalongs they are able to do (like on "ain't no more cane") where you have all these amazing voices singing at the top of their lungs... Why don't people do this anymore???
nathanjhood 2 years ago 10
Amen...and I wish I knew!
andrewptob 2 years ago
You are so right on! Saw The Band several times.... no band rocked better! One of my fav personal music related possesions is a guitar pick Rick gave me.-, right after he gave me a bear hug.
bucks1955mjm 2 years ago
Go see the Cate Brothers live if you can. They have a connection with The Band as well, for those that are not aware. They even play some Band tunes at their shows.
microtechg7 2 years ago
His vocals are spot on in dont you break my heart
Eeasyskankin 2 years ago
What's the bfd and all the noise about Robbie's vocals or lack thereof?!
He does play a bad f'n geetar.
Rico8910 2 years ago
Wow, Garth is awesome. Where the hell was he going in that solo?
He loves that modulator lol(or leslie?). Did they have live modulators back then?
chrispiccaro18 2 years ago
ASelinger,
I really don't think that any of robbie's solo stuff sounded anything like the band. It seemed like a group effort to me. Without the band robbie didn't amount to much.
markowitzevan 2 years ago 3
I wonder if Robbie sang just because he thought it was fun, or if he was trying to get the audience to believe he was singing. either way, he isn't audible in most live recordings, and on the ones he is, the vocal harmonies suffer.
PageandPlant4Life 2 years ago 7
He actually used to like singing along with the guys but since he knew that his voice was bad, they turned the mic off. I don't know why he thought so. If you ever hear 'Out of the blue' from the Last Waltz soundtrack (it's not in the movie,) that's actually him singing because no one could find Richard. But it's actually really good.
YoHuckleberry 2 years ago
He sings a bit on the Bastment Tapes, too, which I thought he sounded pretty good on. Check out "Bessie Smith" from the Basement Tapes on here. Good tune with Robbie singing.
andrewptob 2 years ago
Is that right? Robbie sang "Out of the Blue" because Manuel couldn't be found? Well, good for Richard that day, as Robbie did a good job on a great song.
jirishanca 1 year ago
It has been well documented that Robbie would sing into a mic that was not on. In all of their live stuff, Robbie is singing into a dead mic. His voice was terrible but he liked to sing along during live shows. Levon is not the only one to talk about this.
batemen49 2 years ago 2
i love Levon, but he is unreasonable. Robbie clearly wrote all the Band's material (he is a songwriter, Levon is not), Robbie doesn't call himself a singer.
ASelinger 2 years ago 3
Firstly, Robbie did no write all the Band's material. He wrote the vast majority of it, after the first album. But what you say has little or nothing to do with the comment you were responding to. It's as much a fact as Napoleon's defeat at Waterloo that Robbie was singing into a dead mic.
joeshlatbonk 2 years ago
I think Levon's point was that even if Robbie brought the original song in for playing or recording, the other members made enough contributions on many to be considered co-writers.
jirishanca 1 year ago
I know what you are saying and im sure in some cases that is very true. im sure robbie was a bit of an egomaniac and hogged song writing credits on songs that others were involved in but its also perfectly plausable that levon is a bit jealous and bitter in old age having started out as the leader and longest serving member of his band to have been usurped by robbie. also all musicians add their own style to songs they play on but it they didnt write the tune or the words they dont get the $!!
michaelvkelly1 1 year ago
The Band is incredible.
ThomasMaclennan 2 years ago 7
good stuff
54spiritedwill54 2 years ago
yeah this recording is sweet, its off festival express, a documentary made about a series of festivals in Canada right after woodstock.
ThomasMaclennan 3 years ago
Danko's bass is awesome here.
sateliteoflove202 3 years ago 6
yea and Robbie shreds
1947Chief 2 years ago 4
damn, this song rocks !
zuendapp94 3 years ago 3
I second that emotion!
mysteria31 3 years ago 2
folks this is what happens when every musician in a band is on top of their game. simply amazing
PianoSpider 3 years ago 35
Go Ricky Go!!!
Bundashit 3 years ago 6
now thats a rock and roll guitar solo!
thebetterhalf37 3 years ago 4
shred !
1947Chief 3 years ago 2
Let's give it up for Garth Hudson on organ too. That guy was a magician.
ktbriggs 3 years ago 30
@ktbriggs Garth IS a magician! Not was.
lorenrt303 1 year ago 2
is it just me or is Robbie's mic actually on for once?
CSNY225 3 years ago 3
yeah it is in this. richard is nowhere to be heard, just robbie rick and levon.
famouspogs 3 years ago
that's richard on a very audible piano.....
forfunk49 3 years ago
i meant vocal wise.
famouspogs 3 years ago
robbie can't sing i wouldn't be surprised if his mic is off there like it was on the last waltz
Kilkelly7 3 years ago
he can sing just not in the sameway any of the band members could.
famouspogs 3 years ago
Yeah, probably not good
Theman5505 3 years ago
what makes u say his mic was off on the last waltz
joeyjoejoe1916 3 years ago
read "this wheel's on fire" by levon helm he says robbie wasnt much of a singer
Kilkelly7 3 years ago
maybe not by levon's standards. But he sounds just fine to the rest of us.
sgtcornsack 2 years ago
levon sounds great like always, J Robbie Robertson is just singing into a dead mic
Kilkelly7 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
if i wore lennon glasses would i look like him?-im female i might add
layforDylan 3 years ago
that's a stretch - Robbie likely emulate's American artists ...
1947Chief 3 years ago
wateva
Dizkneelande 3 years ago
sure you are
jacossun 3 years ago
Man, this is great. The band it's best and most entertaining here.
Bluesmen88 3 years ago
lennon was skinny
QuickhandsMcPinch 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Robertson look's like a skinny lennon...
pablohabibe 3 years ago
Man, it's nice to see Richard playing up some steaming piano there. It always seems to be Garth who gets the keyboard-limelight, but Richard, man, what a solid contender!
ElChrissos 3 years ago 2
You could tar, feather and drive this group through a car wash while performing, and they would still sound tighter than any band ever. There were no adverse stage conditions their musicianship could not overcome. Their Dylan boot camp days served them well...
noahf67 4 years ago 7
without a doubt.
1CupidandPsyche 4 years ago
Spot on. But Dylan boot camp? What about Ronnie Hawkins boot camp? They were already the best in town by the time Dylan called them up.
SteerforthBinoculars 4 years ago 7
True, but the Dylan experience saw them up against the toughest audiences in the largest numbers...it was "Play For Your Life!"
noahf67 4 years ago 3
Hah indeed. I guess without either experience they just wouldn't have been The Band.
SteerforthBinoculars 4 years ago 3
robbie robertson cannot sing man.. great guitarist and song writer though
frankdidit 4 years ago
The Best!
darkstar4589 4 years ago
John Lennon did a version too
rjh5885 4 years ago
who orginally did this song??
drowsyrn 4 years ago
I know Little Richard did it
Poway23 4 years ago
Eddie Bo - "I'm Wise." Little Richard stole the song from Eddie Bo and retitled it.
chicofishhead 1 year ago
@drowsyrn buddy holly
TheLazZzar 1 year ago
I first saw this at the cinema in canterbury, there was only 4 people there but this and janis joplins cry baby is on the festival express to that was brilliant but too. has anyone seen any good black blues vids???
MaximumMartin 4 years ago
Great stuff, I never heard them do this one before, they were sure belting it out !!!!
HickoryRose 4 years ago
good stuff
60skid 5 years ago
cool guys gret stuff .
marko1965nsw 5 years ago
love the pianee intro
thedudeabidestoyou 5 years ago
Cool beard on Robbie Robertson! :P
DangerousBastard 5 years ago
hummm seems like they turned Robbies` mic on on this one! hehe
iagobroxado 5 years ago
It's from Festival Express.
astoria1066 5 years ago
This thing is great! Please, more Band stuff. They were the best. Rick's bass sounds terrific here.
salmonroll 5 years ago
Please post more Band videos! These guys are the BEST. Awesome. Good stuff.
oceancoast12 5 years ago
Great stuff!!!
Does there exist more from this show? Or from that period?
rtpx7 5 years ago
This is soooo great! This was supposed to be their standard encore song, but they never played it when I heard them. There was supposed to be a bootleg version of it floating around in the 70s that everyone wanted to hear, but nobod I knew ever heard it.
Now I only want to hear the original demo version of "Don't Do It."
cluelessxpanda 5 years ago
Great live version of this song.
Xavi1900 5 years ago